The second new petition is PE1467 by Andrew McGowan, on behalf of the Scottish Youth Parliament, on a Scottish living wage recognition scheme. Members will have received a note from the clerk and the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing.I invite Andrew McGowan to make a short presentation of around five minutes. As with the previous petition, I and my colleagues will ask a few questions after the presentation and then I will give members of the Scottish Youth Parliament the opportunity to ask questions of their own.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Scottish Living Wage (Recognition Scheme) (PE1467)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Andrew McGowan Scottish Youth Parliament 23
- David Stewart Lab 20
- Jackson Carlaw Con 12
- Chic Brodie SNP 7
- Adam Ingram SNP 6
- Anne McTaggart Lab 3
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
- Louise Cameron Scottish Youth Parliament 2
- Lauren King Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Kelley Temple Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Leona Welsh Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Alexander Griffiths Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Callum Lucas Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Rachael McCully 1
- Adam Wilson Scottish Youth Parliament 1
- Rae Cahill Scottish Youth Parliament 1
The record
83 contributionsOver the past year, the Scottish Government and local authorities have worked together on implementing in the public sector a Scottish living wage, which has benefited thousands of low-paid workers. The Scottish Government and Parliament have a duty to every low-paid worker in Scotland, regardless of whether they are employed by the public or private sector. It is estimated that around 18 per cent of the Scottish labour market—or 390,000 workers—are being paid less than the Scottish living wage. Those workers might not be directly employed by the Government, but that does not mean that it does not have an obligation to tackle actively the problems of in-work poverty.Bar staff like me, waiters and waitresses, and those in retail and other salespeople are most likely to be paid less than the living wage. Since the age of 18, I have worked as a barman and now have nearly two years’ experience. I was being paid £5.50 an hour, which is above the current UK national minimum wage rate for my age, but the fact is that I was being discriminated against because of my age. Four new starts with no previous bar experience were employed at £6.19 an hour; despite having more experience than them and despite the fact that I had to help them with the general operation of the till system or something as trivial as changing a keg, I was still being paid less than them. There is no excuse—that is wrong.Everyone deserves to be paid equally and to be paid at least a Scottish living wage. Workers’ pay should be based on their experience, not their age, and it should reward skills and success. Everyone deserves to live rather than just survive.Families, as well as young people, need that. The level of child poverty in Scotland has risen by 2 per cent since 2010. In tough economic times, the income of a two-child family in which both parents work full time on the national minimum wage would cover only 82 per cent of basic costs. On the other hand, a lone parent on the minimum wage plus relevant top-up benefits could cover 89 per cent of those costs. In the so-called good times and bad times, working families are struggling to make ends meet. Pay freezes by both Government and private sector employers coupled with a period of inflation in the price of necessary goods and services have seen working families hit hardest with real-terms cuts to their limited incomes. We should strive to tackle the blight of child and in-work poverty, and the fight should be fought on many levels. There is no doubt in my mind that making work pay to a level that allows families to live rather than just survive is an effective weapon, if not the most important weapon that we have.You will no doubt agree that there is a strong case for a Scottish living wage. However, there is also strong demand from Scots for a recognition scheme. Our “Change the Picture” manifesto received 43,000 responses from young people, of whom 76 per cent agreed that the Scottish Government should set up a recognition scheme and 78 per cent believed that an equal minimum wage should be paid to all. In under a month, the petition secured around 2,000 signatures. That was made possible by the dedicated MSYPs who have championed the petition and who have been out in force in communities, advocating the need for a recognition scheme and collecting support and signatures.The Scottish living wage recognition scheme that we propose today would see the Scottish Government actively encouraging businesses the length and breadth of Scotland to pay their employees a living wage. Membership of this scheme—unlike membership of the United Kingdom scheme—would be free to businesses and, once signed up, they would receive the official Kitemark. Those businesses could then advertise themselves as ethical employers and, in doing so, encourage their competitors to join the scheme. Glasgow operates a similar employer recognition scheme that has attracted more than 150 businesses to date in the city alone. Our scheme would aim to create a marketplace where consumers and workers could ask whether an employer chose to pay the living wage and, if not, why not.When implemented by employers, the living wage would make an instant difference to the lives of the 400,000 low-paid private sector workers and the two thirds of children who live in poverty but who come from a home where parents are working, enabling them to truly live and not just survive.
