The next item of business is another section 23 report from the Auditor General, for which he is joined by Graeme Greenhill and Michael Oliphant.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Scotland’s public finances: addressing the challenges”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mr Black 14
- Hugh Henry Lab 10
- Colin Beattie SNP 2
- Murdo Fraser Con 2
- Mark McDonald SNP 2
- Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland 1
- Humza Yousaf SNP 1
The record
32 contributionsAs I am sure members know, “Scotland’s public finances: addressing the challenges” was published last month. It follows on from an earlier report, “Scotland’s public finances: preparing for the future”, which we produced in November 2009. Given the challenges that will be facing public finances for the foreseeable future, it must be likely that Audit Scotland will continue to produce interim reports on how the public sector is managing those challenges.I emphasise that this report provides a high-level overview, covering the whole public sector. We will do our best to answer any questions that members might have, but it will be difficult for us to drill down too far because of the nature of the report. However, I am sure that Graeme Greenhill and Michael Oliphant can help us with that.I will touch on the three main themes in the report. The first is the current financial climate and how much money is available, the second is an overview of some of the main cost pressures, and the third is what public bodies are doing to address the challenges that are ahead. I will not dwell on the first part, because everyone in the room will be well aware of the challenges that face the public sector, but I will remind members of the headline numbers. Through the public spending review period to 2014-15, the Scottish departmental expenditure limit budget, which is the money that the Scottish Government controls, will reduce by approximately £3.3 billion, which is 11 per cent. That is a big turnaround from the first 10 years of devolution in which each year there was real growth of something over 5 per cent. We have certainly passed a significant tipping point in the Scotland’s public finances, and all the expert opinion is that we are facing a period of difficulty for many years to come.All parts of the public sector will have less to spend in 2011-12 than they had in 2010-11, although the level of budget reduction varies among the spending areas. In exhibit 6 on page 13 of the report, we have tried to give an account of the main areas of spend—called the portfolio level in Government jargon—and what is happening to each of those. We will do our best to answer any questions about what is happening there if members are interested in that.I will concentrate a bit more on the cost pressures in the public sector. The November 2009 report was particularly helpful in bringing together for the first time in one place the build-up on the cost side of the public sector. That was a serious challenge for us all. We have tried to update that to the best of our ability in the new report, and that might be particularly useful in advance of the publication of the spending review later this month. That section starts on page 16.We have categorised the cost pressures into six areas. They are not mutually exclusive; there are overlaps. We have identified demand pressures, finance pressures, workforce pressures, investment pressures, pressures in maintaining existing assets, and environmental pressures. It behoves me, as the Auditor General, to give bad news and I am afraid that, in this case, the picture is not great. There is a very serious issue to do with how the public sector will cope with the challenge against an 11 per cent reduction in DEL over the spending review period.I will remind committee members of some of the pressures. A significant pressure—and one that has been with us for a few years now—is the ageing of the population. The number of people who are aged 75 or over is set to almost double by about 2030. That will have serious implications. The ratio of older people to people who are active in the workforce is currently 31:100. That will rise to 40:100 by 2030.What implications will there be for our public services? Fewer people will be around to deliver care to older people who need it. Fewer people will be contributing to pensions. Fewer people will be contributing significantly to tax revenues, national insurance payments, and so on. A larger proportion of tax revenues from people of working age will be needed for pensions and national insurance for others; those working people will be contributing more to national insurance, and that will reduce their disposable income. A greater proportion of tax revenues will probably have to go on paying for care for people in need. It is a very serious issue indeed. A question that I am entitled to ask—although I cannot provide a solution—concerns the extent to which we can continue with our existing models of care provision against the background of a scenario that is approaching fast, or is already here.Demand for services that are free at the point of delivery continues to rise. In round terms, we estimate that they cost about £870 million at the moment. I will consider one example: we produced a report on the national concessionary travel scheme a little while ago, in which we forecast that the uncapped cost of the scheme—in other words, the cost if the scheme is not altered but carries on indefinitely—could reach anything between £216 million and more than £500 million by 2025. Assumptions were made in arriving at those figures but, nevertheless, they give an indication of the challenges.Some other demands are difficult to control. In higher and further education, we had 8,000 more students in 2009-10 than we had in 2008-09. That was partly a result of the lack of employment opportunities, but I presume that it was also a result of young people and others coming back to study because they felt the need to maximise their marketability through training. That has implications for the funding of higher and further education.There have been targets for efficiency savings for a number of years now. The previous Government, and the Scottish Executive before that, imposed targets for efficiency savings on the public sector. By and large, the results reported by the