Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Scotland’s colleges—Current finances, future challenges”

Wednesday 5 December 2012 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Evidence session 14 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Item 5 is a section 23 report entitled “Scotland’s colleges—Current finances, future challenges”. We asked for further information from the Scottish Government, particularly on the case for the regionalisation strategy. Members have the response.We previously discussed the possibility of taking evidence on the progress of college mergers, and I think that it was suggested that it would be valuable to hear from colleges that have started or which have perhaps even completed the merging process. Their experience relates to our previous item, on public body mergers.Does any member want to comment?

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I would like to make a brief comment on an issue that I have raised not only in the committee, but in conversation. I am pleased that it is now in print—it is in the second paragraph of annex A of paper 4, which is on Audit Scotland’s report. The issue has not been mentioned much. Annex A says that Audit Scotland’s report“makes clear the very significant growth in colleges’ accumulated surpluses over the period since 2006/07”.We are talking about income and expenditure reserves going up from £98.9 million to £206.4 million. We never really hear that mentioned, so I am glad that it has been. The annex states:“It is against this background that Merging partners are expected to contribute”.I have often wondered why the matter has not been raised, given that some colleges have huge reserves. Audit Scotland’s report says that they are expected to contribute. I wanted to get that on the record, because I have raised the matter time and again in speaking to constituents—obviously, constituents go to see all members about the college situation—but we do not hear it raised very often. However, some colleges have huge reserves, as the Audit Scotland report points out.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The Audit Scotland report says that some colleges have huge reserves and some are seriously struggling. I would not like to give the impression that every college has huge reserves; a few have, and one in particular has the largest percentage of the reserves.First, my understanding is that the Education and Culture Committee is about to carry out an inquiry into regionalisation. I do not know the extent of that inquiry or whether it will look at the educational or the financial benefits related to economies of scale and shared services. I am sorry that I do not know enough about what it is doing, but I am apprehensive about our committee taking the issue a lot further. I do not want to duplicate that committee’s work, so I seek the convener’s advice on the matter.Secondly, I want to return to the 24 per cent cut that is mentioned in the Auditor General’s report. To be honest, the matter has been all round the houses, including the education minister and the First Minister. For my peace of mind, and because of all the debate, I want to write to Audit Scotland to seek clarity on whether the 24 per cent cut still stands or whether the cut is greater or less than that.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

We would have to make it clear that we are asking about whether that 24 per cent cut still stands given the other monies that have been put into colleges.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is what is confusing, which is why I want clarity.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

If the Education and Culture Committee is doing work on regionalisation, I agree with Mary Scanlon’s point. I do not see why we should be doubling up on work at this stage.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

As I understand it, the Education and Culture Committee’s position is that it intends to hold an evidence session with the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning on regionalisation. However, the substantial work that it will be doing is on the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill, which is the statutory framework for that change. We previously thought that there may be some value in our taking evidence on the process of regionalisation and the degree to which the cost-benefit analysis had been done, rather than on the educational value of regionalisation. Our interest is slightly different—it is more nuanced—from that of the Education and Culture Committee. There may still be some value in such evidence as a follow-up to the public bodies mergers work that we are doing—bearing it in mind that we will return to that work because our work programme includes hearing evidence from, for example, the police, once the single police force is in place. I am in the hands of the committee, but there may be value in talking to some of the merged colleges with that emphasis rather than asking about whether regionalisation is the best thing for delivery of further education.On the 24 per cent cut to the budget, I am very happy to write again to Audit Scotland, if Ms Scanlon and Mr Dornan think that is worthwhile. I take Mr Dornan’s point that the question would be about the totality of the in-year and planned FE budget. However, I point out that after the Auditor General briefed us on the report, we asked her to provide more detail. She wrote to us and may feel that she has answered the question.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

I agree with much of what the convener has said. If we were to stray into the educational benefits—or otherwise—of college mergers, we would be straying into the Education and Culture Committee’s remit. We have completed a body of work on learning the lessons of public body mergers, so it would be worthwhile to have the colleges in, given that the Auditor General has pointed out that she is unclear about the costs and benefits of the regionalisation process. It would be worth our while to follow the costs and the public pound and to do a bit of research into that process.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I support that. Page 10 on paper 4 says:“The Edinburgh College merger business plan assumes that that merger can deliver savings of £9 million annually by 2014-15”and page 11 says that“The Edinburgh College merger is estimated to cost around £14.6 million. Of that, around £8 million will come from the SFC/College Transformation Fund.”The conclusion mentions that“the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning ... asked the SFC to make efficiency savings of £18 million in 2013-14 and £33 million in 2014-15.”The Government believes that those savings are achievable and I would go along with that.As long as we do not stray into areas that the Education and Culture Committee’s inquiry is covering, there is potential not only to learn lessons from public sector mergers but—at this early stage of regionalisation—to learn lessons that would be helpful for other colleges.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I wonder whether it is premature for us to do anything further at this point. We are aware that the Auditor General will produce a follow-up report on college mergers early next year. By doing something now, would we not be just anticipating that? Should we wait for the report?

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I was going to say that there would be merit in the work, given that we had agreed not to stray into areas that the Education and Culture Committee’s inquiry is covering. However, I also see merit in Colin Beattie’s point: would we be straying into territory that we will come to soon anyway?

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

We need to choose the most appropriate point for us to have a further look at the outturn figures. That is probably where our focus should be and, at that point, we could have colleges in to tell us about that. At the moment we are dealing with projected figures, so it is probably a wee bit early to do that work.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I suggest that we link the education work with the follow-up work on the police. There will be a point next year when we will return to public sector mergers in general. We have already agreed that we will take evidence from the police and the Scottish Police Authority on how the merger of the police forces has worked out. I suggest that we look at some of the college mergers at that point, too. They will be further down the road and there may be a clearer picture of the course and the benefits. Is that a compromise that would resolve the question about timing? Do members agree to that approach?Members indicated agreement.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Before we move into private session, I have noticed that I should have asked the committee to consider items 6 and 7 in private. For the record, do members agree to hold in private item 6 on the work programme and item 7 on the Scotland Act 2012 correspondence?Members indicated agreement. 10:28 Meeting continued in private until 10:59.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 11
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 12
  4. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 3
  5. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.