Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Energy Act 2008 (Storage of Carbon Dioxide) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 (Draft)

Wednesday 2 March 2011 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee About 10:00 Subordinate legislation 23 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

23 contributions
Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The final items relate to two affirmative instruments. I will get my notes in the right order. First, we will take oral evidence from the Minister for Enterprise, Energy and Tourism on the draft Energy Act 2008 (Storage of Carbon Dioxide) (Scotland) Regulations. I ask him to introduce his team and make an opening statement, after which we will ask questions. At this stage, the minister’s officials can contribute. When we consider the motion, only the minister will be able to speak.

Jim Mather SNP The Minister for Enterprise, Energy and Tourism · Argyll and Bute
link

I am joined by Olive Hogg, Ross Loveridge and Lorna Orr. I thank the convener for the opportunity to make a statement—I will be as brief as possible.Members are all well aware that Scotland’s energy opportunities are vast. However, a balanced energy future for Scotland depends on more than just renewable power—there must be cleaner thermal generation alongside that, because it is clear that hydrocarbons will remain a central element of the energy mix in Scotland and worldwide.We recognise that we have a duty to minimise carbon emissions and ensure sustainable economic growth. The facts are that coal is the most abundant and least expensive but most polluting fossil fuel, and that carbon capture and storage is the only technology that is capable of cutting fossil fuel emissions by up to 90 per cent.One of our energy pledges was to“support development and implementation of”carbon capture and storage“technologies in Scotland, through collaboration with academia, industry and other interested parties.”The economic opportunities for developing a CCS-based industry are considerable. The potential exists for a whole new industry to emerge in Scotland, which could support up to an estimated 10,000 new jobs in the next 15 to 20 years. The skills and engineering experience that we have gained from the oil and gas industry and the power industry are readily transferable to the new sector.Further motivation for CCS is provided by the significant export potential for Scotland and the significant scope for international collaboration. Those propositions are supported by a significant quotation from Lord Oxburgh, a former chairman of Shell, who said:“CCS will be an industry as big as the oil industry”.All those factors combine to support our ambition for the North Sea to become the European Union’s principal CO2 storage hub.Of course, we all recognise the huge opportunity that we have at Longannet to test the technology, to see emissions fall and to accelerate development at the same time. I am pleased that Charles Hendry is in Scotland today and that he has confirmed that he expects a final announcement on funding Longannet this summer.In addition, we are required to implement the EU directive on the geological storage of carbon dioxide. The Scottish Parliament has made great progress on that by agreeing to the legislative consent motion on what became the Energy Act 2008 and by considering the draft regulations that are before us. Scotland’s regulatory framework is seen as world leading by the Global CCS Institute and our approach has been endorsed by the European Commission.In its current state, the 2008 act prohibits exploration or storage in relation to carbon dioxide without a licence. That prohibition applies only to the offshore area, where the Scottish ministers are the licensing authority for the Scottish 12-mile territorial seas.The draft regulations extend the territorial scope of the 2008 act to onshore Scotland and its internal waters. That is dictated by article 2 of the EU directive, which provides that the directive must be implemented across a member state’s whole territory, which is why we must extend the 2008 act to cover the onshore area.However, article 4 of the directive confirms that member states retain the right to determine the areas from which storage sites may be selected. That includes a member state’s right not to allow any storage in parts or in the whole of its territory. That is why I have decided that the regulations will result in no exploration or CCS activity being allowed in Scottish territory without a licence. That is an important safeguard, and I intend to use it by confirming that the Scottish Government will not permit the geological storage of CO2 onshore in Scotland.We will permit offshore storage only, which is consistent with the position that the rest of the United Kingdom has taken. I am glad that there is political consensus on CCS between the major parties in Scotland and, indeed, across the UK. The 2008 act was supported by the Scottish Government and endorsed by the Scottish Parliament, so that we would have consistent regulations for CCS on a UK-wide basis. I am pleased that the new UK coalition Government has retained the commitment that Labour made to consistent regulation and that the amendment to the 2008 act that we propose in the order is also being made for England and Wales by the UK Government.Meanwhile, as I have explained, the opportunities that are associated with CCS for coal and gas are vast. We must ensure that we deliver on that potential. I am happy to answer members’ questions.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Thank you for your opening remarks. I will begin with an obvious question. Why do you require a licensing regime for an activity that you say that you will not permit to happen?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

There are two stages to the regulations. We have the licensing regime, which will bring us into line with what is happening throughout the UK and Europe, and the permitting mechanism. That will ensure that what we have in Scotland is exactly what we want. We do not want onshore storage. The focus should be offshore, where we have saline aquifers and the potential in the North Sea to sequestrate CO2 and to use it in long-term enhanced oil recovery. I have with me talented people who may be able to amend that answer.

Dr Ross Loveridge Scottish Government Directorate for Energy and Climate Change
link

I am happy to add to the minister’s comments. In large part, this is a procedural requirement, as the directive must be applied across the territory of the member state. When we were working with the UK Government on the Energy Bill back in 2007 and 2008, the bill was being prepared in parallel with the directive. At that time, the UK assumed that it would be able to apply the directive offshore only.Since the directive has come into force, there has been a requirement for it to apply across the whole territory of the member state. However, there is scope in article 4 for the member state to determine those areas within its territory where storage may take place, so we will retain the position that the UK Government put forward and which the Scottish Parliament agreed in the LCM—that storage will take place only in the offshore area. We are merely confirming, for purely procedural reasons, the fact that the directive extends the 2008 act. The policy intention, to which the Scottish Parliament signed up, is as it was in 2008—to retain storage offshore.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

So in your view, there is no risk that someone may apply for a licence to store onshore and be able to appeal a refusal successfully on the ground that the licence application was predetermined.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

We do not believe so, because we believe that we retain control.