public sector are encouraging. Efficiency savings have been identified. That has been difficult for us to audit because of the quality of the information but, as we move further into the period of retrenchment, the risk must increase that efficiency savings will have an impact on service delivery. We need to be aware of that.Inflation is much higher than it was expected to be when plans for public expenditure were being prepared. For example, in the health budget, spending on drugs—whether administered in hospitals or issued by general practitioners—tends to rise by between 4 per cent and 11 per cent on past trends. That is significant inflation, and it must be accommodated in the budget. Although that budget is increasing marginally in cash terms, it is not taking full account of pressures building up in the system.All public bodies are witnessing reductions in other sources of income. User charges and fees are tending to go down. We give the example of what has been happening with asset sales in councils. In 2006-07, local authorities raised almost £500 million for capital spending from asset sales. By 2010-11, the estimated figure was under £150 million. That represents quite a big change.There has, quite rightly, been much interest and talk in the media about public sector pay freezes. The pay bill accounts for about 60 per cent of the revenue budget of the Scottish Government. The point that we are trying to make in this report is that even a pay freeze will not prevent the pay bill from going up because it applies only to the annual cost of living rises that people generally look forward to and does not affect movement up scale points. In parts of the public sector, some quite complex and expensive pay deals are in place. Indeed, in the past, I have reported to the Public Audit Committee on the costs of the consultant contract, the general medical services contract and so on, which are substantial in the Scottish public sector.11:15
Public sector pension schemes are under very significant long-term cost pressures. In a report that we put before the last Parliament on this issue, we described the increases in employers’ contributions. That has been followed by increases in employees’ contributions and, of course, the UK Government has recently announced that it will accept the recommendations of the independent Hutton commission. It is too early to say what impact all the pensions changes will have, but this is certainly a very large cost pressure.I am sure that members are well aware that, as part of the public spending reductions through to 2014, capital spending will take a particular hit, with a 36 per cent reduction over the period. As I said earlier, income from asset sales is also coming down, which I think will mean a severe retrenchment in public spending. At a time when it is facing such a reduction, the Scottish Government has 182 major capital projects planned, with a combined estimated value of somewhere in the range of £13 billion to £15 billion. It has committed to using the non-profit-distributing private finance method and has earmarked £2.5 billion in what is in effect a top slice for that but, nevertheless, there is clearly going to be a significant shortfall.There are also some signs that local authorities and others will try to use revenue funding to compensate for the reduction in capital allocations, and auditors will keep an eye on that issue to ensure that whatever financial strategies are put in place are sustainable in future. In the report, we comment on the build-up of private finance initiative commitments, which will reach more than £1.1 billion in cash terms by 2024-25.In our last report, we made quite an issue of the backlog of maintenance and repairs in the Scottish public sector. Perhaps I should reinforce what I said to the committee back then, because I feel quite strongly about this: this is not just an accounting issue that we keep coming back to. In effect, what we are doing is using assets and depreciating their value. Quite frankly, some of them are getting past their usable condition and we are simply passing the problem on to future generations. It is an intergenerational transfer issue. In the past, we have talked about the need to spend about £2.25 billion to eliminate the defects on Scottish roads; about the costs of removing the backlog of maintenance of council-owned property assets, which amount to £1.4 billion; and about the NHS estate, which needs more than £500 million. I could go on, but all I will say is that this is a very significant problem and intergenerational transfer issue that we need to be aware of.Finally in this particular section, we outline certain environmental issues. In reports that we have produced on energy, we have found that public sector spending on energy increased dramatically by 21 per cent in real terms between 2006-07 and 2008-09. However, energy use has not declined. Of course, that increase largely reflects trends in energy prices. All expert opinion, including the UK Department of Energy and Climate Change, estimates that fuel costs will continue to rise over the next 10 years by as much as 35 per cent on average. That would mean, for example, that a litre of fuel would cost 162p. That is another pressure that is very difficult to control, because it is difficult for a lot of public bodies such as hospitals to contain their costs. It all links back to my earlier pessimistic comment about the decline in capital spending because, with the likelihood of a significant reduction in capital spending, it will be more difficult to sustain a spend-to-save approach to energy bills. The Scottish Government has set some ambitious energy targets, the cost of meeting which over the next decade has been estimated by the independent budget review at around £8 billion.I will come to a halt very soon, but I just want to point out to a committee that is coming to some of these issues for the first time some of the huge cost issues that are set out in the third part of the report. I will be very brief and we will, of course, answer questions afterwards.With regard to addressing these challenges, we note that pretty well all public bodies have managed to balance the budget for the current year. However, all the anecdotal evidence that I am getting suggests that things are getting very tough now. There are some risks out there, which