Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Maintaining Scotland’s Roads: a follow-up report”

Wednesday 23 February 2011 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 59 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

59 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 2 is consideration of “Maintaining Scotland’s Roads: a follow-up report”, which is a topical issue. I invite the Auditor General to comment.

Mr Black
link

Thank you, convener. The only interest that I have to declare is that I own a car. Laughter.

Mr Black
link

It was off the road for 48 hours because of an unforeseen pothole.

Mr Black
link

I sometimes think that, if we want media headlines, all we have to do is publish a report on potholes. However, to be serious—and we always report on serious matters—this is again a joint report with the Accounts Commission because of its responsibility for the oversight of local government expenditure. As before, I will offer a few brief comments and then hand over to Ronnie Nicol, who was in charge of this project and who will take you briefly through the main findings and recommendations.As the convener has just acknowledged, this is a matter of great public interest. There has been almost unprecedented media coverage of this particular report. We previously looked at road maintenance in 2004, and this report examines the progress that has been made by both Transport Scotland and local councils on implementing the recommendations that we made then. This report is therefore a follow-up to a previous report in which we made a set of clear recommendations. It reviews changes in the condition of the road network since 2004, how much is currently being spent on road maintenance, and how road maintenance is being managed.I would like to emphasise that the report is based on information that was collected between March and October 2010, so it does not consider the impact of this winter. In particular, it does not consider the severe weather that we all experienced round about Christmas. Even so, I have to say that what we found is rather disappointing. The condition of Scotland’s roads has worsened since our previous report. More significantly, the expenditure trends and the scale of the backlog in maintenance mean that the asset value of the network is not being sustained. As I have said on other occasions, deferring essential expenditure is a serious issue. In the first place, we are simply storing up problems for the future if we do not maintain the infrastructure. Secondly, we are simply passing on to our children and to future generations the burden that arises from our consumption of the assets that we inherited from the previous generation. There is a significant issue relating to fairness between our generation and the generations to come.The Government, local authorities and all public bodies are having to make extremely difficult spending decisions on their competing priorities. However, in view of the fact that our overall performance is slipping back, we suggest in the report that we need to think more radically about how Scotland’s road network is managed and maintained. We have suggested that there might be some kind of national review on behalf of the Government that allows all the parties to come together and seek the solutions that are urgently needed.At this point I will hand over to Ronnie Nicol, who will say a little bit more about some of the key findings.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Scotland’s road network consists of almost 56,000km of road. Transport Scotland is responsible for 3,400km of motorways and trunk roads, and councils are responsible for 26,000km of classified roads and 26,400km of unclassified roads. The road network is valued at £38 billion in its present condition.Despite public spending in Scotland rising by around 25 per cent since our previous report, the condition of Scotland’s roads has worsened. Only 63 per cent are now in acceptable condition.Trunk roads tend to carry higher volumes of traffic at greater speeds, so they need to be maintained to higher standards for safety reasons. Although trunk roads are in better condition than council-maintained roads, the percentage of trunk roads in acceptable condition has declined—from 84 per cent in 2006 to 78 per cent in 2010.The condition of council-maintained roads has also declined. For classified roads, 70 per cent were in acceptable condition in 2005, but that figure fell to 66 per cent by 2010. Unclassified roads, typically those in built-up areas, are in the poorest condition, with only 58 per cent in acceptable condition.As the condition of our roads declines, it is no great surprise that the cost of repairing the road maintenance backlog is increasing. The estimated cost of removing all network defects in Scotland, no matter how slight, is more than £2.25 billion, which is £1 billion more than in 2004. The road maintenance backlog for trunk roads is now £713 million. For council-maintained roads, it is £1.54 billion—although we know that that is an underestimate, as it does not include the cost of removing all the defects of councils’ bridges, lighting and footways.10:15

