Agenda item 11 is consideration of a further two affirmative instruments. The cabinet secretary will give evidence on both of them, alongside his third set of officials for the day. Louise Miller is still with us. She is joined by Chris Graham and Gary Gray, both of whom are from the Scottish Government’s zero waste delivery team. The Subordinate Legislation Committee made no comments on the regulations.I invite the cabinet secretary to make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2011 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Richard Lochhead 20
- Karen Gillon Lab 16
- Louise Miller Scottish Government Legal Services Directorate 5
- Maureen Watt SNP 4
- Chris Graham Scottish Government Rural and Environment Directorate 4
- Liam McArthur LD 3
- Elaine Murray Lab 3
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 2
- John Scott Con 2
The record
59 contributionsI will speak to both sets of regulations. There are two main policy drivers for the changes that are introduced through the regulations. The changes are intended to improve the effectiveness and accessibility of the legislation and to implement amendments that are required by the European Commission and the European Court of Justice.The original Waste Management Licensing Regulations 1994 have been amended on several occasions since they were introduced. As a result, the legislation is fairly cumbersome and it might be difficult to work out the current status of some of the provisions. The 1994 regulations set out the conditions with which those who treat, transport or dispose of controlled waste must comply. They also specify the activities that are exempt from the requirement to hold a licence. The waste management licensing system is in place to ensure that waste management facilities do not cause pollution to the environment, cause harm to human health or become seriously detrimental to the amenities of the locality.The main effect of the draft Waste Management Licensing (Scotland) Regulations is to consolidate the existing regulations into one up-to-date document, which will allow regulators and operators alike easier access to the relevant current law. As part of the joint better waste regulation exercise that was conducted by the Scottish Government and SEPA, we are also introducing amendments that will make the waste management licensing system more flexible and efficient. We have extended the range of activities that are potentially eligible for exemption from a full waste management licence, thereby reducing operator and regulator costs. For example, we have removed the restriction that only meat-free kitchen and canteen waste can be used in small-scale composting under an exemption. Appropriate controls on that already exist under the animal by-products legislation.The other drivers for the amendments are the introduction by the European Commission of a revised waste framework directive and a judgment by the European Court of Justice relating to waste carriers. Members of the committee will be aware that failure to take the necessary steps to ensure that the requirement of the revised directive is properly transposed into Scots law runs the risk of infraction proceedings being instigated. Although the essence of the revised waste framework directive remains the same as the previous version, greater emphasis is now placed on waste prevention and the hierarchy of waste treatment activities.The draft Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2011 transpose those aspects of the revised directive that are not covered by waste management licensing regulations. They also amend the relevant primary and secondary legislation to allow for a more flexible waste management licensing process, in line with our commitment to the principles of better regulation. The ECJ judgment to which I referred is another reason for introducing the regulations. It relates to the registration of waste carriers, which means professional collectors and transporters of waste as well as businesses that might do that as a normal part of their activities, such as joiners, plumbers and landscape gardeners.The court judgment followed a case brought against Italy, and it ruled that all undertakings that regularly carry waste as part of their normal business activities must be registered with SEPA. Previously, the requirement to register had been applied only to businesses whose main activity was the transportation of waste and not to businesses that simply transported their own waste. It is, of course, open to the business simply to contract with a waste management company to transport and dispose of its waste. It would then not have to register.11:15
Members will have noted that the deadline for transposing the requirements of the revised directive was 12 December 2010. It is unfortunate that we failed to meet that target, but I should make it clear that none of the UK Administrations and few member states, we understand, achieved it. The current timeline allows for a coming into force date at the end of March, which is consistent with the rest of the United Kingdom.The introduction of the regulations will not in itself have a major impact on the operation of the waste management industry in Scotland. The revised directive requires a number of additional changes to current practice, including the separate collection of waste streams and the publication of waste prevention plans, but it requires those changes to be introduced over a longer timeframe. Where they require legislation, those changes, which are in line with the zero waste plan for Scotland that we published last year, will be introduced through other regulations, which we have consulted on over the past three months. The consultation proposed a rolling programme of regulations over the next six years in Scotland to introduce the separate collection of specific waste streams so that they can be reused or recycled; banning those waste streams from disposal to landfill; and restricting the input to energy-from-waste plants so that only genuinely residual waste can be burned. It will be for the next Administration to consider the responses to the consultation and bring amending legislation before Parliament.My officials and I are happy to answer any questions on the two sets of draft regulations.
