Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Scotland’s colleges—Current finances, future challenges”

Wednesday 24 October 2012 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 112 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

112 contributions
Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I ask everyone to check that their phones are off—he said, meaning that he should do that.Item 3 on our agenda concerns Audit Scotland’s section 23 report “Scotland’s colleges—Current finances, future challenges”. With us to give evidence on the report are Caroline Gardner, who is the Auditor General; Ronnie Nicol, who is the assistant director of performance audit in Audit Scotland; and Graeme Greenhill, who is the portfolio manager of performance audit in Audit Scotland.I invite the Auditor General to introduce the report.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The college sector has a key role in supporting sustainable economic growth in Scotland by contributing to development of the high-level skills and education that we need for that. The report aims to summarise the financial standing of Scotland’s incorporated colleges just before planned structural reforms come into effect and planned public sector spending reductions have an impact on the sector. The report is largely based on colleges’ 2010-11 financial statements, and establishes a position against which we hope to track future progress in terms of the reforms that are coming.The financial standing of the sector was generally sound in 2010-11, although the financial position of individual colleges varies widely. Most colleges operate to relatively tight margins, and there is no consistent trend in the amount of surplus or deficit that has been reported by the sector as a whole over the past few years.In total, colleges spent £771 million in 2010-11 and received income of £742 million, resulting in an overall operating deficit for the sector of £29 million, which is a small operating deficit overall. Most of the deficit was due to the City of Glasgow College, which reported an operating deficit of £34 million. That was associated with the redevelopment of the college’s campus, and there are no underlying concerns about its financial health. Looking ahead, we know that the sector faces considerable challenges. The Scottish Government revenue grant support for the sector is expected to fall to £471 million in 2014-15, which is the end of the current spending review period. That is a reduction of 24 per cent in real terms. We think that the sector may also face pressure from a range of increasing costs, such as demand for college places, buildings maintenance costs and rising energy prices.Planned structural reforms of the college sector may also create cost pressures. They have the potential to bring a more strategic approach to management of the sector, including some savings from mergers and integration, and to bring more robust planning of education provision, which will have much wider benefits. However, complex change on that scale will inevitably mean that there will be some disruption during the transition period, and there will be transitional costs for things such as redundancy payments, relocation of staff and the integration of administrative and other systems.It is too early to draw conclusions on the impact of funding reductions and how well college mergers are being managed, but we comment in the report on a number of risks that need to be managed during that period. First, the Scottish Government has set the strategic objectives of post-16 education reform, but it has not yet published a quantified assessment of the overall cost of the structural changes to the sector and the expected benefits. We think that that would help to give a clearer picture of the affordability of the process ahead.Secondly, the new regional boards have an important role in providing leadership in the merger of colleges and the establishment of federations, and in supporting the complex change management that is needed. It is therefore important that they hit the ground running so that they can play that role, and also that they establish effective links early on with community planning partnerships and enable the strategic development of course provision.The outcome agreements, which set out how colleges will contribute to the national objectives for education and learning, need to develop further. They concentrate largely on input measures, such as the volume of learning that is to be delivered, and on process measures, such as the development of plans for structural change. They need to be taken further to look at the impact that the college sector should have on the wider education and learning agenda.The report makes a number of recommendations to the Scottish Government, the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council and colleges about what needs to be done to implement the reforms successfully.I will stop there. As always, the team and I are happy to answer questions from the committee.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

One of the report’s key findings, to which you referred, is that“The overall financial standing of the college sector in 2010/11 was generally sound.”That has not always been the case in the past. The report makes it clear that the financial standing of individual colleges varies, but it does not seem to ring any alarm bells, and that also has not always been the case in the past. Is it fair to say that the report’s finding on where the college sector stands is generally positive and is that the sector is in a good place?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is certainly true that progress has been made in the past few years. You are right that some colleges have faced significant financial problems in the past. From the information that is available in their financial statements and from discussions with the funding council, none appears to be in that position at the moment.Exhibit 4, which is on page 11, sets out the operating position for each college. Most colleges delivered an operating surplus in 2010-11. Among most of those that ended with an operating deficit, the numbers were very small. The overall deficit is more than accounted for by the costs of redevelopment at the City of Glasgow College, as I said in my opening statement.Progress has been made, but the operating margins are tight. Given the pressures that we know are coming from rising costs, reduced central Government funding and the short-term costs of mergers, there are challenges that need to be managed carefully for the sector as a whole and for individual colleges.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

