Item 2 is our continuing inquiry on the section 23 report “Managing ICT contracts”. With us from the Scottish Government are the accountable officer, Paul Gray, who is the director general of governance and communities; Anne Moises, who is the chief information officer; Jane Morgan, who is the deputy director of the digital public services division; and Alastair Merrill, who is the director of the procurement and commercial directorate.Mr Gray has submitted written evidence, which he would like to introduce to the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Managing ICT contracts”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Paul Gray Scottish Government 26
- Iain Gray Lab 10
- Mary Scanlon Con 9
- Alastair Merrill Scottish Government 5
- Colin Beattie SNP 4
- James Dornan SNP 3
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
- Jane Morgan Scottish Government 2
- Sandra White SNP 2
The record
64 contributionsThank you for the opportunity to provide evidence on the Audit Scotland report “Managing ICT contracts—An audit of three public sector programmes”. The convener has introduced my colleagues, whom I will bring in as necessary to answer more detailed questions.Audit Scotland’s report is helpful and contains a number of recommendations that are in line with our current direction of travel. However, that is not to say that we cannot learn from the report; we have learned from it. As accountable officer for the administration budget, one of my responsibilities is effective engagement with public bodies. The recommendations on how we can better support public bodies are, therefore, valuable to us.Of course, public bodies have their own chief executives and accountable officers. I know that the committee has taken evidence from Registers of Scotland and has received other written evidence. If the committee has detailed questions about specific organisations, I am happy to pursue those questions with the relevant accountable officers and to revert to the committee, to ensure that I give an accurate response.I make it absolutely clear that I accept that the Scottish Government has an important leadership role in responding to the Audit Scotland report. My written evidence sets out how we are responding to the recommendations; I will not repeat that, but I am happy to expand on it. I thought that it would help to explain briefly to the committee other steps that I have taken since I submitted the written evidence; I can expand on those steps.I have written to the chief executives of relevant public bodies—not just the three bodies that the report covers, but the range of agencies, non-departmental public bodies and non-ministerial departments—to ask them to ensure that the checklist that Audit Scotland has provided forms part of their regular assurance. On 6 December, I will take to the Scottish Government’s strategic board a report on lessons that have been learned and on actions. I have met the chair of the Scottish Government’s audit and risk committee to discuss our response to the Audit Scotland report, and he is content with the actions that have been taken so far. I will report formally to that committee on 6 December, immediately following the strategic board meeting on the morning of that day.As part of our key supplier-management approach, which is intended to enable a joined-up and pan-public-sector approach to dealing with key suppliers, I met Brendan Dick, who is the managing director of BT regions and the director of BT Scotland, on 26 October. He and I have met a number of times to discuss BT’s business with the Government. At the most recent meeting, we agreed that I would regularly attend part of the BT Scotland’s board meetings in order to ensure that we maintain an appropriate relationship with that key supplier. The first of those meetings is scheduled for 23 November. That is consistent with the approach that we are taking with other key suppliers. As committee members will be aware, the Scottish Government recently published a national strategy document, “Scotland’s Digital Future: Delivery of Public Services”. The document was developed with and for the wider public sector, and it aims to drive forward digital delivery of services. It also aims to ensure, in line with John McClelland’s 2011 “Review of ICT Infrastructure in the Public Sector in Scotland”, that we deploy information and communication technology effectively.Aligned with that national strategy, the strategic corporate services board has overseen the development of a linked digital public services strategy for the central Government and will now oversee implementation. That includes some specific actions that we are taking to improve assurance processes for ICT investment by central Government’s bodies.Finally, we have expanded the role of the information systems investment board, as set out in my written evidence, and proposed investment from public bodies has been reported to that board. That board will seek assurance for higher-risk projects that requirements on the Audit Scotland checklist are being met. The strategic corporate services board will discuss the information systems investment board’s initial analysis and proposed next steps this afternoon.We are taking the report seriously; we accept that there is room for improvement and are already taking steps to deliver that improvement. The committee’s comments and consideration will be helpful to us in informing our next steps.
