Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2011 (Draft)

Wednesday 2 March 2011 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 28 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

28 contributions
Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Item 7 is another affirmative order. I invite the minister to introduce his new team and to make opening remarks.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I am joined by Nicola Shiels, Neal Rafferty and Sue Kearns. Thank you for this chance to make some opening comments. I am well aware that the committee is familiar with the renewables obligation, as I have sat before the committee and discussed the matter every year since 2007. In doing so for the last time, I thank the committee for its courtesy and for the quality of its engagement on these occasions.Members will know that the obligation is a fundamental driver behind each decision to invest in renewable electricity-generating capacity. It was introduced back in 2002. In the seven years up to 2009, renewable electricity generation across Scotland has more than doubled. Indeed, the figures for 2009 demonstrate that renewable generation in Scotland from wind and thermal sources such as biomass and renewable waste outstripped generation from natural-flow hydroelectric stations for the first time ever.That trend will continue over the next 10 years. We expect more and more generation to come from offshore wind, from wave power and from tidal stream. This energy comes from sources where Scotland has a huge competitive advantage, and it can create world-leading industries. It is therefore vital that we maintain the legislation as fit for purpose and the ability to continue to attract investment in new technologies and developments across Scotland in a way that is cost effective and sustainable.The amendments that are contained in the order are designed to do just that. In proposing that offshore wind generators that accredit after 31 March 2011 should be able to register their turbines in phases, we are acknowledging the lengthy period over which such very large developments will often be constructed, and ensuring that support for those projects is accessible and is delivered in a way that is consistent with that reality.Offshore wind generators will be able to register five phases of turbines over a maximum period of five years. The first phase should include a minimum number of turbines equivalent to 20 per cent of the proposed total installed capacity of the development. Over time, we believe that that flexibility will have a positive effect on the development of further offshore wind capacity in Scottish waters.Our consultation also found a great deal of support for extending the principle in the future, particularly as wave and tidal projects begin to come forward at scale. We have also agreed, in light of the outcome to our consultation, to extend the principle of grandfathering to stations using biomass and waste. As members will know, grandfathering is the principle that protects the level of renewables obligation certificates banding at the point at which a specific investment is made. Grandfathering means that stations that are financed and commissioned on the basis of a certain number of ROCs per megawatt hour will not have that support reduced as a result of a future review. That mirrors the position across the rest of the UK and takes into account the evidence from stakeholders that grandfathering will protect investment, particularly in small-scale projects.More widely, we have also announced an intention to conduct in the coming year a broad review of biomass support through the obligation. Our starting point for that is a desire to make the support consistent with the Government’s policy aim to see biomass generating plant designed at a scale that is consistent with the most efficient use of what is a limited resource. We want an approach that will make a vital contribution to meeting our ambitious renewable heat targets.The order also introduces new sustainability criteria for biomass and biogas generation. Mandatory reporting against those criteria will take effect from April this year and will be linked to support from April 2013. The new criteria impose a carbon dioxide emissions ceiling for biomass generators and direct land use criteria that are consistent with the relevant European Commission renewable energy directive. The criteria and their continued development will be informed by the work of the UK biomass and biogas sustainability implementation group, which involves direct input from Scotland and Scottish stakeholders.The order also complies with the renewable energy directive through its introduction of mandatory sustainability criteria for bioliquids. In order to qualify for ROCs, generators using bioliquids will need to comply with those criteria from 1 April this year. The order now extends, again in compliance with the directive, to biodiesel that is partially derived from fossil fuel, although ROCs will only be eligible against the biomass proportion of the fuel’s energy content.The changes mentioned thus far are being implemented in a uniform manner across all the UK obligations, but we have one more that is unique to Scotland: an amendment to our enhanced wave and tidal definitions that is designed to enable projects to receive capital grant support as well as our higher ROC band when appropriate. The change has been agreed by the European Commission and warmly welcomed by the vast majority of our stakeholders. The changes will improve the efficiency and sustainability of the obligation. They are designed to maintain confidence in the system—confidence that is more important than ever before. Before I formally move the motion on the order, I am happy to respond to any questions that the committee may have.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Thank you for your opening remarks. The committee has received a written response from Scottish Renewables on the order. It generally welcomes the order, but it raises concerns, stating that“the Scottish Government has not acted upon our suggestion to increase tidal stream support to same level as wave support ... stating that they are not in a position to change the tidal band in April 2011 as part of the current legislative amendment”.Can you explain the Government’s reasoning for that and how you propose to address the issues that Scottish Renewables has raised?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Many respondents to our consultation pressed the Government to reconsider its current level of support on tidal power. Specifically, they pressed the Government to raise it from three to five ROCs, which is the same level for wave power. We are not making that change as part of the current amendments, but we made it clear in our response that we remain entirely open to the case for such a change and are ready to take forward a fresh review should the evidence support such a move.There will be further evidence of that approach in our liaison with the UK Government when we discuss energy market reform with it this evening. I hope that that will open another level of debate beyond what is happening between officials in the Scottish Government and officials in the Department of Energy and Climate Change. I hope that the debate on the renewables obligation will continue to be characterised, as it has been all the way through, by openness and engagement with all the stakeholders.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

There seems to be a difference between the evidence base suggested by Renewables UK and that suggested in the Ernst & Young report. What assessment has the Government made of those two evidence bases to determine whether either or both are right—or wrong?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

