Convener, thank you very much and do not worry—I have been called a lot worse.I am grateful for the opportunity to come along to talk about an important issue that has arisen. I recognise the keen interest that the committee has in all matters European, and I watch its proceedings with some interest, having been a relatively long-serving member of the committee in the past—I say that because I joined the committee in June, was off for the months of September and October through ill health and came back in early November to find myself the longest-serving member of the committee. Things can change very quickly, as we know.On the substance of the letter that I sent, I understand that the committee has decided that it will look again at EU membership once the white paper is published, but one of the points of my letter was to ask the committee to revisit that decision and to consider looking into that issue now. A great deal of debate is raging in Scotland about the issue. The fact that the Scottish Government will come to a conclusion in a year’s time means that a very short timetable will be available to the Parliament for scrutinising the many matters that the white paper will raise. We need only look at the parliamentary timetable to see how tight it will be, given that the white paper will be published a year before the referendum takes place.I encourage the committee to consider the issue earlier, because many of the matters relating to whether Scotland would be an automatic member of the EU—and, if so, what conditions would apply—are the kinds of things that will influence people’s decisions when they come to the ballot box in 2014. If I may say so, it is incumbent on the committee to help by trying to provide some clarity, if not on what the final position would be—there are many views on that—then at least to help to frame the debate. I hope that the committee will reconsider the timing part of its decision.10:30
With regard to the first part of my letter, on how the discussion has been handled in the Parliament so far, I am acutely conscious that the Parliament currently has no mechanism for considering such matters, which might arise from time to time—although I hope not often or indeed at all. I thought long and hard about the issue before I brought it to the committee. Conflicting statements have been made and, given that the conflict is firmly embedded in the whole issue of Scotland’s membership of the EU, it seems to me that this committee, which is the committee with the most interest in the area, is the right place for an inquiry into the facts of the matter.I realise that the First Minister has referred himself for consideration under the Scottish ministerial code. However, nowhere in the structure of things does the Parliament have an opportunity to consider the matter. As a point of principle, responsibility for such consideration should rest firmly with the Parliament, and in this instance with this committee.