I have a procedural point for the committee. The SSI designation forms that are in front of us show—in error, I think—the Justice Committee as the lead committee. It seems to make sense for the SSIs to be before the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee. Perhaps we should confirm that they should be before this committee. That would seem to be proper.
Yes. That is correct. Thank you.
link
Cabinet secretary, you touched on the importance of the hierarchy of waste treatment activities. I think that everybody would subscribe to the notion that we need to direct more effort to reducing the overall amount of waste that we create, but it is inevitable that waste will be created. It is also fair to say that, historically, the ways in which we have introduced, implemented or enforced waste regulations have not always been helpful in maximising the opportunities for businesses, for example, to innovate in using waste as a resource and attaching a value to it. I took from your comments—certainly on the first set of regulations—that you are looking at a more flexible and efficient approach. What reassurance can you offer the committee that the way in which the regulations will be enforced will address the issue of waste without shutting off opportunities for markets to develop to deal with waste and reduce the overall cost to the taxpayer?
You make a fair point. We have made the argument, as all the parties that are represented in the Parliament have, that it is in the interests of businesses to address Scotland’s waste and the waste that they produce. It is clear that businesses can cut their costs. They can recycle and recover value from what they have previously regarded as simply waste.You are right. We must ensure that we carefully plot the road ahead. Many of the measures that are proposed in the zero waste plan for Scotland will be introduced over a number of years. We have just consulted on a number of them, and local authorities and businesses have clearly made the point to us that they want a degree of flexibility and the availability of a number of options to them to address the big issues in moving towards zero waste.
link
From conversations that I have had with the chairman and chief executive of SEPA, I know that they acknowledge that there have been problems with the way in which we have defined waste in the past. That has closed off options for dealing with waste in the way in which other member states appear to have been able to do, entirely in keeping with the spirit and letter of the law, which has enabled them to develop industry sectors that, as you said, allow value to be extracted from the waste while still meeting the other objectives. In your view, have lessons been learned from what has happened in the past? Will the way in which these regulations and others will be taken forward allow us to maximise opportunities?
The feedback that I have received from the business community and other organisations such as the National Farmers Union Scotland suggests that, in the past four years, there has been a sea change in attitudes in SEPA and other agencies. We all welcome that. However, I will not say that everything is completely fine, because I am aware that there are some on-going issues that we must continue to investigate. Just a few days ago, an individual indicated to me that they felt that they were being prevented from using waste oils to recover value and were having to send them south of the border. Clearly, that is causing me some concern in my role as minister. I am investigating the matter at the moment. I will not say that there is not still some way to go to help businesses to recover value from waste and to ensure that we are not gold plating some European regulations. We must strike a balance, but I will not say that there is not a lot more to be done.
link
We have had correspondence in the past on the impact of separation rules, especially on the catering sector. Waste disposal units have been introduced in cafes, restaurants, hotels and so on that may no longer comply with rules on separation. If that is the case, the impact on those businesses could be significant. Can you offer us reassurances about how any change in the rules might be introduced to mitigate that impact or to allow it to be spread over a period?
I can give you an assurance that we are determined to be proportionate and to take into account the need for a transition period. The separate collection of different wastes is one area in which we must be flexible and take our time, but it is really important that we go down that road—and not just because the European directive obliges us to look at the options. I remind the committee that Scotland produces 2 million tonnes of food waste a year, 500,000 tonnes of which goes straight into landfill. That is not good for the environment and it is a waste of a valuable resource. We are losing the opportunity to recover heat or electricity from that through the use of anaerobic digestion or whatever. It is important that we move as quickly as we can, but I take on board your point that we must work with the business community on a transition period.
