6. To ask the First Minister what action the Scottish Government is taking to eliminate the discarding of fish. (S3F-2846)
Official Report · Chamber
Fish Discards
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- John Scott Con 2
- Maureen Watt SNP 1
- Liam McArthur LD 1
- Margo MacDonald Ind 1
The record
10 contributions6. To ask the First Minister what action the Scottish Government is taking to eliminate the discarding of fish. (S3F-2846)
John Scott is right to raise the issue. Across Europe, fishermen are forced to discard—and have been for generations—perfectly good fish back into the sea, although they are dead. That is a waste of a perfectly good and healthy food and a vital economic resource.
As John Scott knows, the Scottish Government has been working with fishermen and other stakeholders, and we are leading the way in efforts to reduce the discarding of fish. This year, our innovative catch quota system was the largest in Europe, and it is one of a number of measures that we are taking to reduce discards.
Reducing discards will continue to be a priority for the Government, along with returning full powers over fisheries back to Scotland. I know that many members support our action against discards, just as many members across the chamber are vehemently critical of the common fisheries policy.
As John Scott knows, the Scottish Government has been working with fishermen and other stakeholders, and we are leading the way in efforts to reduce the discarding of fish. This year, our innovative catch quota system was the largest in Europe, and it is one of a number of measures that we are taking to reduce discards.
Reducing discards will continue to be a priority for the Government, along with returning full powers over fisheries back to Scotland. I know that many members support our action against discards, just as many members across the chamber are vehemently critical of the common fisheries policy.
Most right-thinking people are outraged by discarding—indeed, none more so than the fishermen who are fighting for their livelihoods. Some 41 boats have been tied up this year, yet they are forced to implement this dreadful practice.
The First Minister will be aware of fishermen’s unease with the catch quota approach that his Government has taken, but he will also be aware that the United Kingdom Government has called for an end to discarding coupled with more decentralised decision making, which will be vital to achieving that. In the light of that, will the Scottish Government redouble its efforts to work with UK ministers, European officials and, crucially, Scotland’s fishermen to develop other ways of reducing discards, in addition to catch quotas, and so end discarding for good?
The First Minister will be aware of fishermen’s unease with the catch quota approach that his Government has taken, but he will also be aware that the United Kingdom Government has called for an end to discarding coupled with more decentralised decision making, which will be vital to achieving that. In the light of that, will the Scottish Government redouble its efforts to work with UK ministers, European officials and, crucially, Scotland’s fishermen to develop other ways of reducing discards, in addition to catch quotas, and so end discarding for good?
If we are to end discarding, it will require fishermen to be allowed to land what they catch. The catch quota system is designed to enhance quota to allow that to take place. The catch quota system is extremely popular and has been oversubscribed several times, with many applications for places in the scheme. It is vital that the enhancement of quota is sufficient to allow the catch quota system to operate fully.
I am sure that John Scott will acknowledge—I looked it up when I saw his question—that I made my first speech about discarding in a debate on a motion in the House of Commons in December 1988. It has been a long-term campaign by me and just about every other fishing MP to see the obscenity of discarding removed from fisheries policy. I hope that he will agree that the catch quota system must be allowed the opportunity to provide part of the answer.
I am sure that John Scott will acknowledge—I looked it up when I saw his question—that I made my first speech about discarding in a debate on a motion in the House of Commons in December 1988. It has been a long-term campaign by me and just about every other fishing MP to see the obscenity of discarding removed from fisheries policy. I hope that he will agree that the catch quota system must be allowed the opportunity to provide part of the answer.
Does the First Minister share my view that the only way for the Scottish Government to have a real voice when it comes to the common fisheries policy and the progression of innovative policies on discards and maintaining healthy fish stocks is for Scotland to become a full independent member of the European Union?
Yes, I do. There are two aspects of the common fisheries policy that I will never be able to understand. We have been discussing one of them: discarding is an obscenity and it should be removed. The other is that, under the common fisheries policy, landlocked member states—many of which, no doubt, Iain Gray has insulted from time to time—have more say in deciding fisheries policy than the nation of Scotland, which has a vast proportion of the territorial waters in the European Union. That is why only an independent Scotland will have a seat at the top table and be able to defend the rights of our fishing and rural communities.
link
Although I share the First Minister’s concerns about the extent of discards and indeed his criticisms of the common fisheries policy, he will be aware of the criticisms that were levelled at the catch quota approach this week. Bertie Armstrong, the leader of the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation, described the approach as a perfect control measure for enforcing a system of management that is broken. In that context, what would the First Minister say to those Scottish white-fish skippers who have already registered with producer organisations south of the border and those who are contemplating doing so as a result of concerns about the approach that is being taken to catch quotas and, indeed, conservation credits?
