Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Scottish Network 1 Tourist Board Scheme Order 2004 (SSI 2004/396) Scottish Network 2 Tourist Board Scheme Order 2004 (SSI 2004/397)

Tuesday 5 October 2004 Enterprise and Culture Committee Subordinate legislation 64 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

64 contributions
Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Item 4 is subordinate legislation. Once again we are joined by officials from the Scottish Executive. I welcome Lesley Fraser, from the Scottish Executive's tourism unit, and Kathleen Preston. Are you from the same unit?

Kathleen Preston Scottish Executive Legal and Parliamentary Services
link

No, I am from the solicitor's office.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Jim Logie is not coming—is that right?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

That is right. Kathleen Preston is in Jim Logie's team.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We have two orders to consider this afternoon: the Scottish Network 1 Tourist Board Scheme Order 2004 and the Scottish Network 2 Tourist Board Scheme Order 2004. Would you like to say a word or two about the orders, after which we will ask you some questions?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes, thank you. The two orders set the framework for the new, integrated tourism network that we are hoping to establish from April 2005. The committee is pursuing an inquiry into the area tourist board review, and it has plans to question the minister on that matter later in the session. These statutory instruments will abolish the 14 existing area tourist boards and make available their staff, assets and liabilities to the new network, so that the excellent work that has been undertaken by the area tourist boards can be used as the basis for the new, integrated network from April 2005.I draw the committee's attention to an error in the Scottish Network 2 Tourist Board Scheme Order 2004 that has come to light in the past 10 days. Due to a drafting error, the names of the local authority areas have been incorrectly stated in article 3 of the order. We offer our apologies for that. The error crept in early in the drafting and, despite extensive internal and external consultation with all local authorities, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and VisitScotland, it has only just come to light. We propose to produce an amending order immediately after the recess to amend the Scottish Network 2 Tourist Board Scheme Order 2004.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Christine May is asking what is wrong with the order. I think that four local authorities have been wrongly named in it. For example, Western Isles Council appears as "the Western Isles" instead of the Gaelic version.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

It names "Dumbarton and Clydebank" instead of West Dunbartonshire Council. It uses the old names.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Exactly. Some of them date back a considerable time.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

The names have been transposed from the old orders. When the Subordinate Legislation Committee considered the orders on technical grounds, it had no comment to make; it was quite satisfied and managed to miss the mistake as well.Although the orders are technically fine, how ready are the existing bodies to make the transition?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

It is a complicated process to merge 14 area tourist boards with the national tourism organisation, VisitScotland. After the ministerial announcement in March, teams were set up under the auspices of VisitScotland and they have been working over the summer. There are nine project teams, involving VisitScotland staff, area tourist boards, members of the industry and representatives of local government. All are considering the various aspects that will result in a fully functioning, integrated network from April. I am pleased to report that that work is being carried out to schedule and that we expect that the network will be up and running from 1 April 2005.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

It is some weeks since I had discussions with my local area tourist board. I assume that, if I go back to it and it tells me that that is not the case, it is wrong.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes. The local authorities and the area tourist boards have been working closely with us. A great deal more information about the detail of the new network will be forthcoming. That information is planned to be released at the end of October or the beginning of November. The work is progressing well, and there have been some productive discussions with colleagues throughout the tourism industry on the different aspects.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

I welcome that because there was concern a couple of months ago that things would not be ready.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That is right. I talked about the matter last week with Philip Riddle, the chief executive of VisitScotland. He explained the process of redesignating jobs and how jobs will be filled and so on. I will not go into the detail of that, but I was concerned about there being no estimate yet of the transitional costs for the staff and other organisational changes that will result from the reorganisation. There is no budget line for the costs. Given past problems with transitional changes in the tourism structure, the committee needs to keep a close eye on the situation. I suggest that, when we discuss the budget in November, we should expect the Executive to be able to present an estimate of the transitional costs. We will certainly ask about both the transitional arrangements and their costs.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

It is as well to remind the committee that the minister assured us that the transitional costs would not be met from existing tourism budgets. I am sure that that is on the record. We will probably want to confirm that that remains the case and find out where the costs will come from.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That is right. We will also want to know what the costs will be. They may be minimal, but nobody knows. It is fair for us to expect an answer to a question on that at budget time in November.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

On that point, I am checking our work programme and it seems that the minister is due to come before the committee again in November. Can we not just combine the two matters, so that we not only get a general report on progress, but deal with the specific issue of costs?

