The next item is on the section 23 report “Transport for health and social care”. Joining Mr Black and Barbara Hurst are Angela Canning, Claire Sweeney and Ffion Heledd, all from Audit Scotland. Sorry, I think that Ffion is not here today.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Transport for health and social care”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Barbara Hurst 21
- Hugh Henry Lab 8
- Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland 7
- George Adam SNP 4
- Mark McDonald SNP 3
- Mr Black 2
- Murdo Fraser Con 2
- Liam McArthur LD 2
- Humza Yousaf SNP 2
- Drew Smith Lab 2
- Gil Paterson SNP 1
The record
54 contributionsFfion cannot be here, as she is unwell. Barbara Hurst will introduce this report.
This report, which was published earlier in the summer, is a joint report by the Auditor General and the Accounts Commission, as it covers health and local government. It looks at the efficiency and effectiveness of transport for health and social care in Scotland. Specifically, we examined how well local bodies such as councils and NHS boards work together to plan and deliver services for local people. We identified areas where potential savings could be made and we have, where possible, included good practice examples, as discussed earlier. Access to transport to hospital appointments and social care venues is an important service for many people across Scotland and access can be critical in determining whether people get the health and social care that they need. A number of organisations are involved, including regional transport partnerships, councils, NHS boards, the ambulance service and the voluntary and private sector. We found that public sector organisations that are involved in delivering health and social care need to pay more attention to transport as an integral part of the service that they provide. We also considered their scope to use resources more efficiently and save public money without affecting the quality of the services. I would like to highlight five key issues from the report. This is a service that has not received the attention that it needs. Overall responsibility for transport in this area is fragmented and, in many areas, unco-ordinated. Improvements could be made by having a shared and better understanding of costs, activity and quality and the needs of local people across all the organisations involved in delivering these services. Decisions that are taken in one organisation can have consequences for the services that are provided by another, so it is vital that partners work together. If one body changes its eligibility for transport services or another body changes scheduled appointment times, it could affect a number of providers as well as service users. The case studies in our report demonstrate pilot projects that show scope for savings and efficiencies but which are not being rolled out across Scotland. Case studies 2 and 4 on pages 18 and 19 of the main report provide indicative savings that can be achieved by better co-ordination, improved scheduling of transport and better assessment of local need. Secondly, we identified that £93 million was spent on transport for health and social care in 2009-10. Exhibit 3 on page 12 shows the breakdown across different providers. However, that figure is a considerable underestimate. Not all councils and boards were able to provide us with basic financial information, as the transport costs for patients and users are often subsumed into bigger budget heads and not always separately identified. The lack of identification or understanding of spend is a serious barrier to being able to make the best use of available resources.Thirdly, poor access to transport has a disproportionate effect on people with lower incomes, older people and those with on-going health and social care needs. Decisions about reducing or removing funding from these services can have a significant impact on those groups, but we did not find that the potential effect of such changes is often being assessed or monitored. We did not find that, if something is taken away, care is taken to ensure that services are available in an alternative way. The public sector needs better information about individuals using these services and about the quality of the transport services that it provides.Fourthly, funding arrangements are complex, which makes it difficult to plan and deliver services in a joined-up way. The voluntary sector provides transport in many areas of Scotland, but the current pressure on public sector budgets means that there is a real risk of reductions to its funding. We found little evidence that councils and NHS boards have assessed what impact reductions in voluntary sector transport funding would have on the people who use those services or that they would be part of a wider strategic review of local services. We had a number of focus groups involving voluntary sector providers and users of services, on which we can provide more information if you are interested.10:30
The way in which transport for health and social care is scheduled needs to improve. There is scope for more co-ordination and partnership working. Councils and NHS boards should consider arranging transport through a central team. We found the Golden Jubilee hospital to be a good example of what can be done if they work centrally to provide services—that is in case study 3 on page 18. We recommend that partners should integrate or share services where that represents more efficient use of resources and better services. We also found that staff and people who use the transport services are not necessarily aware of the full range that is available, which can mean some quite difficult journeys or issues for particular people.The Scottish Government has established a short-life working group on transport for healthcare, which is taking account of the findings in the report. The group is due to report later in the autumn. We are also pleased to note that the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Cities Strategy accepted all the recommendations in the report when we published it.We are happy to take any questions that the committee has.
Thank you. Did your work cover the emergency services function of the ambulance service?
No. We looked only at the patient transport element of its work. The ambulance service could give us better information about costs and activity, so it could separate emergency services from patient transport.
