Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Report

“Edinburgh trams interim report”

Wednesday 2 March 2011 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 289 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

289 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We have with us this morning David Middleton, the chief executive of Transport Scotland, and Ainslie McLaughlin, the director of major transport infrastructure projects at Transport Scotland. Would either of you like to make an opening comment?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I will make one or two comments if I may, convener. It might be helpful if I comment on some aspects of the Edinburgh trams issue prior to taking questions.Transport Scotland, with the agreement of ministers, stepped down from the trams project board following the July 2007 meeting. With the Scottish Government having capped its contribution to the project at £500 million, Transport Scotland was clearly in the role of funder on behalf of Scottish ministers. The City of Edinburgh Council was the project owner, and Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd was the project director. We considered it to be good governance for those roles to be separated out to avoid a situation in which Transport Scotland was part of a project board that might make representations to itself as funder.In the context of that proper separation of roles, Transport Scotland continued to monitor the project’s progress: monthly and quarterly progress meetings were held. As the committee is aware from previous evidence, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth and the Minister for Transport and Infrastructure and Transport Scotland officials have on a number of occasions discussed the issues that have emerged regarding the trams scheme with the City of Edinburgh Council and TIE. We have always offered any help that we could to progress the project, and we shall assist in the mediation talks that are to commence next week.However, that does not alter the existing clear roles of funder, owner and project manager for ourselves, the City of Edinburgh Council and TIE. Our role as funder is set out in the grant agreement between Scottish ministers and the City of Edinburgh Council. Given the difficulties that have been encountered, there has been speculation as to whether we should have withheld grant. At no stage did Scottish ministers feel justified in taking such an approach. However regrettable is the project’s delay due to the contractual disputes, expenditure has been legitimately incurred. That is subject to audit, and the city council is required to provide us with certificates to verify that payments have been appropriately claimed.The contractual disputes have meant that the costs of certain items have risen, and we are aware that the City of Edinburgh Council intends that the full project will be completed incrementally. Those issues have been considered extensively at monthly and quarterly meetings, as well as at ad hoc meetings between the Government, the City of Edinburgh Council and TIE. At no time did the withholding of grant appear to be justified or likely to assist in resolving the disputes.Ministers have been clear in their wish for all parties to resolve the on-going dispute so that the project can progress. The immediate priority is to secure a positive outcome to the mediation, and we shall do our best to assist with that process. The issues of re-evaluating the benefits of the project and of considering future governance have to await resolution of the contractual issues. We must all hope that the mediation succeeds.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Thank you for that, Mr Middleton. Essentially, you are the guardians of the public grant that has been given to the City of Edinburgh Council. You are supervising the disbursement of that grant on behalf of Scottish ministers. Is that correct?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

That is to satisfy the process of paying that grant in line with the conditions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Were the conditions that were laid down subject to negotiation between Transport Scotland, on behalf of Scottish ministers, and the City of Edinburgh Council?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

They were certainly put to the City of Edinburgh Council, although they were drawn from standard grant conditions that are used in such situations.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So, Transport Scotland put those grant conditions to the City of Edinburgh Council, and they were cleared by Scottish ministers.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes. They were all drawn from the “Scottish Public Finance Manual”.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay.Is it a condition of grant that the project should demonstrate a benefit to cost ratio above 1?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

That was a condition precedent of the grant: in order for the grant to kick in, the council had to show, through its business case, that the benefit to cost ratio was in excess of 1. Once the grant starts, that is not a continued condition of the grant payment—it is a condition precedent.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You say that, before the project started, there should have been a benefit to cost ratio of 1; you wrote nothing into the condition of grant such that, if the project started to show a different benefit to cost ratio, it really would not matter, and the full amount of money could continue to be obtained irrespective of how badly the project was going.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

That reflected the fact that, once the city council had entered a contract, there was an expectation that the contract payments would be met. The council was contractually committed to the project. The purpose of the grant is to support the council—it is effectively a subsidy to the project. The Scottish ministers’ position was protected in as far as there was a £500 million cap on the total cost to the Government.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You saw your role as being simply to sign the cheques, and not to ask questions on behalf of taxpayers.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

No, that is not the case. We require the City of Edinburgh Council to submit detailed invoices, on a four-weekly basis, of the money that was spent the previous month. Those are backed up by a detailed monthly report, which matches the progress on the actual project. We then reconcile the monthly project report with the invoice that the council has submitted, and then pay that invoice. The council is required annually to give us a certificate of compliance from its director of finance, backed up by a certificate from its independent auditor, to show that all the costs that are submitted are eligible costs under the terms of the grant.09:45

