Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Council Tax Reduction (State Pension Credit) (Amendment) Regulations 2013 (SSI 2013/49)

Tuesday 5 March 2013 Welfare Reform Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 125 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

125 contributions
Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Item 3 is consideration of two Scottish statutory instruments, which will amend the principal regulations on the council tax reduction scheme. Paper 1 briefly sets out the background to the regulations.The observant among you will notice that we have with us Robin Haynes and Jenny Brough from the Scottish Government, who are here to answer any questions that members might have. They are not here to make a statement or provide evidence per se, but if anyone has any questions, they will answer them. Do members have any comments or questions on the regulations?

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

The further correspondence that we have seen around the appeals procedure—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I am sorry. May I stop you there? We will move on to that issue—it is the very next thing that we will discuss. I want to deal with the regulations first.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I will come to you first on the correspondence, Iain. Are there any comments on the regulations?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I apologise, convener. I was told only late last night that I was coming to the meeting today, otherwise I would have checked this for myself. I am curious—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

That is funny, Jackie, because I was told earlier in the day that you were coming, so I must have known something that you did not.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You certainly must have, because I did not know until last night.The regulations were considered by the Subordinate Legislation Committee. I do not have the report of that committee’s discussion, but I notice that the regulations were agreed to after a division. Perhaps we should not ask the Government what happened at the Subordinate Legislation Committee, but would it be appropriate for you to advise us about that committee’s discussion?

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

My understanding is that there was a division, which I think was four to three in favour of the regulations being competent. I am not aware of the detail of the discussion at the committee, but if you have questions about the vires nature of the regulations, you should by all means feel free to ask the Government officials.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Okay. On that basis, my understanding, from what the convener has just said, is that there might be some question over the Scottish Government’s powers in relation to the regulations. Could you perhaps expand on your view of the situation?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I was not at either meeting of the Subordinate Legislation Committee, but I understand that it had a very similar discussion when it considered the much longer regulations that set out the council tax reduction scheme and, again, the committee divided on them.The Scottish Government has been very clear that these regulations are made under section 80 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992. In essence they are about filling the hole that was created by the United Kingdom Government’s abolition of council tax benefit, which is a fundamental part of the benefits system and therefore absolutely reserved, and moving assistance to the vulnerable in meeting their council tax liability away from the social security system to the local taxation system. Therefore, the Scottish Government is quite comfortable that the matter is absolutely within the competence of the Parliament.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Is that satisfactory, Jackie?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

It remains the case that the Subordinate Legislation Committee’s legal advisers were not satisfied. Can you tell me on what precise basis they were not satisfied, given that you will have considered their argument, too?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I think that the Government’s position was made clear in our response to the committee’s questions at the time the original regulations were made.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

To be fair, Jackie, you are asking the witnesses to comment on someone else’s precise legal position, which it is legitimate to do, but—

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I checked with you first, convener, and you told me to go ahead and question them, so—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I did not know what your question was going to be. I am not psychic.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I asked the question on the basis that any Government would have considered what was being said against its proposition. I am asking precisely what the arguments were and how the Government overcame them. I have heard the Government’s side of it, but I have not heard the precise nature of the arguments.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I regret that I do not have our response to the committee to hand. If I did, I would be able to read it out. We will be happy to ensure that it is copied to the committee again if that would be helpful.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am trying to recall, but did we not have a brief discussion on the matter with regard to the underlying, more comprehensive regulations? I am looking at the clerks, as they might be able to help. I seem to recall that the committee had such a discussion.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

My recollection is that it was specifically about this, but—

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I may be wrong, but I think that the matter was flagged up in one of our papers with respect to the 2012 council tax reduction regulations, and the committee had a brief discussion about it. I think that we agreed that there was no issue.

Simon Watkins Clerk
link

The issue was flagged up in relation to the parent regulation, if I can call it that. At that time, we had both the officials before us briefly, although I do not think that there were any questions at that stage, from what I remember.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The issue here is that a benefit is the provision of public money to meet a liability, and council tax reduction is a reduction of the liability. That is my understanding of the legal position. In the light of what Westminster is doing in taking away the benefit, what the Scottish Government has done—I believe successfully—is to find a mechanism to fill the gap and help vulnerable people in Scotland, as one of the officials said. That is my understanding of what the Government is doing. The mechanism reduces the liability, further to the Scottish Government’s powers in relation to council tax. For me as a lawyer, the issue is quite clear.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

For clarification, if the regulations were not put through, what would be the practical effect on people on the ground?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Sorry. Did you say if they were, or were not, put through?