The report makes it clear that, although the starting point is good, it is fragile. The report was produced in the context of significant change being planned in the sector through the creation of regional boards and, associated with that, a number of college mergers, which is reducing the number of colleges.It is worrying that Audit Scotland says in paragraph 58—you repeated it in your opening remarks— that“The Scottish Government has not yet published a quantified assessment of the overall costs of the reform of the college sector and the expected benefits.”Paragraph 64 says that“outcome agreements ... concentrate on input measures ... and process”and do not indicate how the Scottish Government expects the changes in the college sector to produce a greater contribution to employability and the development of an educated and skilled workforce. Is it fair to say that colleges are in a good place, but are entering a period of significant change, and that we lack the rationale, the justification and the metrics for and the expected outcomes from that change?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We think that it is now time for exactly those specific measures and estimates of costs and benefits to be put in place. Because colleges operate to tight margins, small increases in costs or reductions in their income will have a significant impact on them.More widely, colleges play an important role in the objective of achieving sustainable economic growth. We know that the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training is rising. The economy as a whole needs a change in the direction of skills development—for example, to achieve the aim of having a low-carbon economy, we need new skills to come from the college sector. More detailed planning for what that means through outcome agreements and better estimating of the costs and benefits of the transition are needed to manage the risks of squaring the circle.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

We have had quite a significant review—the Griggs review—and we are planning legislation to create the regional boards. Are you saying that we have gone from the review to the legislation without going through the intermediate stage of working out exactly why we are changing the sector and what we expect that change to achieve?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The high-level objectives are clear. What are not clear are the detailed estimates of the costs and benefits of the transition and the detailed outcome measures in the outcome agreements for what the college sector and individual colleges should be contributing. The colleges need that information to be able to take the next step.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

On page 3, you state:“Government revenue grant support to colleges is likely to fall from £545 million in 2011/12 to £471 million in 2014/15.”Can you confirm that that is still an accurate reflection of the budget for Scotland’s colleges?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Yes, we are confident that those figures stand.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

Thanks for that. Yesterday, at the Education and Culture Committee, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning said:“The Audit Scotland report is accurate with regard to the published spending review figures but not with regard to the actual figures for spend.”—Official Report, Education and Culture Committee, 23 October 2012; c 1554.Are you able to comment on the cabinet secretary’s comments?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Certainly. The broad picture is that our figures for 2011-12 and 2014-15 are correct; therefore, the reduction over that period is correct. However, since the spending review there have been a number of one-off allocations in individual financial years for specific purposes, which amount to the £67.5 million that was referred to by the cabinet secretaryGraeme Greenhill can give you more detail on that.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The cabinet secretary said yesterday that college finances can be quite complex, and I would not disagree with that statement.As we say in the report, the September 2011 spending review indicated that the Scottish funding council’s revenue funding for colleges would decrease from £545 million in 2011-12 to £471 million in 2014-15. However, as the cabinet secretary said, since the September 2011 spending review, additional money has been given to colleges. For example, in 2011-12, an extra £11 million was allocated to the funding council to give to colleges in respect of college bursaries and additional places. A further budget addition that took effect for 2012-13 was the £15 million college transformation fund, which was to help colleges to begin to adapt to the structural change.The September 2012 spending review gave another £17 million to colleges in 2013-14, again through the funding council to support bursaries and college places, and just a couple of weeks ago there were further budget additions relating to 2012-13. Those added another £11.4 million to the funding council’s budget for colleges and £13.1 million to the budget for Skills Development Scotland to help to fund short employability courses. The idea is that those courses will be commissioned from colleges and that money will find its way to colleges.An additional £11 million in 2011-12, £39.5 million in 2012-13 and £17 million in 2013-14 add up to the £67.5 million that Mike Russell referred to, as Caroline Gardner just said. That is one-off funding, however, and there has been no addition to the 2014-15 budget. Therefore, the estimated budget of £470.7 million for 2014-15, as set out in the September 2011 spending review, remains the current budget for that year.11:30

