We move on to item 2 and a section 23 report entitled “The cost of public sector pensions in Scotland”. I invite the Auditor General to brief the committee on the report.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“The cost of public sector pensions in Scotland”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh Henry Lab 19
- John Lincoln Audit Scotland 19
- Mr Black 8
- Angela Cullen Audit Scotland 6
- Jamie Hepburn SNP 5
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
- Murdo Fraser Con 3
- George Foulkes Lab 2
- Anne McLaughlin SNP 2
- Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
The record
68 contributionsThank you, and good morning, convener. I would like to offer just a few words and then—with your agreement—I will ask Angela Cullen, who was responsible for overseeing the project, to summarise the key findings in the report.This is a joint report by the Accounts Commission and me on the cost of public sector pensions, which reflects our complementary but different responsibilities for scrutiny in local government and the rest of the public sector. One of the key points in the report is that there are some really quite big differences between each of the six main schemes, particularly in relation to how much employers and employees pay to meet the costs of each scheme, and in the level of benefits that individual pensioners receive.This is our second report looking at aspects of public sector pensions across Scotland. I made a report back in 2006, which members might recall. That report considered the financial pressures that were building up in the schemes then. We have prepared this latest report because those pressures remain significant—indeed, the level of interest surrounding public sector pensions has probably never been higher. As I am sure members are aware, and as we mention in the report, a former pensions minister, Lord Hutton, is currently reviewing public sector pensions across the whole of the United Kingdom on behalf of the UK Government. That review is due to publish options for major pensions reform next month.Audit Scotland’s report is intended to supplement Lord Hutton’s review by providing much more detailed information to help with transparency and understanding of the costs and features of the main schemes that operate in Scotland. We hope that the report will provide elected representatives—in the Parliament and in the Government, and those who oversee the local government pension scheme—with essential information about the current state of the main schemes in Scotland. We hope that that will be helpful in the context of the wider debate on public sector pensions that we expect will follow once Lord Hutton publishes his proposals for reform next month.I ask Angela Cullen to take over and explain some of the main features and key findings of the report.
Our report looks at Scotland’s six main public sector pension schemes, which are outlined in exhibit 1 on page 2. They cover most public sector staff in Scotland, including those who work in local government and the national health service, teachers, devolved civil servants, police and firefighters; in other words, they cover around 1 million people—or one in five of Scotland’s population—and cost around £3 billion a year to provide.In the report, we look at the costs of the six schemes, the benefits that pensioners receive, the operation of the schemes in Scotland and their governance arrangements. Pensions are incredibly complex and we have tried to structure our report to make things as transparent and accessible as possible.Part 1 of the report provides an overview of the key features and benefits of the schemes including how they operate, how much members and employers pay into them, the level of benefits to which pensioners are entitled and what pensioners actually receive. Although entitlements are largely similar, the amount that each pensioner gets varies greatly depending on their pay and length of service.Part 2 deals with recent reforms and Lord Hutton’s current review, which the Auditor General mentioned. It also describes the role of the Scottish Government, the constraints within which it must work and its influence over pension scheme reform in Scotland.The Auditor General also referred to differences among the schemes in the amount that employees and public bodies pay for pensions. Exhibit 2 on page 9 shows that public bodies contribute between 11.5 and 24.7 per cent of pay towards employees’ pensions. On average, employees pay around a third of that, with their contribution rates varying from 1.5 to 11 per cent of pay. Although higher contributions tend to reflect higher benefits, particularly in the police and the fire service, the rationale behind the variation in contribution rates is not entirely clear.As I mentioned earlier, we also looked at how much pensioners receive. Many pensions are low, reflecting relatively short service, low pay or a combination of both. Exhibit 3 on page 10 shows the average annual pension in each of the schemes and the difference in the average pension received by men and women. However, average pension is only part of the story; after all, some of the current pensioners retired many years ago. To provide a more accurate picture of the pensions that people are receiving now, we analysed information on annual pensions received by people who had retired within the past two years from the local government pension scheme—or LGPS—and the police and fire service pension schemes and by teachers who had retired within the past five years. That analysis, which is set out in exhibit 4 on page 12, confirms that differences in pension payments are largely related to length of service, and it is important that policy makers and others take that information into account when considering changes that might arise from Lord Hutton’s review. It certainly reinforces Lord Hutton’s point in his interim report that “It is mistaken