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

It will be the new minister.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Yes, but I still think that it would be appropriate for the new minister to attend. It will not be until the middle of November, so there will be time for—

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

To get their feet under the table.

Chris Ballance Green South of Scotland
link

The two instruments will transfer local tourist boards' property and assets. Presumably, local authorities and boards own such property equally. If that is the case, have you had any representations about the loss of local authority property to a central network?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes. Over the summer, the Executive and members of the network project team went out and met every local authority to discuss in more detail the authorities' concerns. The property issue was raised with us at those meetings. The minister assured local authorities in writing that, if they have built up assets in their area tourist board's local area, those assets will be ring fenced for use by that area in the new network. That will apply in particular to the area tourist board for Loch Lomond, the Trossachs and Stirling, for example, which has invested a great deal in building up tourist information centres.

Chris Ballance Green South of Scotland
link

Is it your understanding that the meetings have reassured all local authorities?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes. The most recent letter from the minister went out within the past couple of weeks and we have not had any feedback from that. So far, we are reassured that the minister's message has got across.

Chris Ballance Green South of Scotland
link

If there was any feedback, would that come before the November meeting as well?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have a couple of further points. I am not sure whether my first will occasion dismay to Miss Fraser and Miss Preston. You mentioned earlier the amendment in relation to local authorities and the board's constitution, but I fear that you will have to make another amendment. In both orders, paragraph 11 in part IV, on transitional provisions, refers to "Any area tourist board established for the purposes of the exciting schemes".I know from experience that the schemes are very exciting, but I think that the word should be "existing". Unfortunately, that mistake is repeated in both orders so there will have to be two amending orders.

Kathleen Preston Scottish Executive Legal and Parliamentary Services
link

Thank you for drawing that to our attention. I think it might have been a Freudian slip.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

The legal adviser to the Subordinate Legislation Committee will be taken to task.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That proves that members of this committee read their papers.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

No doubt the schemes are going to be wound up and dissolved because they are exciting. The new ones will probably be dull.More seriously, I noticed that paragraph 12 on the same page says that all staff will transfer under the same terms and conditions. Does that mean that they will transfer under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations—the so-called TUPE regulations?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

My understanding is that it is not exactly those provisions, but they are analogous, so the staff will have the same protection. Kathleen Preston will correct me if I am wrong, but I believe that although Scottish ministers are not bound by TUPE, they undertake to provide the same protection.

Chris Ballance Green South of Scotland
link

On that point, one of the things that has come up before is the fact that a large number, if not most, of the staff who are employed by the existing boards work on a six-monthly contract from April to September, so the chances are that they might not be employed on 31 March despite the fact that they might have been working in the same tourist information centre for the past 20 years. Is there any protection for them? I have asked the minister about that before and he said that there would be, but I do not see that it is necessarily granted by the orders.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

I would need to come back to you on that specific point. My understanding is that it is intended that seasonal tourist information centres will operate next season as they have operated this season and that those staff will be required, so they would be protected and would find employment there. Perhaps we can come back to you on that just for clarification.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I think that I am right in saying that 70 per cent of the staff who are transferring work in the TICs.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes, a large number of them do. The number coming over from area tourist boards is about 900, whereas there are 200 in VisitScotland, so the area tourist boards are very much the larger partner in this merger.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

My other point is about the formation of the new boards. The orders state:"The Scottish Ministers shall appoint the first and future members of the Board, which members shall be all or some of the persons who are the members of the Scottish Tourist Board",which is currently VisitScotland. How many members are on the board of VisitScotland?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

There are seven members.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

There will be 18 places to be filled with the two new boards.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes, there will be up to nine members on each board.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Does that mean that all members of the VisitScotland board will be on one or other of the two boards?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

The subsequent places will be filled by other people who have been appointed by ministers.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

If that is required, yes.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

There will not necessarily be nine members on each.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes. We have considered various options for the boards of the network tourist board, but the overriding policy reason for considering the VisitScotland board is that we want to create an integrated network, and having the same members on the boards of the network tourist boards as are on the board of VisitScotland is one way of achieving that. The board of VisitScotland also represents the plurality of interests that is envisaged in the area tourist board legislation. There are representatives with strong local government and industry experience, so there is a good mix. We intend that they should be the board members of the new network tourist boards.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Is it your intention that the members of VisitScotland's board should be on both of the new boards? Will any one person be on both boards?

