Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Graduate Endowment (Scotland) Regulations 2008 (SSI 2008/235)

Wednesday 25 June 2008 Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Subordinate legislation 44 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

44 contributions
Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

The sixth and final item on our agenda is further consideration of subordinate legislation. Elspeth MacDonald and Gavin Gray have remained with us and we are joined by Mark Batho, the director of lifelong learning with the Scottish Government, to answer any questions that the committee may have.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The issue with which the regulations deal is a matter of concern in my constituency and nationally. I have raised the issue with the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning. How many students will be affected by the decision, which is a reversal of policy? How many students who are in postgraduate or continuing education have been asked to pay their graduate endowment in full?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

The figure that we have is that 2,457 people had been allowed to defer payment of their graduate endowment under administrative procedures by the SAAS.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

How many of them have paid off their endowment in cash?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

I have the figures here, if you will bear with me while I look through my notes. Following March, 249 of them had paid by cash and 625 had added the amount of the graduate endowment fee to their student loan. That makes a total of 874 who had settled. I am not quite sure what the date of those figures is, but they are the latest figures that I have.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

What is the current status of the others who are included, but who have not taken a decision, so to speak?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

Their status is that they have not responded to a demand for payment. As the situation has unfolded in recent weeks, it has become clear that there was no formal legal legislative underpinning of the decision to defer. Technically, all the 2,457 people had an immediate liability to pay that may have crystallised at any time from 2005 onwards, depending on the length of the deferment that they were granted.The Government's decision in relation to them is that the deferment that was originally granted should, in practice, be allowed to continue on the basis that there is a legitimate expectation on the part of those students that they would not have had to have paid at any point up to the point at which they were told that their deferment would continue, which is the point at which they complete any subsequent higher education course beyond that for which they accrued the graduate endowment liability. In practice, as things stand, those who did not respond to the SAAS letter will receive a letter that will confirm that the deferment that was originally granted to them will be allowed to continue.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So those who did not respond to the SAAS letter will be allowed to continue to defer and will not have to apply for a loan.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

They will not have to apply for a loan now. The substance of the regulations is that those students will have the choice at the end of the deferral period to either pay by cash or to take out a loan.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

That is why the regulations are in front of us today. As the Government looked into the situation it became clear that, in practice, because the decision to defer did not have any legal basis, it had the knock-on effect that those students could not legally apply for a student loan when the period of deferment came to an end. Under the existing regulations, a student can apply for a student loan up to 1 April, when their liability crystallises. For example, a student who finished their first course in July 2006 became liable on 1 April 2007 and if they then deferred because they were going to go on to a one-year postgraduate qualification, they did not apply for a loan at that point, but their liability accrued at 1 April 2007, so they would not have the opportunity to apply later for a student loan, and the regulations would change that legal position to say that such students can apply for a student loan at any point up to 1 April after the second or subsequent higher education course for which the deferral was granted comes to an end.I am sorry; that was an inordinately complicated sentence.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

That is all right. It is a difficult subject but I have a lot of cases about it, so I am aware of its complexities.In practice, postgraduate students in the past applied for loans whether they were legally entitled to or not. Many of those students will be on one-year courses, but some will be on two or three-year courses. Will they be able to defer for two or three years?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

There will be no more deferment because the graduate endowment has been abolished.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

That is right, but will those who are currently in the middle of a postgraduate course that has another two years to go be able to defer until the end of that two years?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

Yes.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Will the 625 who have added their liability to their loans be able to claim back interest on those loans?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

Technically, those loans were granted without legal authority, so they will be cancelled, the students will be able to replace them with new loans and the interest that will have accrued between the time that they took out the loan and the time of the new loan will be met for them. They will not have to pay it.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

We are looking into that. It is not easy, but the cabinet secretary has asked us to consider the possibilities for them. The technical position is that they had a liability that they have now met. In fact, in legal terms they have had an unlooked-for benefit in that they were not allowed technically to have had that deferral take place and should have paid some time ago. The cabinet secretary has asked us to examine the position. I cannot say where that will end up because the situation is complicated.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am not sure that those graduates would agree that they have had some sort of benefit.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

I am speaking in legalistic terms. I refer back to the example that I gave before: if the liability accrued on 1 April 2007, they were due technically to pay from that time because there was no legal basis for deferment. The fact that they have not had to pay up to this point is, in legal terms, an unlooked-for benefit.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

According to the note, the financial implications are minimal, but I cannot believe that. We have offered 625 loans to students at a substantial cost to SAAS if not to the Government. Has that cost not been included in the regulatory paper?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

I invite Gavin Gray to respond.