to talk about ‘gold-plated’ pensions as being the norm across the public sector.”Parts 3 and 4 of the report deal separately with the costs and governance of the five main unfunded schemes and the LGPS respectively. The split reflects the significant difference between the LGPS and the other five schemes, both in their funding and in who is responsible and accountable for their governance.As the largest scheme in Scotland, the LGPS has more than 450,000 members and is administered by 11 local authorities. It is also the only funded scheme, which means that any surplus contributions are invested for the future.The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities is leading a pathfinder project, managed by the Improvement Service and funded by the Scottish Government, that is looking at options to rationalise the LGPS to reduce costs and improve risks and governance in future. Because there are now more pensioners and people are living longer than previously expected, there are significant cost pressures in all the schemes, both in the pensions paid out and in the money paid in towards the costs of providing pensions. The annual amount paid to pensioners has increased by 30 per cent in real terms in the past five years. Over the same period, contributions by employers and employees have risen by 19 per cent in real terms.In the LGPS, there is an additional cost pressure, because the return on investments in recent years has been lower than expected. The unfunded schemes do not have that cost pressure because they do not have any investments. However, contribution rates may rise in the unfunded schemes because of technical changes in how the rates are set. HM Treasury assumptions for calculating the rates are being reviewed, and that is expected to result in an increase in contribution rates.Recent UK Government decisions, including the change from using the retail prices index to using the consumer prices index for uprating public sector pensions and increases in employee contributions that were announced in the spending review, are expected to ease the cost pressures on the public sector. The combined effect of all these changes will not become apparent until later in 2011 or in 2012, when actuarial valuations are completed. Those valuations will take into account any changes made by the UK Government, together with the latest demographic data.Looking ahead to the position after Lord Hutton’s review, our report recommends that the Government should consider the differences among the schemes when deciding how best to implement the changes that may arise from the review. Our specific recommendations are outlined on page 5 of the report. We suggest that there is scope for the Scottish Government to strengthen its scrutiny of this major area of public spending.As ever, we are happy to answer any questions that members might have.
Thank you very much. I have a couple of technical questions. Perhaps you can clarify the position. Exhibit 2 on page 9, to which you referred, shows that, for the new police pension fund, the employers contribute almost 25 per cent, which is the same as with the old scheme. However, the employee contribution has gone down from 11 per cent to 9.5 per cent. What is the reason for that?
The main reason is that police officers will retire five years later and the benefits are slightly lower, so there is less need for employee contributions.
Okay. You indicate that in the LGPS some employees on higher rates can make additional contributions. What is the maximum percentage of their final salary that a senior member of staff can receive when they retire, if they had the maximum length of service?
If they have the maximum 40 years in the scheme, it depends on when they started. The accrual rate up to when the most recent reforms took place was forty eightieths, so people who were in the scheme until then would get half their salary, which includes the lump sum of three eightieths. Since the reforms, there is no lump sum. However, the accrual rate has gone up from eightieths to sixtieths, so the maximum that they can get is two thirds of their final salary. That will happen only for people who retire in about 35 years’ time, because it takes a while for the changes to feed through.
So at the moment anyone who retires could potentially retire on half their final salary, but some chief executives in the future may be able to retire on two thirds of their final salary.
Yes, that is correct. That would be in about 38 years.
Given the furore over chief officers’ pay in the public sector, is allowing them to retire on two thirds of their salary rather than on half meant to be a cost saving?
During the reforms, there were a lot of other changes in the local government scheme. One of those changes was to the rule of 85, which allowed people to retire before the age of 65 on a protected salary. That rule has now gone. There has also been a change in the employee contribution so that people on high salaries—chief executives, for example—pay a much higher employee contribution.Overall, the changes in the local government scheme that happened during the previous reforms getting rid of the rule of 85, the increase in contributions from employees, and the withdrawal of the lump sum—marginally reduced the cost of the scheme for employers.09:45
Under the present scheme, if someone has 35 or 36 years of service—thirty-six eightieths, as you described it—and if for the exigency of the service the council decides to allow that person to go early and to draw their pension early, and decides to give them added years, can you confirm that it is the council that will pay the additional contributions for those extra years for as long as the person lives and draws their pension? For example, if a chief officer goes early—as has been happening over the past 10 or 15 years—is it the council tax payers who will pay for the additional boost to an already generous pension?