Various surveys by organisations such as the Automobile Association, the Royal Automobile Club Foundation and Transport Scotland have shown that users’ satisfaction with road conditions has decreased over time.It is perhaps surprising that we have reported a seemingly limited impact from the severe winter of 2009-10 on the latest road condition results. Although that winter caused significant damage to the road network compared with a normal winter, it tended to affect those roads that were already categorised as being in the worst condition, so their deterioration did not register in the road condition data.During 2009-10, a total of £654 million was spent on road maintenance in Scotland, of which £162 million was spent on trunk road maintenance and £492 million was spent on council-maintained roads. Although that represents an increase in expenditure of 5 per cent compared with 2004-05 after taking account of general inflation, road construction inflation was considerably higher than general inflation over that period. The effect is that, in purchasing terms, councils spent 13 per cent less, and Transport Scotland spent 32 per cent less, on road maintenance in 2009-10 than they did in 2004-05.Transport Scotland estimates that it would need to spend £275 million to get trunk roads into a steady state, whereby a fixed amount of roads need structural maintenance each year. Councils estimate that, to maintain roads in their current condition, they would need to spend £45 million more each year for the next 10 years on long-term structural maintenance. The consequences of not spending at that level are forecast to result in a £1 billion decline in the value of the local road network and a 10 per cent reduction in its condition.Despite the challenging financial outlook, it is still somewhat disappointing to note the limited progress that has been made on implementing the recommendations that were made in 2004 on the management of road maintenance. I will give you some examples to illustrate that. Asset management plans for roads, supported by appropriate inventory and information systems, are a fundamental requirement of good management. Although the Society of Chief Officers of Transportation in Scotland—SCOTS—provides support to councils in developing them, only a third of councils have complete road asset management plans in place, and several councils do not have sufficient data on the condition of items such as bridges, footways and non-illuminated signs.Furthermore, councils could do more to benchmark their road maintenance costs and their performance against other councils and the private sector as a way of identifying potential improvements. The 32 councils use a variety of different performance indicators, and that lack of consistency in the measures that are used makes it difficult to compare performance.There is also scope for more partnership working on road maintenance issues. There is some joint working or collaborative activity between councils—much of it at an early stage—but Tayside Contracts remains the only example of a multi-council consortium being established to undertake road maintenance, and it dates from before the reorganisation of local government in 1996. As we have said in our report, there is scope to develop a costed model that would help councils to assess and understand the benefits of sharing services.In his earlier comments, the Auditor General referred to the difficult decisions that the Government and councils face about spending on road maintenance and other services. There is an urgent need to explore new ways of working, and the national review that we propose represents an opportunity to stimulate service redesign and increase the pace at which the potential for shared services, partnership working and a more flexible use of resources is examined.I hope that these remarks have been helpful to the committee. My audit team colleagues and I will be happy to respond to any questions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I thank the Auditor General and Ronnie Nicol for a comprehensive introduction to a significant issue for us all. You have posed a challenge to politicians of all parties on how they address it. It is quite sobering and worrying to hear what you have had to say.The Auditor General’s point about the responsibility of the current generation of decision makers not to pass on a burden to future generations is well made. We have been the beneficiaries of good long-term planning and better times. There is some evidence that we are spending for the short term but not thinking in the long term.Audit Scotland might not have looked at this, but I understand the difficulties that councils have had in responding to two pretty severe winters that have had a huge impact on our local and national road network. The Auditor General gave us an amusing anecdote about his car being off the road because it hit a pothole, which is an experience that will have been shared with anguish, not amusement, by thousands of people across Scotland. Those who have their cars damaged by potholes are frustrated when they attempt to make a claim and the council’s insurers fall back on a tried and tested routine of asking whether the pothole has been reported. If it has not, the council accepts no liability or responsibility. Therefore, when people see a pothole, it is important that they do not just moan about it but report it, to protect the interests of other motorists.I understand that part of the problem is the budgetary situation, but it is increasingly evident that, when there is a local response to reports of potholes, the councils in general do not fix the problem for the long term. They merely respond to the problem to avoid an insurance liability. I can comment only on the area that I live in and represent in Renfrewshire, which Ronnie Nicol will be familiar with. Some roads virtually have ditches running down the middle of them and you cannot go near the side of the road on others unless you want to inflict significant damage on your car. What has happened is worrying, to say the least. In fact, it is appalling.There used to be a phrase about not throwing money down the drain. Now we see councils wasting money by throwing it down potholes. They are putting on temporary patches, which are only there for days before they start to unravel, but the councils can say that they have responded to the report about the pothole. There is no way on God’s earth that those repairs are going to last.However, I know companies across Scotland that are saying that they can do a job that, although it might initially be more expensive, will solve the problem with a solution that will last and save the councils money in the long run. What do we need to do, first, to get some common sense applied to the problem and, secondly, to address the immediate financial burden of a repair that might be more expensive but which—to come back to the Auditor General’s exhortation—will better serve us and future generations? What needs to be done to bring that common sense to the approach?