Thank you, Mr Gray.You said that public bodies such as the three that the report focused on—the report made it clear that the examples were drawn from the many public bodies that procured ICT—all have their own chief executives and accountable officers. However, you also acknowledged that the Scottish Government has an overall leadership role. Certainly, the report suggested that the Scottish Government had been found wanting in that role. In paragraphs 53 to 56, with reference to the three bodies that the report focused on, the Audit Scotland report says:“Each of the bodies approached the Scottish Government for advice or support”.However, certainly in two of those cases that support was not really forthcoming. Paragraph 55 says with regard to the protecting vulnerable groups programme team that the team sought assistance“from the Scottish Government but was advised assistance could not be provided within the timescale requested”.Although Registers of Scotland“provided periodic briefings to the Scottish Government”,the Scottish Government“did not become directly involved”in that ICT issue“until late 2011”,by which time the partnership approach had been in place for a number of years and the problems had become serious enough to lead in the end to early termination of a contract.Why was the Scottish Government not able to provide support to Registers of Scotland or Disclosure Scotland?
I will start with Registers of Scotland. Anne Moises, who is with us here today, was, in fact, providing support to Registers of Scotland through the gateway review process. She sat on a number of gateway reviews and it was as a result of a “red” assessment from a gateway review that Registers of Scotland concluded that it ought to review its position with regard to that particular contract.In terms of protecting vulnerable groups, I will step forward and then step back. In stepping forward, I say that we are reviewing all the contracts and programmes that are in prospect through the information systems investment board and the strategic corporate services board, in order to ensure that if resources are needed, we are planning for putting them in place. In stepping back, I say that if a public body comes up against a problem and asks for resource at very short notice, the situation in the past has been that we were not always able to provide that. We are not staffed to provide legal, technical and procurement support to every public body in Scotland. That is not to say that we will not provide support, but what we are trying to do—I think rightly—is to move to a situation in which we are better able to plan delivery of support.It is also not the case that we will provide that support directly from within the Scottish Government. We propose that the organisations that need support have access to it where it might best be delivered, which might be the Scottish Government, or it might be elsewhere within the public sector or the private sector. One of the things that are important in such contracts is that the costs include the costs of necessary support, which is one of the matters that we will look at.I am anxious not to come across as being merely defensive or to be saying just that that was then but this is now. I want to convey that we are taking a more structured approach because we think that that is right. However, what I cannot do is cut across existing accountable-officer responsibilities in individual organisations.
We have found in the course of our investigations that the relationship between the Scottish Government and public bodies is central to what has happened. Much of the oral and written evidence that we have had from the bodies involved is that they did not have within their organisations the expertise and capacity to procure the specialised contracts. From the written evidence that you have submitted for today’s meeting, I am still a bit unsure about how you see that relationship. For example, you refer to a“strategic review of current ICT skills availability within central government to identify gaps and the subsequent development of actions to address these”.I am not clear whether, when you say that they are “within central government”, you mean within the Scottish Government or within the wider public sector. Certainly, the evidence suggests that something needs to be done to address the skills gap within public bodies such as Registers of Scotland and Disclosure Scotland.
That is accurate. From 1 October, we have been collecting information about numbers across the wider cohort and we will link that with our work on skills. Our intention is to look across the wider cohort and not simply within the core Scottish Government. As I have said, our intention is not to build up a massive resource pool centrally but to ensure that the resource is distributed in the right way and that it can be shared, which means that the resource might move about from time to time.
On the central resource, paragraph 78 of Audit Scotland’s report states:“In recent years, the number of staff in ... Information Services and Information Systems Directorate has fallen from 300 to just over 200”.From the organogram that you provided, ISIS seems to be key to providing support where it is needed and can be provided, but it has had a drop of one third in its staff. What assurance can be given that the support that ISIS provides in the future will be better than it was in the past, given that it is trying to do that with only two thirds of the previous staff, and that it did not have enough resource previously?
I have three points to make. First, I am not suggesting that all the support that is required will come from the ISIS division. Secondly, my intention is that we will build up across the public sector expertise that can be shared. We are trying to avoid building up for peaks and having far too many people around during the troughs, so we are adopting much more of a shared-expertise approach.Thirdly, it would be dishonest of me to conceal from the committee that the numbers of public servants are falling—that is what is happening. We are trying to look ahead so that we manage in the most effective way the support that is needed.We must increasingly build in to the cost of contracts the cost of the support that is required. If the cost of a programme simply focuses on what it takes to put in an information technology system, but the legal advice, the procurement advice and so forth are not costed, the programme is undercosted. That is one of the issues that we will look at in analysis of the information that I will see this afternoon.10:15
That suggests that at least some of the savings from staffing reductions in the directorate are being pushed out as additional costs to the public bodies that might have looked to the centre for support, because they will either have to use their own cohort to provide support or purchase that support from the private sector. Is that not something of a false saving?