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Did you at any time consider and report to ministers on whether the project remained affordable within the limits that had been set?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

The Scottish ministers’ commitment to the project is capped at £500 million. At one point last year, there were indications from the council that the cost of the project was likely to exceed its original estimated total of £545 million, and we reported that to ministers.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So, it became apparent only last year that the cap was likely to be exceeded. You had no prior—

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

The cap is not going to be exceeded. It is the council’s estimate of the total cost of the contract that will be exceeded.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Yes. I am sorry. On what date did you first become aware that the project cost was likely to exceed the cap?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

The timeline that I have tells me that, on 4 March 2010, in the fifth quarterly report, Transport Scotland received initial indications from the council that, because of the impact of the on-going contractual dispute, it was unlikely that the full scope of phase 1a of the contract was likely to be achievable for £545 million.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So, the first indication that the project was running into difficulties was a year ago.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

Yes—in terms of the likelihood of its breaching the council’s estimate of the total cost.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

When you draw up a grant agreement with another organisation for the disbursement of public funds, particularly funds in excess of £500 million, do you ever think of asking those who receive the funds not only to submit invoices that the money is being wisely or well spent, but to prove that the public purse is getting value for the money that is being paid? That is something that perhaps needs to be reflected on for future projects.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

The value for money judgment is in essence made at the outset, when the Scottish ministers consider whether they wish to contribute. If you are talking about the formal stage at which the City of Edinburgh Council said that there might be difficulties with the project meeting its overall limits, that was reported to us, as Ainslie McLaughlin pointed out. That there were difficulties and contractual disputes was obvious and in the public domain for some time before that, and the Scottish ministers were aware of that. The question was whether probing the City of Edinburgh Council on the value for money of on-going grant payments bore any relation to dealing with the problems that had emerged on the project, which were clearly contractual disputes with the contractor.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Forgive me for my naivety but, with projects where a grant of £545 million is required, I would have thought that certain practices pertain that would not apply to smaller projects. For example, I do not know whether you are a car driver, but I am, and if I put my car in to be repaired, I expect the garage to tell me if major work is required beyond what was originally estimated. I then check at the end, before I hand over any money, that the work that had been agreed has been done. Before you handed over any money, did anyone from Transport Scotland check that the work was being carried out, and being carried out satisfactorily?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I refer you to the points that Mr McLaughlin has already made on the checks that the claims were legitimate.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So you cannot think of anything that Transport Scotland could have done that would have protected the public purse from the situation that now confronts us?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

That would imply that protecting the public purse involved our withholding grant. As I attempted to explain in my opening comments, it was not open to us to withhold grant. The council, through TIE, was entering into a contract, so it would probably have challenged us on any arrangement for central Government money that implied decision points by central Government that were out of kilter with the operation of the contract. However, all that was subject to the fact that Scottish ministers had capped their contribution at £500 million.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So if Scottish ministers had not been so unreasonable and had said “You can have a blank cheque,” everything would have been okay.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

No, we are not saying that. The fact is that contractual disputes emerged relatively early in the project. The Auditor General said in his report:“Contractual disputes between tie and BBS began almost as soon as infrastructure construction commenced.”The fact that the project has had difficulties and problems around the contract has not been unknown to us. We have discussed such matters at progress meetings, monthly meetings and other meetings. The problem is that once a contract was signed and once contractual disputes emerged, the only solutions to those problems ultimately lay with the two parties to the contracts.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

For future projects, are you reflecting on the way in which the different procedures were drawn up, drafted and implemented, or will the same procedures pertain to other major infrastructure projects?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We would always reflect on practice and look at future procedures. We would be foolish not to do that. However, the procedures that have been involved were drawn from standard conditions, which obviously did not anticipate the level of contractual disagreement that emerged in this project.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

The Scottish Government’s arrangements for capping the cost at £500 million, Transport Scotland’s grant arrangements and the contracts for the project itself were all put in place after the Scottish Parliament voted for the project to proceed. Am I correct?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

What would have happened if the Scottish Parliament had not voted for it to proceed?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

That would have been a matter for Scottish ministers to determine. It is not from me to speak on their behalf, but—

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

If the Parliament had not voted for the project, I assume that it would not have proceeded.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