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

If they were not put through. If the regulations were not agreed to, what would be the effect?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

If the amending regulations were not put through, there would be a number of practical effects. First, they address a number of specific points that the Subordinate Legislation Committee raised. Secondly, they reflect the United Kingdom Government’s social security benefit uplift, which was announced just before Christmas. Although council tax reduction is not a benefit, that is important in as much as entitlement to council tax reduction, which replicates existing entitlement to council tax benefit, is a function of the applicant’s deemed income less their living expenses, and not every benefit is disregarded in that calculation of income. If some benefits increase but we do not increase the allowable living expenses, it could result in some individuals’ council tax reduction being less than it would otherwise have been, so while the UK Government is increasing some incomes, we are also increasing some of the deemed living expenses.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I hope that you do not take this in the wrong way, Mr Haynes, but that was quite a technical answer. What I really meant was this—if I was in receipt of council tax benefit and the amending regulations did not go through, what would be the effect on me as an individual?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

You would potentially have to pay, because of the rather complicated thing that I tried to describe, obviously not very well—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

No, you described it perfectly well, but I think that—

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Your council tax liability would be greater than it would otherwise have been.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Do you have any figures on that? What might be the average for individuals who are in receipt of council tax benefit?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I do not have figures, but it has been put to us by practitioners in local authorities and indeed the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities that, if the regulations did not go through and the benefits uprating was not applied, local authorities would find themselves chasing trivial amounts of council tax in a large number of cases. There would be a considerable administrative burden on local authorities, and indeed a compliance burden on a large proportion of the 560,000 people who will receive council tax reduction.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

So that would impact negatively not only on the individual, but on local authorities.10:15

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

It would. The burden on local authorities would be particularly acute, in that the timing has been rather less than ideal throughout the development of the regulations. The timescales were very much imposed upon us and not of our own design.The original regulations were laid just before Christmas and came into force in January, so there was a slightly uncomfortable situation whereby the people who developed the software that local authorities use to administer the scheme were developing that software before the regulations came into force. For about the first six weeks of this year, local authorities were testing and installing the software and training people. My understanding is that the software releases reflect the benefits uplift figures that are in these regulations. Again, that is not an ideal circumstance but it reflects the timescales that have been imposed upon us. If the regulations were not to go through, local authorities would have to unpick the changes that they have adopted for the time being, revert to the original figures and, in effect, run council tax billing again in very short order.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Mr Haynes stated that there would be an effect on 560,000 individuals if the regulations did not go through. Will he confirm that 560,000 figure and indicate how many working families would be affected if the regulations did not go through?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

The 560,000 figure that I used is very much shorthand—it fluctuates each month and there is a degree of seasonality. The last actual figure that I saw was slightly more than 560,000; it was about 565,000. I do not have the figure to hand for the number of working adults, but I am happy to investigate that and report back to the committee.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Even though the figure fluctuates, would it be fair to say that more than half a million working and non-working individuals would be affected if the reduction did not go through?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Is everyone satisfied? Iain Gray hinted at the other issue. We have a paper before us on the appeals mechanism for the council tax reduction scheme. If members have any questions, they should feel free to ask them. However, I turn to Iain Gray first.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Everyone on the committee appreciates how important it is that the regulations are in place, that they work and that they are legal. Part of that, in my understanding, would be an appeals process to enable decisions on council tax reduction to be appealed. It is extremely unfortunate that we have reached the position in which, as I understand it from the cabinet secretary’s letter, no such appeals procedure is in place. What are the European convention on human rights compliance implications of the regulations if they include within them a decision against which, as we stand, there is no system of appeals?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

