1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2838)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2838)
I have been speaking to Jorge Calvet, the chairman of Gamesa, which is the world’s third-largest manufacturer of wind turbines. In half an hour’s time, Señor Calvet will announce that Gamesa intends to establish a research and development centre in Glasgow, creating 130 jobs. Furthermore, he will announce that the company will sign memoranda of understanding with Scottish Enterprise, Forth Ports and Dundee City Council for its intention to establish a manufacturing, organisation and maintenance base in Dundee. I know that the whole Parliament will welcome that benefit to the Scottish economy.
The Scottish Government was caught red handed this week doctoring evidence on Scotland’s economic future. It took from an academic paper the quotation that I have here but changed the words so that it means something else. Will the First Minister tell the Parliament who doctored that evidence and on whose authority it was done?
If Iain Gray is going to hold pieces of paper up, he should get bigger writing so that people can see what they say.
That was Iain Gray’s first question since last September that could be related to the Scottish economy. Basically, it boiled down to his objection to the insertion of a square bracket explaining what fiscal devolution means—that is,
“[the proportion of revenue and expenditure devolved]”.
When I studied punctuation and parenthesis, I was told that a square bracket was where one put a point of explanation. However, if Iain Gray’s objection to getting real economic powers for the Parliament and for Scotland boils down to his objection—following Wendy Alexander’s lead—to a square bracket, the Labour Party has finally come to the end of its role.
That was Iain Gray’s first question since last September that could be related to the Scottish economy. Basically, it boiled down to his objection to the insertion of a square bracket explaining what fiscal devolution means—that is,
“[the proportion of revenue and expenditure devolved]”.
When I studied punctuation and parenthesis, I was told that a square bracket was where one put a point of explanation. However, if Iain Gray’s objection to getting real economic powers for the Parliament and for Scotland boils down to his objection—following Wendy Alexander’s lead—to a square bracket, the Labour Party has finally come to the end of its role.
No. When I studied English at school, if one took a quotation and changed the words in it, it was not a quotation any more. The First Minister cannot just dismiss the point. The Scottish Government used that doctored evidence in its draft budget and published it in its policy paper on financing Scotland. It was the centrepiece of Alex Salmond’s speech to his Scottish National Party conference, but it is simply not true. Will he now admit that it is simply not true?
The quotation is from Professor Andy Hughes Hallett and Professor Drew Scott and, of course, they stand by their analysis that fiscal devolution means
“the impact of devolving both spending and tax powers”.
If the authors of the quotation agree with the Scottish Government that that is an acceptable description of what fiscal devolution means—I repeat for Iain Gray’s information that it means Scotland having power over its spending and its ability to raise revenue—why on earth is Iain Gray objecting to it?
The substance of the argument is as follows: the Scotland Bill Committee, which is dominated by the unionist parties, refused to examine the Scotland Bill’s tax proposals because it knows that there is a deflationary bias that would cost Scotland either £8 billion, according to the Scottish Government, or £700 million, according to the Scotland Office.
The unionist Scotland Office and the independence-seeking Scottish Government agree that the proposals in the bill, if applied over the past 10 years, would have cost Scotland many hundreds of millions, if not billions, of pounds of revenue. The only disagreement is by how much Scotland would have been disadvantaged, so how on earth can a committee justify not examining something that it is meant to scrutinise and which could be of great damage to the Scottish economy? When we should all be seeking to benefit employment in Scotland, how can Iain Gray come along and ask me about a square bracket?
“the impact of devolving both spending and tax powers”.
If the authors of the quotation agree with the Scottish Government that that is an acceptable description of what fiscal devolution means—I repeat for Iain Gray’s information that it means Scotland having power over its spending and its ability to raise revenue—why on earth is Iain Gray objecting to it?
The substance of the argument is as follows: the Scotland Bill Committee, which is dominated by the unionist parties, refused to examine the Scotland Bill’s tax proposals because it knows that there is a deflationary bias that would cost Scotland either £8 billion, according to the Scottish Government, or £700 million, according to the Scotland Office.
The unionist Scotland Office and the independence-seeking Scottish Government agree that the proposals in the bill, if applied over the past 10 years, would have cost Scotland many hundreds of millions, if not billions, of pounds of revenue. The only disagreement is by how much Scotland would have been disadvantaged, so how on earth can a committee justify not examining something that it is meant to scrutinise and which could be of great damage to the Scottish economy? When we should all be seeking to benefit employment in Scotland, how can Iain Gray come along and ask me about a square bracket?
The committee examined the evidence, and it was found wanting. The First Minister told us this week that, as a boy soprano, he had a range of four octaves. I was impressed—Pavarotti could manage only two and a half, although I believe that Julie Andrews has four octaves, too. However, that is nothing compared to how far the First Minister will stretch the truth to try to make his case for independence. The First Minister told the SNP conference:
“We know thanks to the work of Andrew Hughes Hallett and Drew Scott that with economic powers we could grow the Scottish economy ... 1 per cent a year.”
However, the professors did not say that and they still do not say that. It is not true. Did the First Minister misspeak, or did he mislead his own party?
“We know thanks to the work of Andrew Hughes Hallett and Drew Scott that with economic powers we could grow the Scottish economy ... 1 per cent a year.”
However, the professors did not say that and they still do not say that. It is not true. Did the First Minister misspeak, or did he mislead his own party?
I am sure that the whole Parliament is mystified by Iain Gray, as we are week on week, but I suppose that the great mystery is why someone with his magnetic personality has yet to be invited on to “Desert Island Discs”. I have been thinking and wondering what Iain Gray’s selection would be if he ever got invited on to that programme. How about “London Calling” by The Clash or “That’ll Be the Day” by Buddy Holly? I point out to Iain Gray that, if Professor Hughes Hallett and Professor Scott are correct and we get a 1.3 per cent increase in gross domestic product, that means that we have a 1.3 percent increase in Scottish overall wealth every year, after getting economic and financial powers.
