We move to agenda item 5, which is further subordinate legislation. We are joined by Government officials. First, I apologise to Ms MacDonald, whom I tried to dismiss prematurely. She is now accompanied by different Scottish Government officials: Gavin Gray, who is the living costs support team leader, and Anne Marie Hoey, who is the policy writer.Claire Baker MSP has joined the meeting.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Education (Means Testing) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2008 (SSI 2008/206)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jeremy Purvis LD 26
- Gavin Gray Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate 24
- Anne Marie Hoey Scottish Government Lifelong Learning Directorate 21
- Mary Mulligan Lab 14
- Karen Whitefield Lab 8
- Claire Baker Lab 6
- Ken Macintosh Lab 2
- Aileen Campbell SNP 2
- Elspeth MacDonald Scottish Government Legal Directorate 1
The record
106 contributions
link
I will ask about the different decision that was taken in England. I understand that when changes to align higher education means testing with further education means testing were introduced there, they did not apply to existing students—they applied only to new students. However, the Government in Scotland decided to take a big-bang approach, whereby the changes will apply to all students. Did you consider following the model that was adopted down south?
We considered several options, which we presented to the cabinet secretary, who decided to go ahead with the big-bang introduction. One of those options was a phased introduction for new students only.
link
Can you give reasons why the big-bang option was chosen? Was that the minister's decision?
Yes. Ultimately, the decision is for the minister. We tried to weigh up the pros and cons of the impact on students. Obviously, the big bang changes circumstances for some students during their course. However, we balanced that against the wider impact on the student body of running two different assessments at the same time. Having separate application forms might have caused confusion and the Student Awards Agency for Scotland might have experienced operational issues, which might have meant that students did not receive payments on time. Several such matters were considered. The advice focused on what would have the minimum impact on students in general.
link
One or two points follow from that. One difficulty seems to be the idea of running two systems at the same time, although England ran two systems at the same time. However, the most important question is about the impact on students. Was an impact assessment undertaken in Scotland to determine how many students—particularly those who are currently studying—the changes would affect?
On the first point, we are aware that changes have happened in England, but we have not examined them in detail. We discussed with SAAS the implications in Scotland and proceeded on that basis.The project has been with officials for several years and, before implementing the changes, we tried to undertake modelling work on the number of students who would be affected. However, data are not available on partners' income, because that has never been a factor in assessment before. It is impossible to collect that information unless we have reason to do so—unless we assess on that basis. We have tried our best to consider such matters and to model them as much as we can, but it is impossible to collect the data on partners' income other than by assessing on that basis, because data protection law prevents us from asking for that information if it is not to be used in the assessment.
link
So the policy will be introduced without any understanding of whom it will affect.
We know the main groups and the characteristics of the students who will be affected. As the policy papers say, we will work closely with SAAS, which will be in touch with institutions during the year, to monitor the impact on students. If anyone is to receive less support or is in danger of falling into hardship, they will have recourse to university hardship funds.The regulations will make the means test fairer. We are making the changes because the view is that some people are being unfairly assessed, as a large chunk of their household income is not being taken into account in the income assessment. We are trying to create a fair playing field for everyone. We will have to monitor the situation as the year goes on.
link
I appreciate that the minister has given the commitment that the savings from year 1 will go into discretionary funds for students. However, I am concerned about a gap between savings being collected in year 1 and discretionary funds being increased—savings from year 1 might be used in funds in year 2. The minister's commitment is for year 1, but have commitments been made on the cumulative savings from the policy changes beyond year 1?
We will obviously monitor the situation from year 1 to year 2, and money will be moved into the hardship funds. There will be dialogue with SAAS about its budgets; SAAS has the flexibility to move money between budgets as the year goes on.I am not sure that there will be much of a gap. However, we are aware that we are not talking about just one year. Students already in the system might be two or three years into their course, so it will take time for things to filter out.
