Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“NHS financial performance 2011/12”

Wednesday 7 November 2012 Public Audit Committee About 10:00 Committee business 106 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

106 contributions
Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Item 3 is consideration of a section 23 report, “NHS financial performance 2011/12”. I welcome to the meeting the Auditor General for Scotland, who is accompanied by Angela Canning, assistant director, and Gemma Diamond, project manager, from the performance audit group. I invite the Auditor General to introduce the report.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. The national health service is one of our most valued public services and we rely on it at important times in our lives. I should start by saying that there have been big improvements in NHS financial management over recent years, but it is also true that after a decade of growth the NHS is now facing significant financial pressures, particularly as a result of continuing cost pressures and rising demand. The NHS has invested a great deal of work in its quality strategy, which is designed to improve the quality of services for patients while responding to financial pressures. However, achieving that aim will be a challenge and will require difficult decisions to be made in the years ahead. The aim of the report is to highlight the pressures faced by the NHS in continuing to provide quality healthcare for patients while meeting its financial challenges.In pulling the report together, we found that all 23 of Scotland’s health boards met their financial targets in 2011-12 and overall they reported a small underspend against their £10.9 billion budget. That is a real achievement. However, it was achieved through a number of in-year movements in funds that are not clearly reported in boards’ financial statements. For example, although three NHS boards required additional financial support from the Scottish Government to break even, a reader of their accounts would not easily be able to see that support was required, the total amount that was received, and when the board is due to repay the funds.We are also concerned that the requirement for boards to break even each year can encourage a short-term focus while changes to service delivery can take a number of years to put in place and might need up-front investment. As a result, the NHS needs to increase its focus on longer-term financial planning as well as managing the situation year on year.In the longer term, there are several big risks to boards’ financial sustainability. Nine boards reported an underlying recurring deficit, relying on non-recurring funding to break even. Although boards made significant savings of £319 million in 2011-12—or almost 4 per cent of their baseline budget—they need to make further savings of £272 million in 2012-13 to break even.It is getting more difficult for boards to make recurring savings as they have already achieved the savings that are easiest to make. Boards have classified 20 per cent of the proposed savings in 2012-13 as high risk, meaning that there is a higher level of uncertainty as to whether the savings will be realised in practice. To make significant savings in future, boards will need to reconsider their healthcare strategies and the potential to redesign services.Our final finding was that, with the significant decrease in the capital budget, boards are using their available funds for existing projects, meaning that there is little left over to pay for backlog maintenance or new ways of working that might deliver services better and more efficiently.In the report, we make a number of recommendations to the Scottish Government and boards. In particular, we think that, as the requirement for boards to break even each year can encourage a short-term focus, the Scottish Government should consider whether other options might help to promote better long-term financial planning.Secondly, board annual accounts should be more transparent and clearly report how boards have achieved their end-of-year financial position, including details of any additional financial support that has been required. Finally, the boards’ monthly returns to the Scottish Government on their financial position and year-end forecasts could be improved, and the Scottish Government should ensure that boards are reporting their most accurate forecast position and that the means of reporting are consistent across the NHS.As always, convener, the team and I are happy to answer questions.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Thank you very much. I will kick off with a general question. As the report says—and as you have indicated in your opening remarks—all 23 boards have met their financial targets and balanced their books; indeed, the report also highlights a number of improvements in accounting and transparency, some of which have flowed from issues that emerged in the Western Isles, which I know that a previous incarnation of the committee spent a lot of time dealing with. Such developments seem very positive and, in that light, one might characterise the report as a good one.Nevertheless—and you referred to most of these points in your opening remarks—the report also notes a budget that has been falling in real terms for some time now; the achievement of balanced budgets through quite opaque movements of funds; in three cases, such a position only being reached through relatively short-term loans on credit from the Scottish Government; a £1 billion capital maintenance backlog; and future plans that the report on more than one occasion describes as “high risk”. All of that sounds quite bad. Would you therefore characterise this report as a good one, a bad one, or a good one with a warning attached?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Annual financial management is obviously very important for any public body, and it is genuinely an achievement that all 23 NHS health boards have hit their revenue and capital resource limits in 2011-12. That was not the case in the past, and I give the NHS credit for its progress in that respect.However, when we look beneath the surface at the efforts required by boards to hit their targets, we see that some boards found it very difficult. When we strip out the small number of boards that achieved surpluses, we find that the overall remaining surplus is only 0.04 per cent of the NHS budget, which suggests that people are coming in very tightly against a single point target in ways that do not encourage a longer-term focus on financial planning. At the same time, we know that things are going to be tougher than they have been since the advent of the Scottish Parliament as a result of the decade of growth that the NHS has had, the pressures on the available finances, and the demands on the service.I should clarify that we say in the report that the territorial health boards will see a small real-terms increase in funding in 2012-13, but there is a reduction in the funding available to the special health boards in the same year. There is an important distinction between the two kinds of board that is worth being clear about.In summary, I concur with your final classification of the report, convener. The NHS has done well to achieve its present position, but there are significant challenges ahead to maintain that for the future.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

