Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

A90/A937 (Safety Improvements) (PE1236)

Tuesday 25 January 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 71 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

71 contributions
Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We need to carry on because we have a long agenda. PE1236, which is by Jill Campbell, is about the A90/A937 at Laurencekirk. I understand that the minister would like to make a short opening statement.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

Thank you convener, and I thank the committee for inviting me to address PE1236. Although I am familiar with the A90 from being a frequent user of the road, I took the opportunity recently to visit all three of the junctions that are adjacent to Laurencekirk on the A90. At the same time, I met the petitioner, Jill Campbell, and I listened with interest to the issues that she raised. I am grateful to Ms Campbell for her participation and her on-going interest in road safety matters on the trunk road in the vicinity of Laurencekirk.I will take this opportunity to clarify the decision to grade separate a number of junctions on the A9. As Transport Scotland advised in its letter of 19 October 2010, the decision to grade separate the junctions at Keir, Inveralmond and Broxden arose from outcomes of the strategic transport projects review. I mention that because that is one of the issues that the committee has carried over. In roads programmes, it has always been the case that some road improvements are carried out for safety reasons and some are done for other reasons. The improvements that I have mentioned will remove congestion at those locations, thereby contributing to reduced journey times, improved reliability and improved road safety along that nationally strategic corridor. That decision, which was based on the need to remove congestion, is common to several major trunk road schemes throughout the country, including the M74 completion and the Aberdeen western peripheral route.I am familiar with the issues around the petition, and I and my officials will be pleased to answer any questions.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Thank you, and I welcome Mr Anderson and Mr Gillies to the committee.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Minister, what time of day did you visit the Laurencekirk site?

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

My understanding is that the visit did not completely cover the evening rush hour.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

It was a quick visit. I am happy to concede that point.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

Right.I am well aware of where the junction is. There is a significant impact from the use of the junction by people who live in Montrose who cross to turn north as they commute to Aberdeen. There is also a significant amount of development taking place, and that is likely to continue in the future. Have those things been taken into consideration in your deliberations on what is to be done?15:45

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

Yes, they have, in the work that Transport Scotland has done hitherto. Coming from Montrose, we went across the carriageway at the junction that you mention, and we came back from that junction, because I understand that that is where traffic backs up, especially in the mornings. That has been taken into account. As I am sure you know, improvements have been carried out to help to address the situation, although they have not been finalised yet.The point about the potential for development has been well noted by Transport Scotland and the local council in considering how matters might be moved forward.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

It has also been put to me that there is an issue not just for traffic turning on to the road but for traffic coming from the south, say from Brechin, and heading north. Drivers who do that journey say anecdotally that cars often pull out in front of them unexpectedly and they have to slow down. I think that that is due to driver frustration at the junction. As you know, that makes people feel strongly that the only really safe solution to the problem is a proper grade-separated junction.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I understand the strength of local feeling on the issue. I have discussed it with a number of members, including Nigel Don and Mike Rumbles. I refer back to the safety study that Transport Scotland did when the STPR was being put together. The matter was taken into account at that time, which is why improvements to two of the junctions have already happened. The improvement to the third one is still to happen, and I think that it will have an effect. However, I understand your point about the local concerns, which I heard when I met Jill Campbell.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I note that there have been various inputs since our previous discussion on the petition, but I refer in particular to a letter from Councillor David May, an old friend, who I see is in the room, who tells me that, if we go to the junction to sample what happens early in the morning, he will buy us breakfast. Well, he owes me breakfast already, because I have already been there.The minister has seen the data, which confirm that the traffic picks up rapidly at about a quarter to 7 in the morning, and heading north it continues to be significant until 8 o’clock. Incidentally, the traffic heading south picks up at about 8 o’clock and carries on from there, which is rather surprising.The junction is horrible, and unless we do something it is not going to get any better, for reasons that have already been discussed. The difficulty that I have is knowing how we are going to make improvements happen, and we have got to make them happen. I have had conversations with Aberdeenshire Council about how we might get money into the system for flyovers and grade-separated junctions on the road at Laurencekirk, both northbound and southbound. It has spoken about section 75 agreements, with which the minister and others will be familiar, and the amount of money that we might be able to get.The sticking point, as I see it, is that we simply do not know what the cost would be. We have had a wide range of estimates from, I think, £4 million to £22 million. That is a huge problem. I wonder whether we can do something to narrow that range, so that we can talk to the local council and potential developers with a real understanding of what the work would cost and what the possibilities might be.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I certainly understand that, because different partners are involved, such as developers, the council, Transport Scotland and others, it would be useful to have greater certainty about the final costs. I saw the Official Report of the committee’s previous meeting at which the petition was discussed, and a lot of the discussion was about the costs. I think that you noted the difference between a bottom figure of £4 million, which was heavily caveated, and a top figure of £20-plus million.I also recognise that the Aberdeenshire local development plan action programme looks for developers to provide a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk. To that end, I told those whom I had already spoken to about the matter that I would take a fresh look at it. I did that, and although I note the work that has been done up to now, I believe that the point about uncertainty is a fair one, so I have asked Transport Scotland to undertake what we are calling a cost refinement exercise to provide developers and others with a better basic understanding of the amount of money that would be required to fund an upgrade. That is not the full process that would normally be followed under the STPR, and, although I expect that greater clarity can be provided, there is still a heavy caveat, as works will not be undertaken as if the project was going ahead at this stage.The factors affecting the final cost of construction schemes are numerous and complex, and it should be understood that the outcomes of the exercise that I have asked to be undertaken will provide only a preliminary figure that in no way represents a final cost estimate. Also, it will not produce a scheme layout, to which the Scottish Government and its agency, Transport Scotland, are committed. However, it is my intention for the exercise to narrow the doubt as far as possible and to narrow the wide range of between £4 million and £23 million. That will be helpful to all who are involved.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