That brings me back to my previous point about peaks and troughs. We could staff up for maximum demand, but if we did so there would at times be overcapacity. I also make the straightforward comment that we are not making best use of the range of expertise in the public sector or drawing it together as coherently as we could be. If we did that, we might well be able to afford to do what we are planning to do within our cost envelope.Sometimes we need concerted support over three or four months—indeed, that is what we provided for quite a number of months to the protecting vulnerable groups programme—and, sometimes, only two or three days’ worth of expertise is required to make all the difference and unlock ideas. That is the balance that we are trying to strike.
I thank Paul Gray for the additional and very helpful information that he sent us this week.I have no doubt that you read the Official Report of our meeting two weeks ago. Given my feeling that BT was pretty much being given 100 per cent of the blame for what went wrong, I am pleased to hear that you will be attending BT board meetings. Do you think that the assessment that was given by officials two weeks ago was unfair or do you agree with it?
The keeper of the registers, Sheenagh Adams, tried to make it clear that ROS is not trying to blame BT; in fact, when I spoke to Ms Adams this week in advance of my appearance before the committee, she repeated that point. To be frank, I have to say that I am growing in my experience of coming before committees. I am not saying that I am good at it, but I am learning to pick my words carefully.
If I may say so, I think that you are becoming the regular fall guy.
Thank you. I will try to continue to be the straight man.It might well be that someone who does not do this sort of thing very often will not pick their words very carefully. I am clear that Registers of Scotland made a loss over the contract, but I am equally clear that BT did not secure the profit that it expected from it. I am clear that Registers of Scotland understands that it could have done things better, but I am equally clear—I have discussed this with Brendan Dick—that BT thinks that it, too, could have done things better. That will often be the case when things go wrong. Such situations are rarely completely one-sided, and I do not think it was completely one-sided in this case.
That is helpful. It is certainly a much more balanced view than we got two weeks ago.As a committee member, I was given the impression that the four officials who gave evidence had nothing to do with the previous contract and were not in place at the time. However, the contract started back in 2004-05. When I looked back at Registers of Scotland’s annual report, I found in the corporate governance statement on the system of internal control the following statement:“Ultimate responsibility for strategic risk management rests with the Management Board, based upon the advice of the Audit Committee and operational groups and where appropriate, taking external professional advice in relation to specific issues, for example the development of the IT partnership”.It goes on to say:“I am satisfied that overall Registers ... are operating in accordance with Scottish Executive and Treasury guidance as regards internal controls and risk management.”That was signed by Sheenagh Adams, as managing director. Were we misled two weeks ago? I was under the impression that none of the officials had anything to do with the original contract or the review of it. However, those words, which are written on page 43 of the 2005-06 annual report—it is not a question of how she chose her words—were by the person who led the evidence two weeks ago, and suggest that everything was under control. Again I ask: were we misled?
I would not say that you were misled, Ms Scanlon. The “red” gateway assessment was in 2011, not 2004-05. It is fair to say that Ms Adams gave a fair and accurate view of the situation as it was in 2005. Had she been asked the same question in 2011, she might have given a different answer.
The problem was that there had not been a review for six or seven years. The quotation that I read was from the beginning of the process. Last week, Ms Adams stated:“None of the current management team was in post in ROS in 2004”.—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 24 October 2012; c 827.
Ms Adams might not have been in post in 2004, but she might have been in post by the time the accounts were signed off. That information could be provided to the committee for accuracy. I know that her predecessor left the organisation around that time.
I welcome everything that you have said in answer to me and in your statement to the convener. However, I also looked at the civil service staff survey for the Registers of Scotland. In response to the statement,“I feel that RoS as a whole is managed well”,3 per cent of staff strongly agree and 11 per cent agree. In response to the statement,“I feel that change is managed well in RoS”,1 per cent of staff strongly agree and 9 per cent agree.My concern is that the organisation should be fit for purpose to collect stamp duty and carry out land registration. I take what you say with the level of trust with which it is given, but despite everything that you are doing, to me those figures point to a demoralised workforce, so how can the Public Audit Committee have confidence that the organisation is managed well, is fit for purpose and can adapt to change? Only 1 per cent of staff strongly agree that it manages change well and only 9 per cent agree, which leaves a huge 90 per cent of staff having not a lot of confidence in the organisation. What is your view on that civil service staff survey, the results of which appear to be well below the average for other public sector organisations?