I say two things to Liam McArthur. First, it is clear that the catch quota system is extremely popular, as applications to the system have been substantially oversubscribed. He should not give the impression that the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation is against the principle of catch quotas, because it has made it clear on many occasions that it is not. The concern is whether the enhanced quota will allow the catch quota system to operate properly. That is exactly what Richard Lochhead and his officials are dealing with at present.
I remember that the member’s leader once had to resign from a Government over the common fisheries policy. Although I share the concerns about it, if people are critical of the common fisheries policy, as Liam McArthur and I have been, they must consider two things. First, they must put forward proposals to mitigate the impact that the CFP has had and keeps on having on our fishing communities. The catch quota system, which will enhance the quota that is available to Scotland as well as to individual fishermen, is an attempt to do that.
Secondly, it is not a policy just to criticise the common fisheries policy; there must be an alternative—a different style and system of managing this resource. That is why I have always believed that national management of resources is perfectly compatible with European policy. That is what we should seek as a Parliament if we are to take best advantage of our position as one of the countries with the most plentiful fishing in the whole European continent.
I remember that the member’s leader once had to resign from a Government over the common fisheries policy. Although I share the concerns about it, if people are critical of the common fisheries policy, as Liam McArthur and I have been, they must consider two things. First, they must put forward proposals to mitigate the impact that the CFP has had and keeps on having on our fishing communities. The catch quota system, which will enhance the quota that is available to Scotland as well as to individual fishermen, is an attempt to do that.
Secondly, it is not a policy just to criticise the common fisheries policy; there must be an alternative—a different style and system of managing this resource. That is why I have always believed that national management of resources is perfectly compatible with European policy. That is what we should seek as a Parliament if we are to take best advantage of our position as one of the countries with the most plentiful fishing in the whole European continent.
I normally refer to fish with a twist of lemon and a shake of black pepper, but, if I am allowed to intervene in this debate, I suggest that there is an alternative to the suggestion that Maureen Watt made. If Alex Salmond has been trying since 1988 to make sense of the common fisheries policy, does he not draw from that some sort of lesson that maybe we should just get out of the European Union altogether?
I do not draw that conclusion. I would rather just change the common fisheries policy and allow us control of our own resources on fish and other things. However, I do agree with Margo MacDonald that the common fisheries policy is rather like the Schleswig-Holstein question in European history: only three people ever understood it—one is mad, one is dead and I have forgotten.
12:31 Meeting suspended until 14:15.
14:15 On resuming—
12:31 Meeting suspended until 14:15.
14:15 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Jan 2011 →- Protecting Public Services Debate · 48
- Young People (Opportunities) Debate · 29
- Roads Maintenance (Salt and Grit) Questions · 6
- Devolved Taxes and Charges (Forecasts) Questions · 4
- Chief Medical Officer (Annual Report 2009) Questions · 4
- Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (Support) Questions · 13
- UK Consumer Protection Bodies (Reform) Questions · 7
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Change Fund) Questions · 4
- COSLA (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Supporters Direct (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Paternity Leave First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Renewable Energy (China) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fish Discards First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Marine Special Areas of Conservation Questions · 4
- “Low Carbon Scotland: Public Engagement Strategy” (Timetable) Questions · 8
- Salmon Farming Questions · 6
- Sewage Treatment Works (Bothwell Road) Questions · 4
- Local Food Producers (Large Retailers) Questions · 8
- Waste and Recycling (Cold Weather) Questions · 4
- Public Bodies (Reform) Bill (Forestry) Questions · 4
- Justice and Law Officers Questions · 1
- Custodial Sentences Questions · 8
- Police and Fire Services (Angus) Questions · 6
- Scottish Court Service (Weapons) Questions · 6
- Short Prison Sentences Questions · 6
- Domestic Abuse Courts Questions · 4
- Historic Environment (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 28
- “The Interpretation and Legislative Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 and other subordinate legislation Standing Order rule changes” Debate · 3
- Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Act 2006 and Code of Conduct Debate · 6
- “Minor changes to Standing Orders” Debate · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 21
- A9 Dualling (Timetable) Members’ business · 40
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.