Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Lochboisdale-Mallaig Ferry Service (Reintroduction) (PE1394)

Tuesday 6 September 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 21 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

21 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

PE1394 deals with the reintroduction of the Lochboisdale to Mallaig ferry service. Members will have the note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and the petition. I welcome our guests. We have with us Huw Francis, chief executive, and Angus MacMillan, chairman, of Stòras Uibhist; and I would particularly like to welcome Councillor Allan Henderson, the provost of Lochaber, from Highland Council. I invite Mr Francis to make a short presentation of no more than five minutes, after which we will move to questions. For the record, I should say that in my previous existence as a member of the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee, I was involved in initiating the ferry inquiry, which took evidence on the strong case for this particular ferry service.

Huw Francis Stòras Uibhist
link

Thank you for inviting us here today; we are pleased to be here. The islands of Eriskay, Benbecula and South Uist are some of the most remote and economically fragile areas of Scotland. In the 21st century, it is unacceptable that the only direct ferry service from South Uist to the mainland of Scotland operates only four days a week and can take up to 7.5 hours to reach Oban—the worst provision of any lifeline ferry service in Scotland.It is the stated policy of the Scottish Government to reduce regional inequality and create a fairer, healthier society for its population. The islands of Eriskay, Benbecula and South Uist have seen a sustained reduction in transport links and services for generations, which has resulted in economic decline and depopulation, as well as rural deprivation and high levels of fuel poverty.Improved transport links will support the local economy and boost the committed efforts of an island community that has been working towards its own economic regeneration by taking ownership of the South Uist estate in 2006. Since the community purchase of the island estate, Stòras Uibhist, in partnership with Comhairle nan Eilean Siar, Highlands and Islands Enterprise and the Scottish Government, has directly secured more than £20 million of investment from the public and private sectors. Further investment from local, national and international companies has also supported the local economy.However, the poor transport links continue to constrain the benefits that would be brought to the islands from that investment. The highly successful implementation of the road equivalent tariff has boosted visitor numbers to the Hebrides but has resulted in ferry services being stretched and potential passengers being turned away by Caledonian MacBrayne when ferries are booked to capacity. Frequently, the constraint on capacity results in potential ferry users being deterred from travelling to the Western Isles at all because desired sailings are fully booked. Hotel operators regularly report bookings being cancelled because potential guests cannot book a ferry to reach the islands. With a frequent, daily ferry service to Lochboisdale, the constraints on the tourism sector would be significantly reduced, particularly on the important Saturday changeover day.Island residents and business users find that, for many sailings, CalMac ferries will not take further bookings, particularly at short notice, because the sailings are booked to capacity. That impacts on economic activity and the quality of life for island residents. A Lochboisdale-Mallaig ferry service would significantly cut travel times for business users, tourist visitors and residents on all the major routes to Glasgow, Edinburgh and Inverness. That would not only bring economic and social benefits to the islands, but contribute significantly to the Scottish economy and the Scottish Government’s emissions targets.Historically, Mallaig harbour has operated services to Lochboisdale. However, despite the fact that the Fort William to Mallaig road has been upgraded at the cost of millions of pounds and is billed as the road to the isles, there is no ferry service operating to the Western Isles at all. The reintroduction of a Lochboisdale-Mallaig ferry service would significantly boost the economy of Mallaig and the surrounding area, through increased footfall and spend in the local economy. Previous experience of introducing ferry routes has demonstrated that there would be an uplift in users across the range of ferry services. The interisland services between Barra and South Uist and Berneray and Harris are prime examples of that.The Scottish Government recently purchased the MV Finlaggan for Caledonian MacBrayne Ltd to operate on the service to the island of Islay, so an additional vessel is now available in the fleet to improve services to the residents of Scottish islands. It would be a betrayal of the island communities if that spare boat was sold or tied up and left idle when it could be working for the people of Scotland.Comhairle nan Eilean Siar recently completed another consultation on ferry service provision. The overwhelming response from the people of South Uist and Eriskay was for the reintroduction of the Lochboisdale-Mallaig ferry service. The community of Benbecula, Eriskay and South Uist call on the Scottish Government to make best use of its assets in the current economically difficult times to support the people of Scotland’s islands as they strive for economic and social regeneration in one of Scotland’s poorest regions. The reintroduction of the Lochboisdale-Mallaig ferry service in the summer of 2012 should be a priority for the Scottish Government.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that presentation. From reading the briefing on your petition, I see that the Scottish transport appraisal guidance—STAG—assessment, which is the mechanism that the Scottish Government uses to assess routes, was positive. One issue, which has been raised by the petitioners, is the lack of suitable vessels. My understanding is that Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd—CMAL—is responsible for searching for and acquiring vessels and providing them to CalMac. Is that your understanding? Will you say more about what a suitable vessel would be? It is clear that getting the right type of vessel for the route is vital for economic development.