Do you know yet whether the changes to current crewing levels that are being suggested in the ambulance service will have cost implications and whether those cost implications will impact on the ability of the ambulance service to contribute to the work that you were studying?
I suspect that the answer is no, but I ask Claire Sweeney to help on that one.
The answer is no, we do not know. There seems to be a separate system and we do not know whether those changes will have any impact on the patient transfer side of the business.
When the previous committee examined the Western Isles health service, it was told that people were being kept in hospital because of a lack of access to suitable transport. I do not know whether that was a one-off problem or whether you have come across that elsewhere. Is a lack of availability or co-ordination keeping people in hospital for longer than is necessary?
I remember that evidence and was quite surprised at the strength with which the point was made. In paragraph 38 on page 6 of the key messages document, we give some indicators relating to people being picked up after their appointments. However, I do not think that we have any further information about whether people are staying longer than they need to as in-patients; we have information only about out-patient appointments.
The amount of money that is available for transport for health and social care will be critical to how well that service can be delivered. You have considered out-patient activity, but the costs associated with in-patient activity will determine how much money is available for the rest of the function. Would it be possible to determine whether the lack of suitable transport is being affected by a lack of cash and whether people are being kept in hospital longer than is necessary? If they are, that will have huge cost implications for the national health service, never mind the attendant dangers for the patient of keeping them in hospital for too long and the anxiety and stress that are involved. Is it possible to link the two together?
It is certainly possible. Some of that information would not immediately be available at a national level. In order to get at whether people are in hospital longer than they need to be purely because of the transport issue, you would have to do some sort of survey work across hospitals.Delayed discharges are patients—often they are older patients—who are kept in hospital for longer than they need to be. There are some national statistics that show whether that happens as a result of waiting for community care assessment or waiting for a care home place. Claire, can you remember whether there is information about the more nuts-and-bolts issues to do with immediate transport?
We considered the information as part of the audit. It is not in the final report because it did not show the extent to which transport impacts on delayed discharges. There is information there, which goes down to information about whether transport is an issue. We felt that we did not have a full enough picture across the whole system to be able to comment.What has come through, certainly from the field work for the audit, is the potential impact of transport not being arranged as smartly as it might be, the inference being that transport will almost certainly have an impact on whether people are able to get home, or wherever else they need to be, as quickly as they should.
The one health board that has considered the potential impact of transport is the board that includes the Golden Jubilee hospital. None of the other boards has done any work on that.
link
Good morning. I want to ask about the issue of organising transport through central departments, which I think is covered in paragraph 37, on page 15 of the report. Over the page, in exhibits 5 and 6, there is the usual excellent graphic demonstration that we are so used to from Audit Scotland about how that works. It is interesting that while in exhibit 5 we see the usual spider’s web-type graphic, in exhibit 6, where there is an integrated transport unit, much neater lines of communication are shown. That is an excellent visual demonstration of why having integrated units is so important.I was interested to read in the report that only two NHS boards organise transport through central departments. Barbara Hurst referred to the Scottish Government’s working group on transport in the health service. Will that group look specifically at trying to encourage greater use of central departments?
This is where I regret Ffion Heledd being ill, because Ffion has been acting as an observer on that group. Claire Sweeney may have a bit more information.
As far as we understand it, that group is taking account of the recommendations and issues that were raised in the report. The greater use of central departments is a key issue, so the group must be covering that as part of its work.
link
That is helpful. On the related point about councils, you say that 18 councils have developed integrated transport units or are in the process of doing so. Presumably, the remaining 14 councils are not doing that. Is anything being done to encourage them to go down the same route?
That takes us back to our earlier discussion about follow-up. As part of the report, we have a checklist about expectations of the situation locally, and we will ask our local auditors to see what each council is doing. We should have some idea, not immediately but over time, about what else is happening in that area at council level.
The situation is much more complicated for the councils. There are potential complications, given the different departments that can be involved, and the links between the education departments and the departments that look after social care issues.
link
Such transport is important to me because I have worked with many organisations in Renfrewshire that use it. One of my concerns is that many public and voluntary organisations are doing the same job and offering the same form of transport. As the convener was right to say, we now live in a different economic climate.Some regional transport partnerships work, but my concern is that some do not. Unfortunately, my area has the monolith that is the Strathclyde partnership for transport, some of whose services could be a wee bit better. People will go to a local-authority-run disabled centre, for example, on social work buses and MyBus services, which were previously called dial-a-bus.I am concerned that we cannot even find out from an organisation such as SPT how much running dial-a-bus or MyBus costs in our areas. Strathclyde has almost a fleet of vehicles for vulnerable individuals, so we must be able to work the system an awful lot better.I agree with your comment on page 23 that“Transport planning is fragmented and responsibilities are unclear”—SPT is a perfect example of that. Given that, it is difficult for us locally to achieve accountability and to get SPT to change, as it is a monolith.