That is a point on which I would want to ask the keeper of the registers to provide a view. It would not be proper or helpful for me to give the committee my view on the management of Registers of Scotland—I am not the accountable officer for it. If the committee has concerns about that, it would be fair to allow the accountable officer to give an account of herself, or the chief executive, should she wish to do so.
Do you agree that, as well as all the measures that you are putting in place, it would be appropriate for the staff to feel that change is managed well?
I will speak for the Scottish Government. Staff express concerns to us, too, about management of change. They feel under considerable pressure because of the economic circumstances that everyone faces, and the situation with pay and pensions. That flows through to the feeling about their place of work. I can give an assurance on behalf of the Scottish Government’s executive team and strategic board that senior managers across the Scottish Government take change management very seriously indeed and recognise that having an engaged workforce is essential to good performance.
Last week, we were told about three times that lessons had been learned. Again, I take that on trust. We were also told about the success of the crofting register, but that register is not yet active, so how can it be judged to be a success?Secondly, I am concerned that, although Registers of Scotland has had 10 years to cleanse the land register of inappropriate burdens under the feudal tenure reforms, that has not been achieved—as I understand it—with the ICT that is being used. There are now, apparently, no plans to cleanse the register, and every day new and inappropriate burdens are being added.I am considering the practicalities, because I hope that Registers of Scotland is able to collect the taxes, but the crofting register is not up and running. Has ROS successfully done everything that is required under the Abolition of Feudal Tenure etc (Scotland) Act 2000, which Parliament passed more than a decade ago?
I am happy to get that information and to provide it to the committee. I understand the committee’s legitimate concern about how Registers of Scotland functions in fulfilling the duties and responsibilities that are currently laid on it and those that it may have to assume in the future.I am content that the keeper is taking the matter seriously, and that ROS is putting steps in place, but assurance on the detail would have to come from the organisation itself. It would be inappropriate for me to provide that.
link
I welcome the Scottish Government’s submission, which indicates that a review is taking place. That will not be a small review, and a cost will be attached to it. Is there a budget attached to the cost of what is being proposed?
With regard to the review of the projects—
link
With regard to the review that your written submission indicates will take place.
Yes. In reviewing the projects in question, we are using mechanisms that already exist. We are expanding the role and remit of the information systems investment board and placing the review of the projects within the scope of the strategic corporate services board. We are seeking to make use of resource that already exists. However, if the strategic corporate services board concludes this afternoon that there is insufficient resource available to do what needs to be done next, we will ask the organisations concerned to review their costings to ensure that they have adequate provision for the support that they may need.
link
I will continue on the review, and address the scope of it. Sometimes surprises come out. You may or may not have the information available, but are there any publicly funded bodies that are not included in the review and which you would not consider supporting in that regard?
The review covers core public bodies, so it does not—for example—cover the national health service or local government. If the committee would find it helpful, I could provide a list of the bodies to which I wrote; I would be very happy to do so. From memory there are 54 of them—
There are 52.
Sorry. That shows how good my memory is, and why it would be better if I gave you the list.
link
It might be useful for us to know the scope.Last week, we spoke to representatives of Registers of Scotland, some of whom felt—as Mary Scanlon mentioned—that ROS had got its fingers burned with BT. The response seemed to be that, in future, ROS would deal with smaller contractors on the basis that it would not be bullied by the big boys and could perhaps bully the little boys into doing better.Do you agree that there is a danger that an element of fragmentation might occur? If ROS is dealing with a number of contractors, each of whom is doing their own little bit, there is a danger that everything will not join up, and that we will end up with everyone pointing the finger at one another and saying, “It was you.”
I give my colleague Alastair Merrill notice that I will bring him in on that question, but I will make a couple of introductory comments.The first thing to say is that using small contractors does not necessarily result in fragmentation. I have had experience of doing that where there was a lead contractor who was contractually responsible; in that way, someone draws together the pool of expertise.10:30
Secondly, it has been suggested that John McClelland’s report meant that we should simply consolidate everything with big suppliers. That is not what John McClelland meant, or what we are doing. One example will suffice. One reason that I am working closely with BT is that we have a large number of contracts with it, which have been let in different circumstances and at different times. It is actually more efficient for us and for BT to have some consolidation around that, so that we do not have multiple invoices and multiple rates of charge. We will have to work towards that prospect, but that is not to say that we should therefore give everything to one big supplier.Alastair Merrill will say more about what we are doing to engage with not only major suppliers but pools of small suppliers or individual small suppliers, depending on the needs of the organisations concerned.