David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

My question is not specifically about this issue. I am curious about your earlier comment that Charles Hendry will make an announcement in the summer. Can you share with us some more information about that?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

We are told that a decision will be made in the summer—fingers crossed, given that Longannet is the last man standing in the UK demonstrator competition.

David Whitton Lab Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is Charles Hendry visiting Longannet today?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

No, he is visiting the Parliament today and will take part in a session on electricity market reform that will take place tonight in the Macdonald Holyrood hotel. We have debated the issue in Parliament, but it is significant that Charles Hendry and a roomful of other people—apparently, there is not a seat left for the event—will take part in a open debate on it and seek to identify everyone’s aspirations for electricity market reform, to tease out possible unintended consequences and try to work together to address those.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

While we have you here, can you provide us with an estimate of the capacity for carbon capture and storage that exists in the northern North Sea? I have seen it put at a maximum of about 1.5 billion tonnes equivalent.Given that Europe’s production of CO2 from, say, the power stations along the northern coast from Belgium and Holland to Germany is in excess of 100 million tonnes a year, we are really talking about only 15 years’ capacity.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

We have been told that it is anything from 100 to 200 years’ capacity. We will take your numbers and find out. What is your source for those data?

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

They came from an inquiry by the German carbon trust into the output from German power stations. Research to update the figures in my own work up to the mid-1990s into the extraction of oil provided the figure of 1.5 billion tonnes. I would be thrilled to think that there would be the capacity that you mentioned.

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I will bring Ross Loveridge in, as he is more heavily steeped in it.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I am not sure that anyone would want to be steeped in CO2.

Dr Loveridge
link

The minister is absolutely correct. I thank Mr Harvie for raising that point. I do not have the figures from the Scottish study to hand but, when the First Minister launched it in 2009, the estimate was that Scotland can comfortably store its own CO2 emissions for more than 200 years and that we could potentially store in the northern part of the North Sea—taking into account not only the Scottish potential, but the Norwegian potential—between 100 and 200 years’ worth of north-west Europe’s emissions. Those figures are based on the estimates in the study.We are not quite there yet but, in a few weeks’ time, we will make an announcement about the latest analysis following on from the Scottish study. We have to make a more detailed assessment of specific storage sites and the results will be published in a few weeks’ time. I hope that that will reassure Mr Harvie by confirming the storage capacity.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

My question leads on from that. I am sure that you will have given some thought to the fact that a site is not just the place where a hole is drilled into which stuff is pushed down, but a geological structure. I wonder about the implications of a hole being drilled 10 miles offshore if the structure runs under the land. You will have addressed such obvious thoughts. What protocols will be in place for that?

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

The key thing is that the Scottish centre for carbon storage is headed up by Professor Stuart Haszeldine, who is one of the leading geologists in the sphere. We have taken him to various settings to be involved in debate with others, and he has confirmed to us that he believes that the saline aquifers and the North Sea reservoirs offer us both the sequestration capacity and the integrity to hold the CO2.

Dr Loveridge
link

We have the expertise in Scotland—a world asset. It has been supported and endorsed by no less than the European Commission, which employed the University of Edinburgh to undertake its own assessments of the future storage potential across the whole EU.Regarding the potential migration of CO2 from specific sites to other areas, the legislation and the directive make it very clear that any person who prospects for CO2 storage must undertake a very detailed site characterisation assessment as part of the exploration and that the permit must be awarded on the basis of a clear guarantee that the CO2 will be safely contained within the structure as outlined by the applicant to the permitting authority—which, in this case, would be the Scottish Government. That is designed to give safeguards and reassurances to the public about the behaviour of the CO2 and about the minister’s ability to make a clear and effective decision on the basis of that knowledge.12:15

Jim Mather SNP Argyll and Bute
link

We have carried out a world-leading exercise with Russel Griggs, who heads up the regulatory review group. It was essentially a two-day scenario planning exercise, getting all the players in the room. It was not just the geologists, people with oil interests and the generators—it was also the regulators and the local authorities. It involved producing a handbook for how we can make progress on CCS matters. We will give Charles Hendry a copy of it tonight. We have already taken it to the Global CCS Institute, which views it as a useful mechanism for developing the technology. The handbook has also been instrumental in our persuading representatives of the Inter-American Development Bank to come across and see what Scotland is doing on CCS.Last week, in our conversations with the Canadian high commissioner, a great deal of interest was sparked about potential collaboration, as that country is spending about 3 billion Canadian dollars on CCS over the next five years. The international collaboration issue is important, and Scotland earns its place at the table because of the geology, the academic research, the technology and the momentum that we have been able to generate here.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

There being no further questions, we move on to the next item, which is formal consideration of motion S3M-7800, in the minister’s name.Motion moved,That the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee recommends that the Energy Act 2008 (Storage of Carbon Dioxide) (Scotland) Regulations 2011 be approved.—Jim Mather.Motion agreed to.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

The clerks and I will prepare a short factual report to submit to the Parliament, indicating our approval of the motion.

  1. 10:00 International Trade (Scottish Development International) Committee business · 70
  2. 10:00 Annual Report Committee business · 5
  3. 10:00 Legacy Paper Committee business · 53
  4. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  5. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  6. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  7. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 23
  8. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.