The third item on our agenda is consideration of further subordinate legislation—five Scottish statutory instruments that are subject to negative procedure. I intend to debate each in turn, but hope that we will be able to put one question at the end.Does any member have questions about SSI 2009/178?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Education (School Lunches) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (SSI 2009/178)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Karen Whitefield Lab 6
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 5
- Liz Smith Con 3
- Ken Macintosh Lab 1
- Christina McKelvie SNP 1
The record
16 contributionsI have no difficulty with SSI 2009/178, which will implement our party's policy, but at point 10 of the Executive note on the regulations, under the heading "Financial effects", there is the bald statement:"Resources to accommodate these additional numbers are included in the local government financial settlement."The note does not say to how much those resources will amount. This is a controversial issue. Many local authorities are struggling, and there is a general lack of transparency about resources for education at local authority level. Will it be possible to write to the minister to get a figure for the resources?
link
We had this discussion earlier in the parliamentary session. It was clear from the evidence of witnesses from local authorities that the resources have been included in the settlement.Because of the abolition of ring fencing, some local authorities have decided to spend the money on other things. That can happen across the board in local government, as everybody knows. The whole point of abolishing ring fencing was to allow education authorities and others to spend money as they want. However, as far as I am aware, some councils agreed, under the concordat, on this specific measure.
I agree with Mr Macintosh: we deserve costings. I think that 44,000 extra pupils are involved, so it would be helpful to have a figure for the expected cost.
I was going to raise a similar point to the one that was raised by Mr Macintosh. Mr Gibson is right to say that the committee has considered this issue, and I think that we were unanimous in agreeing that it was correct to extend the right to free school lunches to children whose parents receive particular benefits. However, I recollect that the minister was not able to tell us how many children would benefit.I am pleased that, in the Executive note that accompanies the regulations, the Government has said that 44,000 children will benefit. However, Mr Macintosh is right to point out that the note puts no figure on the cost of provision. I am not suggesting for one minute that the money is not included in the concordat, and Mr Gibson may well be right to say that local authorities have chosen to spend the money on something else, but it is right that the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee should find out exactly how much the policy will cost and how much money has been included in the concordat. That is all we seek; it is not for us to argue about how local government chooses to spend the money. It might therefore be helpful if we were to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning to seek clarification.
We need to take cognisance of the fact that the committee took lots of evidence from lots of local authorities. Their calculations were wide of the mark in some cases, and there were stark differences between one local authority and another over the cost of school lunches. We need to take that into account in our calculations. We cannot just work out £1.25 times 44,000, because that is not how all councils have done the calculation.
For that very reason, it might be helpful for the committee to find out the exact figure that the Scottish Government has put on the policy.
link
I am pretty sure that we saw those figures on an authority-by-authority basis towards the tail end of last year. I recall that some local authorities believed that the money that had been allocated by the Scottish Government was not enough; the committee would hear one figure from the Government and another from the local authority. However, some local authorities took the opposite view, and felt that the cost would be less than had been suggested by the Scottish Government: at least three local authorities said that. That was the disparity that Christina McKelvie has just raised. It is very unusual for local authorities to say that their costs would be less than central Government estimates because—obviously—local authorities always try to get every penny they can. We would probably be going round the houses again in seeking information with which we have already, at least in a number of cases, been provided.
Before I let Elizabeth Smith respond to that point, let me say that I think that we are getting a little bit confused about our evidence-taking sessions. We had extensive debates about the cost of providing free school meals to all children in primaries 1 to 3. However, the regulations that are before us will not implement the Scottish Government's policy decision to extend—as it was quite within its rights to do—free school meals to all pupils in primaries 1 to 3, but will implement a policy commitment to extend the provision of free school meals to children whose parents are in receipt of particular levels of working family tax credit. Although we took oral evidence from the minister, we have not taken evidence from local authorities on that. Committee members are simply saying that we would like some costings for the policy.My clear recollection is that the minister was unable to tell us either how many children would benefit from what is a welcome policy initiative, or what the cost of the initiative would be. The committee is seeking to find that out. We need to be careful not to link two separate, although related, policy issues. I hope that Mr Gibson will take that on board.
The convener has made the point that I was going to make. The issues are different, so it is important that we get a different costing.
link
Given that both policies are being implemented, surely the overall cost to the Scottish Government in rolling out the policy is more significant than one specific part of it. I would have thought that the overall impact on education authorities would be more significant.
If I may say so, I do not think that that is quite accurate. We took evidence specifically on the extension of free school meals to all children in primaries 1 to 3. That policy intention was delivered by a vote of the Parliament. The regulations that are before us are about extending free school meals to deserving cases beyond that. As the convener has said, that is a principle of agreement among the committee, but there must be a cost to that extension. As far as I am concerned, we simply want clarification of that cost.
link
I had not realised that some children might not deserve free school meals, but there you go—
Mr Gibson, you did not indicate that you wished to respond.I do not want the committee to debate the issue at length. The feeling among committee members is that we should seek additional information, which I think the Government will be more than willing to provide. I do not think that the Government has any wish to deny information to the committee. We are just seeking some clarification, while welcoming the policy initiative. I hope that you will concede that and agree that the committee should write to the Government in those terms.
link
It is not a question of conceding. I just do not think that it is necessary—because we discussed the matter late last year—to seek further information. If doing so is the will of the committee, that is fair enough; I will not continue to argue the point.
In that case, the committee will write to the cabinet secretary to ask for the cost of the extension of free school meals to 44,000 children, many of whom will not be in primaries 1 to 3.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Jun 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 10 June 2009 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 16
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
- “1st Report 2009 (Session 3): Review of SPCB Supported Bodies Committee” Committee business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.