Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 8 June 2011 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Procedure 46 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Gavin Brown only · show everyone

Gavin Brown’s contributions

20 contributions
Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

The most substantive item on today’s agenda is our approach to developing a work programme. We will want to discuss and decide on a number of things today, including our thoughts on how the programme might develop in the next few months and the next year.There may be suggestions for research that ought to be done or questions that ought to be asked, and it is important that we think about what we might do in the coming weeks. I understand that it may be possible to get at least one of the relevant cabinet secretaries, and possibly both, to attend next Wednesday’s meeting, which will allow us to hit the ground running. We will come back to that in a moment.We have a note from the clerk about the work programme and we have the previous committee’s legacy paper, which outlines what the committee did and the things that it felt, without wanting to bind us in any way, were worth pursuing. I open the discussion to members. I am keen to hear thoughts and ideas from every member. On the basis of the discussion, we can take some decisions and leave others for later. I ask John Wilson, as deputy convener, to share his thoughts first.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

You have picked a very important issue, which is a front pager in a number of today’s newspapers. We may well wish to consider how we drive that forward.I think that I am right in saying that Ofgem is in the Parliament today—I am looking at Patrick Harvie, as I think that he is sponsoring an event. He may get some answers at that meeting, although I am sure that they will be off the record.09:45

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Thank you. That sounds like a good suggestion and we can discuss with SPICe whether it is willing and able to do some research on the issue. Thanks for circulating the paper.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Thank you. Those are all good suggestions. You are right that, as shown in the legacy paper, the committee had two big frustrations in the previous session. One was skills and the other related to infrastructure and broadband, and we were not able to do as much as we would have liked in either area. We are probably still precluded from doing too much on both, but that does not prevent us from working with the relevant committee and, as you suggest, a reporter might be one way of doing that. The issues have an impact on the economy, and it is a little frustrating that we cannot do more on them directly.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

You are right about all those things. The Independent Commission on Banking will report in September. We have had its interim report already, but I am sure that we will also wish to examine the final report.I understand that the business gateway contracts are up for renewal next year, and the committee may well wish to consider that. I see Chic Brodie nodding.To clarify what you were saying about VisitScotland, were you referring to on-the-record briefings, at which representatives of VisitScotland were before the committee in this formal setting of a meeting, or did you mean lunchtime, off-the-record presentations?

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

The second-last report that the committee did in the previous session related to internationalisation and exports. I do not know whether you have been able to see a copy, but we will ensure that you get one. The report contained many conclusions, one of which was, as Stuart McMillan said, to keep a close watching brief on that area, given that there are a number of new initiatives that might or might not work out pretty well. I agree that we should be examining that area.You have spoken about the vision for tourism. Do you mean the vision that the industry has for itself, or the vision that the Government has for the industry, or both?

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

That proposal was noted. Is there any particular angle from which you want to tackle it, or are you talking about taking a more general overview?

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

You would like the committee to have a specific focus on building standards.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

I am not sure what moves were made. The convener and deputy convener of the previous committee sat on the Conveners Group, and the committee’s legacy paper is a matter of public record and was circulated to all members. Probably because the economy—which was always critical—had taken centre stage about a year into the previous parliamentary session, when there were so many purely economic issues to deal with, I think that at the time it was felt that although energy had got a good kick of the ball it maybe had not got the kick of the ball that it merited and continues to merit.On what moves were made, I guess that the result was that things should carry on as normal. The suggestion was made, but it was not strongly pushed by all members. A comment was made and a view was taken, but I do not think that the suggestion will go anywhere unless there are strong feelings that it ought to do so.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

All members have made initial contributions. It was not my intention that the committee should decide today to undertake a particular inquiry. The Christie Commission on the Future Delivery of Public Services will report later this month and in September we will have the Government’s legislative programme and a spending review. I was keen not to take firm decisions on inquiries today, because we want to see how the cards fall on those three issues and others.As I said, we have pencilled in the possibility of hearing from John Swinney and Nicola Sturgeon at next week’s meeting, which would allow us to hit the ground running and get a feel for where the Government is going on its cities agenda and on Mr Swinney’s wider economic brief. Are members content to invite the ministers formally and to make their evidence the focus of next week’s meeting?Members indicated agreement.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

That was a good suggestion. Homecoming 2 will happen in 2014, so the planning stage is now, if things are to go smoothly.We have agreed a proposal for next week’s meeting. Patrick Harvie suggested that we ask SPICe to produce a background paper on the issues that he raised. Are members content to do that?Members indicated agreement.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

As far as I am aware, one energy company has announced that the price of gas will go up by 19 per cent and that of electricity by 10 per cent—

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Observations of what has happened previously suggest that, following such an announcement, there tends to be a period of change over a number of weeks, during which the other companies take decisions. I am thinking out loud here, but I wonder whether we would want to hear from Scottish Power while it is unclear what other companies will do. In a sense, we would be picking on one energy company when others might make similar decisions weeks or months later. The issue has been identified as an important one. I throw open to members how best we as a committee might tackle it without losing the initiative, as John Wilson touched on.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Stuart McMillan’s suggestion is a good one. It would be helpful for SPICe to give us as much background as possible in relation to previous price fluctuations and changes. It has been suggested that I write to Ofgem and the utility companies to seek the kind of information that Chic Brodie suggested we gather. Once we have gathered that information, we could decide how best to take the issue forward.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

I see that members are nodding in agreement. I suggest, therefore, that we go ahead and issue those invitations. After next week, there are two Wednesdays before the recess. Are members content to leave those arrangements with me and the clerks?

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

In the past, we have had short briefings on the subject, so we will be able to get hold of a fair amount of information from SPICe.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

We will ask for that information and take a view thereafter.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

That takes care of next week and the suggestion that was made by John Wilson.What used to be called away days are now, I am told, called business planning days—because they quite often do not take place away from the Parliament. Is the committee content with the idea that we should have a business planning day in late summer or early September to work out our work programme? I am not sure whether it will be possible or allowable to hold such a day outwith the Parliament building but, if it is, do members have any suggestions? I know that Stuart McMillan has one.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Thank you for your good ideas and suggestions, about both sailing and IBM.

Gavin Brown Con The Convener · Lothian
link

Are there any other suggestions at this stage? Some people might not have had time to think about it much, so we are happy to receive further suggestions over the next week. We might not have a choice about whether our away day happens outside the Parliament, but we do not have to take a decision on that today. I thank members for their thoughts and suggestions.

  1. Interests Procedure · 10
  2. Convener Procedure · 3
  3. Deputy Convener Procedure · 2
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 46
  5. Business in the Parliament Committee business · 5
  6. Scottish Trades Union Congress (Joint Seminar) Committee business · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.