Mr Black
link

We have no easy answer to that. If we had, we would share it with you. It is one of those occasions on which the analysis asks more questions than it answers. As we say in the report, the Government, along with partners in local government, including Transport Scotland, needs to think seriously about a long-term solution. It is disappointing to find after five years that the picture is still pretty mixed as to whether local authorities have asset management plans that make sense, that comparative performance information systems are not there and so on. We need to move beyond all that pretty quickly.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I endorse the convener’s remarks. The problem, though, is not just with local roads; driving on the M90, as I do several times a week, I find myself weaving from one side of the road to the other to avoid all the cracks and potholes. Many other drivers do the same and one has to wonder how long it will be before there is a serious accident—or, indeed, more than one—as a result.It is made clear on page 3 that the report is based on evidence that was collected up until last October. We will all be familiar with the impact of the severe weather over the past three months on the roads, but the report predates that and does not take it into account. Would it therefore be correct to suggest that the current situation is much worse than that revealed in your report?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Yes. We carried out the audit work for this report last summer and autumn, and the statistics from SCOTS that we have used are for a similar period.I should point out, though, that our report notes the bad winter of 2009-10, which resulted in a significant deterioration in the roads. However, as I said in my introduction, that deterioration did not really register because the worst roads were already in the worst category. The correlation between very bad weather and the bad condition of roads is certainly very evident.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Perhaps we need another category—“extra worse”, perhaps—for future reports.I was interested to read in the second key message that public spending in Scotland increased by 25 per cent in the six years since your last report. When funding was increasing, money was still not being spent on repairing the roads—you might say that we did not fix them when the sun was shining—and, now that we are in a period of austerity, one has to wonder where that money will be found. What response did you get from councils when you asked them why, when their budgets were increasing, they did not invest properly in road maintenance?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

As this was a follow-up audit, we were essentially looking at the data that we had received in the previous audit. On this occasion, we focused on levels of spending, backlog estimates and the condition of roads; we did not audit councils individually and did not ask them specifically why they had made certain spending decisions.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Exhibit 6 on page 11 compares the situation in Scotland with that in England and Wales. It is clear that we are in a much worse position than they are; for example, the backlog cost per kilometre in Scotland is almost 50 per cent higher than it is south of the border. Why is the situation in Scotland so much worse?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

I am afraid that we did not drill into those differences to find out the reasons for them, but we thought that it might at least be of interest to present the picture.

Mr Black
link

That is another issue that has emerged from the report to which others will have to provide answers.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I do not know how we are fixed with regard to following up this report, but it is an issue that we could consider.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

In much of this discussion it seems that personal testimonies are required. It would be helpful if committee members helped each other in their appeals to local authorities.This is an emerging major issue, and the recent weather has certainly made the situation much worse. I thank Ronnie Nicol for his very helpful introduction, but I have a few issues that you might wish to comment on further. 10:30

If there is any issue that has no big problem of tension between national direction and local autonomy, it strikes me that it is road maintenance, because although it affects people it does not raise the kind of accountability issues that arise in relation to care services, health services, police services and fire services.The first issue is that the initial report came out in 2004, but a number of years later fundamental matters have not been addressed. One of those is asset management, as Ronnie Nicol said. We need national and local direction on that. Perhaps we can consider that issue.The second issue, which is raised in paragraphs 15 to 17 of the follow-up report, is the marked contrast between council-maintained unclassified roads and trunk roads. There is a massive disparity in that regard, and it would be helpful to consider how we narrow the gap with the resources that we have.Thirdly, we must ask how come there has been no radical shift in consortia arrangements, after all the exhortations at national and local level about partnership working and collaboration. I would have thought that we could have made substantial inroads in that regard.Finally, when we talk about £2.25 billion, everyone is terrified, and rightly so, because it is a massive amount of money. How do we bridge the gap? I presume that spending £2.25 billion would give us a Rolls-Royce, de luxe service. Are we just looking for a Lada service?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