First, the law as it stands means that an appeal would be against somebody’s council tax liability and therefore that should go to a valuation appeal committee. However, we are where we are.On the commencement of the scheme, if somebody wished to contest their council tax reduction assessment, they should do exactly what they would do at the moment under council tax benefit. Their first port of call should be their local authority, and the decision or determination would be reviewed by different officials within that local authority. If council tax benefit were not to be abolished and were to roll forward from 1 April, and if that individual still wished to contest their claim, they would, at present, take their appeal to Her Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service and have it heard in the social entitlement chamber. Having read some of the service’s literature on its website, I understand that it would expect to deal with an appeal in between three and eight months.First, it is highly unlikely that appeals about council tax benefit, if it were to continue, or the new council tax reduction scheme, would be made on 1 April; however, if such an appeal were to be made and council tax benefit were to be rolled forward, that appeal might not be heard until November. As a result, although we are in the position that is set out in the cabinet secretary’s letter, we would be confident that we could get something in place on a timescale that, I hope, would be better.To an extent, that position is informed by the likely number of appeals, which again is set out in the cabinet secretary’s letter. If memory serves, I think that, last year in Scotland, there were 459 appeals against council tax benefit determinations, something like 380 of which were joint appeals against council tax and housing benefit determinations. Rolling forward entitlement to a council tax reduction very much replicates entitlement to housing benefit and both will be administered by the same people. As a result, there is a very good chance that anyone who appeals against their council tax reduction will also be appealing their housing benefit and, given that such appeals will have due process through HM Courts and Tribunals Service, we are exploring the idea of local authorities adopting very much as a backstop a protocol by which if a housing benefit appeal is heard the local authority will agree to abide by that in the council tax reduction. We are exploring that and other options with Jim McCafferty and the Administrative Justice and Tribunals Council.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I appreciate that options are being explored and I do not think that anyone doubts the Scottish Government’s desire to have an appeals process in place. Nevertheless, as of today, no such process will be in place. Mr Haynes said that he was confident that it could be in place in time to deal with appeals but the legislation abolishing council tax benefit, which has led to our being in this position, was passed in early 2011. I just wonder why we should have such confidence, given that we have had 18 months and now do not have any appeals process in place. Why should we believe this second attempt—

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

The legislation that abolishes council tax—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Please let Mr Gray finish, Mr Haynes.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Why should we believe that this second attempt will deliver in a matter of months?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I should correct something that you have just said. The legislation that abolished council tax benefit was the UK Government Welfare Reform Act 2012, which, as I understand it, received royal assent only last March, not in 2011.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

It might have received royal assent in March, but we knew that this was coming before then. We are still talking about a year. You are asking us to have confidence that a system can be put in place in a matter of months.In any case, my more fundamental question is: if the subordinate legislation that is before us puts in place a process that, when the Parliament agrees it, will not come with a properly compliant appeals procedure, is there not a problem with its competence? I realise that that is not a happy position, but is that not the position that we are in?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I would contest that interpretation. The appeals procedure is set out in the Local Government Finance Act 1992 and the alternative arrangements, which we are now exploring with great haste because of the situation in which we find ourselves, would also be subject to secondary legislation made under the same act.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

So are you saying that although previous legislation contains an appeals procedure for council tax reduction, that procedure will not exist until these regulations are agreed? I do not follow that.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I was trying to say that we can no longer use the appeals procedure that is set out in primary legislation that we anticipated using. Alternative arrangements will require further secondary legislation to be laid using powers under sections 80 and 81 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

That legislation will be laid in the usual fashion and subject to scrutiny.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Absolutely.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Mr Haynes, you said that you were in great haste to ensure that an alternative is in place. How long will that take? Will the alternative be in place before November, which is before the time when many of the appeals would be held should they go to a UK tribunal?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

That is our ambition. We very much hope to better that, but I would be reluctant to commit to a specific date lest we slipped by a couple of days, for example. Work is proceeding with great haste. We have the greater part of the scheme away from our desks, and we are turning our absolute attention to ensuring that an appeals mechanism is put in place. The person who is probably the most experienced practitioner in Scotland is working with us to identify solutions; we have also engaged the statutory adviser on administrative justice to ensure that people’s rights will be protected under whatever arrangements are introduced.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I think that you said that 459 appeals took place last year, of which 380 were joint appeals on council tax and housing benefit. Is that right?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I recognise those numbers. The absolute figures may be laid out in Mr Swinney’s letter of 26 February.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

We are talking about 79 cases each year relating to council tax appeals only. Is that about right?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Stalling the regulations would affect about 560,000 individuals for a situation in which there may be some difficulty in finding an appeal mechanism in the near future for about only 79 cases. Is that about right?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

That is a reasonable thing to say.