As Paul Gray said, John McClelland called for greater collaboration in letting contracts in his ICT report and his earlier report into public procurement. However, that does not necessarily mean giving contracts to single large suppliers. It means promoting the use of frameworks, and Registers of Scotland is using the IT managed services framework that Procurement Scotland put in place a year or so ago. The framework is deliberately structured to allow for both large suppliers and a range of small to medium-sized enterprises to deliver IT services. John McClelland praised the framework for its flexible approach to the lotting structure to make that facility available.
Before I ask my question, I return to Mary Scanlon’s contribution. My view last week was that ROS did not blame BT; it blamed the contract. ROS believed that the contract had turned out to be not in anybody’s best interests and that it would not want to go into such a contract again. The point was not that BT was bad to work with, but that the contract that was written at the time was not to the benefit of either side. The fact that Sheenagh Adams became involved in 2005-06 may mean that she did not know the details of how the contract was written. She may have seen it working appropriately at that time and may not have seen what was coming down the pipe.I do not want us to go away and think that ROS said that the problem was nothing to do with it and that it was all about BT, although I do not have shares in it so I would be quite happy to have a go at it.
I do not have shares in BT either.
I know that you do not, Mary.If there are still a number of questions to ask Registers of Scotland, the best way of doing that would be either to write to ROS or to get it back in and ask it the questions that Mary Scanlon mentioned.My question is on paragraph 70 of the Audit Scotland report, which talks about the gateway reviews and the lessons learned. It seems that there is“no mechanism to ensure that the learning is passed to all parts of central government”,although it is passed to some parts of the Scottish Government. Are you doing anything to ensure that the lessons learned and best practice are spread out among all affected bodies?
That is a fair question. Part of the function of the strategic corporate services board is to ensure that lessons learned are shared. Alastair Merrill can say in more detail how we disseminate lessons learned.
Gateway reviewing is a well-established process for providing project and programme assurance and ensuring that lessons are clearly learned within the affected organisations. In the past two or three years, we have taken steps to ensure that those lessons are more broadly disseminated. From the Audit Scotland report into major infrastructure projects, committee members will be aware that the infrastructure investment board now regularly reviews major infrastructure projects. Part of those reviews involves the lessons from the gateway reports that have been conducted. We are looking at applying a similar process in the information systems investment board, to ensure that we capture lessons from gateway reviews of major ICT projects in future.A number of checks have been introduced to ensure that, in particular when gateway reviews identify potential problems, the relevant accountable officers and senior responsible owners and the Scottish Government’s assurance director—that is me—are made aware of recommendations and that I provide to the relevant audit committee in the Scottish Government an annual report that draws out key themes in that regard.
You talked about rolling out a process in relation to information systems. Do you have a timeline for that?
I can come back to the committee on the timeline, but the work is an intrinsic part of the developments that Paul Gray outlined.
I understand that the Registers of Scotland contract was defined in 2004-05. As we look back on the problems that arose, we can argue about whether it was reasonable to expect the then Scottish Executive to be at the heart of providing IT support and expertise to ROS or other public bodies—or indeed whether it is reasonable to expect that of the current Scottish Government.However, it is reasonable that committee members express the view that when things go awry a system should be in place to manage the situation and make improvements, so that we do not repeat the mistakes of the past. To an extent, we are dealing with a legacy IT issue that is, I am sad to say, pretty common throughout the industry.If we do not at the outset have the expertise that enables us to define what we want, we end up getting what the provider wants to give us. It is as if someone goes into an electrical shop to buy a washing machine but ends up with a tumble dryer—that is a silly analogy, but it captures what can happen if we do not clearly specify what we want and spend time setting out our requirements at the outset.I am pleased about various aspects of the paper that Paul Gray submitted. Not least, I am pleased about the engagement with BT; I am also pleased by the comment about specification of needs at an early stage. Greater effort must be put in at the beginning of projects, whether we are procuring computer hardware or software and services, so that we are clear about what we need. The Public Audit Committee has returned to that issue several times, and if that lesson is learned from Paul Gray’s team’s experience and our experience, we will progress.Can Paul Gray give a clear indication that that is what is understood by the experience of the process and that effort will be made, not just with Registers of Scotland but with other public bodies, to be clearer up front about what is to be delivered for the public?
