Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Staffordshire Bull Terriers (PE1396)

Tuesday 6 September 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 29 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

29 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

PE1396 is on the overbreeding and abandonment of Staffordshire bull terriers. Members have the clerk’s note, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and the petition. I welcome the petitioners: Ian Robb is the vice-chairman of Help for Abandoned Animals in Arbroath, Dr Alison Kennedy is the chair of the Perthshire Abandoned Dogs Society, and Lisa Hird is treasurer of Staffordshire Rescue Scotland.I also welcome Graeme Dey MSP, the member for Angus South, who is here to support the petitioners. Mr Dey, if you would like to make some comments after we have taken evidence you are welcome to do so—just let me know. Dr Kennedy will make a short presentation.

Dr Alison Kennedy Perthshire Abandoned Dogs Society
link

Our statement to the Public Petitions Committee is on the issue of the overbreeding, ill treatment and abandonment of Staffordshire bull terriers in Scotland. Thank you for allowing us to present the petition to the committee today.We are here to ask the committee to help us to find a solution to a serious and escalating animal welfare problem that now exists in Scotland. A measure of the progressive nature and compassion of any country is the way in which it treats its animals. Our mission today is to speak up for some creatures that desperately need our protection. They are the many Staffordshire bull terriers, or Staffies, that have in recent times been abused, beaten, neglected, starved and abandoned. They have been trained by certain sections of society to attack, threaten and intimidate, and as a result of that, the Staffie now has a reputation as the devil dog and is shunned and feared by mainstream society.All that is taking place at the same time as the animals are being overbred and cross-bred in large numbers by certain sections of society who either cannot or will not care for them properly and who are interested only in any money that they can make from their sale. We are witnessing a crisis of animal welfare and the reduction of what was a fine breed of dog to pariah status. The Staffie, known for a century as the perfect family pet and the nanny dog because of its love of children and desire to protect them from harm, is now unwanted and seen as something to fear rather than something to love and trust.At the sharp end of the mounting crisis are animal shelters, small and large, all over Scotland. Those charities are under great emotional and financial pressure to cope with the ever-increasing numbers of abandoned Staffies. There are three reasons for that. First, some of the dogs have been so abused and traumatised that they cannot be rehomed and must be put to sleep. When that happens time after time, it can cause great distress, even to experienced staff. Secondly, because of their undeserved devil dog reputation, it can take months to rehome those that can be given a second chance. It can take five or six times longer to rehome a Staffie than other breeds or cross-breeds. Thirdly, the sheer number of abandoned Staffies in circulation because of thoughtless overbreeding by irresponsible people is flooding animal rescue kennels to bursting point.All that is happening at a time when the number of strays of all breeds is also rising steeply. The following statistics were gathered in different ways over various time periods, but they give us a clear view of what is happening all over the country. Small animal charities can no longer accept unwanted dogs from members of the public; they are able only to deal with animals that are in serious distress. That is happening at Brown Street Kennels in Dundee, where staff have recorded a 56 per cent increase in the intake of Staffies during the past four years. Similarly, in Fife, Haven Dog Rescue, Second Chance Kennels and Langdyke Boarding Kennels have recorded increases of 70, 50 and 60 per cent respectively during the same period. They all now have to be selective about the dogs that they take in, which means that many animals will suffer neglect and abandonment in the streets as strays. In Oban, Argyll Animal Aid is taking many more Staffies than it ever did, with 10 per cent of its intake now consisting of this beleaguered breed.As for Staffie rescue organisations in Scotland, they are simply swamped with unwanted dogs. One chairperson, Lady Kay Hamilton, has confirmed that the situation that they face is absolutely terrible and they are now able to take in only emergency cases to foster until new homes are found. She believes that legislation for animal welfare should consider Staffies as a special case.The story is the same with larger charities. The Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals reports that five years ago, in 2006, it took six Staffies into its shelters, whereas last year the number was 529. The SSPCA estimates that 40 per cent of dogs in care in west of Scotland shelters at any one time are Staffies, and that in the east Staffies make up 25 per cent of the total. In the Edinburgh Dog and Cat Home, where it takes three to four months to find a new home for each dog, 35 per cent of all dogs taken into kennel care are Staffies.United Kingdom-wide charities, such as Dogs Trust, also cite a marked increase in the numbers of abandoned Staffies in their Glasgow and West Calder rescue centres. In the first eight months of this year alone, 86 Staffies and crosses of the same breed were taken into the Scottish centres, reflecting the same trend in the rest of the UK.The statistics do not tell all the story. In the Perthshire Abandoned Dogs Society rescue kennels at Forteviot, where around 20 per cent of the intake are Staffies, we witnessed the tragedy of two beautiful dogs, who had been taken away from drug dealers. The animals were so traumatised by cruel attempts to make them aggressive and intimidating that in rage and fear they persistently huddled against kennel bars and walls. Eventually they had to be put to sleep, to end their agony and distress. No nation that cares about animal welfare and legislates to protect animals should permit that to happen.In a recent letter to Richard Lochhead, Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment, Angus Council’s chief executive, Richard Stiff, registered his concern about the recent increase in the number of Staffordshire bull terriers being abandoned in his area. He predicted that if overbreeding is allowed to continue, the only outcome will be that dogs are destroyed in large numbers—in other words, a cull. That is already happening in some English cities and I am sure that we do not want to see it repeated in Scotland.The solution that Mr Stiff suggested is to amend existing legislation or introduce new legislation to control the overbreeding of Staffordshire bull terriers. I am certain that everyone who is concerned with animal welfare in general and the sad case of the Staffie in particular would whole-heartedly agree with him. A solution must be found before the issue disgraces our progressive and compassionate nation.May I leave the committee with a final statistic? On one free advertising website only last week, we counted the advertisements for Staffies and Staffie puppies as follows: under “For stud” there were 31; under “Wanted Staffies” there were 13; and under “For sale” there were 415. We need the Parliament’s help. We do not want to see these lovely dogs overbred and born to die.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much, Dr Kennedy, for your helpful presentation.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