Linda Fabiani SNP East Kilbride
link

I want to ensure that we do not, as far as possible, disadvantage people who have had welfare reform imposed on them against the will of the Scottish people and the Scottish Government. We need to get this right.We are talking about—even if we do not finesse the different joint appeals and other things—less than 0.1 per cent of those who could get council tax reductions who might appeal, judging by previous figures.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Yes—if that is what 80 divided by 560,000 comes out at—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

We will not test your maths.

Linda Fabiani SNP East Kilbride
link

I was referring to the original 459 appeals, which is still less than 0.1 per cent. I want that figure to be on the record, because I do not want us to make people think that they will be very disadvantaged.You say that you are working with others to look for a system that properly addresses the issues. Perhaps it might even be possible to improve how such things are dealt with through your discussions with—I presume—the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the appeals tribunal and so on.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

You make an interesting point. I have seen the letter from the Scottish campaign on welfare reform in which reservations are expressed about the original appeals mechanism that was identified. Although we find ourselves in an uncomfortable position, it may ultimately prove to be serendipitous.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I do not wish to put my maths to the test, but I think that the figure is closer to 0.01 per cent.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

You make the point for me, convener. At the end of the day, irrespective of the numbers, the issue is whether or not there is an appeals mechanism at the point at which the benefit transitions to being dealt with in Scotland. In practice, there is nothing on the ground from 1 April.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

As I said earlier, on 1 April, somebody who wishes to contest a decision about their deemed entitlement to the council tax reduction should do exactly what they do at present under council tax benefit, in that their first port of call is the local authority and they can ask for their case to be reviewed.10:30

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Absolutely, but the point that I am making is that the review mechanism is yet to be determined.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

No. There would be an internal review within the local authority—a different administrator would look at it. That is exactly what happens at present.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Okay. Does the person then go to the tribunal, or do you still have to put in place the appeals mechanism?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Sorry, but are you talking about the situation under council tax benefit or the future council tax reduction scheme?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

At present, there is no appeals mechanism—that is what we seek to address.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Okay. So, in practice, beyond the internal review, the kind of appeals mechanism that we are discussing will not be on the ground on 1 April. I just want to be clear about that. You anticipate that it will be on the ground to hear first appeals by November.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

That is not quite what I said.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I said that if the UK Tribunals Service was in receipt of an appeal, it may not be able to determine that appeal until November. We have ambitions to get something in place that could better that.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Fine. What timescale do your ambitions relate to? If you are not talking about November and the UK Tribunals Service, what timescale do you anticipate?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Again, I would not like to commit myself to a particular date, but in our rough working estimates we are looking to something in the summer.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Okay. That is helpful to know. If somebody lodges an appeal on 1 April or at some point thereafter, will their existing entitlement continue until the appeal is heard, or will people be parked on their new entitlement until their appeal is heard?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I will perhaps look to my colleague to clarify that, but my understanding is that their deemed entitlement would prevail.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

As I said, I would be very concerned if people were to appeal on 1 April.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I suspect that the situation that you described is hypothetical.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Sure, but I think that you would share my concern about people being delayed by an appeals process and not retaining their existing entitlement. I am checking whether that backstop will still be there until an appeal is heard.

Jenny Brough Scottish Government
link

Can I clarify the question of previous entitlement? If somebody does not agree with what is determined for their entitlement for CTR, they can ask for that to be reviewed. However, that is their entitlement for council tax reduction. Was that what you were referring to?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Someone’s existing entitlement is normally preserved while they go through an appeal. If people are financially disadvantaged, any delay in an appeal will compound that disadvantage. I am interested in protection for the individual and the speed of the process.