The genesis of the project’s problems was partly the vote for the project to proceed in the first place.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is not for me to comment on the vote, as such.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Can I just clarify a point? That is an interesting line of argument. You suggest that if Parliament had not voted for the project, ministers would probably not have proceeded with it.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I made that suggestion because I was invited to speculate. Perhaps I should not have.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

It is just that I am aware that Parliament has voted on matters such as the national conversation, which ministers proceeded with anyway. There is perhaps a fault with the Parliament’s procedures in this regard. However, ministers can decide whether to proceed with certain matters irrespective of the vote of Parliament. I just wondered whether what you said would have happened was a specific line from Government officials.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

No. I would not dream of inventing a new doctrine of any kind.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

I think that you developed an interesting line of argument there as well, convener.To return to the question, the City of Edinburgh Council does not know how much the project is likely to cost, but it will exceed the original £545 million estimate. At our previous committee meeting, the council said in evidence that it may seek additional funding by turning to Transport Scotland. How do you feel about that?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Having been chastened after my attempt to speculate, even though I was invited to do so, I must simply say that Scottish ministers have said that their commitment is capped at £500 million. To reopen that commitment can clearly be a matter only for Scottish ministers.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Interestingly, you said in your opening remarks that withholding grant funding would at no time have been justified or likely to resolve the problems between the contractor and TIE and the City of Edinburgh Council. What do you mean by that?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Clearly, if at any time in the disbursement of public money you think that the body to which you are disbursing moneys is mismanaging or misgoverning resources, you would then think of a range of actions that you might take to deal with the situation. You would do so where, from all information and evidence, it is apparent that the problem is an extensive contractual dispute. The Auditor General confirmed that in his report. Also, although expenditure was slower and more difficult than the project would have wished, there was no suggestion in the Auditor General’s report other than that expenditure had been incurred legitimately on aspects of the project such as the laying of tram rails in Princes Street. At no point did deciding to withhold grant seem to be an appropriate course of action. Apart from anything else, there is a legal arrangement between ourselves and the City of Edinburgh Council. We would have had to have thought carefully about any such action. I cannot see any circumstances in which we had any justification in taking that course of action to deal with the problem of the project. As reported, the problem was the extensive contractual disagreement between the City of Edinburgh Council and TIE, and the consortium.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Under questioning at a previous committee meeting, the Auditor General made reference to the fact that costs had exceeded projections in other places where new tram or light rail projects have been undertaken. Was not enough regard given to experience elsewhere in advance of this project?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I could not comment on that.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

Those are all my questions for now, convener.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

When Transport Scotland was set up, my recollection is that it was set up as a hands-on agency at arm’s length from Government, if you excuse the mixed metaphor. Is that right?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes. Transport Scotland was set up as an executive agency of Government.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

It has special emphasis on expertise in transport projects.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes. A range of transport projects in Scotland were planned around that time and it was felt that an agency that was dedicated to the purpose with its own chief executive who would also be the accountable officer would be a suitable vehicle for taking forward those projects.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is very much still the case. We have a range of significant projects, some of which are nearing completion and others that will begin soon.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Why did you see this project merely as a sort of accounting exercise in which you check the expenditure every six months and pay on receipt of invoice rather than one in which you would get involved? Surely Transport Scotland should have used the expertise that it has built up. Surely it should have got involved and advised the City of Edinburgh Council using all the experts that you have on hand who know all about transportation and allied matters. Why were you not hands on? Would it not have been sensible to continue on the project board?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

In formal terms, while being arm’s length in one sense, we are still part of Government. We do not pursue projects because we decide that they are good or bad; we progress the projects that Scottish ministers invite us to take forward on their behalf.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You are not, however, like an ordinary department of Government. Transport Scotland was set up to be an agency that would help to ensure proper delivery. You opted out of the trams project. Why?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We did not opt out. I am happy to return to our expertise in a second or two. The role of the Scottish Government, of which we are part, is to take forward projects where Scottish ministers wish it. The role of Scottish ministers in relation to the Edinburgh tram project was that of funder—funder up to the maximum of £500 million. You cannot have multiple project owners; there has to be clear project governance. In this case, the project owner was the City of Edinburgh Council which—in turn—appointed TIE as its project director.I turn to our expertise. Although we remained the funder rather than the owner of the tram project, we continued to meet and discuss the project with CEC and TIE on regular occasions. As I think colleagues from CEC and TIE acknowledged in your previous evidence session, we have been open for consultation and discussion and we have given advice. Clearly, as the Auditor General said, problems emerged on this project from relatively early days. It has been a source of concern to all those involved in public administration in Scotland that these matters be resolved. We have endeavoured to offer whatever assistance and advice is possible, but the ultimate owner of the project remains the City of Edinburgh Council.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