Prior to my visit to Help for Abandoned Animals at Kinaldie in May, I guess that in common with most people I viewed Staffies with considerable suspicion. However, half an hour at the kennels in the company of Ian Robb changed my outlook, not because he suddenly convinced me that Staffies are cute and cuddly but because I found myself beginning to look at not the dog but the individual at the other end of the lead. I forecast that many members will start to do the same thing after today’s meeting. You will come to realise that the case that has been made today is compelling.No one wants to stereotype, but Staffies have become a fashion accessory for people who lead chaotic lifestyles, many of whom would not hesitate to mistreat or abandon their dog. The problem is undoubtedly growing. In May, six out of every 10 dogs that made their way to HFAA were Staffies; the proportion is now about 75 per cent. In the Angus Council area there has been an increase of 100 per cent in the number of abandoned Staffordshire bull terriers since 2006.15:00

It is obvious that the accompanying cost to the rescue centres is extremely oppressive. Help for Abandoned Animals receives from Angus Council £100 per dog that it takes in. So far, that working agreement has brought in £5,400 this year for the centre, which is not an inconsiderable sum, but the vet bills for the Staffies alone over the past 10 weeks have run to £2,100. It costs £160 a time to have a dog neutered or spayed. Of course, as has been said, because of the stigma surrounding this particular breed, it can take in excess of three months to rehome a Staffie—if in fact it can be rehomed.The fear, which was articulated earlier, is that if no action is taken to address this growing crisis, ultimately we could face a culling of the breed, which I do not think that anybody wants. I fully appreciate the challenges that would exist in legislating effectively to tackle the issue, but I contend that a way to tackle it has to be found.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much for that presentation. I now throw it open to the committee to ask questions or raise points on the evidence that we have heard.