The figure was provided by professional transport managers, so it reflects their judgment on keeping the roads in an acceptable, usable condition.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

What role is there for national direction in the debate, given that despite the publication of a major report little has changed dramatically?The differences between Scotland and England were mentioned. Is remoteness an issue? We had particularly bad winters last year and this year, which might be an issue. It is a wee bit colder up here than it is in other parts of the United Kingdom—or so I seem to have noticed over the years.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

I think that such factors are part of what has driven us to recommend that everyone comes together to have a new look at things at a national level. There has been a division of labour on who does what. Attention has been given to prioritising the most important routes—that is why we have trunk roads, classified roads and unclassified roads. A significant amount of money has been available, but it has not cracked the problem. Now is the time to have a more fundamental look at what happens and how it happens.The shared services issue is interesting, because there has been much activity. What is the missing ingredient that makes service sharing happen? That is the puzzle. The review and the coming together of people to talk about making fundamental changes might be a catalyst that offers a way in.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Please excuse the pun when I say that we seem to keep trying to reinvent the wheel. Lord Wheatley had it right in the early 1970s—

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

No. I am talking about the late Lord Wheatley. He is no longer there—at least, I did not notice him, anyway.As I recall, the best time for road maintenance was when we had regional councils in Strathclyde, Lothian and Tayside. The fact that the Tayside procurement consortium still exists testifies to that; people in Tayside are still working together. That was a much better time. Now we have tiny local authorities, which do not have the resources for road maintenance unless they work together. As Lord Wheatley said, the large estuarial authorities had many more resources and were able to do the work.That was not a question. My question is this: am I right in saying that the money for road maintenance comes out of the block grant, so it comes out of the same budget that covers other transport projects?

Mr Black
link

Yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I get the impression—this is not a party-political point in any way—that officials in the Scottish Executive or Government transport department are preoccupied with prestige projects, such as the Forth replacement crossing, which is a total waste of money, and that there is no glamour or excitement in keeping the roads properly maintained. Is that an unfair analysis?

Mr Black
link

If I may, I would prefer not to respond to the latter part of Mr Foulkes’s comment. On the former part, as some committee members might be aware, I have had a long career, which has included many years in local government. I can recall as far back as the time of Strathclyde Regional Council and the cuts that were required as a result of International Monetary Fund intervention. Some really quite difficult decisions had to be made in relation to what we used to call the structural maintenance programme and on-going pothole filling, gully emptying and so on. Going right back to those days, for understandable reasons, members of local authorities said, “We must preserve the care services. We can postpone the structural maintenance.” That was a feature of the 1970s through to the 1980s, and we have now seen it in the new millennium. One of the really difficult issues for any policy maker, whether a politician or an official, is to balance the long-term benefits and costs and the immediate pressures on budgets.On Tayside Contracts, I was very much involved at the time of the last reorganisation in persuading Dundee, Perth and Angus to retain that organisation. Again, however, there was an understandable pressure for people to control their own destiny, and that was not an easy set of conversations. However, Tayside Contracts did survive and, as far as we know, it is doing quite well.The point that Ronnie Nicol made a moment ago is central. Somehow we need to unlock this debate and get everybody around the table to think seriously about how we tackle the issue in the future.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Of course the one good thing about trams is that they do not create potholes, do they?

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We will leave that one for the moment.

Mr Black
link

We will revisit a response to that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

George Foulkes makes a significant point: leaving aside whether you are in favour of a replacement Forth crossing or any of the other big infrastructure projects, politicians will have to make decisions over the next few years about whether to invest in very expensive and open-ended projects or whether to address the basic infrastructure. It is quite clear that we might not be able to afford both. Politicians locally and nationally will face huge challenges.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

I want to follow on from what Frank McAveety and George Foulkes talked about. I refer specifically to part 3 of the report, on improving the management of road maintenance. I note that exhibit 11 on page 23 sets out the benefits of a shared local road maintenance service, drawing on John Arbuthnott’s review on behalf of the Clyde valley community planning partnership. How widespread is that approach? I note that paragraph 80 suggests that that type of approach is being taken forward by some of the local authorities in the south-east of the country. Is that happening anywhere else?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

I am not sure that we have a lot of information on that.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

I do not think that we could come up with any examples, other than what is included in paragraph 80. As you say, action has begun in the south-east, but it is very much at an early stage.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