We know that. Transport Scotland was a member of the project board—it is not as if you declined to be a member. Did you not think that withdrawing from day-to-day participation on the project board would send a negative signal to the City of Edinburgh Council?10:00

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not believe that I have heard any suggestion from City of Edinburgh Council that it took a negative angle on that. The issue of governance and the separation of roles was explained at that time, and I believe that the position was accepted.I know that the council would like to draw on our expertise. It has asked for our assistance and we will assist it in the mediation, but our role is to assist while its role is owner.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

This is my last question. Is it not true, Mr Middleton, that under your directorship Transport Scotland has now reverted to being just like any other department of the Scottish Executive?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I am not sure that the description,“just like any other department of the Scottish Executive”is necessarily good or bad. We are, I hope, an effective functioning unit of Government. We have delivered a number of projects, programmes and services—in road, rail and other modes—that benefit the people of Scotland.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Before I bring in Murdo Fraser, I want to ask a question. You have described that, in the process, you were merely paying over money on the presentation of invoices, and you were not involved in any technical analysis or comment. Why did the finance directorate not take responsibility for that, as it was merely a matter of issuing cheques rather than offering any opinion?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is rather more than just issuing cheques. Ainslie McLaughlin might want to say something.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

We provide an informed view for the Scottish Government from the monthly reports that the City of Edinburgh Council provides us with to support the monthly invoices that it submits. We are able to look at those reports, assess whether they are credible in terms of reporting progress on the works and reconcile that against the amount that is being invoiced. At the monthly meetings that we have to discuss the invoicing and the progress of the works, we can ask intelligent questions about that progress.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So, all the way through, you have been asking intelligent questions and offering informed reports to ministers.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

We have been saying to ministers that the invoices that the City of Edinburgh Council has submitted are for legitimate costs incurred on the project. There is no suggestion, despite the contractual difficulties and disputes, that the money is being misdirected to any other purpose.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Did you offer any informed comments about whether problems were developing?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

Indeed. As Mr Middleton said, it has been quite apparent for some time that contractual disputes were emerging. We were giving ministers advice on how TIE was progressing with its efforts to try to resolve those disputes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But that is only since March 2010—or were you ringing alarm bells for ministers before March 2010?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We were certainly reporting the fact that there were contractual difficulties before March 2010.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

How early did you start to identify problems?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is hard to put a specific date on it. Given the fact that the project was being covered regularly in the media, it was well known that there were difficulties from, I would say, much earlier than 2009—possibly even the back end of 2008. We could clarify that precisely, but I do not think that there was any great national secret about the fact that there were contractual disputes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So from 2008, it was clear that problems were starting to develop.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

What was the significance of what you reported in March 2010?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

That was the first time that the council gave indications that it thought that it would be unlikely to complete the full scope of the project for the £545 million total.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Had you any doubts or suspicions between 2008 and March 2010 that it might not be able to stay within budget?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We were not surprised in March 2010.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You were not surprised, so you must have had some suspicions. Were the suspicions that the project was likely to go over budget reported to ministers before March 2010?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We would never have reported it as a statement of fact.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But you would have given some suggestion.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We would have suggested to ministers that there were difficulties with the contract.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. How early did you start to advise ministers that the project could have difficulties in staying within budget?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

The specific point about staying in budget in total was more formally made in March 2010.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You say “formally”, but you also said that that did not come as a surprise, so you obviously had suspicions before then. At what point did you first say to ministers that there were looming problems?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I draw a distinction between saying that there were looming problems because there were contractual disputes and saying that there was a definite risk to the budget of £545 million.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Right. When did you suggest to ministers that there might be a risk to the £545 million budget?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We would not have done that in any formal sense before March 2010.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. When did you do it in an informal sense?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not think that I could put any specific date on that.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It would have been in informal conversations and discussions; it would not necessarily have been a formal item in the minutes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I appreciate the difference between formal and informal. I am asking whether it was done informally before March 2010.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I think that we would have speculated informally, but we would not have advised before March 2010.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So have you any idea when that informal speculation first started?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