It is common in management in the public and private sectors to use the traffic-light model, so what kind of warning is the report? Is it an amber warning or a red warning? What level of risk has the report identified?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I acknowledge all the work that the NHS is doing to put in place the quality strategy to maintain the quality of services for patients while responding to the financial pressures. However, the financial pressures are real and significant. If you pushed me, I would say that the report is an amber warning.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

One aspect of it, to which you just referred, is giving credit to the health boards for balancing the budgets in-year but saying that in order to do that they required to take short-term measures that might jeopardise, undermine or make more difficult longer-term planning. It would seem perverse if Audit Scotland was saying that it was a bad thing for a public body to balance its books in-year, so I wonder what you suggest would be a more effective system that would allow longer-term planning.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are quite right: one reason why I am so careful to say that achieving financial balance in-year is important is that, if any board fails to do that, I am required to qualify its accounts. It would therefore be perverse of me to criticise a board for achieving financial balance.There are two challenges. First, the fact that the financial regime requires a precise hitting of revenue and capital resource limits every year can get in the way of the longer-term changes that are needed to transform services for the future so that they can meet all our expectations and demands within limited resources. Secondly, the way in which that is done is not transparent in the boards’ accounts. I am a strong believer that financial transparency in financial and performance reporting is important for trust in public services. The International Monetary Fund produced a good report on fiscal sustainability last year that made the same point that transparency is important for good decision making. At the moment, if boards are having to resort to certain measures to achieve financial balance, it is not clear in their annual accounts.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Would it be better if they were required to balance their books over, say, a three-year period rather than annually? If they were shifting resources from one year to another in order to balance the books, would it make more sense for them to be able to that without returning funds to the Scottish Government and then having to ask for them back, which in essence seems to be what is happening now?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have deliberately not recommended a specific set of changes, partly because the current financial framework is driven by Treasury requirements for all public bodies across the UK. There may be some merit in looking at whether that framework can evolve to meet the requirements of financial management now or, indeed, whether there are mechanisms that would let boards develop surpluses for specific purposes that they could then use to reinvest in service transformation. We would be keen to hear the Scottish Government’s thoughts on how that might evolve. However, greater transparency would also help in letting us all see how far those movements are affecting boards as they strive to hit their targets at the year end.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Thanks very much.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I just have two questions, which both relate to risk. The first one refers to exhibit 8 on page 16 of the report, in which the table under the heading “Savings required 2012/13” shows that NHS Highland requires £23 million and that for the “% high risk” the NHS Highland figure is 13 per cent, NHS Lothian is 62 per cent, NHS Shetland is 44 per cent and NHS 24 is 45 per cent. The table also shows that for the Scottish Ambulance Service, which I think struggles to meet the demands on its service, 25 per cent of the savings are high risk. What do you mean by high risk in terms of patient care?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Gemma Diamond will talk to you about that in more detail. In broad terms, we have used the categorisation that boards have used in their financial plans for this financial year—2012-13. It is important to be clear that the figures do not directly reflect any risk to patients; they reflect the risk that savings will not be achieved in practice.11:15

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

When boards set out in their local delivery plans the savings that they are required to make in the next year, they must put savings into three categories—low, medium and high risk. That tells a story of how hard it will be for boards to find such savings. Savings in the high-risk category will be harder to achieve than those in the low or medium-risk category.We raised the issue in the report that some boards classify some of their risks as unidentified, which means that they do not yet have in place a plan to identify where the risks will come from. Commonly, boards classify savings with unidentified risks as high risk because, as no plan is in place, such savings are at a high risk of not being achieved.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Therefore, the high risk relates to financial performance, which could obviously have an impact on patient care. I might come back to that, but I want to let others speak.My second question is about another risk and concerns an issue that I have mentioned in the past. I was amazed that the backlog of maintenance is estimated at more than £1 billion. It does not seem long ago when the backlog was valued at about half that figure. When we talk about backlog maintenance, do we mean maintenance that is essential, critical and necessary to achieve health and safety standards and ensure that patients are not put at risk, or do we mean desirable maintenance? I am not being flippant; it is important to categorise the backlog maintenance. Does the whole £1 billion relate to maintenance that is required to meet health and safety standards and ensure that patients are not put at risk?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The short answer is that the backlog relates to a range of maintenance requirements in different settings and of different types. I ask Gemma Diamond to talk you through how the figure was derived.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