Thank you for your presentation. Currently, the living wage is set by a foundation in London. What is its approach to recognition of whether the living wage is paid? Is there any recognition scheme at all in Scotland for the living wage?
No, not nationally. That is why we propose a Scotland-wide scheme. As I mentioned, Glasgow provides a scheme that has attracted 150 businesses in the city alone. That shows that businesses want to get involved and want to pay a living wage for which they will be rewarded and recognised.
You mentioned that the bar trade is infamous for poor pay. Catering and cleaning also have a bad reputation. The workers in those sectors are predominantly women and younger people, and young women, in particular, are discriminated against. Do you agree with that analysis?
Completely. I speak from personal experience of working in a bar where I am the only male between the ages of 18 and 25—the other seven employees are young females. I completely agree that young women are hit hardest by low pay.
I sit on the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. This week, we took evidence from Professor Joe Stiglitz, the Nobel prize winner, and he indicated the complications, particularly in the States, of the gap in incomes between those at the very top and those at the bottom. You have submitted a very dignified paper. I am surprised that you are not raging a lot more. One of the saddest things to happen in the Parliament was the departure of John Park, who is a great advocate of the living wage. I am sure that the forthcoming procurement reform bill will embrace the notion that any local or national Government procurement must consider the payment of a living wage while we work to reduce the gap between those at the top and those at the bottom.Having run businesses, I have to say that you might get employers who tell you that they are paying the living wage but who are not. You might find people getting an award who really do not deserve it. How do you propose to establish the verity of employers who say that they are paying a living wage?
The Scottish Government has the final say on whether to take the scheme forward. However, as with the UK scheme, if an employer wanted to join the scheme that we propose, they would have to sign a legally binding contract in which they would accept investigation to find out whether their employees are being paid a living wage at the current rate of £7.45 an hour.
What happens if they do not want to sign the contract?
They do not join the scheme.
First of all, the scheme has to be recognised by authorities that can apply whatever rules that you want.
I have a meeting with the Federation of Small Businesses in Scotland at which we will talk about how we could promote the scheme to small businesses, which are arguably the backbone of our economy. It is quite simple, and the scheme is completely voluntary. In Glasgow, 150 businesses feel that they should pay a living wage and are subject to checks to ensure that they are paying a living wage. They should not be able to advertise themselves as ethical employers if they are not being truthful or paying a living wage.
I am confused about how the scheme will work. You say that it will be voluntary. I have absolutely no disagreement with the intent—in fact, I support it—but I think that there will be inherent difficulties in applying a recognition scheme.
Thank you for your point.
Would it not be more sensible to legislate for a minimum wage that is equal to a living wage?
The power to do that is currently reserved to the Westminster Government. I am trying not to be party political here, but I do not feel that the Conservatives or the UK Government would seek to have a higher UK national minimum wage. I feel that the recognition scheme is something that Scotland can promote and encourage businesses to join, but Scotland does not currently have the powers to legally impose something on businesses.
Would it not be more sensible for the Scottish Parliament to acquire those powers?
That is up to the opinions—Laughter.
He never misses a trick.
Again, I am trying not to be party political. I would not like to get drawn into a battle.
That would sort out the problem, particularly with regard to the fact that there are different minimum wage rates and your feeling that young people are being discriminated against.
Putting my constitutional view to one side, I believe that the Scottish Government, the Scottish Parliament and the parties that are represented in Parliament have a duty now. This scheme is needed now and not after 2014. If there is a yes vote, by all means we can work towards a higher minimum wage. If there is a no vote, we should be prepared and have a scheme that we can promote and use to encourage businesses to pay a Scottish living wage to their employees. The figure that sticks out to me is the 390,000 workers who would benefit. Also, two thirds of children in poverty come from a working house. Irrespective of whether we become independent or stay within the United Kingdom, we have a duty as a country to those people.