No, I do not.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

Can I come in on that point? I am not sure that I understand why there has been questioning on how early Transport Scotland advised the Government that the project might exceed its budget. My recollection is that Scottish Government ministers warned the Parliament about that, which is why they and the Scottish National Party voted against the project in the first place and why they capped the contribution at £500 million. All the evidence on previous tram projects in other parts of Europe, and specifically projects in England, showed that they always run into such difficulties.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

No, it is not a question. It is a statement—a clarification to aid the committee.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Except that there are stated reports that the project was on schedule and on cost. Is that not the case, Mr Middleton?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes. There were reports from CEC and TIE to that effect.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Therefore, after Parliament voted, reports were produced to say that the project was on cost and on schedule, and I am now trying to find out when the alarm bells started ringing to show that that might not have been the case.I call Murdo Fraser.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Thank you, convener. I observe on that last point that, if I remember correctly, the vote in Parliament was informed by an Audit Scotland report into the trams project that gave it a clean bill of health. That is why Parliament proceeded with the trams project as opposed to the Edinburgh airport rail link project, which had received a pretty damning report from the Auditor General at the same point. However, that is by the by.I want to take Mr Middleton and Mr McLaughlin back to the offer of grant letter and its terms. I do not think that the committee has seen that letter. It is a public document? Is it available to us?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Perhaps we can obtain a copy of it.Mr Middleton said earlier that the payments that Transport Scotland made to the City of Edinburgh Council were made in exchange for certification that works had been done. Was there any process of verification by Transport Scotland that the certificates were accurate?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

The verification comes through the processes that the council put in place and is a requirement of the grant conditions. In relation to the money that is paid to the contractor on a monthly basis, TIE must measure the work on a monthly basis, certify the payment as correct and pass it to the City of Edinburgh Council, along with any other payments due to other contractors and suppliers to the project. The council then assembles the invoices, adds the project management costs—the TIE costs, in effect—deducts the contribution that the council makes itself and passes the invoices to us. As I said, as a further check, the council is required on an annual basis to give us a certificate of compliance backed up by an independent auditor’s certificate.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Did anything in the offer of grant letter tie payments of moneys to completion of specific milestones in the project’s construction, rather than to reimbursement of invoices alone?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

No. The standard grant process ensures that the council is not put in a position where it has any payments outstanding to contractors. Had we introduced milestones stipulating that money would be released only when a certain section of the work was completed, the council would have had to bear finance charges, which would have been passed on to the project cost. Somewhere along the line, that money would have had to be found and the charges financed.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That clarifies things helpfully. One of my concerns is that out of the £500 million that Transport Scotland is obliged to pay it has, I think, paid over £402 million so far—

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

We have paid over £386 million to date.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

According to the figures that I have seen, that is about 79 per cent of the total. However, only 28 per cent of the infrastructure works have actually been completed. It sounds as though you have paid out a large proportion of the sums that the Scottish Government is contributing without there being any commensurate delivery of the project on the ground. Given those figures, do you think that the offer of grant letter’s terms were sufficiently rigorous to ensure that the public was getting a proper return on its investment in this project?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

I think that we need to separate out progress on the infrastructure works, which is just one part of the project—albeit a significant one—from other project costs that we were covering. For example, a significant amount of money was spent on the advance works, particularly the diversion of utilities under the multi-utilities diversion framework agreement—or MUDFA—which itself amounted to £60 million or more. There were further advance works of about £30 million, and the trams themselves had to be paid for—some have been delivered—at a cost of around £50 million. In common with many other projects, the cost of the actual construction is only a part of the overall project cost. Costs of up to nearly £200 million incurred on value of the work done were not actually associated with the infrastructure project that is currently in dispute.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You just said that a total of £386 million has been paid out so far.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

I believe that that is the figure.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So £114 million is left in the kitty. Could all of that be paid over in exchange for certificates from the City of Edinburgh Council without the project actually being delivered?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

Given that the council is now of the view that the project will not be delivered for £545 million, it is possible that the £500 million grant could be paid out without the project being completed. Indeed, the council has already said that it will need to find additional money to complete the project.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

On reflection, then, do you not think that the offer of grant letter was inadequate in the way it was set up and that it should have put in better protections for this public investment? For example, should it not have been tied to completion of the project?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

I point out that standard terms in the grant protect Scottish ministers’ position should the project not be completed.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

Technically, if the project were not completed, the council could be obliged to pay back the money that the Government had paid out. There is, therefore, an ultimate protection. I am not pretending that such a move would not present the council with a challenge—

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I suspect that that is putting it mildly.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

