Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 8 June 2011 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 46 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Patrick Harvie only · show everyone

Patrick Harvie’s contributions

3 contributions
Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I would be happy for people to come and put difficult questions to Ofgem at the lunchtime briefing, if they want to. I echo some of John Wilson’s comments about energy issues and, in particular, fuel poverty, but it is important to maintain a focus on the aspects of the fuel poverty issue that the Scottish Government can do something about. It does not have the power to alter energy regulation or to influence energy market reform directly. The demand reduction side of the fuel poverty equation is one that we will have to give some attention to as part of the wider—and urgent—energy agenda.On the economy side of our remit, I draw members’ attention to work that has been done on alternative economic indicators both globally and domestically in Scotland. Members have recently had circulated to them the Carnegie Trust’s report, which looks at the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress, which President Sarkozy established in 2008. The report that the commission published is known as the Stiglitz report.In the last year or so, the debate has picked up momentum both globally and in Scotland. The Carnegie Trust is looking at the application of the Stiglitz report to Scotland and there is also the Oxfam humankind index. As I said in my declaration of interests, I am a member of the steering group for that project. Building on its whose economy? work and after wide public consultation, Oxfam is attempting to produce an initial set of proposals on what the priorities ought to be if we are to supplement or build on gross domestic product as an economic indicator.In addition, both the previous Labour and current Conservative-Lib Dem coalition Governments in London and the Scottish Government have taken steps in this direction. The Labour Government did so on the advice of Lord Richard Layard, who was an adviser from 1997 and did work on happiness economics, and the current United Kingdom Government has produced measures of national wellbeing, which the media generally refer to as a happiness index. The Scottish Government’s national performance framework also takes steps towards supplementary measurements that can sit alongside GDP.The committee has an opportunity to pick up on the debate that is happening outwith Parliament and carry it forward into an inquiry that we might choose to hold in the future, which could inform the development of the Government’s national performance framework. I recognise that we will make decisions later in the year about potential inquiries, but I suggest that we ask the Scottish Parliament information centre to conduct overview research on the work that has been done globally, to consider how much of it is being applied in Scotland and to seek initial views from the Scottish Government and other relevant extra-parliamentary stakeholders to establish where the body of work stands in Scotland. That would inform our discussion, if we have one later in the year, about a possible inquiry.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

In the context of my former role on the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee, I can say that there are probably few areas of policy that committees scrutinise for which a case could not be made that they sit well with climate change. Climate change sits well with energy, with buildings and housing—as Mike MacKenzie said—and with transport. The Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee will have to try to take a cross-cutting view and engage with all subject committees on climate change, including the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee.Potential changes in the energy situation that the world faces—not least peak oil, which I think has been subject to less scrutiny than other aspects of energy—will impact profoundly on the economy. There is an opportunity for us to explore the overlap and to consider how energy will continue to impact on the economy and vice versa in the years to come.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Stuart McMillan will be delighted to know that the last time I was at a committee away day, we used as the venue a canal barge that was run by a social enterprise. If we are to have a business planning day away from Parliament and pay for an external venue, I make the case that we should try to find a voluntary organisation or social enterprise that can host it rather than a commercial property such as a hotel. It would probably be cheaper, but it would also be a better use of money we would spend outside of Parliament.

  1. Interests Procedure · 10
  2. Convener Procedure · 3
  3. Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 46
  5. Business in the Parliament Committee business · 5
  6. Scottish Trades Union Congress (Joint Seminar) Committee business · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.