Ms Baker asked about future decisions. The minister’s commitment is clear: we will do this in year 1, but that is on the understanding that cohorts of students still have to move through the system. Once we understand the impact of that, we will be able to factor it into future budgets for SAAS. Any change to the balance between what is paid out in fees and awards or loans and what is paid out through the hardship funds or the discretionary funds, will be factored into future budgets.Obviously, we are not in a position to commit the minister any further than that.
link
That was a helpful answer, thank you.
Will any savings made in the first year be used for the hardship funds? Claire Baker was asking about the second and third years.
This is supposed to be a cost-neutral exercise, so we are not looking to generate efficiencies or savings. We are aware that less support will be available to some people as a result of the changes. However, if people are genuinely put into hardship, the hardship or discretionary funds will be used.The first year will really be a monitoring year with SAAS. We will keep an eye on things and will talk to SAAS and the institutions. SAAS will tell us what has been spent, what needs to be transferred, and whether any additional funding is needed. The information that we gather this year will form the basis for funding decisions on SAAS's budget in future years. Such considerations will become part of the annual budgeting process for the awards agency.
We will all be aware that demand tends to exceed supply when it comes to hardship funds. Will students who are affected by the changes be given any preference over the students who would normally apply to a hardship fund?
They have been made a priority this year in the guidance that has gone out to institutions. Obviously, we will have to consider the money that is to be allocated throughout the year; however, anybody who has to go to the institutions as a result of the means-test changes will be given priority.
And guidance to that effect has already gone out.
Yes.
Regulations 9 and 10 refer to inserting, after the word "parent", a range of possible partners of that parent—whether a spouse, a civil partner or a person living with that parent. Does the student involved actually have to reside with the parent and one of those categories of partner?
At the beginning, when the student applies for support, there are different categories. Certain categories are classed as independent—for example, if the student is married or has been self-sufficient for three years. However, if the student is classed as dependent by the Student Awards Agency for Scotland, the assessment of their income will be based on what is at present called the parental income but which will be called the household income from 2008-09. If a student moves away, they will still be assessed using the household income.
What if the student has never lived within that household? Would they still be included?
If the student is classed as dependent, then yes.
I will try one more time. If a student lives with her grandparents and has not lived in her parental home for some time, will she be included in the scheme?
It depends on the circumstances of the case. If SAAS classes the student as a dependent student, they will be assessed currently on parental income and in future on household income. If it classes the student as an independent student, because they are self-sufficient and live on their own, the household income will not be taken into account.
So the crucial factor is whether a student is classed as dependent or independent.
Yes.
That is helpful.
It was helpful to hear that guidance has been issued to institutions. The guidance will have been published, so we will be able to see it. In answer to parliamentary questions, the Government stated that the funding that will be saved from the first year of the scheme will be allocated to discretionary funds and that no decisions have been taken about savings in subsequent years. Is that correct?
Yes. As I said earlier, the funding will be factored into future budget decisions. We are aware that the effect of the savings is not limited to one year and that subsequent cohorts of students will be affected.
Am I correct in saying that nursing or midwifery students cannot apply to institutions' hardship funds?
Separate arrangements have been made for nursing and midwifery students.
What are they?
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing decided that such students would receive the same level of support and would not be any worse off as a result of the changes.
How will the arrangements work in practice?
The arrangements for student support in nursing and midwifery are very different—a different kind of support is provided and the bursary that students receive is not means tested. However, students are still eligible for a dependents allowance that is means tested—they can claim for children. Because the arrangement is unique to nursing and midwifery students, the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing decided that, when those students apply to SAAS, the support that they receive will be made up to the level that they were awarded in the previous year, so that they are no worse off.
It would be helpful if we could receive more information on how the arrangement will work in practice. I understood that nursing and midwifery students will be eligible to claim dependents grants for their partners but that partners' income will be means tested. There is means testing for nursing and midwifery students.