It is fascinating that Iain Gray seems to believe that the committee has been examining the Scotland Bill, when that is about the only subject that Wendy Alexander refuses to talk about. Time after time, Professors Scott and Hughes Hallett said, “Can we comment on our evidence?” but Wendy Alexander, the convener of the committee, did not want to talk about it. Why not? Because it has a deflationary bias that will cost every person in Scotland money. That is why the Labour Party does not want to talk about proposed legislation that it intends to support. In contrast, economic powers will bring Scotland wealth and prosperity.
It is fascinating that Iain Gray seems to believe that the committee has been examining the Scotland Bill, when that is about the only subject that Wendy Alexander refuses to talk about. Time after time, Professors Scott and Hughes Hallett said, “Can we comment on our evidence?” but Wendy Alexander, the convener of the committee, did not want to talk about it. Why not? Because it has a deflationary bias that will cost every person in Scotland money. That is why the Labour Party does not want to talk about proposed legislation that it intends to support. In contrast, economic powers will bring Scotland wealth and prosperity.
Frankly, the longer the First Minister spends on a desert island, the better for Scotland. Leadership is a question of character, trust and judgment. If you take a piece of disputed research and then doctor it to mean something else, and you then embellish it and multiply the figures to suit your argument, how can you be trusted? If you then base your vision of Scotland’s future on that edifice of nonsense, what does that say about your judgment? And when you are caught out, if you will not put your hands up and admit it, what does that say about your character? Will the First Minister now republish his budget and take that doctored evidence out?
Let us deal with three points. First, Professors Hughes Hallett and Scott, the authors of the analysis, said in The Scotsman on 19 January 2011 that their figures
“were based on the impact of devolving both spending and tax powers.”
That is fiscal devolution, fiscal autonomy, fiscal responsibility or independence over the economy as we understand it. Secondly, the argument that some members in the Labour-Tory alliance on the Scotland Bill Committee have made—I recognise one of them, David McLetchie, sitting over there—was that Professor Feld did not argue about the devolving of both revenue and expenditure. The trouble is that David McLetchie and the committee cited only a part of the quote from Professor Feld’s evidence. I have the full quote before me. It goes on to say, and I quote, without square brackets:
“Decentralisation of taxes and spending leads to a more efficient public sector and it enhances economic performance.”
Enhancing economic performance is increasing economic growth and increasing economic growth is increasing prosperity for the Scottish people. If we can increase economic growth, as Professor Hughes Hallett and Drew Scott argue, we increase wealth and prosperity and employment in Scotland. If we are led by the unionist parties into the Tory trap of reduced Scottish spending that will result from the deflationary bias in the Scotland Bill proposals, we will face 10 to 15 years of progressive cutbacks in Scotland. That is why, when it comes to making a decision, people will vote for growth and real powers for this Parliament and this country.
“were based on the impact of devolving both spending and tax powers.”
That is fiscal devolution, fiscal autonomy, fiscal responsibility or independence over the economy as we understand it. Secondly, the argument that some members in the Labour-Tory alliance on the Scotland Bill Committee have made—I recognise one of them, David McLetchie, sitting over there—was that Professor Feld did not argue about the devolving of both revenue and expenditure. The trouble is that David McLetchie and the committee cited only a part of the quote from Professor Feld’s evidence. I have the full quote before me. It goes on to say, and I quote, without square brackets:
“Decentralisation of taxes and spending leads to a more efficient public sector and it enhances economic performance.”
Enhancing economic performance is increasing economic growth and increasing economic growth is increasing prosperity for the Scottish people. If we can increase economic growth, as Professor Hughes Hallett and Drew Scott argue, we increase wealth and prosperity and employment in Scotland. If we are led by the unionist parties into the Tory trap of reduced Scottish spending that will result from the deflationary bias in the Scotland Bill proposals, we will face 10 to 15 years of progressive cutbacks in Scotland. That is why, when it comes to making a decision, people will vote for growth and real powers for this Parliament and this country.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Jan 2011 →- Protecting Public Services Debate · 48
- Young People (Opportunities) Debate · 29
- Roads Maintenance (Salt and Grit) Questions · 6
- Devolved Taxes and Charges (Forecasts) Questions · 4
- Chief Medical Officer (Annual Report 2009) Questions · 4
- Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (Support) Questions · 13
- UK Consumer Protection Bodies (Reform) Questions · 7
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Change Fund) Questions · 4
- COSLA (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Supporters Direct (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Paternity Leave First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Renewable Energy (China) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fish Discards First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Marine Special Areas of Conservation Questions · 4
- “Low Carbon Scotland: Public Engagement Strategy” (Timetable) Questions · 8
- Salmon Farming Questions · 6
- Sewage Treatment Works (Bothwell Road) Questions · 4
- Local Food Producers (Large Retailers) Questions · 8
- Waste and Recycling (Cold Weather) Questions · 4
- Public Bodies (Reform) Bill (Forestry) Questions · 4
- Justice and Law Officers Questions · 1
- Custodial Sentences Questions · 8
- Police and Fire Services (Angus) Questions · 6
- Scottish Court Service (Weapons) Questions · 6
- Short Prison Sentences Questions · 6
- Domestic Abuse Courts Questions · 4
- Historic Environment (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 28
- “The Interpretation and Legislative Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 and other subordinate legislation Standing Order rule changes” Debate · 3
- Interests of Members of the Scottish Parliament Act 2006 and Code of Conduct Debate · 6
- “Minor changes to Standing Orders” Debate · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 21
- A9 Dualling (Timetable) Members’ business · 40
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.