The figure comes from work that the Scottish Government did. It published a report in January this year on backlog maintenance and the assets of the NHS Scotland estate, and that report came up with the figure of £1 billion as the current level of backlog maintenance.The Scottish Government did a lot of work in the report to categorise the risks that are associated with different areas of backlog maintenance. It might be worth asking the Government about how it has taken that work forward. The latest position was from January 2012.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Information in the past—I do not remember whether it came from Audit Scotland or where I saw it—included a category for essential maintenance that was required to meet health and safety standards. You are saying that that is not broken down in your report, but the information exists somewhere.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The figure as we have reported it does not break down the maintenance. We have taken the assessment that the Scottish Government did in January and reported the total requirement.The figure that you remember probably came from a wider report on asset management that Audit Scotland produced. We would expect the Scottish Government to take the figure further by planning what is required and the timescale over which it is required.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So the Scottish Government would have the figure.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I would hope so.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

The £1 billion maintenance backlog certainly gives the impression that we have a crumbling NHS estate. I know that you have pointed out that the figure came from a Scottish Government report, but do you have any indication of how quickly the backlog figure is rising? Was it previously assessed? What information do you have on timescales?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

The Scottish Government undertook a comprehensive assessment. How quickly the backlog is accelerating and when it will be addressed will differ from board to board, according to the properties that they own. We know that some boards have projects in train to address some of the backlog maintenance. For example, building a new health centre will remove a portion of backlog maintenance when the old building is disposed of. The situation differs for different boards, according to their property strategies.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

The speed at which the backlog is rising will be key to whether the NHS has the ability to tackle it. The Government is moving £320 million from revenue to capital for existing projects. Boards that go over their budgets and then borrow from the Government are now being allowed to repay the borrowing through their capital budgets. Is that not a bit counterintuitive? On the one hand resource is being moved from revenue to capital, but on the other hand, when it comes to borrowing, resource is being moved from capital to revenue.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is not a straight yes or no answer to that. With a budget that is as big and complex as that of the NHS, it is reasonable to consider the best use of the resource in any one year and over the planning period in general. However, there is a strong case for greater transparency so that it is clear where problems are being stored up for the future, for example by using capital receipts to cover revenue expenditure or to repay funding that was provided for revenue purposes. We think that the transparency in boards’ annual accounts could be improved.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

On the issue of using capital receipts to cover up for a revenue overspend, it is normally the case that capital receipts come to the NHS nationally and national priorities dictate where they are spent. Now, territorial boards have control over the capital receipts to cover for their overspends, and the national directive that we would normally expect cannot be given.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Scottish Government approval is required to use the capital receipts in that way. As I say, within the overall system, there might be instances in which that is a good use of a receipt. Our concern is that it is not transparent that that is the case in ways that let us make a judgment on the relative priorities between capital and revenue spending and between particular projects in each expenditure stream. For me, the most important thing is to get the transparency right, because that will let us all make judgments about how well the money is being used.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

I have a small point of clarification to do with transfers between revenue and capital. Paragraph 58 states:“Six boards transferred revenue funding during the year to support £7.16 million of capital spending.”The next paragraph states:“NHS Lanarkshire transferred £3.65 million from ... revenue ... partly to help address the maintenance backlog at Monklands Hospital.”Is the second figure part of the first? In other words, is half of that £7.16 million attributable entirely to one board making a single transfer?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

In essence, that is right. The £3.65 million is included in the £7.16 million.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My overall impression of the report is that the situation is positive, in the face of the challenges of the substantial overall cuts that the Scottish Government is having to deal with. I have one or two questions. The convener asked about NHS board reserves. Paragraph 16 states:“Unlike other parts of the public sector, NHS boards cannot build up reserves from year-end surpluses to support future investment in services.”Is the NHS unique in that in the public sector? You might not be able to answer this, but is there a historical reason for that? I am just curious.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The NHS is not unique in that. Other public bodies operate under the same financial regime but, because of the size and scale of the NHS and the particular nature of its services, which respond to demand, we think that the situation is a particular issue for the NHS. Local government bodies can build up reserves, because of their slightly greater distance from the Scottish Government core.I am sorry, but I have forgotten the second half of your question, Mr Beattie.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