All that I am pointing out is that the relevant powers are elsewhere at the moment. I understand that the Scottish Government has made a public stance of paying a living wage to every one of its direct employees.The NHS provides a living wage for every staff member, and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the Scottish Government are trying to encourage a living wage throughout the public sector. However, it is private sector employers that you have to persuade. There is a difference between persuasion and imposition through legislation. Your campaign is a good one but, as you say, it will be entirely voluntary.11:00
It is always helpful to have Adam Ingram to demonstrate the dictatorship that he would like us all to live in. Yes, we could acquire the relevant powers and then colossally disappoint the nation by not implementing any of the promises that we make. I do not think that the powers themselves would guarantee the objective that the petitioner seeks.
That is a Conservative trick.
Oh dear, oh dear, Adam—think of all those college places that you have axed.I am actually broadly sympathetic with the aims of the petition as Andrew McGowan has outlined them, so congratulations on that, but I would like to follow up on a couple of points. You say that, in Glasgow, a scheme is being operated with 150 businesses and that some kind of monitoring and checking is taking place. Who has responsibility for carrying out those checks? Is that being done by the council?
I am not sure about that.
Do you have any idea of what resource has been made available for the undertaking of that function?
We could look into that and let you know.
That would be interesting. Obviously, your primary objective is to have more people being paid the living wage. You say that the recognition scheme is potentially an access route to more people being paid it, but you would not want resource to be diverted to a recognition scheme per se—the petition is about more people getting the living wage.You mentioned that you are going to have conversations with the Federation of Small Businesses. I presume that, if those conversations were reasonably successful and the federation initiated a programme within its organisation, a bit like Glasgow City Council has done, it would probably carry out its own monitoring of whether those who have enrolled are fulfilling the criteria. More broadly, if there was a national recognition scheme, do you thereby propose that resource should be committed nationally for the infrastructure, process and personnel that would be needed to police and manage the scheme? Since we are talking largely about the private sector, would it not be better for that to arise on a voluntary basis from within the private sector, which you are meeting and seeking to persuade?
Our proposal is that the Scottish Government should do that. The meeting with the Federation of Small Businesses is to get its support and its views and opinions to feed into our proposals.
Does that mean that taxpayers would underwrite the cost of a national recognition scheme?
The Scottish Youth Parliament has estimated that two administrators would be needed. The Government would have the final say on how the scheme should be carried out. We have made a proposal, but we cannot provide the fine details or estimate the payroll. That would be up to the Scottish Government and civil servants.
Given that we are looking to private sector employers to participate more actively in the living wage, why is it preferable to have the Scottish Government use taxpayer resources to run and manage a national recognition scheme than to have private sector representative organisations manage and administer such a scheme, which would not cost the public purse anything?
I feel that the Scottish Government and Scottish Parliament have a duty and an obligation to every one of the 390,000 workers who are presently paid less than the Scottish living wage. They are the people who, arguably, elected you, Mr Carlaw. The Government and Parliament have an obligation and a duty to the people of Scotland to champion and promote the Scottish living wage and encourage employers.
I do not disagree, but is that not more likely to come from the representative organisations of the businesses that you are trying to persuade, rather than through what seems like diktat or bureaucratic intervention from Government?
Each to their own, I suppose. That is your opinion. I feel that it would be an all-Scotland and all-Government response to a problem in our society. For me, politics is about shaping the society that I want to live in. I do not want to live in a society where 390,000 people are paid below—
With respect, that is a separate argument. That is an argument for the living wage. We are talking about a recognition scheme.
Yes, and the recognition scheme would actively seek to eliminate the problems of in-work poverty. It would be Government policy and part of the Government’s agenda.
I do not disagree with that. I am just asking who should underwrite the cost of managing and administering the scheme. You think that it should be the taxpayer.
I think that it should be the Scottish Government.
The Scottish Government has no money; it gets money from the taxpayer. So you are saying that the money should come from the taxpayer.
Yes.
Now you know what it is like being on “Question Time”.As we are a bit short of time, I ask my colleagues to ask just one brief question each, because I want to allow time for the Scottish Youth Parliament to intervene.
