link
I would like to consider two points. In the first paragraph of the second page of her letter, Patricia Ferguson discusses EU issues and raises questions about the euro and the Schengen agreement. I agree that all those areas are likely to be discussed under the work programme, as agreed, when the white paper is published. I believe that that is the right paper for that.I am a bit confused about Helen Eadie’s inquiry. The following paragraph of the letter mentions an“inquiry into this whole sorry debacle to find out the truth about who knew what and when.”That is not about European issues; it is about standards issues and what happened. The letter seems to hang on the position of the First Minister. Ms Ferguson took that position in 2003 in answering a parliamentary question by saying:“By long-standing convention, the general policy of the Scottish Executive is that it does not disclose legal advice or whether it has taken legal advice.”—Official Report, Written Answers, 21 January 2003; S1W-32797.Time has moved on since the letter was written. In answer to questions, the Lord Advocate said last week:“It was possible that the court would rule that this Parliament did not have the power to hold a referendum, in which case the issue would be academic. Following the signing of the Edinburgh agreement, there will be a lawful referendum, so that uncertainty has been removed.”—Official Report, 7 November 2012; c 13131.With the signing of the Edinburgh agreement and the coming publication of the white paper, the timing for considering the issues is absolutely fine. Therefore, I do not support the request for a move in the timescale for looking at the European issues, and I certainly do not believe that the committee should consider the other areas.