Our third new petition is PE1470, by Lauren King, on behalf of the Scottish Youth Parliament, on a young carers grant. Members have a note from the clerk and the SPICe briefing. I invite Lauren King to make a brief presentation of around five minutes. We will follow the same procedures as we did with the previous petitions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Young Carers Grant (PE1470)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Lauren King 13
- David Stewart Lab 9
- Anne McTaggart Lab 4
- Adam Ingram SNP 4
- Chic Brodie SNP 3
- Jackson Carlaw Con 2
- Ashleigh O’Connor-Hanlon Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Sian Hughes 1
- Kelley Temple 1
- Nairn McDonald Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Kyle Thornton 1
- Rachael McCully 1
- Toni Marie McFadyen Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Emily Shaw Scottish Youth Parliament 1
The record
43 contributionsA young carer is a child or young person who provides unpaid support to family or friends who could not manage without that help. That could be caring for a relative, partner or friend who is ill, frail or disabled or who has mental health or substance misuse problems. Young carers are, in essence, an invisible group in society, yet it is estimated that there are 100,000 young carers in Scotland, who save the economy £10.3 billion a year. However, young carers can no longer survive as an invisible group. They play a vital role in providing crucial emotional and physical support and care. On a day-to-day basis, those caring roles lead to young carers and student carers facing multiple problems, such as barriers to their education, social exclusion and health problems, and some often live in extreme poverty.I know exactly what it is like for many of those young carers. I have lived with my severely disabled brother, Ryan, for almost 10 years. I was just seven when I started caring. For many of us, feeding, bathing, changing, dealing with medication and multiple other tasks are a daily part of our lives. However, juggling caring roles, education and/or a job can be extremely difficult for a young carer, so why should they have the added burden of financial fears on top of that?In the Scottish Youth Parliament’s “Change the Picture” manifesto, 88 per cent of young people agreed that young carers in Scotland should be shown that they are appreciated members of this society and should be offered more support inside and outside education. The Scottish Government should produce a carers strategy to help to improve the lives of young people who are carers, for the benefit of every young person who cares in Scotland. Three years into the Scottish Government’s getting it right for young carers strategy, what impact has it had? The young carers strategy highlighted research showing that the majority of young carers had experienced economic deprivation. That could be due to one or no parents being able to work and the family having to rely on benefits. That means that many young carers are currently living on the bare minimum. The studies showed that young carers will experience financial hardship in their own right. Many young carers give up an income, employment prospects and pension rights, which could leave many of them stuck in poverty throughout their lives.While they are at school, a young carer may be eligible to receive education maintenance allowance, but they must maintain a high level of attendance or payments will be withdrawn. With their demanding caring role at home, many young carers have to miss school on several occasions, through no fault of their own. That means that many young carers have to do without money to help to meet the costs of their education and, sometimes, to pay their bills.Since I raised the issue with my local authority, North Lanarkshire Council has been very supportive and has started to investigate some cases of young carers’ EMA being stopped. However, that is not a permanent fixture, and something more has to be done nationally. If a young carer chooses to go on to further education at college or university, they are allowed to access a student bursary or loan, like any other student. Consequently, however, they lose their carers allowance.The maximum level of financial support that a Scotland-domiciled student can access is less than what someone on benefits gets, and it is below the relative poverty line. That means that young students with caring responsibilities do not have access to enough financial support to study and to perform their caring responsibilities together. That has led to an increased drop-out rate, more mental health problems, illness and lower academic achievement. Thirteen thousand young carers provide care for more than 50 hours a week. How can they be expected to juggle a part-time job to help with living costs, like other students do, if they already have a full-time job at home?It has been shown that the current welfare for young carers is not adequate and only leads to more difficulties for the young person. Most young carers struggle to survive with the lack of income support and with the pressures of studying and maintaining their caring responsibilities. Every day, young carers throughout Scotland are crying out for financial help, yet their voices are never heard. That is why something radical has to be done. We cannot ignore the 88 per cent of young people who say that young carers deserve better. I passionately believe that a young carers grant for carers in full-time education or under the age of 18 could make a positive change to a young carer’s life.