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

I take that on board. Although additional moneys have been allocated to particular years, was the cabinet secretary incorrect to say that your figures were not accurate? You have already stated that you believe that your figures are still correct. Will you confirm that you still believe that the reduction in college funding will be 24 per cent in real terms, as stated in the report?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We are confident that the difference between the 2011-12 and 2014-15 figures, adjusted for inflation, is a 24 per cent reduction in real terms. There are a number of movements in the financial years in between, as Graeme Greenhill has outlined, mainly for special, one-off purposes, which are not at this stage committed in any way to being included from 2014-15 onwards. We are confident that our reduction is correct.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I want to return to Caroline Gardner’s earlier answer to the convener on the level of financial and outcomes detail. Did I understand the Auditor General correctly? She described the high-level strategy, for want of a better term, as clear—indeed, that is reflected in the report and in other areas—but said that the bit that is lacking is that neither colleges nor the regional structures yet have numbers, budget details or outcome agreements, again for want of a better expression.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is absolutely correct in terms of the outcome agreements for the contributions that they are each intended to make to the high-level national objectives. The part of the jigsaw that is not yet in place is the Scottish Government’s assessment of the costs and benefits of the structural reform, the creation of the regional boards, and the mergers or federations of colleges. There will almost certainly be savings in the medium term as well as improvements in planning, but we know that there will be a cost in getting from where we are now to where we expect to be in the future as a result of redundancies and relocations, for example. We do not yet know the estimated cost of that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is helpful.Do the proposed regions yet know their split of the budget and the figures that Graeme Greenhill has just given in respect of their budget over the next few years? Do they know even in indicative terms what the numbers will be?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that they are planning on the assumption that their broad shares of the budget will remain as they currently are and therefore that the reductions and, indeed, the additional funding that is available for the years in between will be allocated on that basis. However, I will ask Graeme Greenhill to give members a bit more information about that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

When you said “they”, did you mean the individual colleges? We do not have the regional structures yet.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The funding goes from the Scottish Government to colleges via the Scottish funding council, and it will be planning now on the basis of the spending review forecasts and the additional amounts of funding that have been announced for the years in between, up to 2013-14. I ask Graeme Greenhill to talk members through the detail of what people know at the board and college levels.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The report mentions the development of outcome agreements for the colleges. As part of the process for agreeing the first round of outcome agreements, the funding council has been agreeing budgets for 2012-13 with the regions. Therefore, all the regions know how much money is going to them for 2012-13.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So are the regional boards there already?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

No. The regional boards do not technically exist.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But surely money cannot be allocated to something that does not technically exist. Or perhaps it can be.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

Em—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I am sorry. That is a very unfair question, but it strikes me that it is a bit difficult to give money to something that does not exist.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

By definition, the regions do not exist. Money has been allocated at a regional level, but in practice the individual colleges that make up each region know how much money they are getting for 2012-13.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Your overall finding was that there is a lack of clarity around what the regional costs will be and around the costs of implementing what will be, by any standard, enormous change in the college sector. The colleges may know the figure for next year, but do they know it for the spending review period? What element of those costs will be for regionalisation? What number and percentage are attached to the costs of regionalisation?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is what we are not clear about. There are two elements: the costs of regionalisation itself and, potentially much more significant, the costs of bringing together colleges in mergers or federations. For example, we know from recent press reports that the cost of the Edinburgh colleges merger was expected to be about £10 million but has actually been about £17 million. People are confident that there will be savings as well as improvements in planning in the longer term once that process has been gone through, but there is a significant cost in the short term, especially against the background of falling resources over the spending review period.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

At what level of management are the changes being driven? I appreciate that the Scottish Government has said what it wants to achieve, but who at a practical level will actually deliver these enormous changes?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that that varies across the different regions of Scotland, depending on how far ahead individual colleges are with their merger proposals and depending on the specific circumstances that they face. Perhaps Ronnie Nicol can provide a bit more detail on that point.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

In the report, we were at pains, as the Government has been, to respect the fact that the legislation is still to go through the parliamentary process. However, individuals have been appointed for the proposed new regions to start the planning of the arrangements to manage the transition. Our report was trying to get across that this will be quite a complex exercise that will take place over a period of time, so effective planning needs to be put in place. People need to be clear about objectives and how those very specific objectives will relate to the broad strategic objectives that have been outlined in the consultation documents. Those are things that need to be put in place as quickly as possible in order to navigate through this very complex period.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is very fair. However, your example of the Edinburgh colleges merger and your earlier report into the mergers of public bodies more generally across Scotland tend to illustrate that, yes, savings can be achieved in the longer term, but in the short term inevitably, or usually, the costs have been higher than projected. At the moment, we do not have even projected costs on the mergers. You do not have them and nor has the Parliament.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The Scottish Government has not set out the expected costs and benefits of the structural reform programme, which is part of its wider objectives and aims for this sector in the education and learning policy area.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