The gateway review process has been extended, not just here but by the United Kingdom Government, to include gate 0, which is intended to provide the early review and assurance that you described. Alastair Merrill might give more detail about gate 0. You made an important point. It is important to be clear from the start about what is required. We will look at that.It is also right to say that IT systems, services and offerings change quickly and dramatically, so if we enter into a long-term contract with an IT supplier it is important that the contract is sufficiently flexible to be able to take account of new opportunities that might arise. That is not an easy balance to strike. However, being clear at the start about what is required and how it will be delivered—and, preferably, describing that in terms of outcomes rather than detailed technical specifications—is the right way to get the best out of contracts.
I agree. If I can offer a bit of advice from my experience in the software business—
So long as it is offered for free. Laughter.
Aye; it is free. If time is spent on defining what the users want—particularly in relation to software—and the software can be seen running somewhere else for another customer, that is a great way to enable an intelligent client or potential user to make up their mind that what they are about to get is what they want. The investment in time and effort at that phase of any software procurement project yields future dividends. I hope that Paul Gray will embed that aspect in future processes.
I am certainly clear about the importance of building a little and testing a little to ensure that the system is working as it goes along. I hope that this is not too simple an analogy, but the components of the replacement Forth crossing are being built and tested in stages. Nobody would think to build a bridge and then work out whether it worked after putting the first vehicle on it—that would not be the right way to do that. We should not build systems like that either.
Good morning. I apologise for arriving a second late.From my experience, the current inquiry shows the Public Audit Committee at its best. It is a credit to the Parliament that all these years down the line we are still considering such issues and that we are moving forward.I have three main issues to raise. First, the beginning of Paul Gray’s submission states that costs include the necessary support in contracts. Will you expand on that? Were support costs included in the original contracts that Audit Scotland looked at? If not, will such costs be included in future contracts?Secondly, I refer to the issues that I raised at the last committee meeting when we were talking about the BT contract. We received evidence that in some circumstances it was not necessarily the size of the company, but the length of the contract that was the problem. It is not necessarily SMEs versus big contractors—the issue is that someone can get a contract for eight or nine years that has no get-out clause.Thirdly, I have a follow-up question to James Dornan’s question about the gateway and the lessons learned. Your submission refers to the knowledge hub for Scotland’s digital future. Will that act as a check and balance? Is monitoring contracts part of that learning curve?
On costs, the strategic corporate services board will review programmes of ICT-enabled delivery that have no external contractual element at all. Regardless of the nature of the programme, the built-in delivery costs ought to include the anticipated costs of the support required, whether that is in relation to contractual, legal, IT and technical design expertise or change management. We will be looking to assure ourselves that that happens.The interaction between the size of the contract and the supplier and the length of the contract is not a simple issue, and Alastair Merrill will answer your points in more detail. If we want a supplier to help us to adopt a particular strategic direction of travel, we must grapple with the need for a long enough engagement with that supplier to make it worth while commercially for us both. On the other hand, in my response to Mr Coffey, I said that IT changes pretty quickly and binding oneself into a contract that is for the delivery of a specific form of technology is often constraining.10:45
We would not normally now countenance a 10-year contract. Since 2006, when the McClelland reforms of procurement took off, a huge amount of investment and effort has gone into developing better tools, processes and capability in relation to the management of procurement and the letting of contracts. For example, the procurement journey process, which is used across the public sector, is an interactive means to help purchasing bodies to decide on the procurement and project management processes that are most suitable for their needs. That kind of support and advice means that public bodies are now much better placed to put in place the correct contract management arrangements than they were in 2004.
Jane Morgan can talk about the point on the knowledge hub.
The knowledge hub is for sharing information and lessons learned. Ms White’s reference to monitoring relates more to the information systems investment board, which is involved in seeking assurance on higher-risk projects. I do not think that we should understand the knowledge hub to have that particular role.
