Item 9 is consideration of an affirmative Scottish statutory instrument. Again, the Subordinate Legislation Committee has made no comment on the draft regulations. The Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and the Environment is still with us, but with a different set of officials. They are Louise Miller from the legal directorate; Helen Gordon-Smith, who is a policy officer on radioactive waste; Elizabeth Gray, who is the team leader on radioactive waste; and Stuart Hudson, who is a specialist adviser on radioactive waste.I invite the cabinet secretary to make a brief opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Radioactive Substances Act 1993 Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2011 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Richard Lochhead 7
- Stuart Hudson Scottish Government Rural and Environment Directorate 7
- Maureen Watt SNP 3
- Liam McArthur LD 3
- Bill Wilson SNP 3
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 2
- John Scott Con 2
The record
27 contributionsThank you, convener.As the committee will be aware, everything is naturally radioactive to some degree. The draft regulations form part of a UK-wide revision of the regulation of very low-risk radioactive substances. The Radioactive Substances Act 1993, which I will refer to as RSA 93, regulates the use of radioactive material and the disposal of radioactive waste, and amending regulations are needed to modernise the framework for regulating very low-risk radioactive material and waste. The framework determines whether a substance or article falls within the scope of the act or is exempt from the need for a permit. The amendment regulations will remove the need to regulate the use of very low-risk radioactive material and the disposal of very low-risk radioactive waste. They will not alter regulation of the use of higher-risk radioactive material or the disposal of higher-risk radioactive waste, which will still be subject to robust regulation.The changes are a response to requests for modernisation of the legislation from, for example, hospitals and universities that use radioactive material and produce radioactive waste. They told us that the previous regulatory framework, which remains essentially unchanged since the original Radioactive Substances Act 1960, puts undue burdens on them. Those views were reinforced by the regulators, who assessed the regulation of very low-risk radioactive material and waste as unnecessary. Hospitals, for example, have had to dispose of some waste as radioactive waste even though the radioactivity has decayed away, often in hours or days. Even though the radioactivity could no longer be detected, the waste was classed as radioactive under the legislation. Such an approach is both unnecessary and costly, so in the future such waste can be disposed of through conventional waste routes, which will reduce the regulatory burden and cost.At present, all man-made radioactive substances and very low-level naturally occurring radioactive substances are regulated, regardless of the level of risk. That is not proportionate. It has been clear for some time that the definitions of radioactive material and radioactive waste have needed to be modernised. The 1960 act recognised that low-risk items such as clocks and watches should be exempt from regulation, so over time a piecemeal exemption system built up. The 18 exemption orders, some of which were laid as far back as the 1960s, remove the need for the Scottish Environment Protection Agency to issue permits to use certain radioactive material and waste, but we now need a simpler system that is based on risk. For example, because they use a variety of radioactive substances for study or in experiments, universities have to use many of the 18 exemption orders. In the future, some of those substances might not require regulation and, if they do, the new single order can be used.11:00
Since 2006, we have been working closely with users and regulators on reviewing the legislation and permitting arrangements. The draft regulations and the Radioactive Substances Exemption (Scotland) Order 2011, which is being laid before Parliament as a separate instrument, are the result of extensive stakeholder engagement, including a UK-wide public consultation in 2009. The amending regulations will clarify what lies within the scope of regulation by updating the definitions of radioactive material and radioactive waste, and because the updated definitions will exclude substances that it is impractical or unnecessary to regulate for, RSA 93 will be brought into line with modern, risk-based regulatory practice.The exemption for clocks and watches in RSA 93 will be repealed by the regulations and replaced by the provisions in the order. The regulations and the order will have the effect of creating a modern and simplified regulatory framework that will provide efficiencies for both regulators and users: the estimated net savings for users and regulators in Scotland will be in the region of £1.28 million over the next 10 years or so.Convener, I am happy to answer any questions that you or committee members might have.
link
This is all clearly part of a UK-wide consultation. You might have implied the answer to my question in your concluding remarks, but I note that paragraph 5.5 on page 11 of the business and regulatory impact assessment says:“Businesses were concerned to ensure regulatory consistency across the UK.”I take from what you have said that the process will develop a UK-wide approach, but it would be helpful if you could confirm that. Secondly, were there any specific issues relating to the Scottish dimension of the consultation that opened up any differentiation from issues that were being explored elsewhere in the UK?