The point that I am driving at is that your previous recommendations to the Public Audit Committee have been very clear about the need for such figures to be available at the earliest possible date. However, we are just about to have this change and we still do not have the projections.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I have recommended that the Government should produce them. We do not have them.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Point taken. I have one final question. Paragraph 41 of the report contains a very interesting sentence, which begins:“While the SFC does not record the numbers of people applying to attend college, the volume of learning activity”.I was staggered by that. Do we not actually know how many people apply and do not get in?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There are not national figures for that. The matter has clearly been of some political and media interest over the past few months. Graeme Greenhill may be able to give a more up-to-date picture of where we are with that.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

I imagine that individual colleges will have information about demand for their classes, but that does not prevent the same person from applying to two or three colleges at the same time. As Caroline Gardner said, there is no national picture of the number of people applying for college places.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

It is very difficult to justify a change for whatever reason if you do not know the numbers that would justify that change. I take the point that a person might apply to three colleges, but the system should be clever enough to work that one out. If Tavish Scott applies to three different colleges, his name should ping up three times in the statistics. Does the Government—it does not matter who is in government—not just collect the statistics that would help it to make proper decisions about the level of demand?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

They are not collected by either the Scottish Government or the Scottish funding council, which might be a more appropriate place for the collection to happen given the council’s responsibilities for providing funding to colleges and in future to the regional boards.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Have you reached a view on whether the collection of those statistics would help both the funding council and us in Parliament to make a judgment on these matters?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

My view is that more information on the right things is always useful and that that is one of the things that should be picked up in the outcome agreements that are being put together.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am looking at paragraphs 25 and 30. Obviously, it is good that colleges have a surplus, but public funds should be used for a purpose. The report mentions that it is good practice for colleges to have a certain amount of prudential reserves and that the funding council says that those reserves should be enough for 60 days. What proportion of the total surplus of £206 million is project related and how much is earmarked for the prudential reserves?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am not sure that we have a breakdown of the figures for 2010-11, although I will ask Graeme Greenhill to confirm that. The situation varies a lot between colleges. Some colleges that are expecting significant change and merger are deliberately building up surpluses to use for that purpose.Can we be more specific than that, Graeme?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

I do not think that I can be more specific on that.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The report has been put together from the colleges’ financial statements for the most recent audited financial year. The most recent financial year finished at the end of July, and we are considering how to use that information to provide a richer or more nuanced picture early in 2013 to support the Parliament’s consideration of the wider reform agenda.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Paragraph 28, on page 12, deals with pension reserves. These days, pension funds seem to be a bit of a sword of Damocles hanging over everybody’s head. The report talks about a deficit of £60 million. There are points about benefits to the fund through the change from the retail prices index to the consumer prices index and increased contributions, yet the deficit is still increasing, for a number of reasons that are set out in the report. How long can the deficit continue to increase before the colleges have to address it?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