First, I asked whether the NHS is unique in that—

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is not.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

—and whether other areas of the public sector have the same strictures.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Yes. Other parts of the public sector have the same strictures, but those bodies are not as significant as the NHS in respect of either the size of the spend for which they are responsible or the pressures on their finances.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I also asked whether there is any historical reason that you know of for the situation.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am not aware of the historical reason behind it, other than that the approach is part of the Treasury framework for financial reporting and audit. It takes that approach to annual targets for revenue and capital limits.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Paragraph 34 states:“the auditor has highlighted the need for strong leadership and direction in achieving this plan.”That implies that strong leadership and direction do not exist, or that they did not exist at the time of the audit. Is that the case? Has that been rectified since?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is very much a live issue. The report that we mentioned was finalised at the end of July by the auditor of the special health board in question. You are right: the recommendation or finding suggests a degree of concern about the board’s ability to respond to the challenges that it faces. That issue will be part of the auditor’s work in this financial year and the report that I will receive next summer on the board’s performance. As we said throughout the report, we hope that the Scottish Government is also monitoring progress in the board in its monthly monitoring returns.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

At this point, do we know whether that has been rectified?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Not at this stage. That was the position at the end of July 2012, and that is the most up-to-date position that we have.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Paragraph 62 refers to private finance initiative charges, which are obviously a historical millstone around the NHS’s neck. You stated that the increases were primarily caused by NHS Forth Valley and NHS Fife, with“the completion of the new PFI projects”.My understanding is that an inflation factor is built into most PFI contracts. For information, do we know what the impact of that inflation factor is across the NHS?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I do not have the figure with me, and I suspect that the team will not have it either, but it is available, and we can come back to the committee with it.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I would be interested to know that, because that increase will be with us year on year. Regardless of how much budget is allocated to the NHS, it will be a constant drain.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

One factor that my predecessor as Auditor General reported on was the longer-term impact of PFI charges against the backdrop of the spending review figures that we knew in Scotland and the likely figures thereafter. We can give you information from that reporting after the meeting.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In light of what you say, do we have a projection for what the PFI charges will be for the NHS, taking into account a notional inflation factor?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that those figures are available and that we have reported them in the past, and I am sure that the Scottish Government has them. Therefore, we can provide them to the committee.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

Although those charges will increase with inflation and most of the charges that are referred to in paragraph 62 are historical, is it not the case that the completion of non-profit-distributing projects will increase the budget line as well, as they will similarly have to be supported from revenue?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Absolutely. In effect, any way of funding capital other than by a one-off capital allocation will have long-term revenue consequences. There will be a revenue consequence whether we are talking about a PFI or NPD project or direct borrowing for other parts of the public sector. That is one of the challenges around the capital and maintenance backlog that exists. Any way of resolving it will have an impact on capital budgets in the long term.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

So in a year from now, instead of those increases being down to the completion of the Forth Valley royal hospital and NHS Fife projects, they will be the result of the completion of the Stracathro and Murray royal hospital projects, which will feed through into the revenue line.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

And any other new capital projects that are funded through NPD mechanisms.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

The report is excellent. Obviously, it raises questions, which the Public Audit Committee is here to deal with. I strongly agree with what has been said about transparency. Mark Griffin picked up that issue. My colleague Colin Beattie mentioned PFI contracts.It is important that we have complete transparency in reports. Paragraph 24 of the Audit Scotland report notes that, although hospitals and NHS boards get money from the Scottish Government, that cannot be followed through as there is no trail. I agree with Audit Scotland on that point, and I hope that the Government takes it on board.11:30

The report mentions the maintenance backlog. Do hospitals or NHS boards present any assets that they are shedding? My area of Glasgow contains the Yorkhill children’s hospital and the Western infirmary, which are fantastic land assets that will be sold off. There will be a lot of money coming in to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde from that.I will return to the subject of transparency. Is the health board expected to include in its report that it is seeking to sell off those assets and how much it may gain from that?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I agree with Sandra White that that is an important aspect of transparency. I will ask Gemma Diamond to talk the committee through the way in which those types of transactions are accounted for, and any wider reporting that is relevant.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

