Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Protection of Children (Scotland) Act 2003 (Amendment of Definition of Child Care Position) Order 2008 (SSI 2008/draft)

Wednesday 4 June 2008 Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Subordinate legislation 38 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

38 contributions
Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

The Minister for Children and Early Years remains with us to discuss the order, but he is joined by other Scottish Government officials: Claire Monaghan is deputy director, children, young people and social care; Moira Oliphant is team leader, disqualified from working with children list team; and Laurence Sullivan is senior principal legal officer, solicitors education, land and pensions division. Minister, I know that this is not your responsibility, but your officials could do with snappier titles. I invite you to make opening remarks.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

Thank you for the opportunity to make an opening statement about the amending order.First, let me make it clear that the Protection of Children (Scotland) Act 2003 was introduced, with cross-party support, to increase the protection of Scotland's children by preventing unsuitable people from working with them through paid work or volunteering. There are now 262 individuals on the list of those who are disqualified from working with children, who have harmed or risked harm to children or who have committed grave offences against children. Those people cannot work with children again or work with children for the first time.Schedule 2 to the 2003 act sets out what is meant by "child care position", which is important in the context of the offence provisions in the act. It is an offence for any person on the list to apply for a child care position and an offence for organisations to offer work in a child care position to someone who is on the disqualified list. Although there is no legal requirement for an individual in a child care position to have a disclosure carried out, the only way of knowing whether someone is on the list is to request a disclosure from Disclosure Scotland, so it is hugely important to ensure that the definition of "child care position" is properly formulated in the 2003 act.That is the background. I will now set out the substance of the amendment. As far as we are aware, the 2003 act—which was introduced by the previous Scottish Executive—was never intended to capture within the scope of work and, therefore, of "child care position" the business of parent councils, where they do not have direct contact with children, or activity that is intended primarily for adults. However, that is exactly the legal position, and we and many others are not comfortable with that.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

To some, it may seem a fairly minor matter: after all, surely it is everyone's business to ensure children's safety at school and to ensure that someone who is on the list of those who are disqualified from working with children cannot be a member of a parent council and contribute their ideas to the work of the school; moreover, it is straightforward to get an enhanced disclosure. However, any such sentiment is misplaced. The fact of the matter is that, with some exceptions, the provisions relating to those in a child care position and disclosure checking should be for those who have the greatest contact with children or who work in close proximity to children. Disclosure is an important part of child protection, but it should not be used inappropriately. Indeed, it is against the law, under the Police Act 1997, to obtain an enhanced disclosure inappropriately. For an organisation to access an enhanced disclosure, it must be appointing an individual to a prescribed post such as a child care position. When disclosure is appropriate, it should, of course, be used alongside good practice in working with children and robust recruitment and child protection policies.Schools, local authorities and colleges can open up their premises to various groups as they see fit. However, unnecessary disclosure checking could act as a barrier to parental volunteering, to volunteering to take adult classes or to participating in a group meeting in a school or college. We are not in the business of having blanket disclosure checking for the sake of it. Schools and, for that matter, colleges are community-based facilities that can even be regarded as belonging to the community. They are respected community assets.The amendment is necessary to remove from the definition of "child care position" the work of members of parent councils that usually meet and conduct their business in schools. It is appropriate that all parental bodies should, without being in a child care position, be able to meet in schools, FE institutions or hostels that are used by pupils who are attending schools or colleges.I make it clear that the amendment does not affect parent council members who work directly with children, for example, through running after-school clubs or other activities that involve children. Such members will, of course, be in a child care position.I know that there has been some concern that the order does not achieve that, but I can assure the committee that it does. The amendment must be seen in the wider context of all of schedule 2 to the 2003 act, which sets out child care positions, and should not be considered in isolation, as that presents a wrong interpretation of new paragraph 2A. The amendment is, in effect, a carve-out from subparagraph (a) of paragraph 1 and new subparagraphs (c), (ca) and (cb) of paragraph 2. I emphasise again that the amendment does not impact in any way on the effect of the remaining subparagraphs of paragraph 1. Therefore, parent council members who, as part of their normal duties, care for children, wherever the caring takes place, are in a child care position. The order has been drafted in the best possible way to achieve the effect that we want. I accept that the Executive note could have included a fuller explanation of that and a new paragraph has been added.The order also removes from the definition of "child care position" work done in schools to the extent that it involves an activity that is primarily intended for adults. The same applies with colleges, except that those lecturers and tutors who are employed by the college will be in a child care position. I am happy to provide you with our reasoning during the debate, but it is certainly disproportionate that the volunteer instructor of an aerobics, flower arranging, weight watchers, photography or information technology class that is primarily intended for adults should be defined as being in a child care position.The amendment replaces "educational establishment" with"a school; a further education institution; a hostel".That mirrors the formulation used in the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007.I believe that the amendments made by the order represent a commonsense and proportionate approach. We are dealing with the issue now by amending the 2003 act because we view the matter as being highly important and we want to end the uncertainty that there has been about the issue. I stress again that the order means that certain positions will no longer be child care ones.We would also consider, at a later date, an amendment to the 2007 act, which would be taken forward in the secondary legislation programme for that act, if approved by Parliament. The wording of any such amendment might be different in order to fit the requirements of that act, but the policy would remain very much the same.I assure the committee that we have widespread support for our proposals. Through a number of engagement events on our plans and by speaking to others, we have secured the support of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland, the Association of Scotland's Colleges, the majority of local authorities, a number of colleges, parental representative bodies and others. I am happy to answer questions.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