As with all public sector pension schemes, that is a long-term problem, but a real one. For all pension schemes in which there is a fund—as with the colleges’ pension scheme—at some point the liabilities will have to be brought back into line with the assets, which will require adjustments to contribution levels from the employers and the employees or changes to the retirement age or to other variables in the mix. Obviously, the investment performance of the funds is important.We do not think that the problem is more significant for colleges than it is for other public sector pension funds, but the issue needs to be taken into account in considering long-term sustainability. There is no avoiding those long-term liabilities.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have a supplementary question on pensions. It was not only the figure of £60 million that caused me concern, but the fact that the figure was £10 million in 2007, so there has been a sixfold increase in as many years. The issue is not about the ballpark figure; it is about the fact that the figure has increased sixfold. Does that cause you concern for colleges?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is obviously a concern. However, an odd characteristic of the sector is that, because the pension schemes are funded, there has been a significant impact on the assets that they have invested to meet future liabilities since 2007 because of the global financial crisis and the impact since then on stock markets. It is a serious problem in the short term that will have to be managed over the long term, no matter what. However, in a sense, simply because there are funds there to be invested, the issue looks more significant than it would if it were an unfunded pension scheme, as some of the other large, and much larger, pension schemes in the public sector are.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Given that it is a funded pension scheme, as the local government one is, where does the money come from to make up the deficit and the pay-outs that are required and will increasingly be required given the economies of scale and efficiency savings that we hope will result from the mergers?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a complex and long-term question. A number of factors come into play and will have to be managed over that period, including the level of contributions by employers and employees, the investment performance of the funds, the age of retirement of scheme members and the way in which all that comes together to ensure that, as the liabilities fall due, they can be afforded. It is important to put it on the record that the liabilities will not ever fall due on one day. They have a long lifetime of 40 years or more, as current members of the scheme head towards retirement and start to become entitled to their benefits, and that is the timescale over which the liabilities must be managed.However, you are absolutely right that it is harder to do that in the current climate in which market returns are very low and public sector spending cuts are affecting the budgets of colleges and the take-home pay of scheme members.11:45

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

My next question is a supplementary to Mark Griffin and Tavish Scott’s questions. I had the honour of being at the Education and Culture Committee, so I congratulate Mr Greenhill on explaining the figures. Professor Jeremy Peat looked at the figures two or three times and said that he could not understand them, and two college principals said that there was a downward trend and that they could not understand them. In addition, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning has said that the figures are complex.Mr Greenhill mentioned the different pots of funding alongside the cuts. My understanding from grappling with the figures is that the main cut has been to the teaching grant. Did you drill down to that level? My understanding is that the additional moneys have been ring fenced for student support and so on. Am I right in saying that the front-line teaching grant has borne the brunt of the cuts?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have not yet fully drilled down to that level. Graeme Greenhill had the advantage—or disadvantage, depending on how you look at it—of spending yesterday evening following up on the Education and Culture Committee discussion to ensure that we understood the movements. We can provide you with a note on that. However, we have to do more work to look at the implications for the different elements of support to colleges.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The latter half of paragraph 42 gives me serious cause for concern. It refers to evidence that Scotland’s Colleges gave to the Education and Culture Committee:“It said that based on current cost models and configurations, if colleges ‘took on one in four’”—only one in four—“16–19 year olds not in employment, education or training, and continued to service 18–24 year olds to the same level, there would be no funded provision left for older learners who make up over half of learners over 16 years of age’”.Having spent 20 years lecturing in economics in further and higher education before I became a member of the Parliament, I am passionate about people being given a second chance at an older age when their jobs or careers have not worked out. You are saying that the Government’s commitment to 16 to 18-year-olds and the colleges’ commitment to service 18 to 24-year-olds mean that mature students have not got a chance.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We cannot give you the detailed figures to answer the first part of your question, but it is clear that, against the background of funding reductions over the spending review period and the increasing demand that comes as a consequence of both the number of younger people who are not in employment or training and the need to reskill older workers to meet the demands of the economy that we want to have in future, there is a real pinch. That is one reason why we think that it is so important that the Government should set out the expected costs and benefits of the structural reform and make progress on the outcome agreements that will help to pin down exactly which students will be able to receive support from the sector.Ronnie Nicol may want to add to my comments.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

The part of the paragraph to which Mary Scanlon refers is a direct quotation from evidence by Scotland’s Colleges to the Education and Culture Committee, which explains its view on the consequences of the cuts. Our concern is to ensure that the range of policy objectives that exist across the structural changes and the educational objectives, such as the commitment on 16 to 19-year-old students, are looked at and managed in the round. The outcome agreements are an obvious place where that can happen. The rationing of reduced money must be organised holistically across the range of objectives.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The main objectives are for 16 to 24-year-olds. My concern is the displacement of, the lack of opportunities for and the increased inequalities faced by older learners.We recently looked at the lessons learned from the public sector mergers. It seemed to be a good idea to look at that in the context of, as Tavish Scott said, moving forward to college mergers. In a joined-up Scotland, I would have hoped that the lessons learned in your Audit Scotland report would be implemented. The previous Audit Scotland report on mergers said that merging bodies did not know what success would look like or what benefits could be expected from the merger. They did not know what service improvements could be expected and, as Tavish Scott said, they could not confirm costs or savings. There was“inadequate analysis of savings and efficiencies”and they did not know which efficiency savings that resulted from the merger would have happened anyway. As Colin Beattie said, there was very little, if any, baseline information in the first year of operation on the unit costs, staffing and quality of the service.I was listening carefully to the answer that you gave to Tavish Scott and I wanted you to extend it to look at whether those critical lessons have been learned. Are you confident that, although the structural reform is not in place at the moment, it will be put in place and that the difficulties faced by previous mergers and savings expected but not realised mean that the colleges have learned lessons and that the mergers will deliver?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