I will be brief. I agree with most, although not all, of what Andrew McGowan said. It is important that we act now rather than wait until 2014, because it is a hugely important issue. It concerns me even more that people on apprenticeships are being paid £2.65 an hour. That is just shocking.
Thank you for that. We do not need to hear a response every time, so I will move on.
I congratulate the Scottish Youth Parliament on setting up the one fair wage campaign, and I certainly welcome the proposal for a Scottish living wage recognition scheme. Such a scheme would certainly help to concentrate employers’ minds and encourage good practice with regard to paying the living wage.Andrew, you mentioned that workers’ pay should be based on experience and not on age. I think that you said that you will meet the FSB next week—
We did not set a date, as things were too busy. We will set a date after the sitting.
Okay. When you meet the FSB, how will you respond to the point, which it will no doubt raise, that small firms are struggling as it is and that increasing wages to the living wage level of £7.45 an hour could break some small traders?
It is a valid point. I stress again that the scheme would be voluntary. It would not be imposed on employers. Employers who felt that they could not subscribe to such a scheme and commit themselves to paying the living wage at present would not have to do so. However, there are benefits. As I said at the end of my speech, when the living wage is implemented, it has an instant effect and people’s disposable income is increased. It is an economic truth that, when low-paid workers are given more money, they spend it in their communities, and arguably they spend it with small businesses. Small businesses benefit from that, and there is a great multiplier effect on employment in the community.
I have a comment on self-regulation. It was interesting to hear what Jackson Carlaw said, because clearly his Government has great experience of self-regulation, the Press Complaints Commission being one example—not.
What Government?
Now, now, colleagues. Can we concentrate on asking questions, please?
I just make an appeal. We can legislate indirectly. That is why we are to consider the procurement reform bill. We need to encourage as much effort as possible to be put into supporting what needs to be done on contractual conditions. I take Andrew McGowan’s point on the multiplier effect on society, notwithstanding some of the problems.
Thank you for that. I now throw it open for questions. I intend to take two at a time, and at the end of the questions I would like Andrew McGowan to do a brief summing-up before the committee decides what action to take next.
I would just like to make a statement. It is a wee bit of food for thought. I work as a salesperson and I get £4.10 an hour. Would any of you work for £4.10 an hour? Do you think that you would be able to survive and live your life on £4.10 an hour?
I have been there.
Thank you for that. Will people who want to ask questions raise their hands?
What is your stance on the fact that under-16s are not currently paid a national minimum wage? Would they be included in the campaign?
Sorry—will you introduce yourself and say where you are from?
I am an MSYP for Moray.
We have time for a few more questions. Perhaps people could stand up and introduce themselves for the record.
I am an MSYP for Edinburgh Northern and Leith.I want to reframe Jackson Carlaw’s point about whether the Scottish Government and taxpayers should invest in tackling in-work poverty. I think that, yes, it is worth investing in tackling in-work poverty. The fact that families and people in communities cannot survive while working is at the root of the point that the petition is trying to make. Given the points that Andrew McGowan raised about the harm caused by that, it is absolutely worth it. That is why it is important that the committee takes the petition forward.
We have time for a few more questions. Please raise your hand if you wish to ask a question. I will take a question from the woman in the back row.
I am an MSYP for North Ayrshire, but I am also a modern apprentice with my local authority. I am the youngest of the eight people who are doing my course, so I am paid £2.65 an hour whereas, because the others are aged 19 and over, they get paid more than double what I do. Can someone justify why, when you are 19, you get double what you get when you are 18?
I will take another question from the person in the back row.
I am an MSYP for Moray. What is your opinion of the Westminster campaign to lower the bottom rate of tax? Many people feel that that would do more than bringing in a living wage.
Again, we still have time for a few more questions. If people want to ask a question, this is their big chance. Did I see a hand in the second-back row?
I am an MSYP for Stirling. As has been pointed out by many others, if young people were paid more, they would invest lots of that into their local communities. Everyone here knows lots of people who are drastically underpaid and who are struggling to survive on low pay, especially when that is combined with education. People under the age of 25 are not entitled to welfare benefits, which prop up low pay for other people. For people under the age of 25, their low wages are all that they have.
I can take two more questions before I ask Andrew McGowan to sum up.
