2. To ask the Scottish Government when the Borders railway will be operational. (S4T-00093)
Official Report · Chamber
Borders Railway
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Keith Brown SNP 6
- Christine Grahame SNP 3
- John Lamont Con 1
- Claudia Beamish Lab 1
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
The record
12 contributions2. To ask the Scottish Government when the Borders railway will be operational. (S4T-00093)
link
We expect to make an announcement about the Borders railway shortly, once the commercial terms of the contract between the Scottish ministers and Network Rail have been finalised.
The tone of the minister’s answer is very different from the negativity of the Conservatives and in particular Mr Lamont, who is forever going on about the Borders railway. I suppose that he would have a different tune if the line went through his constituency. In any event, that is not our fault—it was the Liberals and the Labour Party who decided the route.
However, I will raise a positive note, as I am a positive person. Would the minister be willing to consider—even if it affected prices and time—cross-party and local campaigners’ views on accommodating charter trains, given their potential additional economic benefit to the Borders? Will he also give me a further update on journey times?
However, I will raise a positive note, as I am a positive person. Would the minister be willing to consider—even if it affected prices and time—cross-party and local campaigners’ views on accommodating charter trains, given their potential additional economic benefit to the Borders? Will he also give me a further update on journey times?
link
As the member knows, I had a productive meeting with her, Claudia Beamish and representatives from the Campaign for Borders Rail earlier this month to discuss tourist trains at Tweedbank station. I took that proposal seriously, and we have had further discussions with Network Rail.
As I said, we are completing a further assessment. We will have a further meeting with the Campaign for Borders Rail, which I hope will be in November. I expect to make an announcement on our agreement with Network Rail shortly.
As I have said, there is no change to the proposed journey times. The target of a 55-minute journey time remains. In the Network Rail contract, the specified journey time for the new section of railway remains unchanged, at 44 minutes. The fastest end-to-end journey time of 55 minutes also remains unchanged and I intend it to be achieved.
As I said, we are completing a further assessment. We will have a further meeting with the Campaign for Borders Rail, which I hope will be in November. I expect to make an announcement on our agreement with Network Rail shortly.
As I have said, there is no change to the proposed journey times. The target of a 55-minute journey time remains. In the Network Rail contract, the specified journey time for the new section of railway remains unchanged, at 44 minutes. The fastest end-to-end journey time of 55 minutes also remains unchanged and I intend it to be achieved.
Would charter trains make any difference to the regular running of trains? Would they operate at weekends? Would they have an impact on commuting?
link
That important point must be discussed further with Network Rail and the eventual operator, ScotRail. Possible synergies between ScotRail and Network Rail to ensure that those services can happen are important but, obviously, it is more important that the standard services are delivered without interruption. As both Christine Grahame and Claudia Beamish have said previously, there are substantial economic benefits to be had from allowing charter trains, so we want to do that, if possible, while making sure that that has no effect on the regular running of trains.
Councillor David Parker, the leader of the Scottish National Party-led Scottish Borders Council, has indicated that he is happy to see the costs rise provided that the railway is built. Does the minister agree with that analysis?
link
I do not even agree with the terms of the question because, of course, David Parker is not an SNP councillor but an independent councillor.
We will never be happy to see an increase in costs for any project. For example, we are bearing down heavily on the costs of the Forth road crossing, as we have in the case of previous projects, such as the M74 and the Airdrie to Bathgate line. We recognise that rail projects tend to be more challenging than roads projects, so we are not at all complacent about the costs, and we will do all that we can to drive down costs.
To return to Christine Grahame’s original point, which has also been made to me by Claudia Beamish, if there are additions that we can make to the project that will help the economic situation in the Borders, we will look sympathetically at them.
We will never be happy to see an increase in costs for any project. For example, we are bearing down heavily on the costs of the Forth road crossing, as we have in the case of previous projects, such as the M74 and the Airdrie to Bathgate line. We recognise that rail projects tend to be more challenging than roads projects, so we are not at all complacent about the costs, and we will do all that we can to drive down costs.
To return to Christine Grahame’s original point, which has also been made to me by Claudia Beamish, if there are additions that we can make to the project that will help the economic situation in the Borders, we will look sympathetically at them.
I welcome the minister’s remarks about charter trains on the basis of the cross-party discussions that we have had.
How does Transport Scotland plan to ensure the accessibility of all stations for bus users, pedestrians and cyclists?
How does Transport Scotland plan to ensure the accessibility of all stations for bus users, pedestrians and cyclists?
link
Claudia Beamish will know that many of those issues are still under discussion. However, for example, park-and-ride facilities are an integral part of the project. Obviously, accessibility to stations should be built in from the start of a project, rather than being retrofitted, as it sometimes has to be.
In passing, I thank Claudia Beamish for her constructive approach to the Borders rail project.
In passing, I thank Claudia Beamish for her constructive approach to the Borders rail project.
The role of authorised undertaker is being transferred from Transport Scotland to Network Rail, which is also providing finance to the Edinburgh to Glasgow improvement programme. Is there any connection between Network Rail taking on that role for Borders rail and the £350 million reduction in funding for EGIP between 2014 and 2019?
link
There is no connection between those two projects whatsoever. The same body is involved, but the decision on Borders rail was taken substantially before the decision on EGIP. The projects will result in a combined investment of about £1 billion in Scotland’s railways, and we are pleased to be working with Network Rail on something that will so advantage the people of Scotland and public transport networks.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 30 Oct 2012 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 1
- Presiding Officer’s Statement Procedure · 1
- Ash Dieback Questions · 10
- Borders Railway Questions · 12
- The Future of Scotland Debate · 166
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
- Protection of Workers Members’ business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.