It must be very difficult for young people who are carers to keep their education to a reasonable standard. Is that your experience with your own caring duties?
Yes, that has been my experience. It is difficult to study with caring responsibilities. For instance, there are prelims coming up to Christmas, and that is also a time for increased illness. There can be great difficulties.I was part of a young carers forum. As part of the young carers project, I moved on to the forum, and I then did governance work for the charity Action for Children. In the young carers forum, we found that the difficulties experienced by young carers during school time are a major issue. There is leeway with homework deadlines and so on, but it is the financial concerns that worry a lot of people.
How much would you envisage the grant being? Have you made any estimates of what the budget would be for Scotland on a yearly basis?
I have not looked into how much the grant should pay; I am just proposing the petition, and that is something that the Government could decide.
As you know, we will be integrating health and social care at a local level. What involvement have you had in any discussions regarding that?
In my young carers forum we did a lot of consultation work with social work as well as with the NHS. In a lot of cases, we would analyse any surveys that came out and offer criticism, saying, for instance, that some measures would not help young people. We were moved on to the forum as more educated young people, but there are other young people who are quite deprived and are not aware of what is going on around them. They would not be able to understand some of the things that healthcare services are putting towards them, because they have not had the education, they have not had the life experience to understand them and they have had nobody to tell them about such things. In some cases, their parents cannot understand them themselves.
People such as yourselves and your colleagues in the Youth Parliament can articulate the issues so well. Have you personally been involved in any discussions about plans at a local level?
I have had a lot of discussions with young carers, who have raised the issue that they are struggling financially. A lot of young carers feel that nobody listens to them because they are young. Sometimes they are afraid to say that they are a young carer, and sometimes they do not know that they are a young carer. I raised that point in a debate with council members in North Lanarkshire. My young carers group, Action for Children, had young carers there, but the young carer who was going to ask a question about the withdrawal of EMA could not stand up and ask it—the staff member had to ask it for her. That is when I had to say, “Look, I don’t think you’re getting the issue here. The issue is that young carers are not surviving. If they are not getting to school because of their caring issues, that is not their fault. They still want to be in education and they need that money.”Shortly after that—the next day—North Lanarkshire Council started to investigate the problem. Since then, the young carers project in North Lanarkshire has referred to the council several cases of children whose money had been stopped, who were in critical financial circumstances and extreme poverty, and who relied on that money.
Thanks, Lauren, for a great presentation and for sharing your immense experience—both your personal experience and what you have learned in your role. What is your experience of the Scottish young carers services alliance?
I have not had great experience of the Scottish young carers services alliance. The North Lanarkshire young carers project is run through Action for Children, which is a different organisation.
I am certainly not trying to score any political points here. What the Scottish Government says that it will do for Scottish young carers looks really good on paper and it looks like carers will be recognised. You will know about that more than we do. Are you saying that that is not really happening on the ground?
The implementation of the young carers strategy was good at the time. I was part of the consultation work that took place at the young carers festival. When I was at the festival, I did not have a clue what I was being consulted on and I did not know that there was going to be a strategy. There needs to be greater awareness. Now that we are three years into the strategy, its effectiveness has to be reassessed. It is the case now that a lot of young carers have a voice and are saying, “Look, this isn’t right.” It is about time that something else was done.
I hope that you will champion that. You are a great ambassador for young carers.
Would any other colleagues like to ask a question?
You have not given us much of a clue for quantifying what sum of money would be associated with the grant. The EMA is about £30 per week, is that right?
Yes.
Local authorities ought to be sensitive to the issues about stopping or suspending the EMA and they should appreciate the circumstances that young carers have.On top of the EMA, what is required? I notice that the grant would really be for carers in full-time education and those under 16. Can you give us a hint about the sum of money that would be appropriate for a grant?
A lot of young carers who are in education are getting their EMA stopped. I want to move away from the EMA and focus on the need for an unpaid carer’s allowance, because young people in education are still caring. If young people are in full-time education, however, they cannot apply for a carer’s allowance. That restricts their choices. Are they meant to choose money for their family to survive, or an education to better their future? It is a tricky question to ask a young carer: “What do you want to do? Pay for your family or get an education to pay for you in later life?”I do not have a specific sum that I think that they should be paid. That is something to be worked out with the budget.