I thank the minister for his comments. The committee now has an opportunity to question the minister on the Scottish statutory instrument.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I thank the minister for his explanation. I support—as do, I am sure, other committee members—the minister's intention in bringing forward the order, which is a very important one for many of the reasons that he outlined.The overzealous application of child protection legislation can be detrimental both to the protection of children and to volunteering. As the minister says, a blanket-ban approach can reduce the checks to being a tick-box exercise rather than a device that supports other important checks that are made into the background of people who work with children.It is also highly important that we tackle risk-averse behaviour in our society. The one group that the minister did not mention was MSPs who hold surgeries in schools, who could have been covered by the legislation and clearly now are not, although I imagine that many of us have disclosure certificates for other reasons.The minister will be aware of the correspondence that the committee has received—in fact, he has received it, too. I refer in particular to the correspondence from the Scottish Council of Jewish Communities, which believes that the legislation is still open to misinterpretation. I listened to the minister's explanation carefully and I welcome it. I also sought reassurance myself from the Scottish Parent Teacher Council, which has also written to the committee—the letter was too late to be included in the published papers, but I assume that it will be added—and its interpretation confirms the minister's.We are reassured about the intent, but it may be worth restating the position for finality and to reassure the Scottish Council of Jewish Communities and others about how the legislation will be interpreted. I will give an example that we were given. A person who, as a parent, is a member of a parent council in a school is exempt from a disclosure check as a member of that parent council. Therefore, they would not have to have a disclosure check if they applied for a job as a janitor in another school. I would like the minister's comments on that.I appreciate that the area is complicated, but I am slightly concerned that there is room for misinterpretation. It is important that parent councils throughout the country be reassured about their obligations and that local authorities be clear. We are all aware of some local authorities that are assiduous—perhaps overly so—in their application of the legislation, so it is important that we clarify the matter once more for the record.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

I agree with those sentiments. I made clear in my opening remarks that we want to clear up much of the confusion about whether all parent council members should have disclosure checks. I hope that I have made it clear that they should not, but I am perfectly happy to issue guidance to every parent council and local authority in the country to follow through on that point so that we ensure that the issue is cleared up.Anyone applying for a janitor's job in a school is applying for work in a child care position and, therefore, is legally required under POCSA not to be on the disqualified from working with children list, which would require the local authority or employer to seek an enhanced disclosure certificate. The confusion has perhaps arisen through a misinterpretation of the order and the carve-out from paragraphs 1 and 2 in schedule 2 to POCSA. I hope that that clarifies the situation for you, but I refer you to our legal expert on the panel to follow through on that.