The additional dependents allowance for children is means tested, but the bursary that nursing and midwifery students receive is not. If a nursing student is living with her partner and is claiming for a child, her bursary will not be affected by the fact that her partner has high earnings, but she may lose out on support for her child. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing has said that she will ensure that the same level of support that was awarded in previous years will be provided.
The arrangement does not apply to non-nursing and non-midwifery students in that category.
No. The support to which I refer is specific to nursing and midwifery students.
Does SAAS have to operate a separate procedure to provide the same level of bursary to that category of students?
The same application process and computer system are used to provide support for such students.
When the Government was asked why it opted for a big bang approach, it said that the cost to SAAS of operating two systems was estimated at £1 million. It is worth asking whether a second system is in operation for nursing and midwifery student support.
No. Nursing and midwifery students are paid through the same grants and student support system.
Because the number of nursing and midwifery students is relatively small compared with the total number of students with which SAAS deals, their cases are dealt with on an individual basis—there is no need to design an entirely new system. Representatives of SAAS are not here to provide details of the operational impact of the issue on SAAS, so we will need to double-check that with the agency.
It might be helpful to have information on that area.With regard to the eligibility of lone-parent students, for the first time, maintenance payments will be taken into consideration as part of the assessment. That is a policy decision, so we will ask the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning about that. However, I would like to ask you whether you know how many lone-parent students who currently receive maintenance payments will be affected by the change.
SAAS does not record that information, so those data are not available. Currently, SAAS does not take maintenance payments into account in any respect. The situation was different with regard to FE colleges and, because the policy was designed to align the situation in the HE sector with what has been happening in the FE sector, it was decided to take such payments into account. We are aware, however, that we do not know how widespread the impact will be, because we do not have any data for the HE sector.
Is it definite that students who have gone through the new process and are in considerable hardship will be able to access universities' discretionary funds? The criteria for discretionary funds are such that they are not available if a student has gone through the normal, means-tested route of applying for grants and bursaries. The students about whom I am talking will probably have gone through that process, as they are allowed to apply for everything that is open to them. Is it absolutely the case that they will be able to apply for hardship funds for this year?
Students who have been adversely affected by the changes to the means test and who are in genuine hardship can access the discretionary funds.
Will they be able to access the same amount that they are losing?
That is a decision for the institutions. The pay-outs are discretionary.
When I said to the First Minister that students could face hardship, he said:"We have put in place hardship funds to deal with exactly that contingency."—Official Report, 24 April 2008; c 7935. However, you are saying that there will not be a like-for-like replacement of the funds that students have lost out on. The Government has not ensured that that will happen in the way that it has ensured that it will happen for nursing students.
We have never made decisions about what is paid out from discretionary funds.
But it is not in the guidance.
That the pay-outs should be like-for-like? No.
For those applying now, there is currently no statutory basis for the decisions. Is that correct?
It was decided that SAAS should progress on the assumption that the regulations would be passed. The other option was to ask it to stop assessing applications, which would have created a bottleneck. However, anything that SAAS is doing can be undone.
No payments will be made until after the regulations come into force, although the assessments are being made at the moment. If the regulations do not come into force, the work that SAAS is doing could be reversed.
When are students told what the awards are?
They will already have been given an indication, in some cases. It depends on when they applied. The majority of students who have applied will already have been given an indication of their eligibility.
And when will we know how many students are affected?
SAAS will start to build a picture of roughly what the changes in eligibility might be.
So after the summer recess we will know how many students have been adversely affected.
Without talking to anyone from SAAS or any of our analytical colleagues, it is difficult to say what data SAAS will be able to mine. However, we hope that we will have a better indication of the situation.
Currently, however, awards are being denied on the basis that legislation might well be approved—which is to say, there is no legislative basis for the denial of those awards.
The key point is that no payments have yet been made. We are assessing the awards on the basis that the changes will go through.
So even though the cheque has not been sent, students who have been given an award can appeal it, because there is no statutory basis for an eligibility decision by SAAS.