Gavin Gray
link

The cost of providing the loans has always been accounted for in the general accounting for the graduate endowment scheme. As regards having to cancel the loans and replace any lost interest, the Student Loans Company is working with SAAS to look at each case. We are still waiting for the Student Loans Company to tell us exactly what the cost will be, but we think that it will be in the region of £10,000 to £20,000. Although we are still waiting for confirmation from the Student Loans Company of exactly what is involved and what the cost will be, we expect the cost to be met from within the company's existing running costs.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

It might be of interest to the committee to find out exactly what that cost is, perhaps in writing at a later stage.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am pleased that the cabinet secretary has responded to the pressure that has been put on her by my colleague Claire Baker and others: including me, actually—false modesty is a sin, is it not? I am interested in when the cabinet secretary took the decision that there was a problem. I wrote to her about the situation in March and got a response in April that suggested that there was no problem and that we were following the law. I wrote again in May and got a response by e-mail last night, interestingly. At what point between the abolition of the graduate endowment and today's debate on the regulations did the cabinet secretary cotton on to, or make moves to accept, the fact that there is a problem?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

May I clarify what particular problem you are asking about? There are two issues on the table, one of which is the legality or otherwise of the granting of deferment, and the other is the capacity to pay a student loan to students who have deferred. The issues are interlinked and the problem emerged when a particular case was identified that caused us to look again at the whole situation. It was at that point—I have not got an exact date, but there was a report in The Herald, which is easily identifiable—that we identified that there was no formal legal basis for the deferment. Within a short time, we identified the student loan issue, which changed the context in which the original decision was taken in March.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

That is interesting. I wrote in March to say that the Executive should defer payment. I received a response in April, saying that that was not the policy position of the Government. The Government is addressing the matter only because it is being forced to do so by an identified weakness in the law. Would the Government continue to penalise the students if it were not for that weakness? I suppose that that is a policy question for the minister.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

I cannot comment on the latter part of your question, but I can confirm that the instrument is a response to an identified weakness in the law.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do other members have questions that they want to ask?

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Ken Macintosh has covered many of the issues, but I would like to ask about deferment. The legal problems around the supplying of a loan at the stage of deferment arose only because a decision was made to withdraw the ability to defer. It is unclear who made that decision. I have received letters from the SAAS, which say that it was down to accounting procedures. However, Ken Macintosh has suggested that it was a policy decision. Can you give us some information on who made the decision? Was it a consequence of the abolition of the graduate endowment?

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

The way it works is that there is no legal basis to defer. That was an administrative decision that was taken by the Student Awards Agency for Scotland, which was not founded on statute. Therefore, as a legal consequence of the fact that there is no power to defer, there is no power for those people who have deferred to take out a student loan in order to pay after they have missed the cut-off date, which is the point at which they originally became liable. The one absolutely follows the other. As soon as it was identified that there is no legal basis for deferment under the existing regulations, which we are replacing, there could be no payment of a student loan.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So, you are suggesting that there was never any legal basis for deferment, under previous Governments or the current Government.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

Indeed.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I understood that, previously, there had been a direction from ministers that the SAAS should allow deferment for postgraduate students.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

No.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am also interested in when the minister or officials became aware that there was a problem. The letters were originally sent out to students in February, but it has taken until now, towards the end of the academic session, for the amending regulations to be produced to deal with the issue. You have highlighted the fact that the coverage in The Herald brought the matter to the minister's attention.

Mark Batho Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate
link

Yes.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do committee members believe that the officials have been able to answer all their questions? Are we happy to move to the question on the instrument?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am delighted, although I have some concerns. I am concerned that a letter from an MSP highlighting several constituency cases was not enough to illuminate the minister's view on the matter but that an article in The Herald was. It says something about the Government if that is how ministers proceed. Nevertheless, whatever the decision was based on, it was the right decision. Of all the subordinate legislation that has come before us this morning, this is the one instrument that I have no hesitation in supporting.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

In that case, it is appropriate that we move to the question on the motion. No motion to annul the instrument has been lodged, and the Subordinate Legislation Committee has determined that it does not need to draw the attention of the Parliament to it. Members' questions have been covered.The recommendation is that the committee has no recommendation to make on the Graduate Endowment (Scotland) Regulations 2008 (SSI 2008/235). Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

That concludes the committee's business today. I wish you all a happy recess, and I will see you in September.

Meeting closed at 13:39.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 25 June 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Scotland's Commissioner for Children and Young People (Annual Reports 2006-07 and 2007-08) Committee business · 38
  3. Petition Petitions · 159
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 37
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 106
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 44

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.