You will be aware of the public concern around some of these issues. We must balance the business interest with that public concern and ensure that we are getting people the right information. The note that accompanies the regulations states:“The Regulations also include new activities eligible for exemption from full waste management licensing”.You gave us one example, which concerned food waste from schools. That is a good, positive example with which none of us has problems. Can you identify the other activities that will be eligible for exemption from full waste management licensing? It is important that we get the balance right. I know that business always wants to push the boundaries, but we must always be clear that we are not including in new regulations anything that might push the boundary on public health, where there are concerns at the margins.
The impact on public health is always a primary consideration for all these treatment processes. You are right that there is public concern about that. We all know that from media coverage of particular issues in Scotland at the moment. I spoke to an individual last night from the waste sector who said that, in some Scandinavian countries, the dirtiest word that you can use is landfill; everything is fine as long as it does not go to landfill or waste. Of course, we have a slightly different debate in this country, where other forms of treatment are perhaps viewed as not as palatable. However, I believe that most rational people think that we must avoid landfill for waste treatment. My officials can give more examples of what has been exempted, to give you some comfort in that regard.
There are a couple of examples. The activities might not necessarily be particularly new; it might be a refinement of the definition of the scale of activities that makes the change in the legislation. At the bottom of page 64 of the Waste Management Licensing (Scotland) Regulations 2011, a few items are listed:“The treatment of waste organophosphate sheep dip ... with an enzyme preparation, provided that no more than two tonnes of such waste is treated in any one day ... The mixing of ash from the incineration of pig or poultry carcasses at its place of production with manure for the treatment of land as specified in sub-paragraph (2).”On the facing page, we have:“anaerobic digestion of biodegradable waste which is agricultural waste or waste from a distillery.”Those are all subject to the same public health concerns and legislation that you would expect.
Thank you. I suppose that my second question, which is about the removal of the legal requirement for a certificate of technical competence, follows on from that. It seems quite strange that we would want to remove from an operator, particularly one that is operating an incinerator, the requirement for a certificate of technical competence. I understand that you believe that that system exceeds the requirements of the revised waste framework directive, but why would you not want someone to have a certificate of technical competence?
That is one of the issues that arose during the consultation. Our view is that while the certificate is clearly a valuable and valid indicator of an individual’s competence, or of his or her employer’s commitment to training and development, it is not in itself a guarantee that the terms of a waste management licence will always be complied with. The revised framework does not oblige us to retain the certificate as a legal requirement, so we felt that to do so in all cases would be gold plating and that it would place an unnecessary administrative and financial burden on operators.
So it enhances the training that a company gives to an individual and their competence, but we do not think that it is worth while for companies that operate serious pieces of kit. That is not gold plating, minister—it is good practice.
The question is simply whether the certificate should be a legal requirement. I think that the committee would criticise me for gold plating European regulations, if I proposed to do so. We always pay attention to that issue.
Someone would still be unable to get a licence to operate an incinerator or any other comparable facility without first satisfying SEPA of their competence. We are saying that the certificate is not the only way in which to guarantee competence.
I asked SEPA on Monday what checks would have to be undertaken before a company was considered to be fit in that regard: the checks are very basic. The certificate of technical competence is not gold plating. In Scotland, we must decide whether to remove the requirement for the certificate because it is an undue burden or whether to retain it because it enhances a company’s training provision and the management of a facility—I think that it enhances those areas.11:30
I do not think that anybody is arguing with that.
But we are taking it away, minister.
No. Officials can correct me if I am wrong, but I think that SEPA can make it part of its conditions that it wants that requirement to be satisfied.
But why would we transfer the burden from an elected minister to an unelected quango? We have the legislation and regulation from an accountable Parliament and committee, so why would we transfer the burden to an unelected quango?
At the moment, we have a regulator in SEPA.
But we have the provision in legislation. As an elected parliamentarian who has regulations before me, why would I want to transfer the responsibility from Parliament to an unelected regulator?
That is your interpretation of what is happening. We are simply saying—
But that is what is happening; it is not my interpretation.
In transposing a directive into Scots law, we took the view not to gold plate. That does not mean that SEPA cannot take into account the factors that we are talking about in issuing licences to any operator. SEPA has a very good record in being stringent about whom it issues licences to. Anyone who operates any major waste infrastructure project in Scotland will have to adhere to the highest standards. SEPA will take all that into account before it awards a licence to operate. I am not aware of any examples where it has not done so.