So even the local authorities that make up the Clyde valley community planning partnership, where the review was done, have not particularly taken forward the approach, as far as you are aware.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Obviously, the Arbuthnott report covered quite a large range of services. As I understand it, other services have been looked at before this particular area.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Okay. In paragraph 84 you refer to the importance of Transport Scotland and local authorities working with utility companies to try to minimise the impact of road works on those who use the roads. I presume that you are talking about times when it is known that utilities are going into a new development or that there will be road works anyway—so that the road is not dug up for gas works to be put in, only for it to be dug up two months later for electricity cables and so on to be put in. Is that what you mean?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Yes. Potholes often occur where a road has been dug into for some reason and has been patched up. There are also issues with the same bit of road being dug up on more than one occasion because of a lack of co-ordination between the different utility companies. A lot is being done within the industry to improve the situation.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Case study 3 is West Lothian Council’s considerate contractor scheme. Does the scheme try to co-ordinate the activities of the various utility companies?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Yes. That is included as an illustration of what we are talking about.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

You refer to it as a positive example. Is the scheme being run anywhere else, as far as you are aware?

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

Not as far as we are aware from the survey responses that we received from councils.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I thank the convener for enlightening me about the practice of the insurance companies and why you have to report every pothole. I was at a residents meeting in the east end of Glasgow last week at which one of our councillors read out a list of about 25 streets in which he had reported potholes. I could not work out why on earth he was doing that, but that is obviously why. I remember when Councillor Alf Roberts was on “Coronation Street”—

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I do not remember it, actually—I remember the repeats, George.People were always asking, “How are the potholes in Rosamund Street?” It was a dull issue, but it is now the hot topic of the day, for obvious reasons. It is about more than car damage; I wonder whether there has been an increase in the number of accidents. I would be utterly astonished if there had not been, as I am constantly seeing cars that are being driven in front of me suddenly shoot off to the right. The drivers cannot possibly have time to check whether there is somebody behind them. When a driver sees that their vehicle is about to go into a big crater, it is their instinctive reaction to move around it. I would be interested to know whether any work is being done on that.Ronnie Nicol has talked about a national coming together, and the convener and Robert Black have talked about how we all must work on the issue together. It is probably our—the politicians’—fault that such a short-termist approach is being taken to it. Whenever a Government or a local authority wants to invest in taking a long-term approach to any problem at all, politicians from all political parties jump up outraged because such-and-such a service will not get the funding that it used to get. The money must come from somewhere and, as the convener said, decisions will have to be made. We, the politicians, must make decisions on the basis that there are some things on which we really have to work together. We should not be afraid to consider long-term solutions for fear of Opposition politicians jumping up and down saying, “That’s an outrage,” and telling us that we should be doing this or that with the money. A lot of the fault lies with us. I am not convinced that all of us sitting around the table agreeing that will effect any change, but I live in hope.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Members have already touched on some of the more obvious problems connected with the issue, but I have a question for Ronnie Nicol. Do you know what we are paying for the materials that we use to fix the roads? You are giving us a clear message that the costs and spend are going up and up. My attention was drawn to the case study on page 23, which refers to a new technique called crack and seat that seems to be bearing fruit in saving considerable amounts of money. Are we paying an awful lot more for the materials that we use to fix the roads than we might be paying? Your recommendations for the future would clearly be to review what materials we use, what is appropriate and how works can be co-ordinated better among local authorities—an issue that one committee member has already mentioned. What information can you offer in that area?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

I remind you that this was a follow-up audit and that the amount of audit work that was carried out was relatively limited. We tried to illustrate for the reader some of the interesting things that are happening as local authorities try to do things differently, but we do not have a breakdown of the spend. As we mention in the report, we know that the inflation factors for the things that contribute to what is spent on roads maintenance have been much higher, but we do not have any details on the split between how much is spent on labour and how much is spent on materials. We did not go into detail on the techniques that any maintenance operations use, either.10:45

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

The picture presented by the Auditor General’s report is certainly mixed—and that is an understatement. Local authorities and other elected members will certainly have to bite the bullet soon and try to adopt a more co-ordinated and integrated approach. Ronnie Nicol mentioned a case study; I do not know where it was carried out but, if it is anything to go by, there is some hope. The use of better materials will bring benefits in the future, and we could also recycle road materials to repair the roads.You may not be able to answer this question. The number of vehicle movements on the roads must have increased considerably since the publication of the previous report—I am thinking not only of cars but of heavy goods vehicles—and the number of vehicles on the roads must be a contributory factor in the condition of the roads. Furthermore, we have recently had severe winters. Is the salt that we have used another contributory factor in the decomposition of road surfaces?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Priority is given to roads with the highest levels of traffic, in acknowledgement of the fact that greater use leads to greater wear.