If the board is holding any asset that it has formally declared as surplus, that must be recorded as such in the accounts, and you would see it in the assets statement. That means that the board must decide that an asset is surplus.We would expect to see the proceeds from that asset sale coming through in future financial statements, but—as we have discussed—the regime for capital receipts means that the board gets to keep only the amount at which the asset has been valued. Any profit element is returned to the Scottish Government for use in the wider capital budget so that it can be spent across the NHS.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Is there a timescale in which a board must declare an asset as surplus? Is it one year or two years? I know that, given the current situation, it is much more difficult to sell property, but those properties have been under consideration for the past five, six or seven years. The process for the Yorkhill site will come on stream pretty quickly.Is there a timescale for the board to advertise the property and sell it, or can the property languish for a number of years as an empty building? Would it perhaps be included in the maintenance part of the budget?

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Exactly when the formal decision is made that those assets are surplus to requirements depends on each individual board, as does the timetable in which the board will best dispose of the assets. I am not sure whether there are any timescales around that, but we can look into it and come back to the committee if that would be helpful.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Thank you—that would be excellent. I have been trying to find out myself, so perhaps you will be able to do that work for me.I will touch on a slightly different aspect. Your report mentions that health boards would need to redesign their healthcare strategies. Would health and social care integration, which involves working together, be part of the redesign? I think that most people would agree that it is better to put health and social care together, and I would assume that that would save money that we would be able to put into the health service. Is that one of the issues that you raised with regard to the redesign of healthcare strategies?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

At the highest level, health and social care integration is a great example of that redesign. The focus for integration initially is on services for older people. At present, we know that a significant part of the pressure on the health service comes not just from an ageing population—we are all getting older and we use more health services as we do so—but from the fact that a particular group of older people count for a lot of repeated emergency admissions. That does not provide good care for them, and it has a big impact on the rest of the services in the hospital.The health service could already be doing a lot to redesign services to help to keep older people out of hospital by working more closely with social care and primary care to ensure that, if people are admitted, they are discharged safely to the right setting that will provide a safe and high-quality level of care for them in the future. However, investment will be needed in new buildings such as community hospitals and in new ways of staffing services. We are concerned about exactly that sort of area, as the focus on hitting the short-term annual targets can get in the way of investing in the longer-term changes that are needed for better health and care services for us all.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Exhibit 9 gives staffing numbers in the service from 2009 to now and shows that, as the Auditor General said, the biggest decrease in staffing in the NHS is the decrease in administrative staff. I note the drop in numbers in nursing and midwifery, but the drop seems to be more than compensated for by the considerable rise in the number of personal and social care staff—the number has gone up by about 130 per cent.Auditor General, you attributed the recurring savings that boards are making in part to voluntary severance schemes and so on. Do the figures in exhibit 9 show that boards are beginning to shape the future in the way that you alluded to earlier, in response to the convener? The convener suggested that it would be better if budget planning and reporting were done over a longer period rather than annually, and I picked up that you perhaps think so, too. Do the variations in numbers in the table show us that boards are beginning to consider the circumstances in their areas and what is needed if they are to provide the service that we expect of them?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is too early for us to say that. I will make a couple of points before I ask Angela Canning to say more in response to your question. First, the reductions in staffing that we are seeing in the health service are smaller than the reductions that we are seeing in the rest of the public sector, for a range of reasons, primary among which—I suspect—is that the NHS is demand led and must respond to the people who pitch up needing healthcare, as we all expect it to do. There is also the difficulty of reshaping services in ways that can look to local people like a loss of service. People tend to be very attached to hospitals as buildings, rather than to services that are delivered in a range of ways.Secondly, we know that there are significant constraints in the NHS that make it harder to reshape staffing, such as the requirements around medical training and medical staffing. Angela Canning might help with a bit more information on that.