Bill Walker SNP Dunfermline
link

Thank you very much for coming to see us today. I am very much a dog lover, despite having two cats in the house. Over the years I have had several Alsatians or German shepherds, which in the past have suffered from having a bit of a reputation—although, fortunately, they have now recovered from that.Your submission confirms to me that there are very few bad dogs, but there are an awful lot of bad people breeding them and abusing them. If we could wave a magic wand, I would like to license every breeder and so on, but it is probably impractical to do all that sort of stuff.I have met a few Staffies, which, when treated properly, are very pleasant dogs.I will ask what is becoming a standard question, if the convener does not mind. Would you rather that the Public Petitions Committee continued the petition and called for further evidence, or that we asked one of our parliamentary committees to look at it immediately? What would be your preference?

Ian Robb Help for Abandoned Animals
link

I would prefer the committee to look at the petition in more depth. You will have to excuse me, because I am losing my voice from all the talking that I have been doing on this subject. Graeme Dey came out to our kennels and I feel that if MSPs went out into their communities to see exactly what was going on in all the rescues throughout Scotland, they would get a proper feel for the situation regarding the Staffordshire bull terriers. We are at crisis point at the moment; the rescue centres are totally full up with the dogs and they are just looking for some help to get out of this situation before it is too late.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Thank you for your very moving presentation. Obviously you are talking about Staffies, but we have also heard from rescues about greyhounds and lots of other unfortunate breeds of dog that have just been used and abused. I noted that in your submission you suggest that we should look at local authorities carrying out investigations or the Government making legislation to chip puppies as they come along. I also noted what you said about dog registration, which we do not have here in Scotland. If we did have it, would that help? Obviously, the problem is that we have unscrupulous breeders. Nobody knows where they are—well, people know where they are, but the authorities certainly do not appear to know where they are or do anything about it.

Dr Kennedy
link

I know that this is a very difficult area. We are a long way from the old dog licence days and it is very hard to enforce these things, but I really do think that the Staffie should be treated as a special case. The number of these animals coming on to the market, as it were—the rescue market—is becoming quite frightening. Is there some way that, through local authority enforcement, there could be some curtailment of illegal breeding of Staffies and Staffie crosses? They are a special case; no other breed of dog is being bred in such large numbers by people who are not breeders. There will be an animal welfare catastrophe if something is not done.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Would any of our other witnesses care to contribute at this stage?

Lisa Hird Staffordshire Rescue Scotland
link

For every dog that we manage to find a home for, there are another 10 waiting to come in. There is just a constant stream of dogs. There are simply not enough homes out there.

Ian Robb Help for Abandoned Animals
link

Until the Government and local councils get to grips with the people who are causing this problem, there will never be a solution. There must be a way of targeting the individuals who have caused this massive problem; I cannot accept that a Scottish Government or local councils cannot get to grips with them to deal with this crisis. It is only one group in society that is affecting this breed, so I cannot understand why that group cannot be targeted in order to cut out the overbreeding of Staffordshire bull terriers.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Mr Dey, do you have anything to add?

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

No—the petitioners have articulated the argument very well.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are there any further questions from other committee members?

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

I thank the petitioners for giving us evidence. Before you came along, I was not fully aware of this issue. Should there be much more public awareness? The Scottish Government or others could look into raising awareness of this issue.

