The officials who have been here to deal with all our questions about free school meals, which they have been waiting for, have to head off now, so I invite the officials who are here to speak to the instrument relating to PIP to do so.
We are dealing here with the Welfare Reform (Consequential Amendments) (Scotland) Regulations 2013 (SSI 2013/65). The instrument involves the amendment of eight separate pieces of subordinate legislation. I do not know whether the committee would find it useful to go through them regulation by regulation.
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
The simplest thing may be for me to read for the record what is on the table that was issued to committee members. It gives a brief description of what each regulation does. Regulation 2 deals with the Council Tax (Discounts) (Scotland) Regulations 1992, which provide for care workers to be disregarded for council tax—that is, to be effectively treated as if they do not live in the property, incurring no liability and not affecting any claim for single person’s discount by another resident, for example. That treatment is conditional, and a number of factors are to be taken into account. Those include the fact that the individual in question is providing care to a person who is in receipt of“the highest rate of the care component of a disability living allowance”.The amendment adds to regulation 2(3)(c) of the 1992 regulations a reference to the daily living component of personal independence payment at the enhanced rate, so that a care worker will be disregarded if caring for a person in receipt of such an allowance.Shall I simply move on to the next regulation, convener?
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
Okay.Regulation 3 deals with the National Assistance (Assessment of Resources) Regulations 1992. The amendments that are proposed to those regulations allow for the disregard of income respectively from the mobility component and the daily living component of personal independence payment in the calculation of income other than earnings. The intention of these amendments is that those who currently receive either the mobility or the care component of disability living allowance will not have their income from personal independence payment treated differently for the calculation of income following the introduction of PIP.Regulation 4 concerns the Advice and Assistance (Scotland) Regulations 1996. Regulation 16 of those regulations makes provision as to exceptions from the general rule that a solicitor who is providing advice and assistance must first recover fees from property recovered or preserved before seeking any payment from the Scottish Legal Aid Board. That regulation is amended so that, if the advice and assistance that is given leads to the mobility component of personal independence being paid, any payments of that allowance are excepted from the rule that is referred to.Regulation 5 is slightly more substantial and deals with blue badge matters. It amends the Disabled Persons (Badges for Motor Vehicles) (Scotland) Regulations 2000. There are three basic groups of amendments.First, the amendment to regulation 4(2) will create a new category of person who is entitled to obtain a blue badge. The category covers certain personal independence payment recipients, thus allowing that benefit to be used as a passport to obtain a blue badge.The amendments to regulation 6 of the 2000 regulations concern the period for which a blue badge may be issued. Those who are passporting from the personal independence payment will get a badge for three years or, if for a shorter time, until the date on which their PIP award expires.The amendments to regulation 9 of the 2000 regulations will allow a person who, following assessment, does not receive a relevant PIP award to continue to use their blue badge until its expiry date.Do members want to discuss that issue now, or should I just move on to the next regulation?
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
We will go through them first. Members will no doubt want to discuss that issue, but we will go through the rest of the list and then come back to it—I am sure that they will not forget.
Okay. Regulation 6 amends the Repayment of Student Loans (Scotland) Regulations 2000. The definition of “disability related benefit” in regulation 2 of those regulations is amended so as to include personal independence payment. The result is that someone in receipt of PIP may have student loan liability cancelled out if they are permanently unfit for work.Regulation 7 amends the Civil Legal Aid (Scotland) Regulations 2002. Schedule 2 to those regulations makes provision concerning the computing of an individual’s disposable income in connection with an application for civil legal aid. Paragraph 7 of that schedule provides for certain allowances and benefits to be disregarded when carrying out that exercise. The amendment as it is currently drafted adds the mobility component of personal independence payment to that list of allowances and benefits. However, after studying the regulations we have ascertained that that is in fact an error, and that we should be taking out of account the total personal independence payment and not just the mobility component. A fresh instrument will be introduced in due course to deal with that.Regulation 8 amends the Council Tax (Discounts) (Scotland) Consolidation and Amendment Order 2003. Article 4 of that order sets out conditions that must be fulfilled before a person can be disregarded for council tax purposes—that is, effectively treated as if they do not live in the property—on the basis that the person is “severely mentally impaired”. At present, a person fulfils the condition of being in receipt of a qualifying benefit if they are in receipt of the highest or middle rates of disability living allowance care component. The amendment introduces a reference to the daily living component of personal independence payment.Regulation 9, which is a bit more substantial, amends the National Bus Travel Concession Scheme for Older and Disabled Persons (Eligible Persons and Eligible Services) (Scotland) Order 2006. The amendments to the 2006 order will enable all those who receive personal independence payment, at either the standard or the enhanced rate, to be eligible for a concessionary travel card, and those who receive the daily living component of PIP, at either the standard or the enhanced rate, to be eligible for a companion card.Those criteria have been assessed as being the most likely to mitigate the impact of the UK Government’s welfare reforms on the concessionary travel scheme, as they are closest to the current eligibility criteria for those in receipt of disability living allowance.In addition, transitional arrangements are being put in place to allow those who have been in receipt of a concessionary travel card or companion card but who, following assessment, do not qualify for PIP to continue to be eligible under the scheme until the expiry of the card.