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

We know that there are changing roles in the workforce. Nursing staff are taking on additional tasks, which might previously have been done in primary care by general practitioners and in hospitals. We emphasise that boards should do everything with an eye to good, sound workforce planning. It is not just about reducing staff numbers through voluntary severance schemes. Boards must consider the shape of the workforce and build that into their workforce planning, ensuring that they have the right staff in the right place to deliver quality services.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have just kicked off a big piece of work on that across the public sector. NHS workforce planning will be a significant part of the work, so we should be able to give the committee better information next year.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Thank you. Are the variations that we see in exhibit 9 happening on an annual, rotational basis, or is there a long-term plan behind them? It is easy to jump to conclusions and say, “Oh my goodness, there is a drop in staff there,” but reductions are hugely compensated for by other categories in the table. Is that by design? Do the figures reflect what is happening over three or five years, or will the picture be completely different next year?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We will not be able to answer that until we have done the audit of workforce planning that we have just started. However, there is always a concern that when employers rely on voluntary severance they do not have as much control as they would like to have over which members and groups of staff accept the opportunity to leave the service early. At this stage, it is certainly too early to say that the figures reflect a planned reduction or a planned reshaping of the workforce. We will report back on that next year.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

What is happening relates to NHS Highland—I apologise for being parochial. I think that I am right in saying that the table shows that the number of nursing and midwifery staff decreased by 2,000 between March 2009 and March this year. I note that the number of personal and social care staff increased by about 160 in the same period, although no new people have been employed—the home care staff who were employed by Highland Council now work for NHS Highland. The footnote to exhibit 9 in the Audit Scotland report gives the figure of 835 for the number of staff who were transferred, so in essence there are 600 fewer personal and social care staff. I am very familiar with NHS Highland being the lead agency now, so although it has more staff, it is not that more people are employed—they have changed employers under Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations. That still leaves a reduction of 2,000 nursing and midwifery staff. Have I got that right?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask Gemma Diamond to confirm the interpretation of the figures.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

Yes, that is right. Essentially, there is a large jump in the number of personal and social care employees due to that transfer between Highland Council and NHS Highland. That is the only area that was affected by that transfer.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

No, they are not.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is simply that those staff have a different employer.While the convener is kindly letting me in and given that we have spent most of the morning looking at ICT contracts, there is a point in paragraph 58 that concerns me. There are various underlying concerns in the report, but I refer in particular to the final sentence in paragraph 58:“There is also a risk that the investment needed to maintain and develop the clinical estate, equipment and ICT will be unaffordable.”It would be a cause of serious concern if the NHS could not afford to invest in technology and equipment that would eventually save money and would undoubtedly benefit patient care. You have not given a lot of emphasis to that, but do you feel that that will be a serious concern for the NHS?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is certainly one of the reasons why we have reported on the NHS finances in the way that we have this year. Ms Scanlon will recall that we have reported in the past on telehealth, for example, which is a great example of how you can make an investment in IT and save money, and, more important, improve the quality of care.At the moment we do not have evidence of boards being unable to move forward with investments that they would like to make because of a lack of capital. We intend to collect more information about that during this financial year and we should be able to report back to you on it at the end of the 2012-13 financial year as we get a clearer picture.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

My question relates to paragraph 50 in the report, which is about the equal pay claims that may affect financial positions in the future. Obviously, that is a long-running saga and I note from the paragraph that the ending of it is still less than clear as regards what effect it will have on NHS boards.Do you have a better idea of when we are likely to have some sort of conclusion and if possible, can you give us some idea of how drastic the effect could be if things do not go in a positive direction?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

As to when the equal pay claims issue might be resolved, I am afraid that we are not really able to help you. It is a source of some frustration that it is taking such a long time to quantify what the likely cost and impact might be. Members of the committee may be aware that there was a landmark ruling in relation to the local government equal pay claims last week, which will help to give greater certainty about the liabilities in that part of the public sector. My understanding is that that does not help to move us on very far in relation to the NHS equal pay claims. I will ask Angela Canning or Gemma Diamond to give us a bit more information on that.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

At the moment, we do not have any more information. The Scottish Government, the health boards and Audit Scotland are all working together quite closely on the issue to try to move things forward. A number of test cases are going through the courts and liability has reduced somewhat because of the outcome of those test cases.However, at the moment the boards are not able to put a figure on the potential liability, therefore there are no figures in the accounts—it is an unquantified contingent liability. There is a risk that boards may have to pay out in the future but we do not know anything about the quantity, and the timing is also still quite uncertain.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We think that it is a less significant issue in the NHS than in local government because it relates to a specific period between the dissolution of NHS trusts and the implementation of agenda for change. Our best information is that there are around 10,000 outstanding claims in the NHS in Scotland, but the central legal office would be better able to give you information about the work that it is doing to bring those claims to a conclusion.11:45