One lesson that I have learned in politics, particularly in my role as minister, is that the more that we lend ourselves to consultation, the more likely it is that when the consultation is completed, no matter how elegantly we carve our way through it, we may well offend the vast majority of people with our final decision. Our inclination is therefore to get people together to have a debate, such the one that we will have tonight on electricity market reform.Going forward, we will look to ensure that those conflicting opinions are represented in the room, because when you ask people why they hold conflicting views, invariably it does not take long before they converge on a common goal and we have the chance to mediate and resolve the conflict. The fact that we are aware of the conflict is a plus, and the fact that we have a mechanism to handle it is an even bigger plus.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

I will follow up on the convener’s question. Scottish Renewables has said that ROCs should be the same for tidal stream and wave. What is the Government’s argument for not making them the same?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

That is a function of timing. We are not approaching the issue from a doctrinaire position; we are showing a willingness to engage and a keen desire to do that in conjunction with colleagues in Westminster.

Neal Rafferty Scottish Government Directorate for Energy and Climate Change
link

When we introduced the higher bands in Scotland to begin with, we did so on the basis of a piece of work that suggested that tidal stream costs were lower than those for wave, which is why we have the differential now. The Ernst & Young study, which was published in March last year, was quickly followed up by a piece of work by Renewables UK, which is vocal about the need to introduce the same support levels for both sets of technology. It is quite a compelling piece of work. We are currently considering the matter with our UK Government colleagues in the context of a wider banding review.Renewables UK makes a strong case, and we know that the industry speaks with one very strong voice in general, and is saying that there should be a single band of five ROCs for wave and for tidal stream. We are considering that suggestion in the context of the UK banding review and we shall see where that moves over the next few weeks and months. The case is fairly strong and it is being put fairly unanimously by the industry, so there is a good chance that there will be movement on those bands in the next few months.

David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

What would the impact be if we did not do anything?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

It would be negative. We have been flexing with the reality of the sector and the technologies, which are evolving. That has won us a lot of friends and has also meant that many people have read the signals and made the investment—hence we have been able to meet the 31 per cent target and to uplift the 2020 target from 50 to 80 per cent. That approach is allowing the Parliament—let alone the Government—to be seen as an honest, flexible, listening broker.

David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I am sure that there will be an interesting debate tonight on whether the targets are achievable. Where did the pressure come from to allow phased development? Did it come only from the industry or was it recognised within Government that an all-or-nothing approach was a hindrance to development?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

It certainly came from the industry, but you will remember that we held a low-carbon finance conference last year, on 28 and 29 September. Another conference has been announced today, so there is a process. By bringing people together in that format, we identified greater clarity on the risks and rewards that are involved in the sector and developed a greater understanding of the challenges that companies face in making the financial case to get the necessary financial backing. In essence, we are trying to get all the players joined up in common cause and to show the flexibility that puts in place the confidence that enables investment and follow-on investment to happen.12:30

David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Did any local authorities express any reservations about whether their planning departments would be able to cope?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

That will be more an issue for Marine Scotland than for local authorities per se.

Neal Rafferty Scottish Government Directorate for Energy and Climate Change
link

We did not receive any representations from local authorities through the consultation process.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Anything that involves a large amount of civil engineering reminds me instantly of the Office of Fair Trading inquiry at, I think, the end of 2006 into the granting of civil engineering contracts. The OFT found that there was massive capitalisation in that area but then decided to fine the companies concerned a slap on the wrist of a couple of hundred million pounds, which was peanuts in comparison with the $8 billion that the industry was worth then.Is your system robust enough to combat Adam Smith’s old equation that we can be certain that, when two or three people in the same business get together, be it for purposes of play or merriment, within two hours they will have created a conspiracy to raise prices? You have to be robust about that.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

The robustness and scrutiny exist. The scrutiny is not only national but global. We have some interesting parties—such as Ronnie Bowie from the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries, which has repositioned itself as the faculty of enterprise risk managers—looking over our shoulder and the shoulder of the industry to ensure that the industry grows in a way that is conducive to maximising our economy and its competitiveness.Given the massive scale of the civil engineering, we are beginning to see real collaborations, and there is interest from companies from outwith Scotland in being involved and participating here.After the financial crisis that we have all been through and having seen the moral hazards and the disaster that they can cause in the financial sector, I like to think that we are about to enter a new era of a higher level of ethics. There is a requirement for that.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I am not sure whether the Adam Smith quotation was a condemnation of businessmen or a condemnation of the game of golf.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Perhaps it was a condemnation of some of the things that we taught in our business schools in the past, but they are being remedied here in Scotland as I speak.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

We move on to consideration of motion S3M-7872, on the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2011.Motion moved,That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Amendment Order 2011 be approved.—Jim Mather.Motion agreed to.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

This was the minister’s last appearance before this committee—and, possibly, any committee of the Parliament—before his retiral. I wish him the best of health and a long and happy retirement.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Thank you very much indeed. That is much appreciated.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

That concludes the final meeting of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee 2007 to 2011.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

Will members join me in giving the convener a vote of thanks on behalf of the committee? Applause. Meeting closed at 12:34.

  1. 10:00 International Trade (Scottish Development International) Committee business · 70
  2. 10:00 Annual Report Committee business · 5
  3. 10:00 Legacy Paper Committee business · 53
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  5. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  6. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  7. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 23
  8. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.