Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Thursday 15 November 2012 European and External Relations Committee About 09:00 Procedure 76 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Showing Patricia Ferguson only · show everyone

Patricia Ferguson’s contributions

4 contributions
Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Convener, thank you very much and do not worry—I have been called a lot worse.I am grateful for the opportunity to come along to talk about an important issue that has arisen. I recognise the keen interest that the committee has in all matters European, and I watch its proceedings with some interest, having been a relatively long-serving member of the committee in the past—I say that because I joined the committee in June, was off for the months of September and October through ill health and came back in early November to find myself the longest-serving member of the committee. Things can change very quickly, as we know.On the substance of the letter that I sent, I understand that the committee has decided that it will look again at EU membership once the white paper is published, but one of the points of my letter was to ask the committee to revisit that decision and to consider looking into that issue now. A great deal of debate is raging in Scotland about the issue. The fact that the Scottish Government will come to a conclusion in a year’s time means that a very short timetable will be available to the Parliament for scrutinising the many matters that the white paper will raise. We need only look at the parliamentary timetable to see how tight it will be, given that the white paper will be published a year before the referendum takes place.I encourage the committee to consider the issue earlier, because many of the matters relating to whether Scotland would be an automatic member of the EU—and, if so, what conditions would apply—are the kinds of things that will influence people’s decisions when they come to the ballot box in 2014. If I may say so, it is incumbent on the committee to help by trying to provide some clarity, if not on what the final position would be—there are many views on that—then at least to help to frame the debate. I hope that the committee will reconsider the timing part of its decision.10:30

With regard to the first part of my letter, on how the discussion has been handled in the Parliament so far, I am acutely conscious that the Parliament currently has no mechanism for considering such matters, which might arise from time to time—although I hope not often or indeed at all. I thought long and hard about the issue before I brought it to the committee. Conflicting statements have been made and, given that the conflict is firmly embedded in the whole issue of Scotland’s membership of the EU, it seems to me that this committee, which is the committee with the most interest in the area, is the right place for an inquiry into the facts of the matter.I realise that the First Minister has referred himself for consideration under the Scottish ministerial code. However, nowhere in the structure of things does the Parliament have an opportunity to consider the matter. As a point of principle, responsibility for such consideration should rest firmly with the Parliament, and in this instance with this committee.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I did not use the words “revisit the decision”, but I made the point that there is a great deal of uncertainty about the EU issue and I asked the committee to undertake an inquiry. That is the point that I am making.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

If it is possible, convener, I would not mind responding to some of the points that have been made.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I will address them in reverse order. I apologise to Willie Coffey that I could not be here for the entire meeting, but I am also on the Referendum (Scotland) Bill Committee, which is meeting at the same time. I have had to crave the indulgence of the convener of that committee in order to pop out.In some way, Willie Coffey made my point. The gentleman who spoke with expertise at the committee this morning obviously had a point of view, but a different point of view has been expressed by many other eminent people—both politicians and officials—who work in the area. The point that I am making is that we do not know. In my view, the more discussion and debate that we hear around the issue, the more helpful that will be.Clare Adamson also made my point to an extent, because we do not know what will be in the white paper. We do not know what it will say about relationships with the European Union or, for that matter, with any other organisation. That might not be covered in the white paper, because it will be about the law surrounding the issue rather than about further negotiations. That is important.I apologise to Roderick Campbell if my letter did not make sense. I sometimes find to my chagrin—particularly when I read back what I have said, rather than what I have written—that enthusiasm can get in the way of good structure and even good grammar.The position of the Lord Advocate is slightly more complicated than Roderick suggested, because the Lord Advocate frequently comes to the Parliament and to committee to answer questions. Not that long ago, the Lord Advocate came to a committee to explain what the Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Scotland) Bill

meant. The Lord Advocate is in a hybrid position—in part, it is a political appointment. We want to safeguard the Lord Advocate’s independence, but he has commented on the issue. I do not think that his comment clarified anything; I think that he added confusion to the situation, which is one reason why I mentioned him in my letter.It is, of course, for the committee to decide how to structure any inquiry and from whom it should take evidence. It is worth making the point that we do not know what the white paper will say on the European issues, but I am grateful for what I think was clarification of when the white paper will emerge; I now understand that it will be in the spring next year. I have to say that that is a surprise, because it is not what is being said elsewhere.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Eurozone Crisis (Impact on Scotland) Committee business · 39
  3. 09:00 “Brussels Bulletin” Committee business · 16
  4. 09:00 European Union Directives (Transposition) Committee business · 9
  5. 09:00 Work Programme Procedure · 76

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.