But those operators are operating under the current licensing regime, in which they would be required to have a certificate of technical competence. If we pass the regulations, they would be operating under a different licensing regime, in which they would not be required to have a certificate of technical competence.
But they would still be required to demonstrate that competence to SEPA.
Yes, but they would not be required to have a certificate of technical competence.
No, but the certificate is only one possible way of demonstrating technical competence to SEPA.
You said that operators would be required to demonstrate competence to SEPA. Would they be required to do so by law or it is just that SEPA would expect to have competence demonstrated to it? Is there a legislative requirement to demonstrate competence to SEPA?
Yes. Any applicant for a licence has to satisfy SEPA that it is technically competent. The regulations really just affect what SEPA is able to take into account as evidence of technical competence or otherwise. They get rid of one prescribed list of purely national qualifications and allow SEPA to consider whatever it thinks appropriate as evidence of competence. One obvious example might be an equivalent qualification obtained outside the UK, in the case of an operator that was not necessarily based here. That is just one example.
I move on to the revised waste framework directive, which was supposed to come in at the end of last year. It requires separate collection of waste and restricts the amount of energy from waste.Five years ago, Dumfries and Galloway Council signed a 25-year agreement with a company, which will now be in contravention of the directive, because the waste is all collected together and brought to a plant, where it is separated. The paper and the plastics are turned into fuel and burned. That will be in contravention of the directive, so the council will have to do something about its contract with the company to address that.I am aware that there are quite a number of waste incineration and other planning applications around. What sort of guidance is going out publicly to ensure that when councils consider applications at the moment, they are thinking about how they will deal with their waste? When the legislation is fully effected, there are certain things that councils will not be able to do. Some of the applications that are drifting around at the moment would seem to be in contravention of the new waste directive.
Zero waste Scotland has been working closely with our local authorities and, over the past couple of years, we have put in a great deal of effort to ensure that guidance and expertise are shared between local authorities, the Scottish Government and zero waste Scotland. The submission from the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities to our consultation on waste regulations that has just closed, which was circulated to either members of the committee or party spokespeople, welcomed that close co-operation on these issues.I am confident that local authorities are well aware of the expectations and demands and breadth of the directive and the Scottish Government’s policies in terms of moving towards a zero waste society.
If you thought that a local authority had passed an application that would be in contravention, would you call it in?
I cannot answer that question, as that is a planning issue. In any case, I would not call that in personally; that would be a matter for ministers with responsibility for planning. It would depend on the circumstances.
The minister will be aware of the growing environmental crime of illegal waste disposal, which is connected to illegal activities such as money laundering and drug dealing. He will also be aware of the need for new regulation in that regard in the next session of Parliament.Does the opportunity that is before us at this point help us to deal with the emerging and massive problem of illegal waste disposal? Has there been a missed opportunity in that regard, or does the issue require to be dealt with through separate and different legislation?
That is a good issue to highlight, as it is a huge blight and has an appalling impact on our environment. My view, however, is that this legislation is not directly related to that issue. There are other areas of Government that should be working on environment crime, and Parliament in the next session might wish to consider whether our current legislation is sufficient in terms of deterring it.
From the presentation that was made in Parliament last week by SEPA, it would seem to be evident that it is not—I am sure that you are aware of SEPA’s view.
That is one view. I am saying that I would be sympathetic to Parliament considering reviewing the penalties for environmental crime in Scotland. I think that that would have a lot of public support. Of course, there would need to be a debate over whether that would make any difference to the people who are involved in that kind of crime—in some areas, you are talking about organised crime. You say that the problem is that the legislation is insufficient, but we do not know whether changes to the legislation would change the behaviour of organised criminals. However, that is something that Parliament should investigate.
I am somewhat confused by the answer that you gave with regard to the certificate of technical competence issue. On one hand, you say that SEPA can still require it or its equivalent but, on the other hand, you say that it is gold plating.The Executive note on the instrument says:“The Scottish Government believes that this system exceeds the requirements of the revised Waste Framework Directive”.What are those requirements and in what ways does the certificate of technical competence exceed them?
