Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 11 March 2003 Education, Culture and Sport Committee Procedure 37 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Showing Karen Gillon only · show everyone

Karen Gillon’s contributions

16 contributions
Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

Item 4 is an update on the work programme. Do members wish to raise anything before I discuss Gaelic?

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

My response to that will probably depend on the conclusion of our discussion about Gaelic. It is my honest view that, if we proceed to stage 2 of the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill, there will be very little scope within the programme to do anything further, as the time scale will not allow it.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

We have two meetings, on 17 March and 25 March. The meeting that is scheduled for 17 March will be held at Loch Lomond. We will have to discuss the outstanding reports and inquiries, of which there are three. We will have to deal with the Executive's response on the rural schools closures. If we proceed with the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill, we will take evidence, which will be followed by stage 2 amendments. I suggest that the meetings are already pretty full.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

On the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Bill, members have received two letters, one of which is a lengthy epistle from Mr Michael Russell.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

Flipping heck, this is becoming worse than the Hampden inquiry. It is all about who wrote to whom and when. The second letter is the Presiding Officer's response. Do we have a third letter?

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

We have the letter from Mike Russell and the letter from the Presiding Officer. I will take us through them. I am slightly reluctant about taking up Mike Russell's suggestion that we should deal with amendments on 17 March, as I want to tie up a number of other issues on that day. In addition, if we want to take evidence, that will take us a substantial amount of time. For that reason, I suggest that we should not deal with amendments on 17 March.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

As I understand it from the Presiding Officer's letter, we cannot start stage 2 until 18 March at the earliest, because of the dates, unless Parliament agrees to suspend standing orders at a meeting of the Parliament on Wednesday or Thursday. I must deal with things as they are at the moment and not with what might happen in future, which means that we are not in a position to discuss amendments until 18 March.As I understand it, it will be for the Parliamentary Bureau to timetable the discussion in Parliament. It will be for this committee to take evidence and to discuss amendments. As convener, I will not treat this bill any differently from any other bill that we have had at committee. I know that Michael Russell would not expect me to do that. We will scrutinise the bill properly and proceed with amendments on that basis. I have timetabled amendments for 25 March. As the standing orders stand, that would not allow the bill to pass stage 3, because there would not be enough sitting days between us completing stage 2 and Parliament having stage 3. We would require a motion and a vote in Parliament to allow that to happen.On top of that, a financial resolution requires to be laid by the Executive prior to stage 2 commencing. There are issues around that. We have raised concerns about the financial memorandum and its effectiveness. I do not know whether Mike Russell has discussed that with the Executive.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

That would be helpful. We are obviously tied by the procedures of the Parliament. I have amendments timetabled for 25 March, with evidence on 17 March, assuming that everything goes ahead. My only concern with the Presiding Officer's letter is the subordinate legislation issue. We would meet after the Subordinate Legislation Committee had met on the morning of 25 March, so that would be an issue if there were to be subordinate legislation. I am not sure how the amendments will be drafted—whether they create powers is obviously a matter for the draftspeople. Currently, there are no such powers, but we would have to see whether they would be required. It would be useful if Mike Russell could update us on the financial stuff.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

I am a bit confused by what you have just said. Did you say that Orkney and Shetland would not be asked to produce plans?

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

They would still be required to draw up a plan, would they not? My understanding of where we were at stage 1 was that we were looking to have all authorities producing plans and considering how those plans could be used in the development of Gaelic.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

Obviously, yes—as would the plan for the Borders.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

The committee was concerned that the financial memorandum does not cover the costs of implementation. Are the financial discussions continuing?

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

Matters are now in the hands of the Parliamentary Bureau. Unless the bureau refers the bill back to the committee, there is nothing else that we can do.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

With that in mind, I suggest that we go ahead with taking evidence on 17 March. Until the bureau refers the bill back to us, we cannot discuss possible amendments.

Karen Gillon Lab The Convener · Clydesdale
link

We will take evidence on Monday 17 March, and we will see where it leads us. We await the outcome of the Parliamentary Bureau's deliberations. Are members happy with that?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Tuesday 11 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 47
  4. Legacy Paper Committee business · 31
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 37

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.