I will say something in SPT’s defence.
link
That will be a first.
It is an unusual position to be in.We found that SPT was the regional transport partnership that was trying to address some of the issues that have been raised. The others were further off the pace. All the partnerships are starting to consider the issues, but SPT has looked at them longest.
link
I am talking about dealing with the transport situation when many local authorities and other organisations are involved. I will give a perfect example of that. We in Renfrewshire Council undertook a review that showed that we could offer a 24/7 taxi service for people in Renfrewshire that would be cheaper and better than dial-a-bus but, because we are part of SPT, we could not make that change. As your report says, better ways of working exist—I have given an example. SPT is being brought to the party kicking and screaming.
We say in the report—and we agree with you—that what is involved is a partnership. Lots of bodies other than regional transport partnerships are involved, so the problem is being tackled collectively. I assume that members of a partnership would consider together something that was more efficient and effective and which cost less.
link
In a perfect world, we would expect that.
I will continue to talk about Renfrewshire, which George Adam raised. Exhibit 4 on pages 14 and 15 shows that Renfrewshire Council spends £4.8 million, that Inverclyde Council spends just under £700,000 and that East Renfrewshire Council spends just over £700,000. Renfrewshire Council’s population is about the same size as that of East Renfrewshire Council and Inverclyde Council added together, so why does such a disparity in expenditure exist? The areas’ demography and social profiles are not that different. East Renfrewshire has a large affluent hinterland, but Inverclyde and parts of East Renfrewshire do not differ much from Renfrewshire.
We deliberated long and hard on whether to include exhibit 4, because the figures for some areas are clearly underestimates. We tried to identify councils for which the figures did not capture all the costs, and you have just identified councils to which that applies.
link
The convener raised issues that relate to the Western Isles a while back. As the member for the Orkney Islands, I will stay with that theme. I found the report extremely interesting, but it does not contain many case studies of patient transport issues in island areas.The figures for the island areas in exhibit 4, to which the convener just referred and which show the spend of the health boards and councils where those figures are available, are relatively high in a per capita sense. Is there anything in your report to suggest that the health boards and councils could achieve greater efficiencies and better use of patient transfer, either through greater use of telehealth and telecare or better organisation of appointments where transport is unavoidable? In Orkney, that would probably relate to the transfers through the relationships with NHS Grampian; Shetland would be in a similar situation. I suspect that there are also probably internal travel issues, given that there are three sizeable archipelagos that pose different challenges to the health boards.10:45
Orkney NHS Board is one of the two that have a central unit. In a sense, it is interesting that only Orkney has that, while Western Isles and Shetland do not, despite having the same issues.You asked a specific question on telehealth. We will publish a report in October that looks at that issue—avoiding the travel—in more detail; it has some interesting findings. Unfortunately, you will probably not hear our evidence on that as you are not a permanent member of the committee.Claire, do we have anything else on the island boards in particular?
I am sure that we have some examples of innovative practice. One thing that came through across the piece from those in the voluntary sector was a sense of frustration and feeling that they could offer a lot more, and I am sure that we have examples from the island boards in particular where they have done that. I am struggling to recall them off the top of my head, but the voluntary sector across Scotland certainly feels frustrated and that it could do things slightly differently. The point was made earlier about voluntary organisations proving that they can do things in a more cost-effective way or having an idea locally that might work better and then having discussions with the councils and the NHS boards about how to take things forward. It is definitely a feature of the situation, and there are certainly good examples in the islands.
link
I would welcome more information on that, if you could provide it either to the committee or to me.
Throughout, the report mentions a lack of information, limited information and a lack of data. To me, that indicates that the issue has festered for not just a number of years but possibly even decades. You touch on the issue and say that it is largely due to the fact that there is not central, joined-up working between the various different bodies. That is understandable, but it also suggests that there has perhaps been a lack of accountability over the years, if not decades. This might be a somewhat unfair question to ask, but what are the other reasons for the lack of information on top of the lack of joined-up working between the central bodies? Has there been a political decision not to interfere too much with services because it can be a touchy subject for people to get involved with? Why has the situation been allowed to fester over the years?