I was merely making the point that I can see no reason why SEPA cannot take that into account when considering whether any operator is fit and proper to run a facility, irrespective of whether there is a legal requirement on all operators to hold that particular certificate. SEPA considers a range of factors and is stringent with regard to who gets a licence to operate such facilities.
If your rationale for getting rid of it is that it exceeds the requirements of the waste framework directive, can you say what the requirements of the waste framework directive are in this regard and how the certificate of technical competence exceeds them?
I will ask my officials to give you those details.
It would be very unlikely that any European directive would specifically mandate something like the COTC provisions that we have now, because what we have now is one list of qualifications that are exclusively UK qualifications. It is extremely unlikely that any directive would say to member states, “Go away and create a set of conditions for getting a permit that you can obtain only by training and qualifying within your member state.” There is an obvious—
How can you say definitively that the requirements under the COTC exceed the requirements under the waste framework directive?
The waste framework directive just does not contain any provision like that.
So it does not retain any requirement for staff to be appropriately trained, for them to have continuous training and for the company to have appropriate training mechanisms? That is what exists under the COTC.
The COTC requires operators to demonstrate that they have very specific qualifications, which are named qualifications and which they can get only in the UK. There is a list that refers to a specific set of UK qualifications for waste management. No European directive would ever specifically authorise or mandate a member state to go away and do that.I am not saying that there is necessarily an internal market problem with what we have done legally. So far as I am aware, we have never come under any pressure from the Commission on the matter, but it is not obviously internal market friendly and it is not something that would ever—
Does the problem perhaps lie in the wording of the Executive note, which states that“the Scottish government believes that this system exceeds the requirements of the revised waste framework directive”and in your statement regarding the regulation being gold plated? It seems to me that if you gold plate a regulation, you are asking for something over and above the requirements of the regulation. However, if the regulation does not include anything on training requirements, we cannot be gold plating it in respect of such requirements. I suspect that we are not gold plating it, because we should be requiring staff who work in the industry to be properly trained. That is not gold plating but good practice. I expect that the Health and Safety Executive also expects us to do that.
That is still the case. Applicants for a licence will still have to demonstrate to SEPA that they are technically competent to hold that licence. The only change is that SEPA will be able to consider evidence other than named UK-only qualifications on one specific list.
Perhaps the problem is how you framed this piece of advice to the committee.
Perhaps the wording is not perfect, but the key point is that SEPA will issue licences only to those who are competent to operate these facilities in Scotland. We should recognise that a very professional approach is taken to that.
If we were to leave certificates of technical competence as a way of meeting a particular requirement, I wonder whether that would open the door—I think of my own circumstance, as a degree in mathematics that I gained in the 1960s would not sensibly qualify me to be a mathematician today because I have forgotten almost all of it—to people who have qualifications but have not necessarily retained up-to-date knowledge and improved their knowledge seeking judicial review because they have met a certification requirement.If we go down a different road, SEPA will have the opportunity to require very up-to-date and specific knowledge to be demonstrated and in place. The approach that you recommend therefore ensures that we are not required to authorise people who may have undertaken qualifications some considerable time ago but can instead have a regime that is up to date and relevant to requirements.
I am happy to speak to SEPA about the general issue that the committee has raised regarding on-going training, skills and qualifications. The committee raises a fair issue. My point is that, in terms of the statutory instrument, it is perhaps a matter that we can discuss separately with SEPA.11:45
As the committee’s questions are exhausted, we move to the formal debates on the Waste Management Licensing (Scotland) Regulations 2011 and the Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2011. I remind everyone that officials cannot participate in the debates. I invite the cabinet secretary to move motions S3M-7834 and S3M-7835.Motions moved,That the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee recommends that the Waste Management Licensing (Scotland) Regulations 2011 be approved.That the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee recommends that the Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2011 be approved.—Richard Lochhead.Motions agreed to.
I thank the cabinet secretary and all his officials for being in attendance throughout our heavy schedule of affirmative instruments. I suspend the meeting briefly while the cabinet secretary and his officials take their leave.11:46 Meeting suspended.
11:46 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Mar 2011 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 (Post-legislative Scrutiny) Evidence session · 93
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 27
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 59
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.