How would it relate to the benefits system? I could make an obvious political point about welfare benefits, but I would like to get your experience of how the benefits system interacts with your financial circumstances as a young carer.
I am not entirely sure how that would interact with the benefits system. My mother refuses a carer’s allowance because she believes that she should not be paid to look after her own child. However, in some circumstances, it is a parent who is disabled and children cannot survive only on the money that is coming in through benefits—there needs to be something else that supports young carers and not only allows them to have an education, but pays for their families. Most of the disabled parents cannot go out to work or, if the young person is not looking after their parent, the parent cannot work because they have to look after the other person. This is a diverse issue.
Yes, it is complicated.11:30
My sister-in-law died of breast cancer at the age of 48. She had three children. The burden of care fell on a range of people, but particularly on one of her daughters, who—as you said—stepped forward out of a sense of love and duty as much as anything else. A point that arises from your petition that is perhaps not broadly considered is that young people who assist in that way—they are doing so voluntarily to help a family member—are potentially compromising their future at a critical point in their life.I understand the issues raised in your petition, and I have a great deal of sympathy for them. I am interested to know whether you have views beyond the financial support that your petition seeks to secure. Are there other ways in which support should be provided for young people who find themselves in a caring position?
Almost every young carer’s project is run by a different authority. For example, the North and South Lanarkshire young carers’ projects are run by different organisations. Some are run by the council and others are run by external organisations. It is hard to say what else needs to happen.A lot more consultation needs to be done with affected young people because many do not know where they are meant to go and who to give their views to. That is why I represent all young carers in my constituency, and I am putting the issue across because a lot of them have found that to be a big issue.
So there is a hugely variable approach from different local authorities. Would you welcome a more proactively designed national approach, rather than a variable one?
It is a national issue. Obviously, young carers help the country hugely. It is about time that Scotland stands up and says that it supports young carers. A lot of young carers feel a bit invisible and excluded from society. Many people do not understand what they are going through—a lot of people will not even know what a young carer is. It is a big thing for a young carer to explain why they care for their family, never mind them having to deal with not knowing who to share their issues with or how to get financial support.
We are now moving on to questions. We will use the same procedure as before, so please introduce yourself when you get the mike. I will take as many questions as I can before asking Lauren to sum up briefly and answer some of the points that have been raised.
I am the MSYP for Aberdeen Central. Do you not agree that the socialisation process is impacted as much as education is? In my constituency, we have VSA—formerly known as Voluntary Service Aberdeen—which is in control of the young people’s project. The project has a socialisation process which affects the issue. Even young carers need that impact in society.
I am the MSYP for the Scottish epilepsy initiative. I agree with the campaign, but I want know how—money aside—it will be assessed. My sister and I are carers. She does not have to miss education, but I worry about the social aspects. Would benefits be assessed on income or disability?
I am the MSYP for Edinburgh Northern and Leith. A question was asked about how much money should be given to young and student carers. All carers, including young carers, who care for more than 50 hours a week are paid the equivalent of £1.70 an hour through the unpaid carer’s allowance. That unpaid carers allowance is lost when they move into full-time education. That gives you an idea of the scale of the problem that young carers and student carers face. I will give you a proposal off the top of my head. The idea of paying carers the equivalent of what we consider to be the minimum wage or the living wage should surely be considered, given that £1.70 an hour is an absolutely disgraceful amount to expect someone to live on. The minimum wage would potentially not even be good enough, but it is one proposal, given that carers who provide more than 50 hours of care currently receive £1.70 per hour.It is important not only that the gap in benefits for someone who goes into education is addressed and funded, but that the payment is at least above the minimum wage, because £1.70 an hour is just not good enough.
I am from North Ayrshire. We spoke to the members of a young carers group in the area who said that an unpaid carers allowance would be the difference between whether they had a childhood and a social life or not. Surely we must seriously address the need to give young carers the opportunity to have a social life and to be able to go out with their friends.