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
I welcome the clarification on the Civil Legal Aid (Scotland) Regulations 2002, and I look forward to the new instrument being made.I return to where I started: the aspiration and ambition of both the cabinet secretary and the committee, which is that everybody who lost benefit in the migration from DLA to PIP would still be eligible for passported benefits. If my reading is correct, that has not been achieved. We can start with blue badges; the concessionary travel scheme operates on a similar basis. According to the documentation, there is coverage for people who move from DLA to PIP, and there is scope for including more people by widening the criteria.Nevertheless, as regards the blue badge scheme,“27% may not receive a PIP award and will therefore not qualify for a Blue Badge through the passporting process.”Potentially, 27 per cent of people will not qualify once their blue badge expires. I am trying to tease out the point that that does not meet the ambition that we had. Was there a particular problem? I understand that it would be a complex matter to continue eligibility for that group of people.
That group of people will also be able to apply through the normal eligibility criteria, so they may be able to acquire a blue badge through that route. Our main aspiration was to put in place passporting equivalent to what we had under the higher rate mobility component of DLA, and that is what we believe we have done.If we had considered any of the other criteria under the new PIP arrangements, we might have had equivalent numbers but, we believe, the people concerned might not have been the same people who are currently receiving the higher rate mobility component of DLA.We believe that the criteria that we have put in place offer us the best solution to protect most of the people who were formerly receiving the equivalent in DLA. Once their blue badge expires, they also have the ability to apply through the eligibility criteria for the blue badge.
DLA will not exist any more for working-age people—that is correct. They may not get a passport, because they do not come under the PIP criteria, which we believe are equivalent to the higher rate mobility component. That is purely because, on reassessment, the DWP may assess them out of that category, and that is something that we cannot mitigate. However, we believe that they have a separate route in that they can meet the eligibility criteria for the blue badge.
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
They can still apply under the eligibility criteria. They then go through a local authority assessment, which is a desk-based process, and there is a further tier of process with occupational therapists, who assess the person’s mobility. The person will be able to apply through that route.
Given that you think that 27 per cent of people may not make it through the passporting process, how many do you think might not be captured, despite your best efforts?
I have a point to make while my colleagues are looking for the figures. In the coming months, we want to work quite closely with stakeholders to make sure that people understand what the new criteria are for the new passporting arrangements and that there is greater awareness of the alternative criteria under which people may apply so that we reduce the risk of people falling out of receiving passported benefits.
When the DWP is doing reassessments, it believes that it will reassess 100,000 people. Of those, 60 per cent who receive the higher rate mobility component of DLA go on to apply for a blue badge. Drilling down into those figures, we see that possibly 27 per cent would not be able to passport but they would still be able to apply through the eligibility criteria. However, we do not know how many would succeed.
I understand that. I am defaulting to the committee’s aspiration and the cabinet secretary’s helpful aspiration that, even if someone falls out of receiving benefits as a result of the DWP, we would ensure that they are covered. I am trying to explore the extent to which that is possible given the complexities of the system.Convener, might I ask the same question about concessionary travel?
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
Before you do that, I have a question about the blue badge scheme. What is happening elsewhere in the UK? How does it compare with the arrangements that have been put in place in Scotland?