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

We envisage that the board of VisitScotland will be on the board of each of the network tourist boards.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

There is also an issue around local authority representation on the main board. I believe that the chairman is setting up a chairman's committee of the main board to try to ensure local authority representation. Any change would apparently require primary legislation.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

Yes, it would. The Development of Tourism Act 1969 constrains the number on the VisitScotland board to seven, so there is no room to increase it beyond its current size. That is something that we would like to consider as soon as primary legislation can be introduced. In the meantime, there are two proposals to engage local authorities better in the new network. The first is to set up a chairman's committee to advise the board, which would probably have three or four local authority representatives on it. Proposals are also being discussed with COSLA to set up a national convention, so that all local authorities would meet the board of VisitScotland once a year to discuss the key tourism issues that affect them.

Christine May Lab Central Fife
link

I am pleased that we have come to that, because something that is not in the instrument is how local stakeholders—that is a horrible word—who currently have an interest will continue to be represented. I am quite concerned that that is not in the legislation. I welcome the setting up of a chairman's committee, but it will have relatively few folk on it. Something that brings all local authorities together is welcome as a national advisory body, but it is not particularly good for keeping the local economic link, which is what has worried people. If we are going to respond to the minister, we might flag that up as a continuing concern. My second concern is about the answers we had on TUPE and the protection of employees. We have all seen transfers of undertakings. Everything is fine. If the transfer happens on 31 March, everybody is still employed on 1 April, but then on 2 April consultation begins on a redundancy programme. That would have an impact on the transitional costs, because any redundancies that happened after 1 April 2005 would fall into the revenue budgets for that year's expenditure by the body concerned. Will the transitional costs cover both those years? Perhaps that is something that we need to ask the minister.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That is one of my concerns. I do not think that that has yet been agreed, because nobody is sure exactly what the costs will be or what movement of staff will take place. We shall have the minister before us on 30 November—St Andrew's day, appropriately enough—and we can ask about it then. If the Scottish Executive officials can follow up on those issues and update us, that would be helpful, but we will have an opportunity to pursue those questions in more detail with the minister.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I do not want to have a wider discussion, because we are really supposed to be discussing only what is of direct relevance to the statutory instruments. Are all members now satisfied with the instruments? Members indicated agreement.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

This is in no way a reflection on the two ladies who are with us today, but I get the feeling that there is a bit of carelessness in the Executive when it comes to statutory instruments. This is the second lot that we have had in two weeks on which we have had to note amendments as a result of mistakes made. Much more attention needs to be paid to details. It wastes Executive officials' time and our time if we have to go over statutory instruments because of mistakes in the original versions. We would accept that happening now and again, but it is becoming quite regular. I have no doubt that the Subordinate Legislation Committee will be addressing the matter, but I know that other committees are also concerned about it. I make that observation.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

We have learned lessons from the process and will see what we can do to ensure that it does not happen again.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

When the instruments came before the Subordinate Legislation Committee, was the issue of the incorrect names of the local authorities identified, or did the Subordinate Legislation Committee fail to pick that up?

Kathleen Preston Scottish Executive Legal and Parliamentary Services
link

There were no comments from the Subordinate Legislation Committee.

Alex Neil SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I believe that the error was identified by our clerks, which is a reflection of the quality of our clerking team. I thank the witnesses for their helpful evidence. No doubt you will go back with some of those messages. If you could feed us more information on the questions that we have asked, that would be helpful.

Lesley Fraser Scottish Executive Education Department
link

We shall do so.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Culture Committee Tuesday 5 October 2004 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 4
  3. Arts in the Community Inquiry Committee business · 57
  4. Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 69
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 64
  6. Work Programme Procedure · 36

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.