I can confirm that a UK-wide approach is being taken in order both to ensure that we have regulations that people can better understand and that have been simplified and written in modern English, and to identify very low-risk substances for exemption. As far as I am aware, a very similar approach is being taken across the whole of the UK.Perhaps my officials might be able to say whether any specific Scottish dimension has arisen in the consultation process.
Broadly speaking, we have not seen any significant differences. You might, for example, highlight the oil and gas industry, which is a significant industry that is primarily based in and more unique to Scotland, but such work is also carried out in England and Wales.
link
So, it is more a matter of emphasis with regard to industries that are more prevalent in Scotland than elsewhere than of a pattern of usage or impact that is different in Scotland for some other reason.
That is right.
link
That is helpful.
I take it that the reference to clocks and watches is to do with luminous paint, which is also widely used on the compasses that are used by hillwalkers and others, and on the instrumentation for certain modes of transport. Do the provisions as they now stand extend in an even way to all these different but basically very similar uses?
I will ask Stuart Hudson to comment in a moment, but you are right to pinpoint the use of luminous paint on clocks and watches.
As the 1993 act applies only to industry, it does not affect the use of, say, compasses by individuals. I also point out that luminous articles are already exempt and where possible we have carried them over into the new regime.
If the act applies only to industry, is it possible for certain restoration projects seeking to restore to their original state instruments or compasses in vessels or yachts of one sort or another using luminous paint to continue or are they now excluded?
There will be no change to the impact on that kind of project, to my knowledge.
You said that the regulations cover hospitals and universities. Do they cover the Ministry of Defence?
I would not expect so, but I will ask Stuart Hudson to give you an exact answer.
The changes that we are making do not make any change to the coverage of the Radioactive Substances Act 1993 with respect to the Ministry of Defence, which is exempt under section 40, or thereabouts, of the 1993 act.
Just so that I can be absolutely clear, are you saying that when the Ministry of Defence decides to dispose of depleted uranium shells in Scottish waters—they dishonestly claim that they are harmless when there is solid evidence that they are harmful—no one regulates that, and the Ministry of Defence is a law unto itself when it comes to disposing of radioactive material in Scottish waters?
There are no formal powers under the Radioactive Substances Act 1993 for SEPA to authorise the disposal of radioactive waste or the use of radioactive materials by the Ministry of Defence. There are letters of agreement under which, for example, Faslane operates.
The main point is that the MOD has Crown immunity from all the regulations. As you know, the Scottish Government strongly opposes the Ministry of Defence’s testing of depleted uranium shells on Scottish soil. That is our policy. However, the regulations will not affect that activity because of Crown immunity.
The MOD continues to be a law unto itself. Thank you, cabinet secretary.
I think that a political point was being made there. I will resist the temptation to rise to it. An election is coming; that is what it is about.I want to ask the minister about the disposal of low-level, low-risk radioactive waste. What practices will change in the future as a result of the regulations? In what way will they change?
Clearly, special arrangements have to be made for the collection and disposal of materials or waste that are classified as radioactive under the 1993 act and are not exempt. The changes are that those materials and waste that are exempt, such as those that might be found in hospitals and universities, can be disposed of using conventional routes because they will not be classified as radioactive substances under the regulations. The radioactivity can decay in a matter of hours in these substances, so they just become the same as any other waste.
So, was one hitherto meant to dispose of a watch or clock that had a luminous face in a different way?
The history of such items is that they were exempt.
The act was in place for businesses and their undertakings. It did not apply to individuals anyway, and that has not changed.
As there are no more questions, we will move to the formal debate on the regulations. I invite the cabinet secretary to move the motion.Motion moved,That the Rural Affairs and Environment Committee recommends that the Radioactive Substances Act 1993 Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2011 be approved.—Richard Lochhead.Motion agreed to.
The next item is a vote on the Waste Management Licensing (Scotland) Regulations 2011. Cabinet secretary, would you like to move the motion? Interruption.I beg your pardon; I am on the wrong page of my brief. I understand that the cabinet secretary needs different officials for the next item on the agenda. I suspend the meeting for a short time.11:09 Meeting suspended.
11:11 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Mar 2011 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 (Post-legislative Scrutiny) Evidence session · 93
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 27
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 59
- 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.