We made an administrative decision to process awards in anticipation of the regulations being approved. If the regulations are not approved, SAAS will have to reassess all the applicants using the previous means-test arrangements.
This is quite significant. If I were a student—or indeed a lone parent—whose income had been assessed I would be able to challenge my award, because there is no statutory basis for SAAS having made its decision.
Off the top of my head, I am not sure about the legal status of the award letter from SAAS. I do not think that it is a definite statement that that is what someone will get.
Does the Government know?
We would have to look into it and get back to you.
Have legal officers in the Government considered the issue?
We have not looked at that specific point.
So the Scottish Government legal directorate has not considered whether it is legal to send out letters making indicative awards.
The work that we have done to try to get the regulations in place would support this. We have been working quickly to try to address the anomaly in the system and the unfairness—
I understand that, Mr Gray. It is a subjective point whether there are anomalies. Award letters are being sent out, presumably this week—
They will have been sent out.
In the award letters that have been sent out, some students will have had their eligibility changed because of the new requests from SAAS. You are telling us that the Government has not checked whether it is legal for SAAS to make those indicative awards. You need urgently to come back to the committee with clarification. I do not think that there is any more that we can ask at this point. The Government does not know, and nor do we. We need urgent clarification.
Hopefully the officials will take that message back to the minister. It would appear that Mr Purvis's line of questioning has highlighted what could be a considerable concern.
I am not sure how we will address that, because the parliamentary recess is looming. It is clear that the minister will need to answer our questions. I am struck by the contrast between this measure and the measure that we are about to consider. I have every sympathy for SAAS and the Government wanting to be ready to implement policy changes, but presuming parliamentary authority for something can lead to difficult situations, such as the one that we are in now. Like Jeremy Purvis, my concern about the changes is that we may have deterred students who are at university already or who are entering university from proceeding, on the basis of a letter that has no standing. It is a serious matter that the minister will need to address urgently.I am not sure how the committee should proceed, because we cannot do anything before the summer recess. The Government has chosen a big-bang approach, but I am afraid that it has been a bit of a disaster. A big bang without permission is not good. I suggest that we write and ask the minister to suspend the implementation of the regulations immediately. If we go back to the existing regulations, no one will be worse off, whereas, if we go ahead with the planned changes, a lot of students will be worse off. That is the danger so, until the matter is finalised, the safe position would be to revert to the existing legislation right away and for SAAS to contact the students immediately. Either in the Parliament or through the convener, we should ask the minister to withdraw the regulations immediately and ask SAAS to continue with the current system for another year—I assume that it would have to be that long. It is not difficult to ask that we ensure that new students do not have the new system. It is what has been implemented in England and Wales anyway.Can I suggest that as a constructive way forward, convener?
You can certainly suggest it and I am sure that it was meant constructively, but the committee does not have the power to do that. The options that lie before it are to approve or annul the regulations.It is apparent from Jeremy Purvis's line of questioning that there are some legitimate concerns, so I suggest that, rather than ask whether we agree the regulations, I write to the cabinet secretary on the committee's behalf enclosing a copy of the Official Report of the meeting, asking her to reflect urgently on our concerns and requesting that she come to the committee in the first week after the summer recess to answer further questions on the regulations.The consequences of the regulations are not clear and we have not been able to reach a conclusion. You may be right, Mr Macintosh; they may have serious consequences but, equally, they may not. Therefore, the only course of action that is open to the committee is the one that I suggest. I remind members that we have until 8 September to conclude the committee's consideration of the regulations, so it is possible for us to do everything that I suggest. Does the committee agree that that is acceptable?Members indicated agreement.
Mary Mulligan has a question for the officials.
On regulations 9 and 10, to which I referred earlier, am I right in thinking that, when somebody applies for financial assistance, they are asked for information about their income and that that is the basis of the assessment?
Yes.
However, because we have not agreed the regulations yet, there is no legal basis on which you can ask for that information. Is that correct?