I suppose that, if you look at the situation purely in terms of spend, transport for health and social care is not a high-spend area. We often choose to look at areas that involve big money; this time, we chose to look at something that we knew had such a significant effect on individuals. This comment goes well outside any evidence that we have, but it may be that the issue has not been the biggest to look at. Nevertheless—the convener alluded to this earlier—if we do not get the issue sorted properly, a lot of perverse things happen elsewhere in the system. For example, people may not turn up to their out-patient appointment just because the bus does not turn up to pick them up.There are difficult issues, which are intractable in lots of ways, but given that health and social care need increasingly to be managed together there are a lot of opportunities to start managing the transport for some services together too. To date, a lot of the work around that has been largely around individual budget heads but, with the move towards better integration of those services, there is no reason why bodies could not get their budgets aligned as well, so that they could make more efficient use of their money.
Does that give Audit Scotland a wider focus to examine those areas that do not have a huge spend or a big spend? You are suggesting that there is a lot less accountability in those areas, and I imagine that they would add up to form a significant part of the public budget.
Earlier, I mentioned two of the things that we use to inform our selection of topics. Two others are partnership working—we absolutely have to consider that, because that is the way in which a lot of services are being delivered—and the issue of user focus. Although an area might not necessarily involve the biggest spend, if we think that there are particular issues for subsets of the public, we might well focus on it—that comes back to your question about whether the public have a say in what we do. That is a judgment call. I think that I said previously that it is an art, not a science. It is an important area to consider, though.
Can I add to that? Linking back to the conversation that we had around the annual report and impact, I point out that, at the back of the report, there is a checklist—that is quite a typical feature now. We would strongly encourage the regional transport partnerships and the councils to consider that checklist and ask themselves those questions. That would give a bit of a push to the issues that we are discussing.
I know that you have given a health warning about how far you can drill in but, apart from examining spending in the report, do you examine cost? In other words, when things are not joined up, do you examine the cost impact of, for example, one person not turning up for an appointment, in terms of the clinicians waiting for that person and the associated downtime? Have you considered that, or should the committee consider that?
We would have loved to consider that, but the information was not available for us to start trying to cost it. Certainly, in future reports, if we can get access to good information about how many appointments were missed and what the implications were for the way in which doctors and nurses use their time, it would be possible to do some modelling that would tell you the opportunity cost—it would be opportunity cost, not a saving, because the staff are there anyway. However, the information did not allow us to drill down that far into what the cost might be of things not happening.
You have identified that we are dealing with a case of too many cooks. Will the proposals that are on the table to bring about more integration of health and social care provide us with a means of resolving some of the problems, particularly those around communication between organisations? That theme seems to be emerging. At our previous meeting, at which we dealt with the community health partnerships report, we discussed the difficulties that seem to exist between local authority social care departments and health boards and the lack of communication and joined-up working that exists in that regard. Do you see the integration agenda as a means of solving some of those problems and bringing about the positive outcomes that you are looking for?
Yes.
Short and sweet. The next one might not be quite so.You said that you wrestled with the idea of not including exhibit 4, but I think that it is very helpful. All the local authorities, bar three, provided estimated figures, and four were not able to give you any information at all. That causes me a great deal of concern, as local authorities ought to be able to say where every pound is being spent, because every pound is vital in the current economic situation. Is there a reason why certain authorities were not able to give you any information, or even an estimated sum? Do you intend to go back to them at some stage to try to get that information?Beyond that, local authorities have their own audit and scrutiny committees. Do you intend to flag up to local authorities that their audit committees might want to look at particular spend in those areas? They might drill down to a level that you were not able to reach.
I will pick up on your last point, and then ask Claire Sweeney to tell us about those councils that could not give information.We would love local audit and scrutiny committees to drill down and look at some of our reports. This is a classic area in which that would be a way to achieve some local leverage in terms of driving improvement.
The information was not provided. We spent quite a long time going back and forth, trying to validate the data and ensure that the correct people were being approached for it, and trying get the final returns signed off. The process of validation went on for months beyond the point at which we had asked for the initial data, and the information was still not provided. There is definitely an issue, in that people do not have enough information about the cost, quality and activity around those services, and authorities certainly need to follow that up locally.
My concern is that when local authorities come to set their budgets, how can they be sure that the money that they are allocating to a service is what is needed? They could either be spending too much on it or, conversely, not enough.It concerns me that certain authorities are not giving you the information, because that raises the question of what information they are giving to the councillors who are making the decisions locally on those budget headings. Local audit committees should be taking an interest in this area and trying to get some of that information.
