2. To ask the Scottish Executive what discussions it has had with the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency regarding PIP breast implants. (S4O-00860)
Official Report · Chamber
PIP Breast Implants
Scottish Executive Question Time Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 3
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 2
- Jackie Baillie Lab 1
- John Scott Con 1
The record
7 contributions2. To ask the Scottish Executive what discussions it has had with the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency regarding PIP breast implants. (S4O-00860)
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
Scottish Government officials have been in regular contact with colleagues in the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Authority and the Department of Health about PIP silicone breast implants.
I take this opportunity to inform members that we have recently been advised that one patient from NHS Highland received PIP implants at St John’s hospital in 2006. Our extensive checks have not identified any further patients who had PIP implants on the NHS. Therefore, with that one exception, the position remains that no NHS patients were affected.
I take this opportunity to inform members that we have recently been advised that one patient from NHS Highland received PIP implants at St John’s hospital in 2006. Our extensive checks have not identified any further patients who had PIP implants on the NHS. Therefore, with that one exception, the position remains that no NHS patients were affected.
There are many issues and anxieties for the women affected. I will raise a couple on behalf of a constituent who has contents of a ruptured PIP implant inside her body. First, will the cabinet secretary put pressure on the MHRA to analyse the contents of my constituent’s implants, which were removed by the NHS? Failing that, will she ensure that the contents are tested in Scotland? Secondly, given that the MHRA put out an alert two years ago this month, is it not reprehensible that the women affected heard nothing about the problem until December 2011?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
Malcolm Chisholm will appreciate that two reviews are on-going just now. The one into the more recent incidents around notification and how the matter was handled is due to report soon. It is appropriate for all of us to wait and see what that review has to say about whether all the correct information was given at the correct time.
I understand the reason for Malcolm Chisholm’s first question and the desire to ensure not only that all the women affected get the clinical care, treatment and support that they need and deserve, but that the right testing and data audit are carried out so that lessons can be learned. The MHRA is responsible for collecting all the evidence, but that does not require it to retrieve every PIP implant, although it needs sufficient evidence to carry out the checks.
I will pass the concerns that Malcolm Chisholm has raised on behalf of his constituent to the MHRA, and I will be happy to share its response with him.
I understand the reason for Malcolm Chisholm’s first question and the desire to ensure not only that all the women affected get the clinical care, treatment and support that they need and deserve, but that the right testing and data audit are carried out so that lessons can be learned. The MHRA is responsible for collecting all the evidence, but that does not require it to retrieve every PIP implant, although it needs sufficient evidence to carry out the checks.
I will pass the concerns that Malcolm Chisholm has raised on behalf of his constituent to the MHRA, and I will be happy to share its response with him.
link
The cabinet secretary will be aware of the report that was published this week by the House of Commons Health Committee, which criticised as
“flying in the face of common sense”
the situation whereby women who are entitled to the removal of PIP implants on the national health service for clinical reasons, because their private provider refuses treatment or because the provider no longer exists, must have any replacement surgery done separately, outside the NHS, even if they are prepared to pay for the replacement as part of the same surgery. In those limited circumstances, will the cabinet secretary give consideration to how a single removal and replacement surgery might be possible, particularly in view of the risk for women of undergoing two surgeries in rapid succession?
“flying in the face of common sense”
the situation whereby women who are entitled to the removal of PIP implants on the national health service for clinical reasons, because their private provider refuses treatment or because the provider no longer exists, must have any replacement surgery done separately, outside the NHS, even if they are prepared to pay for the replacement as part of the same surgery. In those limited circumstances, will the cabinet secretary give consideration to how a single removal and replacement surgery might be possible, particularly in view of the risk for women of undergoing two surgeries in rapid succession?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy · Glasgow Southside
link
I am more than happy to give consideration to that. We will give careful consideration to the House of Commons committee report, which was published this week. I have made clear on previous occasions our position on removal and replacement: any woman whose private provider has not delivered the level of service that I would expect it to deliver will be cared for appropriately within the NHS. The NHS will not routinely replace implants unless there is a clinical reason to do so. When there is a clinical reason, I expect the decision whether there should be one or two operations to be a clinical decision as well. There is guidance on co-payment arrangements in the NHS, which I expect would apply. Many of the issues require clinical decisions, and I expect clinicians in the NHS who are dealing with any women in that situation to put the clinical needs of the women first. That is our clear expectation of the NHS.
We have been dealing with extraordinarily important matters, but if we can have succinct questions and answers we might get to the end of the questions.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 29 Mar 2012 →- Cycling Debate · 40
- Local Energy Companies Debate · 50
- Skills Development Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Planning System Questions · 4
- Libraries and Museums Questions · 4
- Aviation Industry Questions · 4
- New Businesses (Environmentally Sound Practices) Questions · 4
- Youth Unemployment (Greenock and Inverclyde) Questions · 6
- Crown Estate Questions · 4
- Gaelic-medium Education (Teaching Staff) Questions · 4
- National 4 Qualification (Grading Standards) Questions · 5
- Marine Estate Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Alcohol Pricing First Minister’s Questions · 6
- College Courses First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Cities and Towns (Economic Performance) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- NHS Lothian (Meetings) Questions · 8
- PIP Breast Implants Questions · 7
- Child Poverty Questions · 6
- Attendance Allowance (Care Home Residents) Questions · 4
- Medical Negligence Complaints (Guidelines) Questions · 4
- Methadone Detoxification Questions · 4
- Cardiac Assessment of Young Athletes Programme Questions · 8
- Veterans (Support) Questions · 5
- Insulin Pump Funding (Glasgow) Questions · 5
- Heart Surgery Questions · 7
- Vitamin D Supplements Questions · 4
- Maternity Services (West Scotland) Questions · 6
- Tribunal System Debate · 35
- Auditor General for Scotland Debate · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 16
- Community Transport Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.