Good morning and welcome to the 18th meeting in 2009 of the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee. I remind everyone that mobile phones and BlackBerrys should be switched off for the duration of the meeting, as they interfere with the sound system.The first item on the agenda is consideration of subordinate legislation: the draft Adoption (Disclosure of Information and Medical Information about Natural Parents) (Scotland) Regulations 2009. I am pleased to welcome Adam Ingram, the Minister for Children and Early Years, to speak to us about the regulations. He is joined by Scottish Government officials Laurence Sullivan, senior principal legal officer, and Paul Wilson, policy officer.Minister, I understand that you wish to make some opening remarks.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Adoption (Disclosure of Information and Medical Information about Natural Parents) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Karen Whitefield Lab 5
- Adam Ingram SNP 5
- Ken Macintosh Lab 2
- Liz Smith Con 1
- Paul Wilson Scottish Government Education Directorate 1
The record
19 contributionsIndeed. The regulations are part of a suite of subordinate legislation that will implement the Adoption and Children (Scotland) Act 2007. The committee has already discussed the other pieces of legislation; these regulations are the last substantive set.The regulations prescribe the conditions for two separate functions of the adoption agency, and it is important that they remain clearly separate. The first function is the disclosure of information held by a local authority concerning a particular adoption case. That takes place post-adoption and applies strictly to the disclosure of information about an adoption to an adopted person or another specified person. The second function is the disclosure of certain medical information by a general practitioner to an adoption agency while that agency is preparing documents for an adoption. That applies strictly to information gathering prior to an adoption and would not include disclosure of that information to anyone other than the adoption agency.Part 2 of the regulations deals with the disclosure of information on an adoption case record by an adoption agency to an adopted person. It prescribes the only circumstances under which information on the child's adoption case record can be disclosed. Those circumstances are: disclosure to the adopted person over the age of 16, or 18 when in England and Wales; limited disclosure to the adopted person under the age of 16; disclosure to certain other persons acting on behalf of the adopted person; access to information for the purposes of carrying out the agency's functions; and access to information for the purposes of research and inquiries.Part 2 largely restates the current provisions, although it introduces one substantive change to the current arrangements. Previously, only adopted people over the age of 16 had an automatic right to access information on their adoption, but the adoption policy review group identified that adoption agencies have been using their discretion to give limited access to information to adopted people under the age of 16. The group recommended that that limited access should be made clearer in legislation. The regulations will allow adoption agencies to provide limited information to an adopted person under 16 if that information does not identify the adopted person's natural parents.Part 3 of the regulations relates to the disclosure of medical information by a medical practitioner to an adoption agency. The provisions that it contains are entirely new.The adoption policy review group identified that, in practice, there were three situations in which local authorities and adoption agencies find it difficult to obtain medical information about a child's natural parents: when there is no consent because the natural parents were never asked for it; when there is no consent because the natural parents are absent and therefore cannot be asked for it; and when there is no consent because the natural parents refuse to give it. The APRG indicated that not being able to obtain such information hindered good planning for the child.During its consideration of the Adoption and Children (Scotland) Bill, the committee agreed that there is"justification for adopted children to be able to gain access to information relating to their birth parents' medical history where they may be relevant to health care decisions that require to be made."In drafting the regulations, the Government consulted the British Medical Association, the Royal College of General Practitioners and the General Medical Council. We listened to their concerns about potential overdisclosure of confidential information without consent, for example when a comprehensive medical report that may contain information that is not pertinent to the care of the child is requested by an adoption agency and consent is not given by the patient.We have attempted to strike a balance between the concerns of adoption agencies that need medical information if they are to place a child for adoption successfully and the medical profession's justifiable concerns about patient confidentiality. That is why part 3 of the regulations is subject to the Adoption Agencies (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (SSI 2009/154), which the committee has already discussed. Under those regulations, an adoption agency must make every effort to gather the information with the consent of the natural parents.Furthermore, the information that can be requested under the regulations is strictly limited to any history of genetically transmissible or other significant disease in the family history of the father or mother. We have not sought to give adopted children an automatic right to access their natural parent's medical information; adopted children will have no more right to access the medical information of their natural parents than other children do.Disclosure will be made by a medical practitioner, and only relevant information that falls within the limitation of the regulations must be disclosed. The decision on what is relevant will be left to the medical practitioner who holds the information, but we will provide guidance to help put in context the release of information so that medical practitioners are made aware of what types of information aid the placement of children.In summary, the regulations will allow vital information to be gathered that will help with the assessment and placement of children, and they will give people who have been adopted access to information about their adoption and their past.