When my report was published, the Scottish Government accepted the recommendation and it has agreed to publish the expected costs and benefits of the structural reform, specifically the mergers. I very much hope that that will take account of the range of information that we think is needed and the lessons learned from that report. We look forward to seeing it.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Will it include the outcomes and the opportunities for students?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Absolutely. All those things are needed to manage the costs of getting to where we need to be and ensuring that the expected benefits are achieved in practice.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I am sure that the commitment is welcome, but is it fair to say that those criteria that your previous report found to be missing in previous public sector mergers are all missing in this case as well?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

They are not available at this stage, yes.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I thank Graeme Greenhill in particular for clarifying the comments that the cabinet secretary made yesterday and putting it on the record that there was absolutely no intention of confusing or misleading the committee, which I suspect is what Mr Griffin was trying to say.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

We should not make assumptions about what committee colleagues have in mind.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Okay, but I am confident that that is what Mr Griffin was trying to imply.I have a supplementary question to Tavish Scott’s point about recording the number of people who apply to colleges. Do you agree that this period of time during the mergers and when new systems are being put in place would be a good opportunity to begin to do that? I agree that it would be very important information for us.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The mergers provide an opportunity to put systems in place to collect those figures on a national basis, but they are also important for thinking about the outcome agreements that the new colleges and college boards should be signing up to.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Absolutely.Mary Scanlon talked about the previous Audit Scotland report, “Learning the lessons of public body mergers”. It mentions previous college mergers. Has any work been done on the financial benefits or otherwise of previous college mergers, and has it helped Audit Scotland to write this report?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have not done that. I am not sure whether the Scottish funding council has done that, so I ask Ronnie Nicol to come in on that question.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

There has been developing learning from the recent mergers. We have done a little bit of a case study and we know that the City of Glasgow College has engaged with colleagues about its experience.The Scottish funding council recently issued guidance on mergers that takes account of our generic report on mergers. A number of things have been put in place recently to support the merger process.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I have listened to all the different viewpoints. The convener said at the beginning of this evidence-taking session that colleges are in a good place. Is that correct? I think that the Auditor General and the convener said those very words.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The college sector as a whole has come a long way since the problems in the first decade of the century. The margins to which the colleges are operating are tight given the pressures that they face in future.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

However, they are in a good place—that is what has been said. I was a bit confused when the convener came out and said that, but that is not the question that I want to ask.I am interested in the recommendations that you made for the future strategic planning—in particular, the last recommendation in the second column on page 4 of the report, which concerns ensuring that colleges work with local businesses and the local community. Will the regional structure that is going to come about help to facilitate that? I am interested in the reference to community planning partners. It seems to me that that recommendation is not simply about education but involves everyone in the different regions.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is certainly one of the objectives that the Scottish Government has set for structural reform. It seems to us that the mergers could well help to achieve it.At the moment, the pattern of colleges tends to reflect the fact that responsibility for them sat with local authorities until 10 years or so ago. Therefore, patterns of provision are still a bit historical and, to an extent, colleges have been competing with each other for students.Bringing them together through the regional boards and, beneath that, the mergers and federations of colleges will allow a more strategic approach to determining what courses are needed where and how they meet the needs of young people, older learners, industry and business locally. It is a real opportunity in the structural reform. We would like that to be set out as part of the costs and benefits that are expected and the individual outcome agreements between the funding council and the colleges.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I agree that it is important that those plans are set out as soon as possible.The last recommendation says that colleges should “explore opportunities to reduce their costs”.Earlier, we took evidence from the ROS about its big IT system. Does that recommendation concern individual colleges pooling their resources for IT systems, perhaps? I just wonder what you mean by colleges exploring opportunities to save money.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is a range of ways in which it might be possible to reduce costs. Again, that is one of the expected benefits that the Scottish Government has set out for its reform programme. It could mean sharing IT systems or shared services for finance staff, human resources staff and the other background services that most colleges have. It might mean rationalising provision and ensuring that a college’s courses for a particular type of subject are in one place, which might bring opportunities for savings.The key point for us is that, without clarity about how the outcome agreements will work in practice, we simply do not know what the expected savings might be and how far they will offset the costs in the long term.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