Dr Kennedy
link

There should be more awareness. Only by raising public awareness, and by giving the Staffie a makeover, will we be able to reduce the problem.Earlier, we spoke about a cull. Committee members may or may not have seen the story in The Herald today. There has been a 130 per cent rise in the number of stray dogs being destroyed—despite there being a 9 per cent fall in the number of stray dogs being collected by wardens last year. I do not know whether that has anything to do with the Staffie situation, but I suspect that it does. Some dogs are so traumatised that they cannot be rehomed, and it takes a long time to rehome a Staffie, so more of them may be being put to sleep. Despite a general decrease in the number of stray dogs, more dogs are sharing the fate of being put to sleep.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I thank the petitioners for coming along and highlighting the plight of Staffordshire bull terriers. If memory serves, we have come through a cycle of the overbreeding of certain breeds. A number of years ago it was Border collies, and action has been taken to deal with puppy farms where breeders were overbreeding and inbreeding certain breeds, causing health problems.I am interested in tackling this issue. Yesterday, when covering a similar story nationally, the BBC highlighted the plight of greyhounds. Breeders and trainers often abandon greyhounds, with horrendous consequences. Because greyhounds are tattooed inside their ears when they are bred in Ireland, owners in the United Kingdom cut off the dogs’ ears before abandoning them—so that they cannot be identified by their tattoos. How far should we go in chipping dogs? How can we ensure responsible ownership and breeding of dogs?Staffordshire bull terriers are described as “devil dogs” in some articles, but people in certain sections of society will move on to other breeds. How can we curtail that? Staffordshire bull terriers might be covered by legislation or by action from the authorities, but people will move on to something else and then continue to abuse the breeding of other dogs. I am trying to remember the name of some of the breeds when legislation on the control of dogs was going through. Certain breeds are now in vogue among certain sections of society—breeds that are bigger, more powerful or more alarming looking.How does the panel think that we should deal with this, so that people do not just move on to another breed and so that we can resolve once and for all the overbreeding of certain breeds?

Ian Robb Help for Abandoned Animals
link

I think that there should be a national register of people who want to breed each breed of dog. Every puppy that is born should be microchipped; the breeder who is making all the money from the sale of the puppies should be made to microchip every puppy before it is sold. There is a database with all the microchipped numbers on it, so this should work in the same way as the documentation for a car. When every puppy is microchipped, its registration number is there. When the owner sells it on, they should be held responsible for ensuring that the registration passes to the new owner. If they do not inform the microchip company, so that the puppy can be reregistered, they should be liable to be given a spot fine, which would make them accountable for passing on or selling the dog without notifying the microchip company. That is the way forward.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That certainly seems a sensible solution. Thank you for that. I am afraid that we are running out of time, so if there are no further questions from my colleagues, I ask them to consider how they wish to take forward the petition. The options available to us are set out in the note by the clerk.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

There are a number of options open to us. There is the suggestion that Bill Walker made. The remit of one of the parliamentary committees—the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee—covers animal welfare. I do not know what the timescale is and we will have to ask the clerks whether that committee is carrying out other investigations, but it has the power to investigate. I do not know how much of a backlog that committee has, given its other work.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

My understanding from the clerk is that we do not think that it is doing any work in that particular area. So, the suggestion is that we refer the petition to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee. What is the view of other committee members?

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we tackle this issue on our own before we refer it on to another committee. There are questions to ask the Scottish Government about the issues that the petitioners raise. We really need to get the Scottish Government to look at the issues and we should find out whether there are any proposals to extend the Control of Dogs (Scotland) Act 2010. That legislation is part of this, because it is not just about the handling and control of dogs in public but about how they are dealt with in private. Clearly, the overbreeding of dogs that is taking place is taking place in private, where a lot of the issues are being hidden. I suggest that we refer the matter to the Scottish Government.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That of course does not rule out our referring the petition to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee in the longer term, but I think that you are suggesting that we do a bit more homework first.

Bill Walker SNP Dunfermline
link

I agree with John Wilson. I do not want to make this a bigger project, but there is an issue about the registration of all dogs. I was perhaps a bit flippant in saying how expensive that would be earlier on, but the system could be self-financing through a levy on the breeders. Where the issue starts is with the uncontrolled breeding of all dogs. In a couple of years’ time, the problem could be with another breed of dog. My colleague John Wilson is not as old as me, but I remember dog licences. I thought at the time that it was crazy to do away with the dog licence. However, technology moves on and perhaps we can use it in a system that is self-funding.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do committee members agree to continue the petition in line with the clerk’s paper and the additional points that John Wilson made?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank the committee for that recommendation. I also thank our witnesses—Mr Robb, Dr Kennedy, Ms Hird and Mr Dey—for attending and giving evidence.We will suspend for two minutes to allow new witnesses to come aboard.15:14 Meeting suspended.

15:16 On resuming—

  1. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 30
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 21
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 29
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 29
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.