I am from Glasgow Southside. I was recently told that, at times in my life, I would have qualified as a young carer, which is not something that I ever took into any great account during those experiences. That highlights the point that Jackson Carlaw was getting at: we need to consider other aspects, especially in relation to letting people know that there are young carers and that there is support for them.Chic Brodie mentioned the health and social care reforms, but I have never seen any consultation with young people on any of those reforms. Public sector reforms in my local authority area of Glasgow have meant that the city council officers have decided to remove young people from planning bodies and public areas as community representatives. That is a general point about young carers and young people—public sector reform is at times acting against those voices—and it relates to the petition. We also need to look at ensuring that the voices of young carers are not lost among the general voices in Scotland.
It is important that young carers are identified. I am the MSYP for East Kilbride in South Lanarkshire, which has done a lot of work with North Lanarkshire. The councils have spoken to all the young carers—we have quite a lot of carers in these areas, and the services for young carers in North and South Lanarkshire are quite good.One thing that the carers brought up was the fact that, when young people who are getting the EMA are off sick, they can take a sick note in to school and they will still be paid the allowance. However, if they are a young carer, they cannot take in a young carers note and say, “I’m off because of this,” so they will not get paid. We need to think about that and how we can communicate properly with the schools, as it is a big problem.
That is a good point.
I am the MSYP for North Lanarkshire, and my point ties in with what Kyle Thornton said. Where will the line be drawn? Who is a young carer, and how are you going to identify that? Some carers are not being identified and are not given the recognition that they deserve, so we need to look at where the line will be drawn to identify them.
I am the MSYP for Shetland, and my question relates to the point that not all young people are in education. As someone who worked full-time and is now a student, I would like to know what Lauren King’s proposal has to do with young people who are young carers and perhaps working part-time. If they are caring for 50 hours a week, they might not be able to hold down a full-time job or even get a reasonable wage, which is relevant to the previous discussion. What are your thoughts on that?
In response to Emily Shaw’s point, the proposal would apply to young carers under the age of 18 as well as those in full-time education, because that is an issue.I will pick up on Kyle Thornton’s points. I became a carer when I was seven, but I was identified as a young carer only when I was 13 and in high school. That was mainly because a young carers project took the initiative in going into schools, seeking out young carers and doing presentations to every single first year social education class. I was identified because of that organisation and not because of a Government policy that says that we must identify every young carer.It is vital to identify every young carer as soon as possible. For instance, my primary school teachers, doctors and social workers knew about my situation, but nobody linked things together and thought “This is a young person with a disabled brother, so she must be doing something.” I empathise with Kyle Thornton’s point. It is vital to recognise young carers as quickly as possible so that they can get more support.Nairn McDonald and Ashleigh O’Connor-Hanlon talked about social inclusion, which is a huge issue for young carers. A lot of young carers feel socially excluded. That can be because of financial worries. If somebody’s parents rely on benefits, they might not have enough money to fund going out with their friends, or enough time to get a job. Just allowing for time away from caring to go out with your friends is hard enough without having to think of where to find the money to do that. We need to make life a wee bit easier for young carers because, obviously, they save the Government billions of pounds every year.
It is now over to the committee to decide on the next steps. The procedure will be the same as with the previous petitions. We clearly need to do further investigation. It certainly seems a sensible next step to write to the Scottish Government, COSLA and the Scottish young carers services alliance, but I ask my colleagues for views.
Although it is fine to write to COSLA, as I keep saying, we need to drill down to find out what is actually happening. It might be worth while to write to each of the councils, asking for a timeous reply, to find out exactly what on earth they are doing. For example, we have just heard about differences between the Lanarkshire councils.
We should ask the Scottish Government to evaluate whether it has done what it said that it would do. That evaluation might be sitting there, but we do not know. We should also write to the Princess Royal Trust for Carers, which has a young carers service, for some advice.
As there are no further suggestions, do members agree that we will continue the petition and write to the organisations that we have just referred to?Members indicated agreement.
I thank Lauren King again for her presentation and for answering the questions so well. I know that it is intimidating to give a presentation in the Scottish Parliament. We will keep you up to date with how the petition is going. I ask you and your colleagues please to stay on until we finish at 12, so that we can hear from Andrew Deans.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Mar 2013 →- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 91
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 83
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 43
- 10:00 Current Petition Petitions · 67
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.