the auditors will monitor.We have not seen much of an attempt to try to rethink the core priorities within the Scottish Government’s national performance targets, the single outcome agreements and so on and to put money where it is most needed. It occurred to me that transport for health and social care is a classic example of this. We do not even know what money is spent on it, but we do know that public bodies are cutting flexible budgets where they can to meet this balanced budget target. We do not have any detailed evidence on this but, unless a priority-based approach is taken, we will be trying to achieve marginal reductions to balance budgets at a time when more than 60 per cent of costs are staff costs. That will be quite difficult to sustain in the longer term without rethinking service delivery, particularly with new challenges such as the ageing population.In the report, we describe how public bodies have tended to concentrate on reducing staff numbers as quickly as they can through voluntary early severance agreements, retirements, natural turnover and so on. That can take one so far, but it is not straightforward. For example, public bodies have lost quite a lot of senior staff in key areas such as finance. When I was a local authority chief executive, which I was for many years, the first question I asked myself when I was thinking about joining a local authority—which I did twice—was, “How strong is the finance function?” Did it have a good strong director of finance who sat alongside the chief executive and knew the numbers well? A lot of experience has gone out the door in a short time just as we have reached this tipping point. Good workforce planning has to look not only at how old people are and whether we can get them out the door quickly but at the skill mix that will be needed. That will require finding a new way of thinking about these things.In conclusion, we have set out one of our checklists in appendix 4 on page 38, which we hope will help councillors, non-executives and public sector leaders in general to ask the right sort of questions in their own organisations.
Thank you very much. That was a very thorough and sobering presentation. In many respects, what lies before us is frightening. In which of the next few financial years will we see the greatest cuts in public expenditure?
At the moment, the greatest reduction will happen in the current year. In fact, exhibit 4 on page 10 of the report shows that we are currently in that situation. As members will see, the dark blue line, which is the lowest on the chart, declines steeply between 2010-11 and 2011-12; gets slightly shallower between 2011-12 and 2012-13; and then declines again towards the end of the spending review. There is no doubt that the reductions in the Scottish DEL budget will be significant over the period. Of course, it remains to be seen how the spending review, which the Scottish Government is about to announce, will be shaped through to the end of the spending review period.
Although you are saying that the most significant cut is in this financial year, exhibit 4 shows a more shallow decline in 2011-12 and then a very steep decline. In fact, if we are basing our analysis on exhibit 4, bad as the situation is this year, it is not as bad as it is going to be next year and the year after.
I think that you are correct in absolute terms. The budget in 2014-15 will be lower in real terms than it is in 2011-12 but, as Bob Black said, in percentage terms, the cut is bigger between 2010-11 and 2011-12 than it is in subsequent years.
Are we living beyond our means?
I would refer you back to my comment about the build-up of demand pressures. The central question is how to set out priorities so that the public services that we deliver are of the right quality, are delivered to the right client groups and are affordable over the longer term.
But there is a real danger that the promises that are being made and the aspirations that we have are simply not affordable.
There is certainly a build-up of spending commitments. In this report, we have evidence of the extent of that, which is very significant.
You said that public bodies are addressing this problem in two ways: a pay freeze and redundancies. However, redundancies have both short and long-term costs. When people go out the door early, under early retirement deals, there is a continuing cost to the public body of subsidising those deals. Presumably there is also a cost to the pension fund. What we have seen in the past is that some of the people who go out the door under such deals then come back into the public sector in different disguises—working for different organisations doing slightly different things but, nevertheless, still clearly capable of carrying out a productive role. I think that I have raised this issue before, but has any work been done on the costs of redundancy and early retirement and whether the short-term fix might lead to long-term problems?
As you might remember, not that long ago we produced a report on the overall position with the public sector pension schemes in Scotland, so that is on the record. We would be very happy to offer a refresher briefing on that for the committee if necessary but, of course, it predated the Hutton report and other changes to the schemes. It highlighted—we have reproduced the high-level numbers in the report—the very significant cost that will have to be met of sustaining public sector pensions, although it is a moving picture and the change from the retail prices index to the consumer prices index is making a significant difference to the actuarial estimates of the liabilities.On how public bodies take decisions on these matters, it is fundamentally a best-value question—if people are being given payments to release early before the normal retirement age, value for money should be demonstrated. In other words, it should be demonstrated that, within a reasonable period, there is a payback that is sustained into the future. I would expect auditors to satisfy themselves that that was happening and to report it if it was not happening. We do keep an eye on those things.People have terms and conditions of services, which both the employer and employee signed up to. It would be a breach of contract to do anything other than honour those requirements. It is a tough issue for employers to address.
