Like the convener, I want to make a brief reference to the fuel price inquiry, which is in midstream, so to speak. I would like us to conclude the meetings and private sessions with the oil companies and either come to an interim conclusion or set a timetable for coming to a definitive conclusion. We should do that irrespective of what might be happening at the Department of Trade and Industry, although that will have an impact on our inquiry.The background paper was helpful, as we must decide between large and small inquiries and, whatever we do, we must focus our work on those issues where we can make the most difference. As became clear from our work on tourism, in certain instances that might involve us tagging on to Executive initiatives and making a difference to the final document that it produces, although it would also include an entirely separate consideration of issues that concern us. As a consequence of our most recent inquiry, we have flagged up congestion in lifelong learning. The question that arises is when we will do that work, not whether we will do it. The convener referred to student finance legislation as having a major impact, but it seems to me to be problematic to return to that subject before legislation is introduced, although other members may have different views about that. I know that we discussed the impact of the new economy early in the session; that issue merits some short-term consideration. I was struck by the suggestion of looking at Scotland's competitive position in relation to the impact of the new economy, as I do not think that we can consider the impact of the new economy without considering globalisation more generally. I am not trying to broaden out the debate, but we cannot consider the impact of the new economy, skill demands and the commercialisation of science without taking account of the fact that Scotland is competing in a global economy. Our relative competitive position is vital to our productive capacity.I remain intent on considering further and higher education governance, which, as we know, is a topical issue. That relates to the funding policies of SHEFC and SFEFC and issues of FE expansion and finance. It is a question of timing. If asked to choose, I would say that we should be considering the impact of the new economy in the short to medium term and laying down a timetable for returning to the issue of congestion in lifelong learning. That would be compatible with our consideration of student finance legislation—the two are inextricably linked.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Allan Wilson only · show everyone- John Swinney SNP 23
- George Lyon LD 12
- Nick Johnston Con 9
- Fergus Ewing SNP 6
- Elaine Murray Lab 5
- Duncan McNeil Lab 5
- Elaine Thomson Lab 4
- Allan Wilson Lab 4
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 2
- Simon Watkins 2
Allan Wilson’s contributions
4 contributionsWe should not forget that we made five recommendations on lifelong learning, only one of which we said we would return to—on congestion. In my view, we should carry out the inquiry that Marilyn Livingstone suggests after scrutinising the legislation that arises out of the Cubie report. If the choice is between a short-term, focused inquiry into the impact of the new economy and a longer-term inquiry into lifelong learning and, specifically, the issue of congestion, we should do the inquiry into the new economy first and return to lifelong learning later. Logistically, that would make most sense.
I reject the premise that either the committee or the Parliament has not been mindful of the problems in all parts of Scotland. In fact, I remember this committee discussing Continental Tyre and the issue of the rapid response of the Executive early on. Crises, whether in the manufacturing sector or anywhere else, should, as Duncan McNeil said, be looked at carefully. I have no objection to meeting Highland Council and others to discuss the Highland economy. We have to schedule that for our next meeting or arrange a separate meeting, because, given our agenda for 27 June, we cannot address this issue then. There are scheduling issues to be addressed. I am also mindful of what the Deputy Minister for the Highlands and Islands said in debate on it as a matter for consideration by the committee—that is a matter of record.
It seemed to me that the two things could be combined. We should return to the question of the risk aversion of financial institutions, but I did not include it in the short to medium-term schedule because of the inquiry into business support.
In this meeting
Everything on 31 May 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 31 May 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Education and Training (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 7
- Local Economic Development Committee business · 7
- Work Programme Procedure · 72
- Transport Bill Bill debate · 6
- Local Economic Development (Joint Seminar) Committee business · 7
- Petitions Petitions · 10
- Royal Society of Edinburgh Committee business · 3
- Business in the Chamber Committee business · 1
- “The same as you?” Committee business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.