Nevertheless, the grant is made in good faith that the project will be completed.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is interesting. So Scottish ministers could seek to recover the sums that have been spent if the project does not progress.Paragraph 72 of the Auditor General’s report says:“Transport Scotland and CEC are reviewing the conditions contained in the grant offer letter.”Why are you carrying out that review?10:15

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

It is clear that the project is overrunning. The grant was put in place for three years, but the council is now looking at phasing the delivery, so we must consider how the grant conditions should be amended to reflect how the project will progress. We are looking at that.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

The mediation talks will start next week. The reality is that, in many respects, the mediation talks—which we hope will be fruitful—are the dominant factor on the horizon. The review of the grant arrangements—or reviews of anything else—will follow on from what we hope will be a positive outcome from the mediation.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am unclear about one issue. Is the grant offer letter in effect a contract, so any change to its terms must be agreed by both parties?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I want to clarify two points following Murdo Fraser’s questions. Are you absolutely clear that the grant offer imposed the condition that, if the project was not completed, the City of Edinburgh Council could be liable to repay all the grant that the Scottish ministers provided?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

That is a possibility.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

That possibility exists, but I do not think that the Scottish ministers have suggested—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No. Is what I described a condition—not just a possibility—that is written into the contract?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is in the contract. If the circumstances arise in which the Scottish ministers want to and feel able to exercise that measure, it is there.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You have described how you approve payments on the presentation of invoices. Which of the partners that are involved is responsible for managing the process and determining whether invoices accurately reflect work that has been done?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

TIE deals with the payments to its contractors—principally the contractor for the infrastructure construction contract. The City of Edinburgh Council deals with the moneys that it pays for its overheads—principally TIE and project management.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Is the City of Edinburgh Council responsible for—

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

Ultimately, the council must do certification and give us certificates of compliance annually.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

David Middleton said that, if the project was not completed, measures of recourse would be available to the Scottish ministers, whether or not they chose to exercise them. The grant offer was for three years. Is that correct?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

The current grant is for three years.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

By what measure do we say that the project is not complete? After three years, is that sanction available? Do we say that the project has not been completed in three years, so it is not complete, or do we have to wait for a time further down the line?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

What you say is a statement of fact. The Scottish ministers are aware of the contract situation and of the pending mediation talks. They have not attached particular significance to the three-year period—doing so would destabilise the situation.

Jamie Hepburn SNP Central Scotland
link

You say that a statement of fact is involved. Under the grant letter, does the project have to be completed within three years?

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

No. The letter says that the Scottish ministers’ obligations under the grant’s terms expire after three years.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Good morning. As you know, many people are astonished that, when £500 million of public money was committed to the project, the Scottish Government decided to step back from the project board. Have you backed off in that way—from being at the table, a full partner in the project and a full member of the project board to no longer being so—from other major projects?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I confess that I cannot immediately quote a precise example. Not very many projects of a similar size and significance have taken place—a range of examples does not exist. In the trams project, the decision was taken that good governance pointed to us as the funder not being part of the project board.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It was the Scottish ministers, which are all of us, legally—Transport Scotland is legally part of the Scottish ministers. As officials, we consulted ministers and agreed on the course of action.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Was it a ministerial decision on which you made a recommendation?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I did not make any recommendations at that time, but I do not believe that it was a recommendation or a decision or a direction—I think that there was a discussion and an agreement between ministers and officials that that was the appropriate course of action.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Have you reviewed the papers from that time? You are telling us that you were not the chief executive at the time, but have you reviewed the papers so as to be able to give us an accurate description of what happened?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I am not sure that it is appropriate to say whether an official was told, officials advised or an option was chosen. In such a position, it is simpler to view Government as being seamless, with ministers and officials agreeing that it was appropriate for Transport Scotland, as the agency, not to be on the board. I do not think that it is a question of going back through other options and so on—it is simply what was decided by the Scottish Government.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I am asking you to talk us through that decision-making process. A lot of people view the decision that was made as crucially important, and we are very interested to know what the executive agency responsible for transport in Scotland recommended to ministers in relation to a £500 million investment of taxpayers’ money.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not think that there was any disagreement between officials and ministers; officials and ministers reached a straightforward conclusion that it was appropriate to adopt the role of funder and not to be part of the project board that would run the project and which might make representations back to the funding body.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So, on the fourth-largest capital project in Scotland, with £500 million of taxpayers’ money involved, the transport experts—the executive agency responsible for transport—were quite relaxed about withdrawing from the project board.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not think that it was a question of being relaxed or otherwise. That is the decision that was taken. Someone is either the project owner or director and is in that seat or they are not. We were not in either of those roles.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