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I welcome the report, which I think is very positive in the main, although clearly there are a couple of issues. I would like to touch on the financial assistance for the three health boards that were talked about earlier on. Is it not true that two of them had new hospital builds at that time and were therefore under specific financial pressures? Is it not also true that the money is not given to boards unless there is an arrangement for them, not to go back into profit, but to be able to run steadily in the near future? What are the financial projections for this year for those three boards?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is certainly true that the Scottish Government provides additional financial support to boards only when it has agreed a plan for how that support will be repaid, either in the immediately following financial year or over a period. It is also true that NHS Forth Valley and NHS Fife had new hospitals coming on stream. We were not able to determine whether the cost pressures of the new hospitals—in particular, the transition to the new hospitals—were as foreseen in the financial planning that the boards had done with the Scottish Government, or whether there were unexpected pressures as a result of the timing of the moves or of capital receipts. There was a lack of transparency that we were not able to overcome. Gemma Diamond may be able to give more information about the repayment plans for all three cases.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

When offers of financial support are agreed between the Scottish Government and the boards, the best repayment plan for those funds is worked out and put in place. For example, NHS Forth Valley’s repayment plan will be timed around when it gets receipts from the property developer. All three boards are forecast to be in recurring financial balance in 2012-13. The Scottish Government will certainly be looking at that and we will be looking at it through our audit process, to ensure that that is the case and to see whether the boards have any problems along the way. We will keep an eye on the process. The boards are all scheduled to start making repayments on the financial support that they received this year, as well. Making those repayments will be an additional pressure that they have to work into their financial plans.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Can you confirm that the amount that was loaned—if we want to use that word—was miniscule, at about 0.1 per cent of the annual NHS budget? Can you also confirm that the viring of money in that way is not unusual and was actually agreed by this committee some time ago?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Exhibit 5 on pages 10 and 11 of the report sets out the amount of support provided to all three boards, together with the repayment schedule. The amounts involved are relatively small in relation to the overall NHS budget, which as you know is very significant—£10.9 billion for the territorial health boards. The support has been used in the past. Our concern is not about the ability of the NHS to work together and manage its finances. As I said at the beginning, I think that that is good thing. Our concerns are that it appears to be getting more difficult for some boards to achieve their financial targets and that it is not transparent in the accounts what support has been received, how it is being used and how it will be repaid. We hope that this report will be a useful contribution to that debate. The challenge for us is to make sure that the financial management helps achieve the long-term transformation that is needed, given the pressure on resources faced by all public services and the particular demand pressures faced by the NHS.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I acknowledge that Audit Scotland did not make claims. Rather, one of the national newspapers suggested that this was something unusual and very different for people to deal with.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

I will make a quick point. On exhibit 11 on page 21, you identify the highest-earning directors’ roles and bands of pay. I would like to ask about the variances there. In NHS Ayrshire and Arran, the highest-earning director’s band of pay is £210,000 to £215,000, whereas in NHS Lanarkshire, in my region, it is £155,000 to £160,000. NHS Lanarkshire has a higher budget than NHS Ayrshire and Arran, yet the highest earner in NHS Lanarkshire earns significantly less than the highest earner in NHS Ayrshire and Arran. Is there any reason for that? Is any national direction given on pay?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There are three things that affect the pay of senior managers, and particularly medical directors, in the NHS. The first is a link with the size and complexity of the board; the second is the length of time that the person has been in post and therefore the progression that they have made over that time; and the third—particularly for medical directors—is the distinction award system, which can have a significant effect on consultants’ salaries. I cannot comment on the specifics, though.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