Jenny Brough Scottish Government
link

We will take that away and get back to you on it.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Let me see whether I have understood your question. Supposing that we were to apply the timetable that the UK Tribunals Service suggests could be applied and somebody applied for their council tax reduction on 1 April, with the local authority making a particular determination that went through internal review. The individual could appeal that and the appeal could be heard, but in November they could be told, “Ah, no. In point of fact, the entitlement to a reduction was greater.” The local authority would therefore re-bill backwards.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I am sorry, Jackie, but Kevin Stewart has a brief supplementary question. I will come back to you.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

On average how long would it take a local authority to complete an internal review?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

I am sorry, but I genuinely do not know.

Jenny Brough Scottish Government
link

I could only speculate.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I think that it would be interesting for us to know that, convener. I know from my local authority background that such processes often take a very long time indeed. I would have to go back a number of years to find a case that I was involved in, but if my memory serves me right, it may take upwards of three months. It is important that we get that information; the position needs to be checked.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Okay. We can reflect on that when we consider the regulations.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I will move us on very quickly. When we pass legislation we need to ensure that it is ECHR compliant and that it is adequate for the job at hand. My genuine concern is that, despite what has been said about the primary legislation, in practice an appeals mechanism is not on the ground, and provision for it is not contained in secondary legislation. I am not suggesting that we do not approve the regulations, but I am concerned that they are not ECHR-compliant and that we may run into difficulties as a consequence. What can you say to reassure me that I am entirely wrong?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

As a humble official, I am probably not best placed to provide that reassurance. I point you towards the assurance in the cabinet secretary’s letter of 26 February, which I hope conveys his commitment to ensuring that something is in place.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I suppose that I am not asking you as a politician. Let us say that I am asking you as an official or a lawyer. I am concerned with the legislation that is before us, not with your intentions, which both you and the cabinet secretary have made clear. I am asking whether we are in danger of passing legislation that is inadequate because arrangements are not in place. It is not ECHR-compliant because there is no appeals mechanism, irrespective of the number of appeals that may come forward.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

The best reply I can give is that the regulations that are in front of you were never intended to create or establish an appeals mechanism. That is not their purpose.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

I am basically looking for the same reassurance that Jackie Baillie is looking for. Having heard the discussion, I see no alternative but to approve the regulations. So many people are dependent on them and the timescales are such that it would be inappropriate for us to do anything else. However, I am looking for the same reassurance that we will have an appeals mechanism that will protect individuals from any disadvantage that they may experience because that mechanism will not be in place on 1 April.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Perhaps I could offer a different assurance by demonstrating that we are now working on this almost full time. For example, I spent two hours with Jim McCafferty yesterday, and we are scheduled to meet the UK Tribunals Service at the beginning of next week. We are continually engaging with COSLA and with the profession, and we have other engagements with the Ministry of Justice to explore particular avenues there. As I said earlier, now that our desks are clear of the main rump of the regulations, this issue is the absolute focus of our attention.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