That momentous decision did not require a ministerial direction, then. It was something that officials were content with. Is that correct?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Officials are always content with ministerial decisions.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I feel slightly hesitant about getting into what was said between ministers and officials. There is still a degree of confidentiality about that. One thing is a statement of fact: there was no direction by ministers in the formal sense in which that term is understood.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

That is helpful—that is what I was asking about.Are there any major projects where you have moved the other way and brought a project in house, rather than leaving it with a different project owner?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I believe that there is one project in that category, which I suspect you are leading me towards: the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine rail project.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

That is helpful.Are there other projects where £500 million is put in by the Government as the funder and not the owner?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

As I said, I cannot immediately think of precise examples in the Edinburgh trams category. I am not sure that there is a whole range of precise comparators. Each large project is different. Edinburgh trams was a particular project for the city of Edinburgh, and it was clear that the City of Edinburgh Council would be the owner.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

What is the largest other capital project in Scotland where you have been, or are, the funder and not the owner, with no place on the project board?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I cannot immediately give an example in that category.

Ainslie McLaughlin Transport Scotland
link

No—I cannot recall any other such example at the moment.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Is there any other capital project that Transport Scotland is involved in where it has chosen not to have a place on the project board or equivalent body?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not believe that there would be any other project of that size that has local ownership, so I am not sure that I can immediately see a comparator. The other projects of any great significance—the M74, the M80, the impending Forth replacement crossing, the planned M8 upgrade and the Aberdeen western peripheral road—are all projects that Scottish ministers had in their programme and which Scottish ministers decided that they wished to pursue, at one scale and pace or another.We know that there was a vote in Parliament on the Edinburgh trams project, and we know the position of Scottish ministers. The owner was always going to be the City of Edinburgh Council, but Scottish ministers agreed to provide funding. It is its own story in that context.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So, uniquely, you decided to withdraw from the project board in relation to the trams project, and although you can be clear with us that it was a ministerial decision, you cannot tell us anything more about it. Is that a reasonable summary?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I can tell you that it was a decision that was agreed with ministers, yes.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

It was a decision that was agreed with ministers—you are very careful in your wording there. Was it a ministerial decision? Was it a decision of—

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It was a ministerial decision, but I am not saying that it was a ministerial decision to imply in any sense that officials were not entirely comfortable with that decision. I am not saying that they were or that they were not. Officials and ministers reached a view; I do not think that it was a particularly difficult view to reach, given the nature of this particular project.The particular circumstances were that the City of Edinburgh Council was to be the owner and that it was appropriate for us, in the role of funder for the project, to take a different role rather than being on the project board. As we have outlined, we have always taken an interest in the project and sought to help and assist its progress where possible.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So, just to be clear, it was a decision taken by ministers.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

You have given the impression that you were in fact more involved with the project than some people have implied, and yet one of the key recommendations in the Auditor General’s report is that you should get involved in the future. Is it true to say that your involvement has been minimal, and that it could have been a lot more extensive and probably will be in the future?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I would not like to describe our involvement as “minimal”, given that we have described today our arrangements for paying over the grant in line with the grant conditions. We have sought, with the agreement of ministers, to be helpful to the project when it has clearly run into difficulties. Colleagues from CEC and TIE are on record, I am glad to say, as saying that they found the discussions that they had with us and any informal advice that they received to be helpful.As for our future role, we have agreed, with ministers’ endorsement, to participate in the mediation talks, because there is clearly a collective will among many parties—with a small ‘p’—in Scotland to secure progress in this difficult project.Ministers have said that now is not the right time, in advance of the mediation talks, to discuss future governance. We will be open to discussing with ministers and others what our future role might be, but the crucial immediate angle to the Edinburgh trams project is that the mediation talks should succeed and that some understanding and a way forward should be agreed among the various parties to the main contract so that the project can make progress. That is the central issue of the moment.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

In reply to a question that I asked the Auditor General, he said:“the Scottish Government facilitates the provision of central hubs of expert advice to support local authorities and health authorities in the commissioning of major projects. In this case, it seems to me that it would be appropriate to bring in the expertise that resides in Transport Scotland to support and advise a local authority in delivering a major and complex project.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 9 February 2011; c 2542.Would you be content to assume that role in relation to this project?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We will be content to assume whatever role is decided by ministers, CEC or others in the light of a way forward on the project, if and when the mediation produces a resolution of the contractual disputes. The contractual disputes are the central hurdle that must be overcome in the Edinburgh trams project.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