It was most remiss of me not to welcome Jackie Baillie to the committee. I apologise to Jackie for that.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Thank you, convener, and thank you for the committee’s time. I have a couple of questions. Some helpful clarification was sought by Mary Scanlon on the fact that the reduction in the nursing and midwifery line in exhibit 9 is not compensated for in the personal and social care staff line. If nurses and midwives, whether they are in hospital or community settings, are described as nurses and midwives, they would be counted in that line. On that basis, would you comment on whether the boards were highlighting a further decline in the number of nurses and midwives? What will the number of nurses and midwives be in the future?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am not sure at what point in the session you came in, Ms Baillie, so I apologise if I am repeating things that you heard earlier. At this stage, we do not have clear figures about the future direction of staffing numbers for clinical and non-clinical staff. However, we have just started a significant performance audit, which is looking at managing workforce reductions across the public sector. Our aim is to look at what plans people have in place to manage within future financial constraints and to ensure that they are doing that in a way that is designed to maintain the quality of service and the shape of services that will be required in the longer term.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I will very much welcome that report when it emerges. Our perception, from board papers, is that there is to be a continuing decline, particularly in nursing and midwifery numbers. Is that your experience?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I cannot comment on the specifics, but it is clear that, within the spending review targets throughout the public sector, a further reduction in the number of staff employed in the public sector is likely to be needed. Our interest is in how that is being achieved, to ensure that the opportunity is being taken to transform service delivery rather than simply salami slice numbers in ways that would be risky to the quality of service provided.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I think that that is an ambition that we would share.Voluntary severance packages are the flip side of that discussion. You said that they accounted for £20.8 million and that the average package was £45,000, among about 400 people. Did you make an assessment not just of the higher levels of management that were exiting with voluntary severance packages but of the average package for those who are more appropriately described as front-line staff? Does that include compromise agreements that health boards were arriving at, or is that measured separately?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will start off and then ask Angela Canning and Gemma Diamond to amplify my response. The information that we are reporting here comes from NHS boards’ annual reports. They are now required to make disclosures in their annual reports about remuneration, voluntary severance packages and compulsory severance packages, where those are an issue, which they are not this year. Our auditors will ensure that that information is accurate in relation to the financial information that they are auditing. They will also apply some audit work to the decision making on voluntary severance packages to ensure, for example, that they are in line with the boards’ policies and any regulations that apply, and that the governance around the decision making is appropriate. They will test a sample of individual cases to ensure that they are being handled properly.The individual boards’ annual reports will contain quite a lot more detail than we have summarised here about the number and value of packages by range. Angela Canning and Gemma Diamond may want to add to that.

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

I am not sure that we have anything to add.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

No. As Caroline Gardner has said, this report essentially confirms the boards’ annual accounts and that they have gone through the audit process. We do not have any supplementary information, other than what is in our report; the boards’ annual accounts would break things down a bit more. Indeed, you could look at the accounts to see whether the difference in the average exit cost for the special boards is down to a different level of staff going last year as compared with this year.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

So you do not know whether the figure includes compromise agreements.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It includes all agreed voluntary severance packages, some of which will, we understand, be covered by compromise agreements. However, we have not separated those out in the report.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Thank you very much for that. I wonder whether I can pursue a couple more questions, convener.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

It depends on what you mean by a couple, Ms Baillie.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I have only a couple. I might have some supplementaries, though.With regard to the maintenance backlog, which Mary Scanlon pursued, am I correct in thinking that about half of that has been ascribed to repairs to things at serious or catastrophic risk—those are not my descriptions but the ones used in the asset register? Can you confirm whether my memory is correct in that respect?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I cannot. We had a similar question from Ms Scanlon and Mr Griffin, but we do not have a breakdown of the figure in our report, which comes from the latest Scottish Government survey of the condition of the estate. We agree that it is important for people to understand the seriousness and urgency of the investment required so that they can plan the funding to respond to the situation.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

The committee might want to pursue the issue.You have rightly pointed out a number of future pressures that have been identified as well as the fact that the sums of money concerned have not been. Have you or, more appropriately, the NHS assessed the scale of the impact on two areas that are exciting a lot of interest: pensions and pay? What provision has it made for that in future budgets?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The report that was produced by my predecessor 12 months or so ago on Scotland’s public finances attempted to assess the likely pressures on pay and pensions. If it will help, we can provide those figures through the committee.As for the NHS, we are looking at the issue in our work on workforce planning. After all, an accurate assessment of the costs of the current workforce will be required to measure what changes are needed to the shape and size of the workforce and, therefore, how you get to that position. It will be a big element in the piece of work that we have just kicked off.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Finally, on future pressures with regard to spending on medicines, you rightly highlight that, as a percentage, the cost of the challenge facing boards will be greater than the uplift they receive. I have two questions on that issue. First, given that prescribing pressures are evident now, not at some point in the future, have the boards been taking measures in-year to deal with them? Secondly, will the report that we look forward to receiving in January or February—I do not know when—highlight some of those key issues?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You have given me a lovely opportunity to leave the committee on a cliffhanger. The report that we are working on is throwing up very interesting information both on the scale of the pressures on prescribing, particularly in general practice, and on the response by the health boards and the Scottish Government. However, you will not expect me to steal my own thunder by giving you the answer just now.

Iain Gray Lab The Convener · East Lothian
link

As the Auditor General says, we will leave things on a cliffhanger. I thank Audit Scotland for its evidence and move the meeting into private for our next item.11:58 Meeting continued in private until 12:24.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 64
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 106

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.