I thank the member for raising the issue. The Scottish Government is extremely concerned about the threat from ash dieback, and is working closely with the United Kingdom Government to try to eradicate or contain the disease.
On 29 October, the UK Government imposed restrictions on imports and movements of ash plants and seeds into and within Scotland and the rest of the UK. Ash planting had already been suspended on land managed by the Forestry Commission Scotland.
Ash dieback has been identified on one site in Scotland’s national forest estate, and all the plants have been removed and destroyed. A second planting site in Scotland is now under investigation. There has also been one confirmed nursery infection in Scotland. All infected trees are to be destroyed by the end of October.
It has been estimated that 80 million trees could be infected with the disease in the UK. What steps has the Scottish Government taken to assess the number of trees that could become contaminated in Scotland? I am grateful that the Scottish Government is collaborating with the UK Government to determine the best course of action, but can the minister say how many trees are at risk?
Paul WheelhouseSNPThe Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
Around 1 per cent of Scotland’s tree population is made up of ash trees, and a substantial area is under cover: there are 11,700 hectares of ash in Scotland alone. Ash is not the largest tree species in Scotland, but it is clearly important for the biodiversity of our national forests.
Surveys are under way of all other nurseries and planting sites that have plants from potentially infected sources since 2007 and of ash sites that were identified as having potential health issues during the national inventory survey and the native woodland survey of Scotland. Earlier in October, the Forestry Commission Scotland issued a briefing that advised woodland owners and managers of the threat from Chalara dieback of ash. Advice is also being provided on alternative species that are suitable for planting on native woodland sites.
What is the Scottish Government doing to make the public and owners of trees aware of the disease and its signs and symptoms? Given the difficulty of identifying the disease in the autumn months, does the cabinet secretary, with the benefit of hindsight, now wish that he had made the Parliament aware of the presence of the disease in Scotland before now?
Paul WheelhouseSNPThe Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
John Scott has raised the issue of the awareness of the disease. It is worth pointing out that, in Scotland, the presence of the disease was first suspected in July this year. In England, its presence was suspected in February and confirmed in March. We had no reason to believe that it was present in Scotland until July, and its presence was confirmed only in August. Thereafter, we took decisive action in removing all the infected trees from the national forest estate site that I identified, at Kilmacolm in Renfrewshire.
On the question about my regret for not making the Parliament aware of the presence of the disease prior to now, it is worth noting that, when the disease was first identified, it was misunderstood. It was expected that a different fungus was causing the problem, so there was a delay in recognising the fungus in its own right. Obviously, action has been taken at the UK and Scottish Government levels thereafter.
The minister will be aware of newspaper reports that the Forestry Commission was aware of the threat of ash dieback as far back as 2009. When exactly did the Scottish Government and the Forestry Commission Scotland first become aware of the threat of ash dieback and what action was taken then to stop the disease spreading?
Paul WheelhouseSNPThe Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
The member is correct in her assessment that Scotland has been aware of the disease. Work is on-going to identify exactly how it is being transmitted to the UK and within the UK.
As I said in response to John Scott, the disease was first identified in Scotland in July and was confirmed in August. Until that point, there was no evidence of its presence in Scotland. We are now undertaking extensive survey work to identify the extent of its presence in Scotland. I assure the member that we will do everything that we can to move forward, to manage the disease effectively and to try to eradicate it in the best way possible.
One high-risk pathway for the disease’s entry to the UK is through imported ash saplings. Many such trees are of Scottish provenance but have been grown in Europe before being imported back, potentially with the disease. Supporting such sapling nursery business in Scotland would seem more beneficial. What can the minister do to support that industry, especially now that the import ban is in place?
Paul WheelhouseSNPThe Minister for Environment and Climate Change · South Scotland
Alison Johnstone is right to raise an important point. It was not necessarily understood that the recent infection was of seedlings that were taken on to the continent and then brought back. Growing on seedlings in continental Europe and then bringing them back is a well-established practice. We are trying to make buyers aware of the risk that seeds that have been germinated here, transported to the continent and brought back could be a transmission source.
As I said, we are trying to understand exactly how the disease is transmitted. I understand that one suspicion is that it can be carried on the wind by up to 20km at a time. On a visit to Roslin this morning, I spoke to Forest Research researchers who said that exactly how the disease is transmitted is still uncertain. We need to do more work through Forest Research and other agencies to identify the exact risk.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.