Some of your colleagues have tried to make me commit to a date. The best I can do at present is repeat the ambition I expressed earlier, which is that we hope to be able to come forward with something in the summer.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I will pick up on a couple of points. First, I note that in his letter of 26 February, the cabinet secretary provides background as to discussions with the Scottish valuation appeals committee forum. He said that his officials “met representatives from the Scottish Valuation Appeals Committee Forum on April 3 2012 to discuss ... intentions and the implications for Valuation Appeals Committees”. Those discussions continued and there were several exchanges during the summer of 2012, culminating in representatives of the forum “engaging on number of detailed points and identifying a likely training need for VAC members and secretaries ‘around the time of implementation’. The cabinet secretary goes on to state: “Having reached agreement on a way to proceed, it was therefore disappointing that it was not until 22 November 2012 that the VACs first expressed a very different view of their ability or indeed willingness to take on CTR appeals.”That is important in understanding some of the background. The timing has already been discussed. As I understand it, the legislation has derived from the Scottish Government’s determination to ensure that people do not lose out as a result of the Westminster Government’s welfare reform proposals in this area. Therefore, the timing has not been of the Scottish Government’s making and it has tried to do its utmost to have everything in place, in the form of the supplementary regulations that we are considering today. It is important to bear that in mind. I understand that, as with all legislation that comes before our committees, the regulations have already been proof-tested for ECHR compliance in terms of the Parliament’s legal advisers’ role. I assume that the regulations are not an exception to that rule. I also note what has been said about the fact that the regulations do not provide an appeal mechanism per se. However, an appeal mechanism for something that the UK Government is in effect taking away is now being considered. I hope, as Mr Haynes said, that that will provide something better than what was in place before.I take on board the cabinet secretary’s letter of 26 February 2013, in which he said that he is determined to ensure that there will be a system in place as soon as possible. From what we have heard this morning, I hope that that will be a better and more timeous system. Taking into account all that has been said this morning, that is what we should rely on, and I am happy to do so. The situation is not ideal, but it is not of the Scottish Government’s making.The key point is to ensure that the vulnerable individuals whom we have talked about this morning will not see any cuts as a result of UK Government action on this issue. That is not to say that the potential 79 appeals are not important, but it is also important to take into account the practical timing of any appeals. It has been quite clearly stated that, taking an extreme hypothetical example, even if someone was to lodge an appeal on 1 April 2013 it seems highly unlikely that there would be any date when there was no alternative mechanism in place, given the processes that we know would have to be gone through at the local authority level.I speak from years of practical experience as a lawyer. We have to look at the legal position against the provisions that are in place, but also in relation to the practicalities of what is involved in invoking those provisions. That is important.Having listened to the debate, I agree that the position is not ideal. Nonetheless, for the reasons that I have stated, I am keen to ensure that the regulations come into force on the date intended, which is 18 March 2013.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I will be brief. I want to follow up the discussion that we have had, which I started with my initial questions. I agree with Alex Johnstone that there is little alternative except to approve the regulations, for the reasons that Annabelle Ewing has outlined.I remain concerned about the principle of the requirement on us to pass legislation on the basis that it is ECHR compliant, and a little disturbed that Mr Haynes is not able to give us his assurance that the Scottish Government believes that to be the case in this instance. My question is in two parts. First, is it possible for Mr Haynes to consult his colleagues and to correspond with the committee in order to provide us with the assurance that the regulations are, in the view of the Scottish Government, ECHR compliant? That will be after the fact but we are not in an ideal position—that is for sure.Secondly, if the regulations were never intended to introduce a new appeals system, does that mean that, when the appeals system is designed, further regulations will be laid before the committee in order to put that system in place?

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

On the latter point, I think that Mr Haynes has already given that commitment, but I invite him to clarify that.

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

The answer to Mr Gray’s second question is yes. We already know that we will need to bring forward regulations, under sections 80 and 81 of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, to create a different appeals mechanism. I can tell you now that it will be called a “review” rather than an “appeal”.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Thank you. Can you also answer Mr Gray’s other question about ECHR compliance?

Robin Haynes Scottish Government
link

The best answer that I can give is that we are happy to come back on that point. My initial feeling is that our response will say that, in strict legal terms, there is an appeals mechanism in place called the valuation appeals committee. However, we all know that, with the position that we are now in, in practical terms that will not work. In strict legal terms, there is an appeals mechanism.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

However, we can receive that further assurance after the fact.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Okay. If everyone is satisfied that they have had a chance to have a say thus far, I ask members whether they are content to note these instruments.Members indicated agreement.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I thank Robin Haynes and Jenny Brough for their attendance. We will have a short four-minute break—we will come back at 10 minutes to 11—to allow for a change of witnesses.10:46 Meeting suspended.

10:50 On resuming—

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Item 4 concerns passported benefits regulations. I thank the witnesses for their forbearance. I think that they were told that they would be starting a little earlier, but the last agenda item took longer than planned.We will hear oral evidence from the Scottish Government officials on the statutory instruments that have been laid in connection with making provision for access to passported benefits in light of welfare reforms. I hope that the witnesses will forgive me but, because there are so many of them, I will not introduce them all.I suggest that we deal with each instrument in turn, inviting the officials to give us an explanation of the effect of the instrument, after which members can ask any questions that they might have.Are members content with that approach?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Given that the officials are sitting in a particular order, it would be helpful if they could introduce themselves.

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Deputy Convener · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

They can do that when they speak about the instruments.

  1. 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 18
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 125
  3. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 72
  5. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
  6. 10:00 Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (Informal Meeting) Committee business · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.