I agree. Because of the timing, that is the first issue on which we should take evidence.I fully agree with the list of issues, which covers many of the areas that we discussed before the summer recess and again at our away day. However, I would like to add a couple of issues. The first is that of risk, which I have mentioned before and by which I mean risk management and the whole issue of risk aversion in the context of child protection.We will be dealing with a lot of subordinate legislation on child protection. It would be helpful to put that work in context by having a general discussion on where we are with risk management. The convener and other members may know that I am concerned that many individuals and organisations behave in a very risk-averse manner. That is not due to any one particular factor but to the cumulative effect of health and safety legislation, criminal injuries compensation and a blame culture in which someone is always responsible for any accident and is to be sued if possible.There are many issues to address. There is a feeling that some of the child protection legislation may exacerbate the problem rather than providing a clear path through it for the organisations in the voluntary and statutory sector that have to take decisions on these issues. We could easily have a one-off evidence session, and we could perhaps start with a written paper and some correspondence to explore some of the issues. The committee could have a short working session to discuss them.A second issue that is not on our list is that of Steiner schools. It is not a pressing issue, but I apologise for not having raised it at the away day. There are several Steiner schools in Scotland, which operate in the independent sector. They are not private schools in the sense that we might think of private schools. If we support a pluralistic education system, there is a strong argument for those schools being part of the state sector. The issue has bubbled away, but I am sure that it is an immediate concern for Steiner parents and pupils. I should point out that there are no Steiner schools in my area. The Executive is not prioritising the issue at the moment, but perhaps the committee could address it as a one-off. We might be able to add something to the debate. I wanted to throw that into the mix.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Ken Macintosh only · show everyone- Karen Whitefield Lab 5
- Ken Macintosh Lab 4
- Liz Smith Con 2
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
- Rob Gibson SNP 1
- Pauline McNeill Lab 1
- Christina McKelvie SNP 1
- Aileen Campbell SNP 1
Ken Macintosh’s contributions
4 contributionsI want to add a couple of items to the list. It would be helpful to reiterate the order in which I see them proceeding. I think that there is a consensus. We have discussed the issues at length in private. For the record—but without wanting to repeat our discussions—it is worth making a few points. Rob Gibson mentioned post-legislative scrutiny. We are keen to do some work on the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004 and other legislation at an early stage. However, at the away day, the Executive signalled that it will be doing some work in that area, and we agreed that we would wait for its review to be published. There is to be an announcement on the skills strategy next week, which might colour some of our decisions. That will link with the governance of further education colleges and higher education institutions, which Liz Smith highlighted. There is no doubt that under the skills strategy and the role that it envisages for colleges, school-college links will be at the forefront of Executive thinking. We should quickly address accountability in the FE sector—that has a bearing on institutions' charitable status. As Liz Smith says, we should also prioritise the financing of the higher education sector generally.I believe that there will be an announcement on the new Scottish Broadcasting Commission in Parliament next week. I hope that we can find time to invite Blair Jenkins, the head of the commission, to come and speak to us. That would not take too long. We should not delay in finding time for that. I agree with Pauline McNeill that the commission's work will have an impact on the creative industries. If the budget for the creative industries is to move from Scottish Enterprise to the creative side, this is the time to express any views that we have on the matter and to take evidence on it. Class sizes will be a running issue. The work programme paper refers to"Issues related to the school estate".Much will depend on the spending review, which I think is due to come out in October, and we can add to the debate. There will be issues in every local authority area about how class size targets are met, not just in terms of teacher numbers but in terms of the space that is available in classes. Many authorities will have problems meeting the targets, whatever deadlines are set. I hope that those comments help. I think that they confirm colleagues' comments.
I believe that we will not meet for two weeks. Will we discuss the detail of the work programme in two weeks' time or will we give you discretion to start then with the first business?
That is what I hoped. The discussions have been relatively general, but I do not feel that we need to discuss who will appear before us.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 16
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.