First, the law as it stands means that an appeal would be against somebody’s council tax liability and therefore that should go to a valuation appeal committee. However, we are where we are.On the commencement of the scheme, if somebody wished to contest their council tax reduction assessment, they should do exactly what they would do at the moment under council tax benefit. Their first port of call should be their local authority, and the decision or determination would be reviewed by different officials within that local authority. If council tax benefit were not to be abolished and were to roll forward from 1 April, and if that individual still wished to contest their claim, they would, at present, take their appeal to Her Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service and have it heard in the social entitlement chamber. Having read some of the service’s literature on its website, I understand that it would expect to deal with an appeal in between three and eight months.First, it is highly unlikely that appeals about council tax benefit, if it were to continue, or the new council tax reduction scheme, would be made on 1 April; however, if such an appeal were to be made and council tax benefit were to be rolled forward, that appeal might not be heard until November. As a result, although we are in the position that is set out in the cabinet secretary’s letter, we would be confident that we could get something in place on a timescale that, I hope, would be better.To an extent, that position is informed by the likely number of appeals, which again is set out in the cabinet secretary’s letter. If memory serves, I think that, last year in Scotland, there were 459 appeals against council tax benefit determinations, something like 380 of which were joint appeals against council tax and housing benefit determinations. Rolling forward entitlement to a council tax reduction very much replicates entitlement to housing benefit and both will be administered by the same people. As a result, there is a very good chance that anyone who appeals against their council tax reduction will also be appealing their housing benefit and, given that such appeals will have due process through HM Courts and Tribunals Service, we are exploring the idea of local authorities adopting very much as a backstop a protocol by which if a housing benefit appeal is heard the local authority will agree to abide by that in the council tax reduction. We are exploring that and other options with Jim McCafferty and the Administrative Justice and Tribunals Council.