I open the 15th meeting of the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee in 2008. I welcome all members and visitors to the committee and remind everyone present that mobile phones and BlackBerrys should be switched off.Agenda item 1 is consideration of subordinate legislation. I am pleased to welcome Adam Ingram, the Minister for Children and Early Years, to the committee. He is joined by Louise Sutherland, team leader in the higher education governance branch of the Scottish Government, and Helena Janssen, senior principal legal officer in the solicitors education, land and pensions division. Thank you for attending the meeting today. I invite the minister to make some opening comments about the draft Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992 Modification Order 2008.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992 Modification Order 2008 (SSI 2008/draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Adam Ingram SNP 11
- Jeremy Purvis LD 6
- Karen Whitefield Lab 5
- Liz Smith Con 2
- Louise Sutherland Scottish Government Higher Education and Learner Support Division 1
The record
31 contributionsGood morning, colleagues. I am pleased to have the opportunity to outline the need for the modification order.The order is required to address a specific point that has been raised by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator in relation to the charitable status of the post-1992 higher education institutions and the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992. All Scottish higher education institutions are charities and are required to meet the charity test that is set out in the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005. The 2005 act provides that a body will not meet the charity test if its constitution expressly permits ministers to direct or control its activities. OSCR has indicated that it considers that the power in section 47 of the 1992 act, which enables ministers to close a higher education institution, constitutes a ministerial power of control.Ministers consider that it is important that the charitable status of all the institutions in the HE sector is maintained. The order is important for post-1992 institutions, whose charitable status would be at risk from ministers' power to close them. The order therefore modifies the power to close an institution that was established under an act and that has the closure power as part of its constitution. In those cases, closure will be subject to the consent of the governing body.OSCR has indicated that it considers that such a modification represents sufficient mitigation of ministers' power to close an institution and that those institutions will not, therefore, be at risk of failing the charity test.The amended closure power will apply to institutions that were established under the 1992 act, which therefore have the 1992 act and the closure power as their constitution, as defined by the 2005 act.Post-1992 institutions that were established under the Companies Act or which were not established by enactment will need to consider their individual constitutions. Any changes that are considered necessary to ensure that they meet the charity test will be a matter for those institutions and will not require legislation.The order is important to remove the uncertainty about the charitable status of the post-1992 higher education institutions as a result of the ministerial power of control that OSCR identified in the 1992 act. When the closure power is part of the constitution of a higher education institution that was established by enactment, the modified power will apply and the institution will not be at risk of failing the charity test.
Committee members now have the opportunity to raise issues, concerns or questions with the minister. I will ask one question. The Government has taken the right course of action by addressing the concerns that further education establishments raised with the committee about the risk to their funding—their charitable status contributes significantly to their revenue. However, when the Parliament was considering what became the 2005 act, the voluntary sector had strong and robust views about the importance of the independence rule. Did the Government consider that and consult all stakeholders on the position? You are right to respond to the FE sector's concerns, but did you give the wider community in civic Scotland the opportunity to be involved?
The order's focus is narrower even than just FE colleges—it concerns only the post-1992 higher education institutions. I ask my colleague to answer your questions.
The order will not exempt post-1992 institutions from the charity test; rather, it will modify a specific power that OSCR identified in the 1992 act for the institutions concerned. The order will not change the charity test.
When this or another committee considers the order that deals with FE colleges, perhaps the issue that the convener raises could be addressed.
Are you confident that the process for colleges that need to amend their constitutions will not be too difficult and will not involve complications?
I am not aware of problems. All the information that was available to me was that we had just one particular problem with the ministerial power in relation to HE institutions, which the order will deal with. I have no broader indication of significant problems.
So the colleges that I mentioned are not concerned that amending their constitutions could have a detrimental effect on them.
If colleges have such concerns, they have not been brought to my attention.
It is good that the Government has produced the order. I have one question, which is about circumstances that might be rare. Dispute could arise about what ministers wished to do with an institution. If consent were denied, what process would be followed? Ministers will retain a legal power, but it will be amended so that it can be exercised only with consent. What would happen if consent was denied?
The status quo ante would apply in those circumstances. However, I do not imagine that the situation would arise. We have no plans to close any higher education institutions. The situation would be an extreme one. I would hope that the normal processes of discussion and negotiation would lead to a conclusion, but you are correct to say that ministers would not be able unilaterally to close an institution.
In the circumstances that I mentioned, the institution would be able to sustain itself—and access public funds—even though ministers had decided that it was not in the public interest for it to continue. Ministers would have no legal grounds on which to challenge the institution.
If I am permitted to say this, we will cross that bridge when we come to it. We do not have a blueprint for how to deal with that scenario.
The power existed for a purpose, but it is now to be negated. Given that an institution might well withdraw its consent, would it not be better to remove the power? The Government says that it wishes to retain the power because it is there for a purpose, but it will be negated. The purpose of the power is not to deal with an institution that wishes to wind itself up or change its constitution but to deal with a failing institution. OSCR stated that the power constitutes a direction, but it would be a different scenario if it was in the public interest for ministers to exercise their power to close an institution.
I presume that, in the scenario that you describe, a significant public debate would be raging on the performance of the institution. Other pressures can be brought to bear on institutions. I am sure that the influence of ministers would be felt in those circumstances. The scenario that you paint is an extreme one that is unlikely to arise. I appreciate that we would have to think through how to deal with such a situation, but I am sure that we would be able to do so.
I do not deny that it might well be an extreme situation. However, the fact is that you are not repealing the power. In effect, you are making it redundant, which could potentially—
No, I do not think so. The power will be retained, but it will be modified.In that situation, we would engage in dialogue with the board, and it would not be in the board's interest for ministers to make plain their view that they would like to close the institution. Ministers will still have a significant lever to influence boards.
Which gets close to the reason why OSCR was concerned in the first place.
Indeed, but the modification apparently satisfies OSCR.
Thank you for answering the committee's questions.
Motion moved,
That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the draft Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992 Modification Order 2008 be approved.—Adam Ingram.
The Parliament's standing orders allow us to debate the motion for up to 90 minutes. I remind members that they should make points rather than pose questions to the minister, who will have no opportunity to respond to questions.
I understand that the move has the support of OSCR, which is welcome, but I am slightly concerned that it is not clear whether alternative approaches were considered. I am also concerned about being asked to recommend the approval of an order on the basis of an approach of, "We'll cross that bridge when we come to it." I will not oppose the motion, but perhaps the minister will reflect on points that were made about other institutions, which might be relevant to the next such order to come before the committee.
No other member wants to comment, so I ask the minister to make closing remarks.
This order specifically relates to higher education institutions, but the Government will make another one that will relate to FE colleges. I hope that that will happen before the summer recess and I undertake to address the issues that you and Mr Purvis raised prior to that.
Motion agreed to.
That the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee recommends that the draft Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992 Modification Order 2008 be approved.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Jun 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 4 June 2008 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 161
- Annual Report Committee business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.