Thank you for that helpful summary of what the regulations will do. Could you give us a bit more information about the circumstances in which information may be disclosed for the purposes of research and inquiries? Perhaps you could give us an example of a situation in which such disclosure might be appropriate. What kind of research and inquiries were you referring to?
An inquiry could be made under the Social Work (Scotland) Act 1968 about an issue that had arisen—it might even be a child protection issue. Information might be sought on the child's background or the circumstances that led to their being taken into care. That is an example of an inquiry that might be relevant.The Scottish Public Services Ombudsman might want to look at a particular case record, the Scottish Commission for the Regulation of Care might want to look at case records in the course of its inspections, and the courts themselves might seek information about a child.
Thank you for that clarification.
You correctly referred to GPs' concerns about patient confidentiality and said that you have reworked the proposed legislation to allay their fears. Are they entirely happy with the proposal?
Yes. When we initially prepared the regulations, we carried out a full consultation with the GMC, the RCGP and so on, and they are now happy with the regulations. We will also work with them on the guidance that I mentioned in my opening remarks.
The Executive note to the regulations says that, in the consultation,"Responses were in broad agreement".Given that the matter was quite controversial during the passage of the Children and Adoption (Scotland) Act 2007, did none of the respondents raise any issues that were not in agreement with the principles, for example on the control or disclosure of information on the identity of natural parents?
When we consulted thoroughly with the medical profession on the original regulations, points were raised about the post-adoption seeking and provision of medical information. Perhaps my colleague can tell us a little bit about those proposals, which were dropped in the end.
In the pre-consultation with the medical profession, we proposed full post-adoption access to medical records. However, we dropped the proposal when the information commissioner and the GMC opposed the move. As the minister said in his opening remarks, an adopted child will now have no automatic right of access to information and, indeed, will have no more of a right than a child who lives with their natural parents. Although the adoption agencies disagreed with that decision and felt that the proposal should be kept, we listened to the medical practitioners—who, after all, hold the information—and agreed with their points about patient confidentiality.On the identification of natural parents, the provisions on the disclosure of information on natural parents affect children under the age of 16. One or two adoption agencies disagreed with our approach, pointing out that at the moment adoptive parents sometimes give children their family history, which, in conjunction with other information, identifies their natural parents. We felt that, in cases in which contact arrangements are not already in place, the identity of the natural parents is protected as, for example, a child under 16 cannot contact them. The new provision extends rights to children under 16, who now have access to more information. Previously, they did not have a legal right to such access.
Thank you. I remember the issue being controversial when the Adoption and Children (Scotland) Act 2007 went through the Parliament. To be honest, there is less secrecy about the identity of parents in modern adoptions, but there are still a number of cases in which their identity is secret. The big issue was control of that information, in particular the adopted person being refused it.I understand the process that you have been through. Are there any plans to keep the matter under review or to monitor implementation? Will the various monitoring and adoption sub-groups continue to exist and monitor the impact of the regulations?
We have a group that we consult on adoption and fostering, although we have no specific plans to review the legislation. If issues arose, we would be in a position to address them, presumably by introducing further regulations, but we do not anticipate any problems. As you know, the act was passed two years ago. We have put the regulations together carefully and were careful about consulting appropriately.
That concludes our questions to you, minister.
Motion moved,
That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the draft Adoption (Disclosure of Information and Medical Information about Natural Parents) (Scotland) Regulations 2009 (SSI 2009/draft) be approved.—Adam Ingram.
Motion agreed to.
I suspend the meeting to allow the minister and his officials to leave.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Jun 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 10 June 2009 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 16
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
- “1st Report 2009 (Session 3): Review of SPCB Supported Bodies Committee” Committee business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.