You suggested that capital spending could be down by, I think, 36 per cent. You said that the Scottish Government has 182 projects, with a value of between £13 billion and £15 billion, but you indicated that there is a significant shortfall. Are you suggesting that the money is not there for all the projects that are in the pipeline?11:30
I am not suggesting that. All that I am saying is that, at present, the Scottish Government has more than 180 major capital projects planned or in progress, the estimated value of which is £13 billion to £15 billion. Given the scale of the reduction in capital spending that will be required, there must be every prospect that the Scottish Government will have to think seriously about its priorities and about which projects will go ahead and which might have to be put on the back burner, as the saying goes.
So it might be that not all the projects that are on the books are affordable.
That is highly likely.
link
I was a bit alarmed by section 91 on page 29, which is on shared resources. Many councils anticipate substantial savings from arrangements to share resources with neighbouring councils. The statement that“evidence of savings is limited”is a bit of a worry because councils are investing quite a lot of money in such measures. I know of councils that are putting several million pounds into shared services in anticipation that, down the line, there will be a long-term benefit. It is a worry if there is no evidence so far that that level of savings will be produced.The paragraph distinguishes between improving the efficiency of front-line services and back-office functions. Obviously, both present opportunities to save money. Is there evidence that greater savings can be gained by improving the efficiency of back-office functions compared to the delivery of front-line services, or is that immaterial?
It is fair to say that we do not have the audit evidence for that, so I am sorry but I cannot help you terribly much on that.On the first part of your question, the report mentions the business case for shared services that was produced by seven of the eight Clyde valley councils. The business case, which was produced recently—in August of this year—proposed that the councils could generate savings of £30 million a year after five years, but that that requires an up-front investment of between £28 million and £31 million over the first five years. That significant initiative is currently the subject of discussions on whether and how it can be implemented. However, we can see that, even if the project goes ahead and the business plan holds together well, it will be some time before there is a net saving. That is the sort of problem that the public sector often faces—up-front investment is needed to generate savings.I will take a flyer and say that, in relation to front-line services, there is not really scope for significant savings in the administration costs of delivering those services. What really matters is the big spend on the front line where, understandably, people are concerned to maintain standards of service. It is interesting that the major services of education and social work are already having significant reductions in staffing, as is itemised in part 3 of the report. That will have an implication for the sustainability of the service models in the longer term.
link
The report highlights the substantial element of risk in sharing services. Councils are making huge investments in shared services, yet the example that you gave involved the possibility of a £30 million saving after a period, but an up-front investment of £29 million or £30 million. That does not seem a huge return from a sharing of resources over a period, given the risk of committing that money up front and the fact that public service contracts do not always seem to generate the benefits that one would hope for—there does not seem to be much of a margin there. Will Audit Scotland focus some of its efforts on ensuring that councils are getting value for money from shared services? As I said previously, a lot of councils see it as a significant way forward through which they will garner huge savings, but there are risks involved.
It is an area that we will continue to monitor through the audit process, but the decision on whether to opt for the shared services model is a policy matter for the bodies concerned. We can play a role in providing an independent audit and commentary on how well the business plans have been put together and whether the savings have been achieved. However, as I remarked earlier and as is reflected in the report, there is not much evidence—your question reflects this—that such initiatives will produce substantial savings in the short term.
That highlights a real problem. It is not your responsibility and we, as members of the public and elected members, are not directly involved in those decisions. Nevertheless, we are all investing a great deal of faith in the ability of those organisations to get it right. You suggest that there is not a lot of evidence to support the model and Colin Beattie is quite right to talk about the risks. The problem is that, due to the nature of the job that you are responsible for, your main comments will come after the event. It is worrying that we are entering a process from which, we are told, there are huge savings to be made, but it appears that there is no evidence of that and we will not be able to challenge the people who make the decisions until after they have been made. By that time, huge amounts of money could have been squandered, jobs will have been lost and services will have been affected. Perhaps that is something for the Government rather than Audit Scotland to consider.
link
My question follows on neatly from the convener’s comments. On page 33, from paragraph 106 onwards, the report talks about the need for strong leadership. For some reason the issue of leadership has been very much on my mind over the past few days. If we are to deliver financial savings, there will need to be strong leadership in the public sector in areas such as local government. I was taken with what you said, Mr Black, about your previous experience in local government. Are the skills there? We have seen some evidence from the public sector that there is a tendency to opt for what we might call the easy hit when it comes to making cutbacks. Perhaps a more considered, long-term strategic approach is required. Do we have people in position with the ability to take that more strategic approach?
