Agenda item 2 is consideration of the Scottish Government’s formal response to the committee’s report on the section 23 report “Cardiology services”. We have to decide how to take the matter forward. I open up the discussion to members.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Cardiology services”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Mary Scanlon Con 2
- Willie Coffey SNP 2
- Colin Beattie SNP 1
- Sandra White SNP 1
The record
11 contributions
link
Under “Health Practitioner and Patient Relationships” on page 5 of the response, I am not sure that the Government has answered the question adequately. Our report talked about the fact that deprived areas have fewer general practitioners than wealthier areas have. The Government has told us about various initiatives, but it has not addressed that particular issue.
That is a good point. When I read the response, I wrote down the words “Slightly flippant and dismissive”, although that may be an exaggeration. The response talks a lot about what the Government is already doing. For example, paragraph 39 states:“A healthy, balanced diet is essential for long term health.”I think we all knew that. I feel that the response does not give a direct answer to our questions but simply says, “This is what we are doing at the moment.”That said, paragraph 4 refers to the interim and final reports on evaluation of the performance of the keep well programme. I will certainly look forward to the interim report, which is due in spring 2013. Apart from that, I was, to be honest, slightly disappointed. Instead of being told about a range of things that the Government is already doing, might do or might consider doing, I would have preferred more direct answers.
I think that it is quite good that the Government has laid out what projects are on-going.However, I am concerned about the deep-end practices, which are mentioned in paragraph 10 on page 5. I was shocked to read that those are“100 general practices serving the most socio-economically deprived populations in Scotland (86 of which are in Glasgow).”That is a shocking figure. I appreciate the answers that we have been given because they bring the focus back to home. Can we get more in-depth analysis on the deep-end practices?
Without wanting to jump ahead to agenda item 6, which we have agreed to take in private, I say that it may be worth reminding ourselves that Audit Scotland has said that its next report will be on health inequalities, and we expect that it will be published within the next week. Like Ms White, I think that we should take the opportunity to return to some of those issues, including the deep-end GPs and the concentration of areas of deprivation in and around Glasgow. There may be an opportunity to return to that almost immediately—at our next meeting.
It is important to note some of the positive messages that are in the response. The covering letter from Derek Feeley reminds us about the reduction in chronic heart disease among the most deprived communities. I do not recall seeing that statistic during our journey through the study, so that message is encouraging.I agree with colleagues about GP numbers, to which we might return, as the convener mentioned. Are GPs in the right places? I am encouraged by Mr Feeley’s response, but I would like to see more progress.Convener, I draw your attention to the response to recommendation 48, which is on page 6 of paper 1. I recollect that on the day of our visit—you were in the same group as I was—more rounded support for our GPs was requested. Do you remember that? I took it from that not that we expect our GPs to be the experts on everything but that we want them to have better or wider partnership arrangements with other agencies. The Government’s response is perhaps a wee bit off the mark. I did not expect GPs to take on greater responsibilities; I want them to have access to more support services and so on.On page 7, my attention was drawn to the access to local information to support self-management—ALISS—scheme, which seems to offer hope. That is where I draw a positive from the response. Paragraph 19 says that GPs will be able to access such information and support services through ALISS, of which I was not previously aware. I am quite encouraged by that scheme, which will be integrated with GP systems that are in place. From what I have seen of the GP support services and information technology systems that are available in practices, such integration will be pretty tricky, but the message is encouraging.I still have concerns that there should be more progress on improving GP services in the most deprived communities, but I am encouraged by some of the work that is going on. Mr Feeley’s response gives us encouragement that progress is being made.
It is right to say that the response to recommendation 50, rather than that to recommendation 48, gets more to the heart of the issue that we discussed on our day in Glasgow with GPs from deep-end practices. As Mr Coffey was, I was struck by the ALISS initiative, which seems to deal with some of what the GPs talked about. I note that that initiative is being rolled out not directly by the Scottish Government but by the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland. At the risk of jumping ahead, I say that when we look at Audit Scotland’s health inequalities report, it might be worth investigating that initiative and perhaps asking the Health and Social Care Alliance to provide detailed evidence. As Mr Coffey does, I think that the initiative goes to the heart of what the GPs were saying.
I agree.
I agree with Willie Coffey that paragraph 17 drills down to answer the questions. My concern was that the ALISS programme had not been rolled out across Scotland, but I see that actions have been taken to roll it out.I will give an example—I apologise for not giving it earlier. The first sentence of paragraph 11 highlights what I said earlier. It states:“From the Scottish Government’s point of view, the Deep End initiative has been encouraging and almost certainly good value for the resources we have put into it.”We were concerned that there was not enough teamwork and support for GPs, and we do not know whether the initiative has been“almost certainly good value for the resources we have put into it.”That highlights the uncertainty. Let us be honest—there was a little criticism of the money that went into the keep well and deep-end initiatives. I wanted to put that on the record.
On how we take matters forward, one option would be to add those on-going concerns to our consideration of the Scottish Government progress reports, such as the keep well programme’s evaluation that Ms Scanlon referred to, where the interim report is due out early next year and the final report is due the following year. We could add that to the committee’s list of topics on which we keep a watching brief.Another option would be to pick up some of those points in our consideration of the health inequalities report. I take it from colleagues’ comments that some of our questions have not been completely answered in the Scottish Government’s response, but we might be able to pick up those points in our next piece of work. Do members agree?Members indicated agreement.
Do we also agree to add the report on the keep well programme to the list of progress reports that we receive?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Dec 2012 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 11
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 12
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 3
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 14
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.