Wales is passporting under the same criteria as Scotland. In England, the Department for Transport has decided to tighten its criteria and it will passport only on the moving around component. It has actively excluded those who have a sensory impairment who would have come through the higher rate mobility component of DLA, and who could possibly still come through PIP. In effect, Scotland and Wales have reached a better position in trying to maintain equivalent criteria wherever possible.
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
No, it is okay. I just want to ask a similar set of questions of those who are responsible for concessionary travel. How many would qualify, and how many might drop out? You are offering continuation of the transport card until its expiry date—is that normally three years?
Three years is a function of the time limits that are put on disability-linked cards. They normally have a time limit after which they come up for reassessment. The effect of the regulation is that if a card issued by virtue of DLA is reassessed for PIP and the individual comes out of DLA, they will still have the card but only until it expires. After that point—or indeed before it—if the individual is in receipt of PIP, they will qualify for a card. If they are not in receipt of PIP, they could apply on the basis of the basic eligibility grounds.Those grounds are somewhat different from those for the blue badge. There is a longish list of grounds and they are fairly well defined and objective. For example, the applicant has to bring proof, and if they have lost one or both lower limbs or if they are profoundly deaf, they will qualify for the card on those grounds. I stand to be corrected, but I do not think that we have a detailed understanding of how many people have a DLA-linked card at the moment who would qualify under some of the other, more specific grounds.
It is the same as with the blue badge in that we know who will qualify because we have the criteria that the DWP has provided. What we do not know is what are the characteristics of the individuals who will lose out as a result of the move to PIP. We are not able to say whether they will definitely qualify under other criteria.
Historically, we have not collected in any great detail the specific grounds of disability on which applicants were given a card. Since, I think, February, we have been collecting that information, which should help us to monitor the impact of the changes as they come in over the next couple of years. That should give us an indication of whether there is any systematic change in eligibility that might need to be addressed.11:15
If you are making the same assumption as your colleagues who are responsible for blue badges, you will assume that 60 per cent of people who are currently eligible would qualify under the change from DLA to PIP but 40 per cent would fall out. If I heard you correctly, you are doing a piece of work to establish the underlying characteristics of applicants and, therefore, determine whether they would be eligible. Basically, the gap is as much as 40 per cent. If you are monitoring those characteristics, do you plan to be flexible about the eligibility criteria in the future?
We have been able to do some work based on the information that we have received from the DWP. Using the information that it has provided on outcomes of reassessment, we think that up to 40,000 people who are currently eligible for concessionary travel as a result of DLA would receive no PIP award.That is a maximum figure, and at least 50 per cent of those who are eligible take up concessionary travel, so around 20,000 people might lose out. However, there are some assumptions in the figures that mean that the number will probably be lower than that. We know only the proportion of all DLA recipients who will get no award, so we have to assume that people with a higher rate award will have the same chance of losing their award completely as those on a lower rate. That is why we think that the 40,000 is a top-end estimate and the actual figure is likely to be below that.
The intention is to review the criteria in the light of experience over the next couple of years. The criteria are specific and well defined, so it will be more a question of whether the Government wishes to introduce changes to them if a pattern emerges of people dropping out of eligibility and not managing to get in by virtue of one of the other grounds. However, we will have to see that in action. We cannot model that degree of detail at this stage.
It would be good if we could clarify that no one who currently has a blue badge or national concessionary travel card will have that taken away from them. Is it correct that it will run until its expiry?
It would therefore be fair to say that, in many cases, we will have a period in which to consider how many folk fall out of eligibility from passporting.Ms Mulholland said that all 32 local authorities now operate the blue badge scheme on the same basis. Is that the case when it comes to eligibility criteria, or do some local authorities still have some of their own? Is it a matter of interpretation?
There is a national scheme and we have a set of eligibility criteria that are consistent across that scheme. That was introduced in legislation last March, I believe. We also introduced in legislation an independent mobility assessment with occupational therapists from September 2012. The scheme should be consistent. I cannot comment about whether local authorities are all abiding by that, but that is the intention.
For the record, interpretation matters on such regulations. That is the case even within a local authority. Different parts of a local authority can interpret regulations differently.
Okay. I knew that that was going to be the answer, but I thought it wise to ask. That comes back to the point that local authorities sometimes do their own thing. Interpretation is a great thing in terms of leeway.You said that work is being done on the eligibility criteria. What factors are being considered?