That is enormously welcome—it will be good just to get some clues as to what the number is really going to be, rather than dealing with the ridiculously wide range of figures that have been thrown at us. That will enable those of us who are concerned about the matter to continue to talk to people and to find a way of getting the money together. That is hugely welcome.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

The local member brought to the committee’s attention the fact that the minister has agreed to build three grade-separated junctions between Perth and Stirling, albeit not personally—you are not doing it yourself. The petitioners and the member for the area are genuinely concerned that an error has been made in the decision-making process. It seems that, over the past 11 years, there have been no fatalities at the areas where those three grade-separated junctions are being built, whereas there have been four fatalities at the junction at Laurencekirk.I know how long it takes to build up major transport projects, as I was involved with the A80 and the grade-separated junction at Auchenkilns. I held my hands up at one meeting and admitted that I did not know what a grade-separated junction was until the Auchenkilns roundabout was removed. Anyway, among the plans for major projects that were to be carried out, where was Laurencekirk and where were the other three projects? I ask you also to refer to the various studies that have been done over the years, through which we plan ahead and determine what capital works are required. Has a mistake been made, as the petitioners feel might be the case?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

No, mistakes have not been made, and all cases were analysed.It is interesting that you mention Auchenkilns. In that case, I knew what a grade-separated junction was but I did not know what it was called, prior to getting this job. That project showed how hard it is to judge the exact cost in advance. You will remember better than most people the complications that arose when that work was undertaken.In my area in 2001, a new road project was undertaken in an area that was not deemed to be particularly unsafe and which was not in any scheme or programme. We have also pushed forward with the Forth road crossing, which is driven not primarily by safety but by the economy and other factors. All those factors are taken into account.I am happy to allow David Anderson or Hugh Gillies to discuss the process that has been developed, as they have been involved for longer than me, but to my mind it is entirely reasonable for the STPR to include projects that are undertaken for reasons other than safety, as well as for there to be a balance of projects that are undertaken for reasons of safety.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

That is absolutely right. As the minister mentioned in his opening remarks, the STPR started by considering the longer-distance commute and strategic linkages, which have already been discussed today. The STPR therefore considered both road and rail links.One key reason for considering upgrading the junctions on the A9 is that it connects the country together. There can be significant delays at each of the roundabouts on the A9, as has been mentioned. The aim is to improve connectivity and the reliability of flow. Those factors were included in the recommendations for dualling up the A9.The Laurencekirk junction was considered in the context of how the A90 works as a connectivity corridor. The A90 works very well, in general. It is a dual carriageway with a number of junctions, and clearly accidents happen at some of those junctions at times. However, the accident rate on that corridor in general is lower than it is at other parts of the network. For that reason, the addition of a specific junction at Laurencekirk—in the context of the STPR, which considered the really big stuff—was not included.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Does that stand for the strategic transport projects review?

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

It was undertaken over 2007-08 and was reported on to Parliament in December 2008.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Right. There have probably been a few strategic transport reviews, but I know that one started in 1997 that said what the major transport programmes would be for 10 or 15 years or whenever. Did work at Laurencekirk go up or down in the order of importance in the review that was completed in 2008?