Laurence Sullivan Scottish Government Solicitors Education, Land and Pensions Division
link

I have read the letter from Leah Granat. The legislation does not have to explain every detail. She makes a point about work that a person does in their capacity as a parent council member, and that reflects how the order will be interpreted. A school janitor whose child attends the same school and who is a member of the school's parent council will remain in a child care position in his role as a janitor working in the school. He would not be in a child care position by dint of also being a member of the parent council. The order is entirely a carve-out of schedule 2 to POCSA, and the carve-out applies only to paragraphs 1(a) and 2 of schedule 2. The rest of the hooks in subparagraphs (b) to (i) of paragraph 1 of schedule 2, wherein a person can end up in a child care position, are all entirely unaffected by the order. If a person does not fall within the carve-out, they remain within the generality of child care positions.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I thank the minister and Mr Sullivan for their explanations. It is therefore the case that, although adults engaged in adult business on school premises are exempt, they are exempt only for that purpose and not for any other in which they are in a position of child care supervision.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

Exactly so. I ask Claire Monaghan to make a point or two.

Claire Monaghan Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Division
link

There is a general point around janitors and the detail of the order. There is also a more general issue behind Mr Macintosh's point about the overzealous use of disclosure checking and risk-averse behaviour by bodies when they engage individuals. Obviously, we have Disclosure Scotland oversight responsibilities, now that they have transferred to Government. We have been looking carefully at how to bolster compliance around people who apply for disclosure certificates, to ensure that the requests are legitimate and that authorities or other organisations do not stretch the rules as far as they can. The fundamental reason for that is that the whole vetting and disclosure regime must counterbalance the need to protect children with the rights of the individual and the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974. Therefore, we have bolstered the compliance office in Disclosure Scotland and are working closely with it on the issues that are tripping it up and what that then means for guidance to the sector, so that the guidance that we put out nips all the issues in the bud.There are many big issues around risk-averse behaviour that must be tackled on a number of fronts because they have a sufficiently serious impact on individuals. We are satisfied on the technicalities of the specific point that the Scottish Council of Jewish Communities raised. However, there is a much more general point about ensuring that the vetting and disclosure regime is being used responsibly and for the child protection purposes that it was designed for.

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

It is a positive move that there will be guidance for parent councils, local authorities and schools because concerned parents often ask headteachers about the issue. As the minister knows, parent councils do not just meet as committees: the parents involved often attend school trips and other school activities involving children. For clarity, do normal duties with children include or exclude, for example, irregularly accompanying children on school trips, helping out at school fêtes and being involved in regular school activities that are not part of the normal work environment? It is the case, certainly in rural areas, that parents on a parent council will also be on another school's parent council and will often help at other schools, so there is a mix there.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

The member makes the point well about how complex the area is. Perhaps I can refer his question to Moira Oliphant.

Moira Oliphant Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Division
link

Mr Purvis is right that parents are involved in many different aspects of the life of not only an individual school but other schools, and have many different roles. The formulation refers to normal duties of work in a school, and if a parent's work in a school is pre-planned, rostered and carried out a number of times a year, it would be considered to be a normal duty. For example, if a parent running the school disco, for example, frequently planned that activity, that would be considered a normal duty in a child care position. If parental involvement in the life of the school and working with children is ad hoc and not pre-planned or rostered, it will not come within the scope of normal duties.We plan to issue further guidance in the autumn on child care positions under POCSA. That guidance will give further information on and explanation of normal duties. We recognise that there have been issues around interpretation.

Claire Monaghan Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Division
link

That is the reason why we specifically opted not to make it compulsory for those in a child care position to undergo a vetting check. The offence is to employ someone or to have someone undertaking those duties who is on the barred list.Some members might recall that there was quite a debate on this point when we were taking the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Bill through Parliament. The scheme that has been developed in England and Wales is compulsory, so people who are in child care positions there must be members of the scheme. We opted for an alternative approach because the boundaries will never be crystal clear—it will depend on the predictability of the child care, the extent to which it is rostered and the exact duties that take place. If vetting was to be made compulsory in the Scottish scheme, we would trip over the sort of issues that we have been discussing today much more regularly.The reason for vetting people is to avoid the risk of putting someone in a child care position if they are disqualified from working with children. The number of people on the list is relatively small and we are managing the risk in the best way that we can. Compulsory vetting is much more serious. We are managing the approach to minimise the impact on individuals.