Last year, we redefined part of the eligibility criteria for the blue badge scheme to make it consistent across local authorities. Slightly ironically, we redefined it in line with the higher rate mobility component of DLA. However, we still think that that offers a more consistent approach. We redefined the mobility aspect of the eligibility criteria to bring in persons who are“unable to walk, or virtually unable to walk”.We believe that that has brought greater consistency across local authorities.That has, in tandem with the independent mobility assessments, allowed occupational therapists to work to a model that can be applied across all local authorities, whereas previously the arrangements were very much down to what happened in local areas, so we saw great inconsistency in awarding of badges and the types of mobility impairment that were being awarded badges. I hope that over the next two to three years we will see consistency across the local authorities.
Thank you. I want to move on to the national bus travel concessions scheme. It has been suggested that some of the changes that we have in front of us today may result in an increase in eligibility. Has that been analysed?
The expected headline increase in the number of individuals eligible to apply for cards is from around 171,000 now, moving up to 174,000 by 2018. That is the long-run expected change, all other things being equal. In that total are a number of people who are eligible to apply for companion cards. The forecast increase in the number who are eligible for that is from 125,000 to 134,000. That is the number who are eligible to apply; about half of those who are eligible do so. The costs then depend on usage.
Going back to the blue badge scheme, I want to clarify one point in annex A in the letter from the cabinet secretary. The following statistic was given in relation to the scheme: “29% may receive a decreased award. However we have mitigated for this by setting the criteria for passporting at 8 points or more for the "moving around" activity. This is comparable to the current arrangement and will ensure that the majority will continue to passport.”Can someone clarify the position on that? Excuse my ignorance, but how does putting the threshold at eight points equate with the current situation and therefore mitigate for this group of people?
Under the higher rate mobility component of DLA, the criteria for mobility seemed to be wider. When we looked at the threshold for PIP, we saw that a lot of people would have been removed from the enhanced rate of PIP. The DWP’s intention was to remove a lot of people from the enhanced rate of PIP and to reduce their payment to the standard rate of PIP at 8 points. We wanted to mitigate the effects of that and to protect a number of people on the higher rate mobility component who had perhaps not lost their award through PIP, but who may have had a reduced payment, so we included the standard rate at 8 points or more.
We cannot anticipate the percentage because we do not know what is going to happen. We know that the DWP has publicly intimated the intention to reduce awards under PIP, so all that we can do is try to mitigate the effects of that for passporting. We cannot say how many people will be affected because the DWP has not told us how many or at what levels.
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
For clarification, are those the people about whom we talked earlier, who are covered by the initiative that is being taken by the Scottish Government and the Welsh Assembly Government?
I was going to ask what the other nations of the UK have done. It seems that Wales has taken the same approach—or that we have taken the same approach as Wales. What is happening in England on the specific mitigatory measures?
There seems to be a general measure based on the benefit that can still be passported from, but when we get into the territory of there being no underlying benefit, that passporting becomes a bit moot in strict legal terms because there is nothing to passport from. I guess that you have been wrestling with that for some time.
Yes—you mean for someone who is not getting benefit at all. On the difference between ourselves and Wales and England, Sharon Grant has been describing the “moving around” mobility activities. Scotland and Wales have included one other criterion—planning and following a journey. We believe that that fully reflects the intention of the higher rate mobility component of DLA, but the DFT has not followed that.
I have a final question. The changes will have a major effect. I commend you for doing the best that you can, but some folk who would previously have directly passported will have to enter through eligibility criteria. Will there be a campaign telling folk that they can still apply through the eligibility criteria method, to ensure that as many people as possible still get access to the blue badge scheme and national concessionary car schemes?
We are working with the DWP to put pointers in award letters and no-award letters saying that people can contact their local authority to apply for blue badges. The DWP is also issuing a leaflet covering frequently asked questions on the personal independence payment, which will also have pointers on blue badge schemes and other concessionary schemes that are available across the country. We are considering how we get the information to local authorities through our guidance pack and how we can work with local authorities to get that information out to current blue badge holders who may be affected—without causing fear and alarm.
I suppose that that is the least that it can do, considering the slash-and-burn approach of the Westminster Government when it comes to these benefits.11:30
Jamie HepburnSNPThe Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.