So that Sandra White is clear, I point out that my initial remarks were that the colleges were in a financially sound place in 2010-11 and that that is a good place to be. However, if their income is reduced by 24 per cent in real terms, they are unlikely to be in a good place by 2013-14.We had some discussion about what the colleges count. One thing that they count is the number of students that they have. The report refers to a figure of 300,000 students, although I appreciate that that is not 300,000 full-time students. The witnesses said that Audit Scotland’s figure of a 24 per cent real-terms reduction in the revenue budget by 2013-14 was correct. If that is the case, is it remotely conceivable that our colleges will be providing learning opportunities for 300,000 students by 2013-14?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is a real challenge. The 300,000 figure for students needs unpacking a bit as well. Fewer part-time students and more full-time students are coming through colleges. If you would like to know more about that, Graeme Greenhill could take you through the technicalities.It will certainly be a challenge to meet the demand that exists, which may increase in future as we try to shift to a low-carbon economy and try to get young people into meaningful training against a background of significant funding reductions. It is a difficult circle to square.12:00

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

The other complexity is the difference between revenue and capital funding, which we have not talked about. Paragraph 46 states:“The reductions in public sector capital funding available to colleges over the next three years mean that colleges are unlikely to be able to sustain the same level of new-build campuses”.In the past, the cabinet secretary—indeed, the First Minister—has said that if we look at college funding in the round, including both revenue and capital funding, we will see that there is no reduction in the budgets. However, paragraph 46 combined with the 24 per cent reduction in revenue funding must surely mean that, in the round, we expect a reduction in funding for the college sector over the next few years. Is that fair?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

A reduction in total funding for the college sector, both revenue and capital, is planned between 2011-12 and 2014-15. To make sure that I do not confuse the issue by getting the figures wrong, I ask Graeme Greenhill to clarify what that reduction is.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The budget figures that we have at the moment for capital funding for colleges—that is, funding coming from the funding council—show that such funding is expected to fall from £45 million in 2011-12 to £27 million in 2014-15. The Scottish Government’s written evidence to the Education and Culture Committee yesterday spoke about investment—it is important to draw a distinction between investment and funding—increasing from £590 million in 2011-12 to £655 million, I think, in 2014-15. The 2011-12 figure is the combined capital and revenue funding coming from the funding council to colleges, whereas the 2014-15 figure includes £157 million of investment that the private sector plans to put into college estates development work. Basically, college campuses will be funded through the non-profit-distributing model. That is why the overall picture of investment—

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Sorry, let us be clear. The second figure includes the capital value of a project that will be delivered by a private finance initiative contract.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

Yes, but it is no longer called PFI; it is called the non-profit-distributing model. For example, a big new campus is planned for City of Glasgow College and a procurement exercise is currently under way but it is being funded through the non-profit-distributing model—

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Which Mr Swinney has said is a member of the PFI family. Does that figure include the whole asset value of that project?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

It is the planned investment for the year 2014-15.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I just want to get this absolutely right in my thick brain. In comparing those figures, I would not be comparing like with like, would I? That money is very different from the traditional forms of capital procurement that you described in relation to the 2010-11 figure—is that true?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The funding council is giving colleges capital investment money—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But not through the Scottish Futures Trust at the moment or anything like that.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

No. The money is coming from the funding council.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

In that sense, it is a Government grant coming through the funding council to colleges for capital expenditure. However, what you describe happening in the future is not a Government grant but a Scottish Futures Trust private sector investment in college campuses, which is a different form of investment altogether.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is worth being clear that the £157 million element of the total figure that relates to NPD will deliver improved infrastructure for colleges, which is important, and will also have a revenue consequence for capital budgets—colleges will have to meet the capital cost of that on a continuing basis once the investment has been made.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Is the revenue implication of the Scottish Futures Trust investment clear and detailed?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Not at this stage.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So that is something else we do not know.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