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

If a chair of a parent council wants to err on the side of caution and decides that all members of the parent council should go through a check, that will not be permitted.

Claire Monaghan Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Division
link

That goes back to the point about the compliance office.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

Parent council members are not in a child care position.

Claire Monaghan Scottish Government Children, Young People and Social Care Division
link

If they did additional duties—

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

My point was that, knowing how people operate, the situation is very difficult. Schools do not have a yearly plan showing that parent A will help out on seven school trips, for example. It does not work like that.

Jeremy Purvis LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

The parent council might want to say that all the members who will accompany the children have gone through the disclosure process, so that all parents and everyone in the school can be satisfied. However, that will not happen.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link

I will move us on from the order. Given his responses to Jeremy Purvis's questions—and I associate myself with Ken Macintosh's comments about the importance of disclosure and its use—perhaps the minister will say a bit about how disclosure is not in itself the end of the matter. We have to protect all our children, whether someone has a disclosure certificate or not, and procedures are in place to ensure that they are protected as much as they can be while still being allowed to be children.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

As Ken Macintosh will remember, we had long debates about those points during the passage of POCSA and the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Bill.In itself, the disclosure process does not protect children; people protect children. We must have a system of safe recruitment practices, and children need to be made aware of and have a proper appreciation of risk. That is part of what we should be doing with children more generally, both in our education system and as parents. We should not wrap children in cotton wool, but we must give them an idea of what the risks are and bring them up to have an appreciation of how to assess those risks.Although I very much agree with the thrust of Mary Mulligan's comment, the disclosure process is an important safeguard. The last thing that we want is for people who we know to have evil intentions towards children to be allowed into child care positions whether in a work capacity or a voluntary capacity. We have to get the balance right.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

That concludes our questions.Item 4 is our continued consideration of the draft Protection of Children (Scotland) Act 2003 (Amendment of the Definition of Child Care Position) Order 2008. I ask the minister to move motion S3M-1921.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the draft Protection of Children (Scotland) Act 2003 (Amendment of the Definition of Child Care Position) Order 2008 be approved.—Adam Ingram.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Once again, we have up to 90 minutes to debate the motion. I remind members that the minister will have an opportunity to respond to any points that they make when he responds to the debate. Government officials are unable to contribute to this part of our consideration.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Notwithstanding the slight uncertainty about one part of the order, which we have now clarified, I welcome it and hope that it is part of an on-going process. I know that the children's commissioner and others are engaged in work that will expand on our work on the protection of children. Legislation by itself is not the answer or the only way to address the problem. It is very important that we do not provide a false sense of security through a very widespread disclosure process. I hope that the order is part of an on-going process to explore the child protection system in our country.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

As no one else has indicated that they wish to speak, I invite the minister to make any closing remarks that he might have.

Adam Ingram SNP South of Scotland
link

I give an assurance that what Ken Macintosh suggested is being developed. Obviously, I have regular meetings with the children's commissioner; she has expressed concerns on the matter and we are working together on it.We are looking to commence the Protection of Vulnerable Groups (Scotland) Act 2007 next year, and secondary legislation will follow, which will come to this committee. Committee members can anticipate the debate being developed through that process.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

The question is, that motion S3M-1921, in the name of Adam Ingram, be agreed to.

Motion agreed to.

That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the draft Protection of Children (Scotland) Act 2003 (Amendment of the Definition of Child Care Position) Order 2008 be approved.

Karen Whitefield Lab The Convener · Airdrie and Shotts
link

I suspend the meeting to allow our witnesses to leave and for a short comfort break.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 4 June 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 161
  5. Annual Report Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.