I am not sure off the top of my head whether we would need that. We would have to check that with SAAS and our legal colleagues would have to consider further what the legal requirements would be. I cannot answer that question right now, but we can look into it further.
How would SAAS make the assessment if somebody did not provide the information?
It may be that SAAS makes provisional assessments and then seeks further information before it finalises assessments. I do not know whether provisional assessments are made in this case. We will have to check that and get back to you.
When you say "provisional assessments", would SAAS staff base those just on the information that they had in front of them?
Yes.
But they would recognise that that might not be the whole picture, depending on how people responded.
Yes.
I appreciate that it is difficult for the officials to answer, given that they are not dealing with such applications on a day-to-day basis, but I have concerns that are informed by issues that have arisen in my dealings with SAAS.Following Jeremy Purvis's questions, I am concerned that students who have been given an indication of an award may decide on their future on that basis. That is extremely worrying, so the convener's suggested course of action is probably the best that we can do at the moment.
I have another practical suggestion. For the same reason that Mary Mulligan and Jeremy Purvis outlined, single parents and lone-parent families, whose vulnerability to changes in income is well known, will be among those who are affected. Perhaps we should record our expectation—it is certainly my expectation—that SAAS contact each student that it can identify and let them know that the information that they have received so far is only a guide as to what will happen if the regulations go through. It is important that we do not just wait for two months before Parliament reconsiders the matter and that the individuals concerned are contacted and given information on their situation. If that does not happen, they might act on the wrong information and take the wrong decision for their futures.
The committee cannot recommend a course of action to SAAS at the moment, but when the minister reads the Official Report of the meeting, she will realise that we have serious and highly legitimate concerns that people are being placed in an extremely difficult position and might make wrong decisions based on information they have been given. Our letter to the minister can stress the urgency of the situation.
I, too, have a question for the officials. What is the content of the letters that have gone out? Do they contain an indication that the situation might change?
I do not have a copy of an award letter in front of me. In general, whether someone will definitely get an award or whether their award is provisional depends on their circumstances. We can check the position with SAAS and get some copies of the award letters.
It would be good to find out about the content of the letters—that could inform our decision.
It is unfortunate that SAAS is not represented here today. It was up to the Scottish Government to decide which officials came along this morning, but I hope that when the minister appears before the committee in September, serious consideration will be given to bringing along a representative of SAAS who deals with such matters on a day-to-day basis, because such input would be of great assistance to the committee.
I absolutely support the convener's suggestion on the way forward and hope that the process can be expedited. I understand that Ms MacDonald is the divisional solicitor in this area. Tomorrow is the final day of the parliamentary term. I do not know whether it would be possible for us to get any information from the Scottish Government this afternoon on the legal position, but it is of the utmost urgency for those who have received such letters to find out what their legal status is. I agree with Aileen Campbell: we do not know the answer to that, nor does the Government and nor do students. The fact that we urgently need absolute clarity will dictate the letter that we send to the cabinet secretary. I hope that my request is reasonable; clarification is required today.
I am not sure whether Ms MacDonald feels able to respond to that; she might feel that it would be more appropriate for the minister to respond.
It is more appropriate for us to consider our views. I accept Mr Purvis's points on urgency, but points have been raised today that neither I nor my colleagues have had a chance to consider. We may be good, but we may not be able to respond that quickly.
It is important that we write to the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning as a matter of urgency. In the letter, we will stress the committee's serious concerns and the serious potential consequences for students the length and breadth of Scotland, and ask her to consider the issues as a matter of urgency.That concludes our consideration of the regulations on means testing. I suspend the meeting to allow a changeover of witnesses, although I understand that Ms MacDonald will stay with us.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Jun 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 25 June 2008 Committee business · 1
- Scotland's Commissioner for Children and Young People (Annual Reports 2006-07 and 2007-08) Committee business · 38
- Petition Petitions · 159
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 37
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 106
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 44
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.