When someone retires early in those circumstances, the council will ask the pension fund for a valuation of how much it will cost. An actuarial evaluation will be carried out by the pension funders to ascertain what is termed the strain on the fund. The council will then have to pay the additional cost of that person’s pension to the pension fund. It will have five years in which to do that.
link
I thank the Auditor General for his report. Exhibit 3 on page 10 certainly gives the lie, for a significant part of the public sector and for women in particular, to an issue that we hear about often—gold-plated public sector pensions.Can you give us further details? The exhibit gives a useful breakdown of average annual pensions for men and women, but I notice that figures are not available for the civil service. Why is that?
We asked the National Audit Office to ask the Cabinet Office on our behalf for that breakdown, but it was not able to provide it within the timescale that we gave.
link
So it could provide the breakdown but it might take a bit longer.
I think that it may have been able to provide it, but was not able—
link
Okay.
Before you move on, Jamie, I ask John Lincoln whether, if the Cabinet Office was not able to provide the breakdown within the timescale required for this report, it has provided the breakdown since.
It has not since provided us with the breakdown, no.
Is that something that you are pursuing?
It is not something that we are actively pursuing at the moment, no.
Okay.
link
I presume that that information is available and that someone could ask for it.What definition of civil service is used in the exhibit? I am a little surprised that the civil service is at the bottom of the league table, as it were. That can only indicate wild variations in civil service pensions, because I cannot imagine that the top mandarins receive an average pension of £4,222.
The civil service pension scheme covers a wide variety of staff—including, for example, fairly junior staff in the Scottish Government, clerks, people in jobcentres and so on. The scheme covers a huge variety of staff, so there will be an averaging effect.
link
Have you been able to break down the figures further, or are the figures shown in the exhibit as broken down as they can be?
We have not broken them down further.
Future pension liabilities are covered on page 24 of the report. I have never fully understood why we talk about a pensions black hole facing society. We know that the population is ageing, and we know that salary levels are generally on the up, so I would have imagined that Governments, financial planners and so on would be able to forecast changes in society in order to make provision for future pension liabilities.It seems clear from the Auditor General’s report that some variations are attributable to continued low interest rates; they appear to be one of the bigger factors in determining future pension liabilities.Exhibit 9 shows the extent of the problem that we potentially face. Over four years, the set-aside goes from £47 billion to £69 billion, which is an increase of nearly 50 per cent. How much of that change in liability is attributable to changes in society, and how much is attributable to interest rates, which have been steady over the past few years?
It is a mixed picture: we now have more pensioners than ever before because of an historical increase in the public sector workforce; public sector pay has increased over time; and people are living longer. There are demographic factors that influence the number of pensioners, how long they live and the pay that they retire on. However, interest rates are a major factor for the reported liabilities and for their valuation. Interest rates in 2007 were around 5 per cent, but they are now historically low, at 0.5 per cent. That has a major effect on the valuation of the pension liabilities, which now have a much higher valuation than they would have had if the interest rate had been 5 per cent.
I understand that. It is probably impossible to get an answer, but this is what I am trying to get at. If and when interest rates normalise, recover, change or increase—or whatever the term is—the pension liability will come down significantly, I think. For me, it is about how much of the liability is attributable to interest rates and how much is attributable to societal changes, which we well know about and presumably have been planning for over a number of years. It is hard to see what the breakdown is. Major changes in pension policy could come about because of flat interest rates over a number of years rather than because of changes in society at large.
Yes—there is a combination of factors.
There is a small section on the issue in Hutton’s interim report, which states:“The changes in the discount rate assumptions ... did not result from adjustments to the assumed security or generosity of public service pensions. Instead ... they were linked to”interest rates and corporate bonds, and reflect“the change in assumed risk of corporate defaults during ... the credit crunch.”So, that is what is driving things. The report continues:“A change of this kind in bond yields has no implications for the actual cost of providing public sector pensions, so such estimates of accrued liabilities need to be used with caution.”I think that that sums it up.
The conclusion that I draw from that technical information is that quite a lot of the pensions black hole is attributable to interest rates rather than to the societal changes that we have been told all along are the principal reason for the liability increasing.