Huw Francis Stòras Uibhist
link

You are correct that the STAG appraisal cited a requirement for a new vessel. CalMac included the provision of the service to Lochboisdale from Mallaig as part of the tender for the Clyde and Hebrides ferries contract, but it cited the need for a new boat. With the Finlaggan now in the CalMac fleet, there is capacity available. We believe that that capacity should be used on the Lochboisdale-Mallaig route.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Would there be a strong market for pedestrians on the route, or is it predominantly a vehicle service that you have in mind?

Angus MacMillan Stòras Uibhist
link

It is both. The route is essentially for passengers, but it is also for freight and the tourism industry. Over the years, we have been served at two ends of the islands by triangular routes, which have failed all the communities. The essential thing in delivering ferry services is the time at which they depart, particularly from the island port. That is what supports the fishing, fish farming, tourism and, even more important, the Hebrides range, which has just been given further investment through the United Kingdom Ministry of Defence. All those things are being stifled. For example, people are trying to sell fish four days a week, but that just does not work. We are trying to attract tourists, but they do not know on which day or when the ferry will sail. Those are the essential impediments that are causing difficulties.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

On freight, you make the important point that time is crucial. As you will well know, the long-awaited and welcome upgrade of the Mallaig road makes a big difference to the timings involved for freight.

Huw Francis Stòras Uibhist
link

For freight, the timing implications are obviously huge. The shelf life of fish and shellfish is hugely important and the quicker the product gets to market, the more valuable it is. A lot of the shellfish caught on the islands go for export, which boosts Scotland’s export potential. That is important for the Scottish economy as well as for the island economy.

Bill Walker SNP Dunfermline
link

It is nice to meet you, and thank you for coming. I am a great backer of ferries. Obviously, like most Scots, I love your part of the world. Is the reason for the ferry not being reintroduced simply—to put it crudely—a lack of money from the public or private sector, or have rational reasons been given for why it is not a good idea?

Angus MacMillan Stòras Uibhist
link

There are no rational reasons for it. In fact, it is irrational that the ferry has not been introduced. A journey time of seven and a half hours from Oban is a nonsense in this day and age, as is a service on four days a week. A three-hour service between Lochboisdale and Mallaig would serve not only South Uist, Eriskay and Benbecula but the whole Outer Hebrides chain, because it would allow other ferry activity. It would increase opportunities in the mainland areas of Lochaber as well.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I very much support shorter journeys, which would enable me to get from Glasgow to the Western Isles or beyond more quickly. I have a couple of questions because, unlike the convener, I am not familiar with the ferry situation. You mention in your submission that there was a proposal in 2008 for the reintroduction of the ferry link and that the minister said that £1 million would be available to facilitate that. However, the proposed vessel—I do not know what it was—was apparently not suitable for the route. What was the matter with the proposed vessel? What happened to the £1 million? Is it still available?