The withdrawal from the board has been a key issue this morning. You have given what I regard as a technical explanation for that, but is it a credible explanation, given that the type of financial relationships that you have described meant that the payment of the money was more or less automatic? Would it really have been a conflict of interest for Transport Scotland to sit on the board, or is that, as some may suspect, a smokescreen for what may have been the real reason?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not think that there is any reason to use terms such as “smokescreen” at all. We took a decision; it happened at the time. I do not believe that CEC or TIE were critical of or resistant to it. They may have taken it as a “fait accompli”—I think that that was the phrase used at the previous evidence session. I simply do not believe that it bears that construction. We took a decision to act as the funder, and to withdraw from the project board. I have really nothing to add to what I said earlier.10:30

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

You said to Nicol Stephen that you have not withdrawn from the board of any other project. In that regard and, indeed, in relation to the project as a whole, are you saying that the fact that the Scottish Government did not initially support the project has not had any influence on Transport Scotland’s behaviour at any point in the process?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not believe that it has.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Some people have commented on how odd it was that when the Auditor General’s report came out, the first sentence of your press release referred to the Scottish Government not supporting the project.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We speak on behalf of Scottish ministers and our lines to the media reflect the views of Scottish ministers. What you refer to was clearly a point to be made. There have been political angles to this discussion and Scottish ministers have sought to emphasise that point in a number of their comments. However, although they have emphasised that point in political debate, as I think CEC and TIE would acknowledge, the cabinet secretary and successive transport ministers have always had their doors open for discussions with the various parties to assist and advise.The cabinet secretary has made it clear on a number of occasions that he wanted to see the project progress, notwithstanding the views that he offered at the outset. Once the commitment was made, he wanted to see the project progress and the contractual disputes resolved. He has offered our assistance in the mediation. Whatever the political debate was in 2007, the cabinet secretary is anxious that we do all that we can to help the project go forward.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

So if the Scottish Government had been an enthusiastic supporter of the project, you do not think that that would have influenced the decision about the level of your involvement or your presence on the board.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not believe so.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I will pick up a point that the convener made. You accept that it was ultimately a decision of the Scottish ministers to go ahead with the project, because they were not obliged to accept the vote of Parliament. In that sense, is there a different relationship with this project in comparison with other projects that Scottish ministers have supported?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

There is a different relationship in the governance sense. You are either the project owner or you are not. We are not the project owner of the Edinburgh trams project; the City of Edinburgh Council is. That is the difference. The issue of which parliamentary votes are binding and which are not is secondary to that point.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Can I just clarify something before I bring Anne McLaughlin in? Going back to the decision to withdraw from the project board, I understand the protocol that advice from officials to ministers remains confidential, but in this case we know what the issue is and about the decision to withdraw from the project board. Can you just go back again to the sequence? Did ministers indicate that they wanted to withdraw from the board?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Ministers agreed the proposition. I really do feel uncomfortable—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But I am not seeking the advice that was given. What I am seeking is where the suggestion came from. We are legitimately entitled to know whether the suggestion of withdrawal from the board came from ministers.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not believe so. When you look back at exchanges, it is not always possible to determine who initiated something. However, I do not believe that ministers in any way told us, informally directed us or led us to that conclusion. There was a consideration between ministers and officials around the governance of the project, given that we would be funder and not project owner and director, and it was decided that we would withdraw from the board on that basis.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

It is interesting to listen to this. It would be amusing were it not for the fact that so much public money is involved. I have listened to the difference between Mr Middleton’s interpretation of the decision not to be on the board and that of some of my committee colleagues. Nicol Stephen called it a “momentous decision”, whereas you seemed to suggest, Mr Middleton, that it is fairly standard practice. In fact, I think that you said that it is good governance for funders not to be on the board because they could be approached by the board for funding. My first question is, if it was good governance to do that, would it have been bad governance for you to be on the board?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It could have clouded roles and responsibilities. In that sense, it would have been bad governance. Bad is quite an extreme term, but it was good governance to withdraw from the board; it clarified roles.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Report Committee business · 289
  3. 09:30 Public Audit Committee Report (Response) Committee business · 8
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports (Responses) Committee business · 1
  5. 09:30 Section 23 Reports (Responses) Committee business · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.