On that previous point, the Government is looking at scrapping housing benefit for under-25s. If under-25s no longer have housing benefit and have to work for such a low rate of pay, that will make things 10 times worse. How do you justify that?
I can take one more question. Is there anyone who has not asked a question who would like to ask one? I will take a question from both people on the front row, since they are next to each other.
I am an MSYP for Dumfriesshire. The petition could help not only young people but a number of people in our society. In particular, it could reduce inequalities for gender as well as age. Also, the petition could help to improve employee relations at a time when many employees in the public and private sectors are demotivated.
I am an MSYP for Glasgow Kelvin. I would just like the Scottish National Party members of the committee to stop hiding behind the procurement reform bill, which has been put forward as a buffer or as a reason for not supporting the Scottish living wage. To be honest, that is a great fallacy. The trade unions have been working extremely hard—not just in the UK but in Europe—to fight for the Scottish living wage, so we have a perfect opportunity. Of course, people say that businesses will need to sign up to it and blah-blah-blah, but that is not a problem. Why not implement the recognition scheme and give businesses the chance to do that? That would be a step forward, surely. It is a chance to give people the living wage that they deserve.
Before I ask Andrew McGowan to respond, let me just say that generally in this committee, although four members are from the SNP, we tend not to be partisan. Certainly, that has been my experience.Let me just make Andrew McGowan aware of a couple of points. First, I was in Westminster when the minimum wage legislation was put through, so I know that an inspector scheme was set up legally to enforce the new measure. Secondly, as someone who is involved in the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, which runs the Scottish Parliament, I know that we have looked carefully at living wage issues and have found that there are difficulties with putting a requirement for a living wage into procurement contracts. Alex Neil got advice from Europe on that. I am certainly not hiding behind that—personally, I am keen to make that a condition of our new contracts for catering and cleaning—but we got pretty strong internal legal advice about that. I would love that problem to disappear. There is no doubt that it is a big problem for the public sector in making conditions for future procurement. Sure, there might be some changes in legislation in Scotland, but the difficulty is to do with competition directives from Europe. I am not asking for an answer to that point. You are probably aware of the issue. Perhaps you could take my comment on board and get some other research on the matter.Would Andrew McGowan like to sum up briefly?11:15
I thank members for their views. I am proud of the Scottish Government and Scottish Parliament for the broad support that they have shown and the steps that they have taken with regard to the Scottish living wage. I reiterate that the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government have a duty to each and every one of the 390,000 low-paid workers and the two thirds of children who come from a working household but find themselves in poverty.The Scottish Government should be actively seeking to encourage businesses to pay a living wage, which will enable Scottish people to live, rather than just survive.
Thank you for answering our questions. As with the other petition, it is now up to the committee to consider the next steps. We should take further advice as we consider the petition. It would be sensible to contact the Scottish Government and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. Are there any other views?
We should ask for the views of the FSB and other employer organisations. We should also seek the views of the Scottish Trades Union Congress. Clearly, it will have a vital interest in this area.
I was going to make a similar proposal. I have been pretty impressed with the presentation that we have had from Andrew McGowan. I would have thought that, as well as seeking views, we should be asking the Government to say how such a scheme would be run and what the implications of that would be. If there is a model, and the Government is not inclined to implement it, it might be that there are other ways in which that can be progressed through the business sector.
I take your point, convener. I suggest that you read the Official Report for what has actually been said by SNP members on the living wage. On Europe, I understand the difficulty in terms of the guidance. When we write to the Scottish Government, we should say that, although the legislation says “encourage”, we need to drill down and see exactly what is happening in a European context. That should happen in the case of the procurement reform bill.
I would like to find out more information about the Glasgow scheme. Perhaps we could ask the Scottish Parliament information centre to do some research into that.
Yes. Do colleagues agree to the suggestions that have been made?Members indicated agreement.
As you can hear, Andrew, we are interested in the petition and will continue our consideration of it. We will keep you up to date with developments. Thank you for your contribution. Please stay to listen to our consideration of the other petitions.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Mar 2013 →- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 91
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 83
- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 43
- 10:00 Current Petition Petitions · 67
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.