Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 5 October 2004 Enterprise and Culture Committee Procedure 36 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We move on to item 5, which is the final item on our agenda. Although we are considering our work programme from now until the Christmas recess, members will note the suggestion that, at our meeting of 23 November, we discuss our work programme from January to June 2005. Therefore, it would be helpful if between now and our meeting in November, members would feed in to the clerks and myself ideas for issues that our programme between January and June next year should address. Obviously, we want all members to feed into the process; the programme should feature not only the priorities of the convener and deputy convener.The paper on the work programme includes ministers' names; however, as of yesterday, some of those names have changed. Obviously, we will need to double check that the new ministers are able to make the dates and times that are shown in the programme. Subject to that proviso, are members happy with the draft work programme?

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I have one comment about the taking of bill evidence, which I made to the clerks on a previous occasion. The NUS is included in the programme as is the ad hoc group CHESS—the Coalition of Higher Education Students in Scotland. There is no democratic structure in that organisation, so it has always seemed odd to me that we should choose that organisation instead of other democratically organised organisations and student committees.Everyone knows how partisan I am on the issue. I am not saying for a second that we should invite only the NUS to give evidence. I am simply suggesting that, rather than invite a non-democratic forum to give evidence, we should invite the NUS and two institutions outwith it, or the NUS, one university outwith it and one FE college within it. That would give us a different perspective. The people who would give evidence would also be directly accountable to their student organisation, which is an important point.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The problem is a perennial one. I feel as if I am suffering from déjà vu: when I was last a member of the committee, we took evidence on lifelong learning. At that time, we took the position—which I assume members would agree with now—that, as a committee, we did not want to get involved in the internal student politics between different student organisations. I think that I am right in saying that we reached a compromise last time by inviting both the NUS and two institutions—I think that it was the University of Aberdeen and a college. We managed to accommodate both positions.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

That would be preferable. Unfortunately, not all universities are affiliated to the NUS—the University of Glasgow is not, for example.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I am not disputing that. I am simply suggesting that, if we want to get a view outwith the NUS viewpoint, it would be good to invite institutions that are directly accountable to their students.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

In other words, we are saying that we should invite the NUS plus representatives from other institutions but not CHESS.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I agree. Richard Baker's suggestion was that we should invite an FE college and a higher education institution that are not in the NUS's membership.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

To be fair, the vast majority of the FE colleges are affiliated to the NUS. I would not want us to be prescriptive about which institutions we invite. I agree that we want to get the point of view of the non-affiliates, but we also want to get cross-sectoral views. We should have a university outwith the NUS, if needs be, but I would not want to apply the same caveat to the FE colleges, as most of them are affiliated.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I want to clarify my remarks. When I talked about institutions, I meant the student representatives of the higher education and further education institutions and not the representatives of the institutions themselves.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We should not restrict ourselves to democratic organisations; if we did that, we would not have many witnesses.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

I have one further comment on the draft work programme. I ask members to look at the suggested agenda items for our meeting of 23 November. Are we trying to bite off more than we can chew at that meeting? The agenda has three fairly big items: the business growth research presentation; an opportunity to take evidence from Jack Perry and Sandy Cumming; and the draft arts report. Can we manage all of those without staying in the building overnight?

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That is a fair point; the agenda does look heavy. That said, we have allowed two discussions on the draft report.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

Perhaps the convener, the deputy convener and the clerks could consider the issue.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Do the clerks intend the draft arts report to be signed off after the second discussion?

Simon Watkins Clerk
link

Yes, as that is the second meeting at which the committee would discuss the draft report. Although the extent of controversy on the issue would be a factor, by that stage the item might not take as long as would be the case on the first occasion.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

That has not been my experience of other draft reports.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The alternative might be to have the business growth presentation as a one-off open meeting on another day that week or at another time of the day. It is important that we do as much as we can in public—and I remind members that we are still in public session now. We do not want to rush it, as we have a lot of questions to ask. If we took that presentation out and tried to have it on another day, perhaps for an hour or an hour and a half, would that be helpful?

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

I would rather have a considered reflection on the matter from you, the deputy convener and the clerks than a decision now.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Okay. That is a fair point. We can come up with a recommendation.I have two more points to make on the work programme. First, I remind members of something that Mike Watson has suggested that we do, and which the committee has done in the past, which is to get out and about in Scotland a bit more. When we are drawing up our work programme for 2005, we should bear in mind the fact that there is no need for us always to be based in Edinburgh. There are obviously cost and time implications, but it has always been the aim of all parties to make this a Parliament of the whole of Scotland. In the past, the committee has gone to Inverness, Shetland, the Western Isles and various other places.Secondly, what is the status of the football report, which Richard Baker and Brian Adam were preparing?

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I have been liaising with Stephen Herbert in SPICe about it. An interim report is being compiled at the moment although, unfortunately, we have not received a huge number of written submissions from football clubs. Dundee United Football Club is a notable exception, as we received an excellent submission from it. The lack of written submissions has been of particular concern; therefore, we have been trying to meet representatives of the clubs instead, which has extended the process somewhat. Most of the meetings for the report should have taken place soon after we return from the recess. Some are being conducted during the first week of the recess.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I take it that Brian Adam is no longer involved in the report.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

My understanding is that he cannot be, as he is no longer a member of the committee.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Would it be an idea to bring in Michael Matheson in Brian Adam's place, to help you to finish it off?

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I am happy to take whatever input is offered, but we are pretty far down the road, having taken evidence and submissions.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

What does the committee think?

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

The report is just about complete, is it not?

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

When are we going to get it?

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Is that acceptable?Members indicated agreement.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

How long will we need for discussion of that report? Three hours?

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Forty-five minutes each way should do.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Is everybody happy with the work programme, with those amendments?Members indicated agreement.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Okay. Thank you very much.

Meeting closed at 15:53.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Culture Committee Tuesday 5 October 2004 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 4
  3. Arts in the Community Inquiry Committee business · 57
  4. Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 69
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 64
  6. Work Programme Procedure · 36

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.