I will be bold in my reply to that question, as it merits that. When I use a phrase such as “strong leadership”, I am talking about elected representatives and chief executives working together. I am absolutely convinced that, both within our political parties and within the senior levels of executive leadership in public bodies, there is bags of talent. Since our first overview of public finances, I have spoken at lots of meetings and conferences and I have attended dinners at which I have interacted with chief executives and so on. There are plenty of people out there with good ideas and a commitment to the public sector, but we need to find somewhere where we can get a good conversation going about how we—all of us together—will face up to the challenge on delivery issues that Scotland faces. Preventative spend is a very good example in that context. We will produce a report on telemedicine and telehealth in Scotland—Claire Sweeney has been involved in that. That report will clearly indicate that investment in that area can deliver good outcomes and savings, but spending will need to stop in other areas. The number 1 issue that we will face will be the challenge of deciding where to stop spending within a framework of strong leadership and priority setting. We will somehow need to find a way of having a conversation about that in which it is recognised that we are all in this together.
link
That is a very interesting response. You talk about the need for a conversation. Are there enough opportunities for those conversations to happen? Are local authority chief executives regularly coming together to discuss how they will tackle the issues?
Yes. Conversations happen in many places. I am sure that there is a lot of activity in the Government at the moment, and chief executives get together quite regularly in the local government and health service constituencies, for example. There are places where such conversations take place, but we need to bring the whole thing together somehow and say, “What does this mean for our road map for the future for Scotland?”
All public bodies will have to consider seriously priority-based budgeting. I note my interest as a member of Aberdeen City Council, which has gone through priority-based budgeting. It decided to do so. It was realised that the salami-slicing approach would perhaps yield an annual saving, but would not help to reshape the organisation’s finances and structures to cope with the pressures that are coming further down the line. It is still denied in some quarters that what is needed is the fundamental reorganisation and reform of services, as opposed to simply a continual salami-slicing approach.I wonder about the budget-setting process. In Aberdeen, we decided to start the budget-setting process much earlier than had previously been the case. It used to be that a couple of weeks before the budget meeting people would be presented with papers that said how much money there was to play with and gave a representation of the savings that could be picked from. There was often very little flexibility available. We decided to start the budget-setting process much earlier and involve external organisations and partners in it. What has developed from that, alongside the priority-based approach, is a much more bullet-proof budgeting process in which people drill down much deeper into the budget headings.Are other local authorities following that approach or are there still madcap last-minute dashes to set budgets that will balance? In the current situation, we need to start the budget process earlier and move to a priority-based budget approach across the public sector. The old ways of salami-slicing at the last minute will not cut it.
I will answer the second part of your question first, then the first part.On what is happening out there now, the data for the report were collected around the turn of the year into the early months of this calendar year and things are, of course, changing so fast that that picture is already out of date. We do not have detailed information about every public body in Scotland. The information that a sample of 47 public bodies were willing and able to share with us at that stage in the process was used. As we say in the report, it is clear that they have done most in the workforce area, through freezing vacancies, voluntary early release schemes and so on. That must be the case, as that is where 60 per cent of the cost is, so there has been a lot of activity around that. There is less evidence of people thinking seriously about service redesign and repackaging. Although there are some good examples of that throughout Scotland, we do not have a comprehensive picture of it.11:45
The convener alluded to the voluntary severance issue and spoke about a quick fix. In cases where voluntary severance is not tied to a reorganisation, restructuring and reform agenda, it could potentially be just a quick fix. If people do not get in, get their hands dirty and start to fix structures in the council, those two things cannot be tied together.
I agree with that statement and build on it by reminding members of my comment on the risk of losing key skills at a challenging time.
What do you think the impact of the Christie commission will be on the findings?
The Christie commission document is interesting. I enjoyed reading it and the independent budget review report before it, to which our report refers. However, the response to Christie is essentially a policy matter for the Scottish Government, so I am not in a position to help you terribly much with an answer to that question.
If that is all, I thank the witnesses very much for their contributions. There is no doubt that we will come back to what we have been discussing. There are big challenges for the committee, the Parliament, the Government and all public sector bodies—and a fairly stark future—ahead of us.We will now move into private session.11:46 Meeting continued in private until 12:13.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Sep 2011 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 5
- 10:00 Audit Scotland Annual Report 2010/11 Committee business · 16
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 54
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.