The second item on our agenda is our work programme. This is an opportunity for us to reflect on our away day discussions, which, I am sure we all agree, were useful. We have before us a paper that, if agreed to, will be published on the committee's web pages for people to access.I invite general comments on the paper, and I hope that we will reach agreement on some particular issues. Although we will not agree today to hold any major inquiries, I hope that—in light of our discussions at the away day and this morning—we can agree that the committee should hold a series of context-setting hearings at which stakeholders from across the wide remit of the committee will have an opportunity to engage with us. Those hearings will allow us to set the context for our future deliberations; to investigate matters relating to the budget and finance; to investigate subjects on which we may want to hold inquiries in future; and, if necessary, to hold the Executive to account.It will be important for the committee to try to innovate and to ensure that we do not go just to the usual suspects and stakeholders but try, whenever possible, to speak to the users of services and to people who might not always engage with the Parliament but who certainly benefit from, or require, the services that we will be considering.I would like us to reach general agreement on the topics for those hearings. We have a list in front of us that we have already more or less agreed on, but it would be helpful if we could consider our priorities—for example, whether we want to consider further and higher education at the beginning or whether the school-building programme should come first, and where issues such as the Scottish Broadcasting Commission should fit in.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Karen Whitefield only · show everyone- Karen Whitefield Lab 5
- Ken Macintosh Lab 4
- Liz Smith Con 2
- Jeremy Purvis LD 1
- Rob Gibson SNP 1
- Pauline McNeill Lab 1
- Christina McKelvie SNP 1
- Aileen Campbell SNP 1
Karen Whitefield’s contributions
5 contributionsI thank Mr Macintosh and all members for their comments—some good points have been made. Many of the issues were discussed at length at our away day. Christina McKelvie and Rob Gibson made the good point that the committee's remit is extremely broad, so we will have to ensure that no part of it is neglected or forgotten. That will present challenges to us, as the committee will be required to act when primary or secondary legislation is before us or when a matter is of greater political importance. The committee will need to reflect on that at times but, in the context of setting our work programme, members' points are valid.I do not want our deliberations to focus on one part of our remit, especially as the committee has decided to operate slightly differently in this session. We do not want to jump into doing an in-depth inquiry on one issue; we are keener to set our own agenda, to contextualise matters for future deliberations and to hold shorter sessions to investigate issues with stakeholders from across the committee's remit.We could all add to the list that is before us, but the challenge for us is not to add to it. We do not want to raise expectations unrealistically among people in civic Scotland that we will do something that will never happen. However, when we can consider the issues that have been raised this morning, we will try to tie them in with our existing workload. The committee will consider secondary legislation on vulnerable adults, so we can consider and take evidence on risk then. If we operate in that way whenever possible, we should have as broad a perspective as possible on all matters.We have a fair degree of consensus on what we think will be our priorities—the governance and financing of further and higher education, the Scottish Broadcasting Commission, the curriculum for excellence and the school estate. Jeremy Purvis mentioned class sizes and school meals. The committee will consider both those issues in relation to secondary legislation and we can consider them as part of our work programme.I hope that that discussion allows us to move forward. Now the clerks have the difficult job of drawing up a more detailed work programme for the committee's meetings between now and Christmas and of making approaches so that we can start the process of taking evidence. If necessary, we might want ministers to return to the committee at the end of that process, in the light of the evidence that we hear. The approach is slightly different from that of previous committees.Do we agree to the work programme that is before us, subject to our discussions this morning?Members indicated agreement.
That is great.
I hope that the committee will give me discretion to get things under way.
I will attempt to be as consensual as possible. I will take forward members' suggestions and circulate information informally. However, it will help to move forward, as otherwise all that we will do is discuss our work programme and have nobody before us. It is time for us to move on and get to work.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee Wednesday 5 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Work Programme Procedure · 16
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.