These figures were discussed only in the past few days as part of the submission that was examined at the Education and Culture Committee.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have been able to reconcile the £655 million with the figures in our report and demonstrate how they relate to each other. We do not have any detail about the revenue consequences of the £157 million, but there will be consequences.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We could provide a note on the issue, convener, if that was helpful. I realise that it is complicated.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Mr Greenhill has offered to provide further detail to the committee. I think that that would be helpful, given that everyone seems to have acknowledged that the finances are complex.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I was going to ask about capital funding and so on, convener, but the issue was raised in the previous round of questioning. Instead, I will focus on an aspect that is covered in the report, rather than on matters that are not but which we hope will be covered in future reports. On page 10 of the report, you say:“The overall financial standing of the college sector ... was generally sound”and refer to“accumulated surpluses totalling £206 million and ... a combined £205 million of cash and cash equivalents”.My simple question is whether those are two separate amounts, which means that there is a total of £411 million.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

No.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I do not think that you can simply add those figures together, but I will ask Graeme Greenhill to take you through the detail of it.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

The income and expenditure reserve is a reflection of colleges’ ability to generate year-on-year surpluses over a number of years. That is different from cash and cash equivalents, which basically comprise free cash for paying on-going running costs such as monthly salary bills, investment money and so on. Some of that cash will undoubtedly have been generated through the accumulation of year-on-year surpluses, but you cannot really add the two together, as that would be double counting.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

So the real figure is £206 million.The figure is mentioned again in paragraph 26, in which you say that the asset has doubled since 2006-07. I think that that is testament to the college sector’s good performance over a number of years. Indeed, I probably read the previous report about 2006-07 as a member of the previous Audit Committee.I think that a really good story is hiding in that little paragraph. What is principally responsible for the doubling of the college sector’s cash assets in that short space of time?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

Again, we probably need to make a distinction between the income and expenditure reserve and the cash reserve. The former has been accumulated over a number of years through colleges’ ability to deliver year-on-year surpluses, and exhibit 5 on page 12 shows how much of that reserve belongs to each college. How colleges have individually been able to generate that reserve is probably best answered by the colleges themselves, but one might ask how, for example, Aberdeen College has managed to build up a healthy income and expenditure reserve through surpluses over a number of years. It is a big college, so there might have been economies of scale or it might have benefited from the oil industry by developing training courses in oil-related subjects that are delivered and paid for by the private sector. How those reserves have been built up probably differs from college to college, and I think that the colleges themselves are better equipped than I am to explain how they reached that position.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

That is very interesting.I recall hearing at a previous meeting that the college sector’s cash reserves are healthy. However, now that we are moving into the merger process, where will these reserves and assets go? Presumably they will become the cash reserves for the new merged body, but to what purpose will they be put in future? I have to say that I see the reserves accumulating year on year, and it is a great story that should be commended. Given the current economic climate and given that budgets from the United Kingdom to the Scottish Government are being cut—I realise that we can argue about that all day—I think that this shows a healthy side to the story of college performance over a number of years, and I am keen to find out how the money will be deployed in the future that we all face.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Some of the reserve will have been built up deliberately with the aim of enabling either mergers or the redevelopment of college campuses that might deliver savings and other benefits in future. Part of it is planned; it is not like a piggy bank into which people put money year after year. Very often reserves are built up with a specific purpose in mind, and one reason why we think it important for the Scottish Government to set out the expected costs and benefits of the structural reform is that the reserves are one source of meeting the costs of it.The funding council has put a lot of effort into ensuring the financial sustainability of colleges over the period. You will recall discussions about individual colleges that were struggling seven to 10 years ago, and we are not seeing that sort of thing to the same extent now. We would expect the reserves that are being built up to transfer to the new merged colleges or to be available to the federations, if that is the preferred approach, but that is not yet clear from the way in which regional boards will carry out their responsibilities. The situation may vary from place to place.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I thank our Audit Scotland colleagues for their evidence. We look forward to Mr Greenhill’s elucidation of further education sector finance. It should be a treat.We will now move into private session. I invite the Audit Scotland witnesses to remain to give evidence and ask members of the press and public to leave.12:11 Meeting continued in private until 12:33.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 99
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 112

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.