Just before I bring in George Foulkes, I want to follow up Willie Coffey’s point. Do the figures that you have shown also reflect the changes that the present UK Government has introduced, which will steadily erode the value of pensions?
No. Those figures were from March 2010.
So will the changes that have now been introduced have the effect of reducing the pensions liability?
Yes. The assumption in the Hutton review was that the change from using the RPI to using the CPI would reduce overall payments by about 15 per cent.
Can I perhaps supplement John Lincoln’s very full answer to Mr Coffey’s question? I refer members to page 41 of our report. As Mr Coffey indicated, it is important to be aware of the overall liabilities in the longer term, which could stretch out for around 70 years. It is also important to be aware that the major factors involved are the interest rates and the actuarial revaluations that are based on those. In the extreme right-hand column of the diagram on page 41, we can see the cost of the scheme in-year. For example, we can see that the local government pension scheme has a positive net cash flow of £266 million. The national health service scheme is similarly positive. However, there are negative figures for the schemes for teachers and the civil service, and the schemes for the police and firefighters break even.That tells us—perhaps this reinforces the point implied in Mr Coffey’s question—that there is not an immediate crisis, as all the funds are being managed appropriately, but we need to ensure that we have a searchlight that looks to the future to see how liabilities are building up in the light of the performance of capital markets and the growth in the number of pensioners and what they are entitled to.
Can we put matters into a bit of perspective? We are talking about 172,300 pensioners. That is the figure given in the key messages in the report. The cost of those pensions is coming up to £2 billion, which is a little less than the Royal Bank of Scotland pays in bonuses, on top of huge salaries, not to mention pension contributions—paid for out of taxes from the public, including from public service pensioners. Is that correct?
We have not audited those numbers, but I acknowledge the point that you are making, Lord Foulkes.
It is about time that we put matters into perspective. Public sector pensions are not generous in the context of some payments that are being made to people in the private sector, particularly in the banks, which provide services that bear no comparison with the services that are provided by the doctors, teachers and nurses whom we are talking about. It is about time that people realised that.
link
I will ask about the comments on aspects of final salary schemes on page 13 of the report. How many of the six schemes that we are talking about are final salary schemes?
It depends on when the person joined the scheme, to a certain extent. Apart from the new civil service scheme, all the schemes are final salary schemes. People who have joined the civil service in the past three or four years are in the nuvos scheme, which is an average salary scheme. All the rest are final salary schemes.
link
So they are all final salary schemes apart from the most recent civil service scheme. Have you done any comparison with the private sector and considered the percentage of people who are employed in it who are in final salary schemes?
We did not directly compare the numbers.
We have not made a comparison against final salary schemes, but paragraph 12 on pages 6 and 7 of the report states:“Around 500,000 current employees are active members of one of the six main schemes in Scotland, which is around 85 per cent of the public sector workforce.”That compares with only 35 per cent of the private sector workforce who are currently in pension schemes. The paragraph says:“The Pension Act 2008 due to come into effect in 2012 will require”all private sector“employers to automatically enrol most employees into a qualifying pension scheme.”Therefore, steps are already in place to try to redress the imbalance, but there is quite a stark difference between the number of public sector employees who are currently in pension schemes versus the number of private sector employees who are in them.
link
Most private sector employees do not work for banks and are not on very substantial salaries, of course. Thank you.
I want to raise an issue to do with final salary pension schemes that is not in the report. I wonder whether Audit Scotland has come across it. I have not worked for a local authority and am not entirely sure how things happen in them, but I have worked with a vital community project in the voluntary sector. It was a small project that dealt with a number of clients in a mental health setting, and it inherited the pension agreements of staff who had transferred to it. Because of the cuts, which will get worse in the coming years, some money was lost and redundancies had to be offered. When they were offered, there was a wait to find out whether certain people who were in one of the pension schemes and had paid into it for a long time would accept those offers. Obviously, it was hoped that they would not, but they did. The project, which was vital, had to close because it was told that it faced a massive bill—I think that it was liable for more than £1 million, which was impossible for it to pay. How often is that going to happen? How commonplace is it going to be? Projects will have to offer redundancy. Is there going to be a problem in the voluntary sector because of small organisations that simply cannot meet their liabilities?10:00
We have not considered that issue specifically in this report. There are quite a few voluntary organisations whose employees are members of the LGPS—there are around 600 admitted bodies in the LGPS, in addition to the 32 councils.