Graeme Greenhill Audit Scotland
link

Paragraph 10 on page 7 of the report says:“The volume of traffic on Scotland’s roads has increased by 27 per cent overall in the last 15 years.”Much of that increase relates to traffic on trunk roads.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Do the materials that we use to de-ice the roads have an effect—ultimately causing the potholes that we see in the spring and summer?

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

That is a technical issue that we did not consider in any detail. However, as a friend of mine who is a roads engineer once said, “We build roads to last for 30 years. The problem is that people start to use them.” Laughter. Inevitably, the more a road is used, the more it wears. Everyone acknowledges that.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I was interested in the new reconstruction technique that is mentioned on page 23 of the report. It is clear that some of the changes in the way in which our roads are upgraded or reconstructed could be having an impact.Committee colleagues will know that in many instances a sandstone-coloured finish has been introduced in the 100m of road before traffic lights, roundabouts and other junctions—particularly but not exclusively on trunk roads. When the finish was first introduced, it was explained to me that a new and slightly experimental approach was being taken in order to give a better grip and to get a better safety record at those junctions. However, the finish is softer and does not last as long as other finishes. Therefore, if you commit to it, you have to invest in maintaining it. There are quite a number of examples of that sandstone finish on the trunk road network having deteriorated markedly.I will give one important example. Some people here will know the section of road in Aberdeen between Great Western Road and Cromwell Road as you go up Anderson Drive. An entire section has failed where one strip of tarmac joins another that the construction company has been laying. Could the contractor be held responsible for that? At the moment, a seam is opening up in a section of carriageway that is approximately 600m long. It is the outside carriageway of a busy trunk road going through the centre of Aberdeen, and it is very dangerous. I would be interested in getting a bit more insight into such issues, and I would be interested in a further follow-up report, given the importance of this subject and the substantial deterioration in many aspects of the road network over the past few months.My final question relates back to Murdo Fraser’s comment about the M90, but it applies to any trunk road dual carriageway with a 70mph speed limit. If a significant pothole appears on such a trunk road, is there any time limit or target for repairing it? In some cases, we have had to wait for weeks for dangerous—indeed, life-threatening—potholes to be repaired. Ultimately, this is not only about legal liability and compensation claims; as more than one member has said this morning, these potholes could cost lives.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Much of the detail that you have asked for is beyond the audit work that we carry out. Certainly there is a problem with surfaces that for safety reasons have been laid on top of roads: they tend to deteriorate because, as you have acknowledged, they have other purposes.We did not look in detail at how contractors are held to account, but we know from our general intelligence how local authorities operate. They are always seeking to ensure that contractors who have to work on a piece of road restore it to a certain quality, and I have no doubt that all the local authorities have officers who check that type of thing. However, I am afraid that we did not examine the issue in this audit.As for your question about targets, although we do not know enough to be able to give you the numbers today, we do know that quicker responses are required for certain categories of roads. There might be, say, a 48-hour target for a particularly busy road or major artery; it might be longer for roads that are less busy. However, although those targets are certainly in the system, we did not audit their efficacy.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

And the target would be 48 hours rather than, say, 48 days.

Ronnie Nicol Audit Scotland
link

Yes. One of my colleagues has certainly mentioned 48 hours as the target for a fairly high-priority area.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I thank the Auditor General and Audit Scotland staff for their contribution to this discussion. I suspect that a future audit committee and, indeed, transport committee of the Parliament will want to return to the issue, given the shared view that the problem is worsening and will be a challenge to us all.Before we move on to item 4, which is an evidence-taking session on the section 23 report “Edinburgh trams interim report”, I will suspend the meeting for a few minutes.10:52 Meeting suspended.

10:58 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 7
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 68
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 59
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 253

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.