Could you expand on the distinction between the two things? Presumably, the digital public services programme board is about the delivery of public services through new technologies and access, whereas the information systems investment board seems to be more about internal ICT in public bodies. However, the more I think about these issues with regard to Disclosure Scotland and the impact on people who are trying to get their PVG registration, on the Crown Office, with the follow-on impacts on witnesses and others in the criminal justice system, and on the Registers of Scotland and people who are trying to use the land register, the difference between the two things seems to disappear. Is it a weakness that the digital public services programme board is way over on one side and the information systems investment board is way over on the other side? Are they not closer than that, in reality?
That is a fair point, and I will attempt to answer it. The digital public services national board is chaired by me—there is a board for health, a board for local government, a board for police and fire and so on, each of which has its own chair. For my sins, I also chair the central Government strategic corporate services board, so I am responsible for the overall national strategy.The information systems investment board reports to Barbara Allison, who is the director of human resources and organisational development. Anne Moises, Jane Morgan and Alastair Merrill are all members of that group, which reports to the strategic corporate services board. We are trying to make a direct, linear link between the three in order to avoid that point of disconnection. However, we are considering whether the membership of the information systems investment board should be broadened to bring in further public sector bodies, so that it can be more representative. We think that that would help.
In your submission, you say that the knowledge hub“will ensure that public bodies are signposted to review lessons learned and contribute to the knowledge hub”.I have not been on the committee for long, so could you say, in layman’s terms, where the information about lessons learned will go? Surely it would be better if it went to the top—to you, Mr Gray? I wonder whether there might be duplication somewhere along the line.
The decision to implement the knowledge hub was taken by the board that I chair. If there are key lessons, I expect them to come to the board. We want the knowledge hub to enable individual experts to give more granular detail. It will not just be about lessons that come out of gateway reviews at a high level. If there are particular local issues that colleagues feel that it would be helpful to share, they will have the capacity to do that. At the moment, if someone had learned something and wanted to share it, they would have to find 50 or 60 email addresses, and I have no doubt that it would be a different list each week. The service has been put in place so that everyone knows that that it is where they can put information and look for information. However, as Jane Morgan said, I am not regarding it as part of our assurance mechanism. I am not saying, “We’ve got a knowledge hub over there, and that’s the assurance I need.” The assurance will have to come through the formal governance structures.
You make me glad that I chair only one committee. You chair so many boards that you must have trouble remembering which one you are chairing at any given moment.
I have a follow-up question to Willie Coffey’s question; I thought that it got to the heart of the matter. On page 19 of its report, Audit Scotland suggests that“The Scottish Government could look to the role of the Major Projects Authority, established by the Cabinet Office in England,”not just to assess the viability of a project before it is initiated, but to undergo regular, planned scrutiny. That is a reasonable suggestion from Audit Scotland. Were you in touch with the Major Projects Authority in England before doing what you did, giving us evidence and coming here today?
Yes. In fact one of our senior director colleagues went through the most recent cohort of the major projects learning experience at a cost, if my memory serves me, of about £30,000. We take this very seriously indeed and we will learn from wherever we can learn from. Alastair Merrill may want to say a bit more about the Major Projects Authority.
The Major Projects Authority works in a different way in England and Wales. It takes a more proactive and central approach to managing on-going multibillion pound projects.The committee may recall that in response to the Audit Scotland report on major capital projects in Scotland, Alyson Stafford, the Scottish Government’s director general of finance, set out the arrangements that are now in place to provide scrutiny for major infrastructure projects. We work closely with the Major Projects Authority, particularly in the on-going development of gateway and associated integrated assurance tools, such as the key stage tool that the Scottish Futures Trust uses. However, it is perhaps also worth noting that the National Audit Office recently highlighted the resourcing challenge within the Major Projects Authority and the potential risk that it faces in living up to its aspirations to scrutinise the full quantum of major projects south of the border.
We should probably finish by asking you the straight question that we have been alluding to all morning, which is whether you are confident that the governance structure that you have put in place makes instances such as the three that we have been studying as a result of this report significantly less likely in the future.
I am, and I am grateful to you for the phraseology “significantly less likely”. I cannot guarantee absolutely that nothing will ever go wrong again, but what we are doing makes it significantly less likely. To pick up what I said to Mr Coffey, I am applying to this the technique that I would suggest is applied to major ICT developments. We are building this, we are testing it, and if we need to refine it, we will refine it. This is not absolutely fixed. We will learn as we go along.
Thank you all very much for your evidence this morning.10:53 Meeting suspended.
11:02 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Nov 2012 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 64
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 106
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.