I want to return to those figures. The issue is not just that some councils are not providing the information—frankly, it looks as though the information that has been provided is totally useless or completely inaccurate. One begins to wonder whether councils either do not know what is going on, or are not doing their job properly.I use Renfrewshire Council as a benchmark because it is the council with which I am most familiar. It is, allegedly, spending nearly five times as much as North Lanarkshire Council, which is at least twice the size. Either Renfrewshire is just throwing good money after bad, or North Lanarkshire is not doing its sums and accounting properly and is not in a position to make accurate judgments.City of Edinburgh Council’s spending is not that much higher than that of Renfrewshire Council. The whole thing is completely inconsistent. I know why Audit Scotland struggled with councils not providing the information—frankly, it beggars belief. It is almost worse than useless.That is a criticism not of Audit Scotland, but of those who are compiling the figures and delivering them to you. There is something badly wrong here.
We do not take it as a criticism of us—thank you very much.We really wondered whether that information was worth including; Claire Sweeney underestimates the grief that the team experienced in trying to compile the table. However, although it begs more questions than it answers, we decided—for the reasons that the committee has been discussing—that we would put it in the report. It shows that there is quite a lot of work to do locally to identify exactly what is spent. I suspect that a lot of the figures do not include fleet costs or anything like that, because that information will be held somewhere else.11:00
To what extent did the scoping report look at how to prevent unnecessary journeys, which was mentioned earlier? Will you elaborate on the extent to which you were able to look into that? Did you get a sense that it was a serious consideration, particularly on the health board side? I notice that Traveline Scotland is mentioned in relation to a number of health boards, but health boards continue to make decisions that are pretty challenging for people who want to use any means other than patient transport. I am thinking of the services that are being moved to Yorkhill, which will eventually be moved to the Southern general. There are people who could get a bus to hospital, but they will not be able to do so in that case as it is simply not possible to get a bus to Yorkhill. How far are health boards aware of that issue? Do they have any plans in place to tackle it consistently?
I will pick that up, although Claire Sweeney might want to elaborate.We looked at the process—in other words, we considered unnecessary travel from the point of view of the type of transport that individuals used. We did not look at whether they did not even need to go to hospital in the first place—that was way outside the scope of our study, which was on the process.A good example that we included in the report is the work that Forth Valley NHS Board did to ensure that there were bus routes that went to its new hospital. The board did the right thing by trying to ensure that, at local level, the hospital was accessible. A lot of people will want to go to hospital by bus and not drive, for whatever reason. That was a good example of where such planning has worked well but, as you know, there are other examples where it has not worked so well. It requires discussion with private sector bus operators, which brings in another complexity. Do you have anything to add, Claire?
That is right. It is a case of the issue not being made enough of a priority and not being thought about early enough in the planning process. Although there is the example of Forth Valley NHS Board seeing that as a priority and investing in such work around its new build, there are examples of new builds where transport has not been considered early enough, which has had consequences for people who need to use those services. The situation varies; it goes back to whether the issue is seen as a priority for people.Whether health boards see transport as their responsibility, given the role of the ambulance service, is certainly an issue. There is an interesting dynamic there, with health boards starting to realise that provision for transport to services is an important part of the work that they do. That change is starting to happen, but the situation is variable across Scotland.
It is interesting that you raised the issue of discussion with private contractors about bus routes, which takes us back to regional transport partnerships. My interpretation of the situation is slightly different from that of other members, particularly as regards what Barbara Hurst said. It seems to me that there are differences across Scotland because we have different models of regional transport partnerships. There might be some areas of the country where the kind of work that is possible where there is a more developed partnership is not happening.Health boards can try to integrate transport services within their areas—that is all to the good and we would encourage that. Equally, we would hope that councils would try to integrate their various transport needs. However, to return to our discussion around CHPs, if we leave health boards and local authorities—some health boards have to deal with a number of local authorities—to come to a more integrated approach across health and social care, it ain’t gonna happen unless a third party is involved, which would seem to me to be the role of some kind of regional transport planning organisation. Is that fair?
Regional transport partnerships certainly come into their own where there are cross-border appointments. A number of the health boards run regional and national services, access to which would not be picked up for all patients by the local transport arrangements. It is an issue that has to be addressed not just at local level, but at regional level.
I draw the discussion to a close and thank the Audit Scotland team for their evidence, which we will reflect on later in the agenda.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Sep 2011 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 5
- 10:00 Audit Scotland Annual Report 2010/11 Committee business · 16
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 54
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.