Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 11 March 2003 Education, Culture and Sport Committee Procedure 37 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Showing Michael Russell only · show everyone

Michael Russell’s contributions

15 contributions
Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Although I have an interest in the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill, I am sympathetic to what Cathy Peattie has said. The situation at Grampian Television is serious. The assurance that, once it is in its new premises, it will not reduce the number of jobs for the duration of its present licence represents a small gleam of light, but that is a small consolation if one recalls that, 10 years ago, Grampian Television employed 380 people and when it moves to its new premises, it will employ 78 people. The reduction in 10 years is most extraordinary. I am also sympathetic to any discussion on Gaelic, but we will have to see what we can manage. Cathy Peattie and I will want to raise the situation involving Scottish Television and Grampian Television directly with those organisations and through the Broadcasting, Entertainment, Cinematograph and Theatre Union, which has already been in touch with the two of us.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

There should be a third, which is my response to the Presiding Officer.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I asked my office to give the third letter, which is my response to the Presiding Officer, to Susan Duffy at lunch time, but in the interest of economy of paper, I will explain what was in it when we come to it.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Perhaps I could say a word or two in introduction. I am conscious of the fact that there could be an unreasonable burden. I copied the material to each member of the committee as soon as I drafted the letter to the Presiding Officer, and I made the point that dealing with the bill would require a lot of good will. The suggested timetable is only a suggested timetable; it is no more than a template on which we could start to build an argument about where to go.Considering that the one amendment that I suggest could be dealt with on 17 March is absolutely non-controversial, and that it is agreed by the Executive, me and everyone on the committee, it would not create any difficulty if it were taken singly at another session. However, I am conscious that there are two other sets of amendments, one of which is almost as simple. However, the issue of how to do it is complex. That will be informed by evidence, although progress was made in the stage 1 debate in understanding how the bill might be expanded. I know that the Parliamentary Bureau is discussing the issue this afternoon, but I put it on record that I will do everything that I possibly can to get the bill through.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

You are absolutely correct in what you say. The reality of the situation is that the Parliamentary Bureau must refer the bill to us—I presume that it will do that—but we cannot start stage 2 without a financial resolution. I was in discussion with the Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport last week. I am open to discussion with him and his officials, as is the non-Executive bills unit, but so far, that discussion has not taken place. I have made it clear, both in the letter that the committee has seen, which went to the minister, and in the subsequent letter in response to David Steel's letter, that I am still open to that. Of course, it is possible to amend the financial memorandum as the bill progresses and is amended, and it is possible to lodge a financial resolution to allow stage 2 to start—that is not uncommon. That is what I am asking the Executive to do, and it will be able to say at the bureau meeting this afternoon whether it will do that. If it decides to lodge a financial resolution, we can follow the timetable that you have suggested, which would allow us to take stage 2 on 25 March. The Executive would then be required to agree to a suspension of standing orders to allow the bill to go on to stage 3 on 26 or 27 March. At the moment, I do not anticipate that there will be subordinate legislation provisions that the Subordinate Legislation Committee will have to consider but, if there are, I would ask the Subordinate Legislation Committee to make the appropriate arrangements so that the timetable could be met. These are unusual circumstances. The lateness of the bill is not entirely of my own making—there were technical reasons, which relate to the non-Executive bills unit. However, given the good will that the Parliament showed the bill last week, it is technically possible, with the suspension of a single standing order, for stage 3 to take place in the final week and for the bill to be passed. I concur with what Jackie Baillie said. The real difficulty lies in the final area of consideration and does not relate to the ombudsman or even to the simple technical matter of making the bill apply to the whole of Scotland. The question is how the bill applies. The precedent that is being considered most closely at the moment is the reporting that takes place on Gaelic's place within the national priorities in education. Some authorities do not have to report and some do, and some report minimal activities. Considerable work is being done on that, and I have already discussed the matter briefly with the minister. That might provide us with a way forward and a template for inserting a preamble to the schedule to the bill to remove the obligation to prepare a Gaelic language plan on those places that do not need to do so. I referred to that briefly in summing up last week, when responding to a point from George Lyon that the Deputy First Minister also made. Tavish Scott made a point to me privately about the position of Orkney and Shetland, and those are two local authority areas that would obviously not have to prepare a plan. A lot of thinking and work must go into those areas, and I have said that the best way to achieve that would be for the minister and his department to work closely with me and others to see whether we can formulate amendments in an agreed fashion so that they can be presented to the committee for scrutiny.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

There would be an obligation on all authorities in Scotland, but Orkney and Shetland would not produce a formal plan of the complexity and length that would be required for other areas. I thought that that was the main point that was made in the debate on Thursday. Orkney and Shetland have no history of using the Gaelic language.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

The point that I am making is that Orkney's plan or Shetland's would be very different from the plans for the Western Isles or the Highlands.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Essentially, we are talking about a minimal plan—nothing of the complexity of the plans for the Highlands or the Western Isles. The Borders plan might be somewhere between the two. There is a precedent for that in the national priorities on the use of Gaelic. We need to dig into the detail of that and find out about it.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Yes. I have asked the minister to let me have access to his officials, so that they can discuss the matter with me, and he has agreed to that. They have not yet indicated that they have any new thoughts on the matter, but they are thinking about it. I hope that they will have those new thoughts quickly. The non-Executive bills unit is also willing to enter into discussions to revise the financial memorandum in the light of that. It is difficult to make estimates in this area; even Executive bills have run into such difficulties in the past. The costs that would be involved for Orkney and Shetland would be of a quite different order from those involved for Highland or the Western Isles. I am open to such discussion. As I explained in my evidence to the committee, nothing in the financial memorandum is designed to pull the wool over people's eyes. The difficulty lay in estimating the costs, so the default position was to estimate the costs of producing a plan. The costs of implementing the plans will be variable, but I would put up no barrier to our arriving at suitable estimates—quite the reverse, in fact.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

The purpose of the bill is not simply to put in place Gaelic language plans; it is also to enshrine in law the basis of equality between English and Gaelic, and to give a means to express that. Gaelic language plans could be arrived at in any sort of way; the purpose of the bill is to enshrine in law what I would call the sacred principle, and then to give some initial articulation to that. The committee and I have been struck—as has everybody, I think—by the strong belief among the Gaelic community that the provisions of the bill would be something of tremendous symbolic as well as practical use, particularly so because this is happening in the first Scottish Parliament in 300 years. One is inevitably juggling all sorts of requirements. I am rational about the bill, yet I am also quite passionate about seeing whether it is possible for us to carry out this task in what is a brief period of time, while balancing out all the requirements. Indeed, it is a balancing act.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I think that the Gaelic community would be grateful for our taking a step, rather than rushing. The bill represents a step forward. I have always referred to it as a modest measure and a step forward, and that is what it would be were it implemented.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Every bit of progress is welcome. If we reach the stage of taking evidence, that will be welcome, too. The area is important. The committee will understand that I and many others—I spoke to a number of people over the weekend—are keen to make as much progress as we can.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I understand that, and I am grateful. The commentary on the debate about the bill has been that the Education, Culture and Sport Committee has moved the issue a giant step forward in its serious and positive deliberations during the five evidence-taking sessions that have taken place. I cannot quote him by name, but a senior figure in the Gaidhealtachd, with whom I spoke over the weekend, was of the opinion that the committee has made a bigger contribution to the future of the language than any parliamentary committee has done at any other time, here or elsewhere.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Tuesday 11 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 47
  4. Legacy Paper Committee business · 31
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 37

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.