It is worth making the rather obvious point that this is not simply a problem for bodies that are admitted to the local government pension scheme. It is an issue to do with the employment rights in law of employees who have been with an organisation longer than two years and are entitled to a statutory redundancy payment. I acknowledge absolutely the point that this situation could tip small organisations without a strong cash flow over the edge. However, we have not considered that in any way.
Is there any scope for you to consider it? Who else would consider it? One of the Governments needs to consider the issue in case it causes a big problem. The project that I mentioned cannot be the only one that is affected. It never expected to be in this position. It accepted that it had responsibilities, as an employer. However, because the project is small and is dependent on public funding, which is reducing, those responsibilities resulted in closure.
My immediate thought is that the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations would be the first port of call for information about what is happening to the viability of some of those organisations and the extent to which the issue is a problem.
Over the past 15 or 16 years, early retirement has become a feature for senior and middle management, as a means by which local government, the health service and the civil service can reorganise. The argument is that downsizing in such a manner enables those public sector bodies to reduce their costs. However, as I have said before, there is an underlying cost to allowing those early retirements, as has become obvious over the past 15 or 16 years. Have you done a calculation of the additional cost to the pension schemes of allowing those earning more than, for example, £50,000 a year to take early retirement? What is the additional cost to the body that allows them to go, in terms of the additional contributions?
We have not considered that issue specifically. In part 3 of the report, we comment on lump sums being offered. The take-up of those has been relatively high and increased to around 25 per cent of total pension payments in 2009-10. In the report, we say that the costs of any decisions that are made on early retirement are borne by the employer, which must assess the business case for that, as John Lincoln said earlier.
In general terms, if a public body is minded to offer someone voluntary early retirement, we would expect it to present a business case that shows a financial benefit to the public purse, over an appropriate period of time. A few years ago—before devolution—in a report that I did for the Accounts Commission on the costs of local government reorganisation, I highlighted the issue of the number of staff leaving during that period and the question whether the substantial cost of that was offset by a financial benefit. It is fair to say that, in the years since devolution, greater discipline has been applied to require people to be able to demonstrate the business case for early retirement packages.
If a senior director decides to go a bit early and leave with 38 or 39 years’ service—let us use the example of eightieths—normally the only justification for giving added years is that there is a saving to the council. However, if the council replaces the director with another director, there is no obvious saving. What penalties or implications are there for a council that gives added years to someone who is already entitled to a generous pension?
It is for the individual local authority, non-departmental public body or other public body to make the business case. It is not impossible that a post at any level would be replaced broadly on a like-for-like basis but consequential vacancies down the scale would not be filled, which might generate the saving. That is not an unknown set of circumstances.
No, but if that does not happen, the council should not make additional payments to a director who is going in such circumstances.
It is difficult for me to comment in the abstract on that, but I acknowledge the point that you make.
Would the Accounts Commission consider the matter in such a situation?
The auditors of local authorities would be vigilant over what was happening with regard to early release of staff.
Not just chief executives but many heads of service and directors are earning more than £100,000, and many of them have been at that level for only a few years of their working lives. That brings me back to the issue about final and average salary. I do not have a problem with the final salary approach for people who earn modest sums for most of their lives, but I have a problem with people who earn modest sums contributing to generous pensions for a small number of people who have not been at a very high level for long.If someone is on £100,000, the forty eightieths rule gives them a pension of £50,000 per year in the local government scheme. Is the lump sum calculated on the basis of three times the pension? Does the person get a tax-free lump sum of £150,000?
Until the most recent round of reforms the lump sum was thirty eightieths. There are no lump sums in the new local government scheme, so a person who wants a lump sum must give up a proportion of their pension to get one. If they give up £1 in pension, they get £12 in lump sum—that is the ratio.
Do the new arrangements apply only to new entrants or do they apply to everyone?
I think that everyone still retains the right to the lump sum of thirty eightieths of salary up to 2009. After 2009 they do not get the lump sum.
What point in 2009 are we talking about?
I do not recall the operational date. It is probably 1 April.
Okay. If there are no more questions, I thank the witnesses for their evidence. I am sure that public sector pensions will continue to be a significant issue in the years to come.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Feb 2011 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 7
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 68
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 59
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 253
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.