Huw Francis Stòras Uibhist
link

The proposed vessel was a former CalMac vessel that operated the route many years ago. It was privately owned and we wanted to bring it back on to the route. The minister told us that money was available, so we made our proposal. However, it was deemed that, due to some new legislation, the vessel was not suitable and it seemed that the money would not be available by the time a new vessel came along.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I hope that we can raise that issue with the minister. I want to clarify another point. You said that your proposed service could be incorporated in the CalMac service. Does that mean that you would not necessarily need another vessel? You point out in your submission that a ship has become available. Does that mean that you could utilise that ship rather than existing ferries?

Huw Francis Stòras Uibhist
link

Since we submitted a proposal in 2008, a new vessel—the MV Finlaggan—has come into the CalMac fleet. That replaced the boat that was being used on the route. The MV Finlaggan has gone back into the fleet and its capacity is available for use.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

My experience from the ferry review by the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee is that there is a gap concerning who is responsible in the public sector for locating and developing new routes. Certainly, when I met the CalMac board, they referred me to Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd. When I spoke to them, they referred me back to the operator. So, there is a gap there. I know that a route such as Gill’s bay has a private sector operator. Perhaps the Scottish Government’s ferry review could develop something on how we proceed on the issue of that gap. The wider question, which we do not have time to explore today, concerns the acquisition of new vessels. Certainly, in the past, there was a long lead-in time for that because of the shortage of engine parts. However, I think that the situation has changed. For example, the provision of the new CalMac vessel took three to four years from start to end. It is clearly important to get the right vessel for the right route.14:45

Angus MacMillan Stòras Uibhist
link

We are asking for the matter to be referred to the minister because he has the ability to decide on a new route and because clearly it is up to him to include this route in what he asks Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited and CalMac to do. That is our understanding. I hope that that helps.

Councillor Allan Henderson Highland Council
link

I realise that in your case, convener, I am preaching to the converted, because you were very much involved in the initial stages. So much money has been spent on the improvements to the A830, for which we are very thankful, and we now have great links between Mallaig and Fort William. It really has become a transport hub for the whole of the west coast. Traditionally in the islands you would have had fishermen—deep sea men, actually—coming through Mallaig and then going south to their jobs; now we have workers in the offshore oil industry, who are heading for the east coast, and such hubs will be quite important in ensuring a much quicker direct journey from Lochboisdale to Mallaig, then to Fort William and on to the east coast. People could pick up buses, which run frequently—indeed, every two hours—either to Inverness or, if they wanted to go south, to Glasgow.On the back of the investment in the A830, we already have a new marina in Mallaig, which we did not have before. Moreover, we have had a complete turnaround in the way of thinking of the Mallaig Harbour Authority, which always had a presumption in favour of fish because the dues on that side were higher. As everyone knows, the fishing industry is struggling and, as Angus MacMillan pointed out, people have to get their stuff to market as quickly as possible, especially if they are coming from the Western Isles. They do not want it to be on the road for too long.Mallaig now sees that it has to diversify from the fishing industry as well as embrace the tourism industry. We have also had investment from the fish-farming industry because, as it moves offshore, it will be taking more and more stuff through the west coast and Mallaig and will need to be able to get it out to its new west coast locations.

Bill Walker SNP Dunfermline
link

I think that our guests have put forward a very impressive case, which, broadly speaking, I support. Indeed, I am concerned that nothing has been done about it. I might be jumping the gun a bit, but I hope that we will refer the petition to the minister.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It was certainly my thought that we should continue the petition and seek views from the Scottish Government in light of the recommendations in the clerk’s paper. That would be useful.If members have no other comments, I ask the committee whether the suggested course of action is agreed.Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Councillor Henderson, Mr Francis and Mr MacMillan for attending the meeting and giving us very helpful evidence. We will continue the petition and seek further information from the Scottish Government with regard to the suggestions that were made earlier.I suspend the meeting for two minutes for a changeover of witnesses.14:48 Meeting suspended.

14:49 On resuming—

  1. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 30
  2. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 21
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 29
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  5. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 29
  6. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  9. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.