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

The review was not carried out like that. It was not a case of having a list and working out the pecking order. The evidence from a 20-year period was looked at, and it was asked what Scotland needs to achieve the purpose of sustained economic growth and all the other things with which members are more familiar than I am. It was about asking what things we should consider doing over the piece and coming up with a number of ideas and options.What was confusing about the STPR was that we had a list of things that people wanted to be considered as part of strategic projects, and we had to go through them and say, “Is that in or out? Should we or should we not do that?” We went through that process in a transparent manner and considered the objectives for individual corridors. In certain corridors, the issue was improving safety; in others, it was improving connectivity or doing a number of different things, all of which were tied to the national transport strategy. However, the exercise was certainly never a ranking exercise. It was about considering the evidence and the correct generic solutions, the details of which could change and be developed over time, as it was recognised that the fixes were not all easy.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

You will understand that I took great interest in previous strategic transport reviews—until I got what was necessary in my constituency, I suppose. From memory, Governments would put in programmes, and whether a particular project was to be done within a year, two years, five years or 10 years indicated the importance attached to it. Was that approach taken?

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

When we initially worked on the STPR, it was stated that it would follow the current programme, which contained a number of items and was published on Transport Scotland’s website. We certainly always looked beyond that. The STPR always looked to the medium, long and very long distance, and tried to get away from the idea of a pecking order and moving things up and down. Rather, it was about considering what we need as a country.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I welcome Mike Rumbles to the meeting. Nanette Milne wants to get in on that specific point, but do you want to get in on it, too?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Yes. I want to ask about Mr Anderson’s evidence. As the local constituency member, I am frustrated and quite angry at the evidence that he has given to the committee. I am very angry that he has said to the committee that the route in the corridor works very well in general. I know what he is trying to say—that the accident rates are okay on the A90 between Dundee and Aberdeen. He did not say that, but that is what he implied. I am very angry about that for my constituents in and around Laurencekirk because, from the very start of the process, the previous transport minister made it clear—he did so under questioning—that he put nothing into and took nothing out of the plan that Transport Scotland gave him. Therefore, the plan is Transport Scotland’s; it produced it. That is what the previous transport minister said in Parliament.The accident statistics following the safety measures that were introduced in 2005 were disputed right from the beginning, until the minister understood that they were his and Transport Scotland’s statistics, through Grampian Police. We did not bring any new statistics. The accident rate at the three junctions around Laurencekirk has increased since the safety measures were put in place. That is beyond dispute.16:00

When we asked for an estimate of the cost of building a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk, we all understood that a cost could not be given unless a plan was done. The response from the minister was £23 million. When we found out how he got that figure, it turned out to be the most expensive grade-separated junction ever quoted in Scotland. The quote came from Transport Scotland. That is one of the things that annoys me about the obfuscation that we have experienced. When we delved further into Transport Scotland’s report, we found that it had indicated that the junction would actually cost about £4 million, because it would be very straightforward.We were then told that, from the previous minister’s point of view, the most important aspect of transport was road safety, and that he had other priorities on road safety. The other campaigners and I said, “We hold our hands up. If that’s true, Laurencekirk will take its place in the queue.” We asked him what those other priorities were and he was not forthcoming. We looked at Transport Scotland’s plan, which the minister had approved, and found that over the past 11 years there had been no deaths at any of the grade-separated junctions that the plan had identified. We suddenly find that the previous transport minister’s number 1 priority—to save lives—does not apply to Laurencekirk, where there have been four deaths and some serious accidents. My question is simple. The campaigners and the people of Laurencekirk and the Mearns do not expect Transport Scotland, or indeed the minister, to come to this meeting with a bag of cash and say, “There you are. We’re building a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk.” What we are looking for is justice—we want the right thing to be done. We are asking the transport minister to put together a plan so that an essential road safety scheme for Laurencekirk can be included in the strategic transport plan. According to the advice from Transport Scotland, the minister can do that. This is about ensuring that the Scottish Government honours its responsibilities for the trunk road network and does the right thing at Laurencekirk. We are looking for a long-term solution, not a short-term bag of cash.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

As I said earlier, and as I have expressed to Mike Rumbles and others in my discussions with them, my intention has been to try to move things forward as best I can and to try to eliminate some of the doubt about the cost of any solution, not least because other people would end up paying substantially for it. I have done that in good faith, which I had hoped would be welcomed by Mr Rumbles. I totally support the idea that many of the projects in the STPR have a rationale other than safety. That has always been the case. That has been the case for every Government in the past, and we are following that proposal. The STPR was the first attempt to consider transport, across modes, as fairly and transparently as possible. Cathie Craigie talked about lining up a series of projects. I am trying not to make a political point, but if you do that, and then you have an £800 million cut to your capital budget, the plans lie in ruins. In the past, there was at least an expectation of stable or increasing capital programmes. It is no longer possible to plan on that basis.I have come to this fresh, but I have talked to Jill Campbell and I am genuinely trying to find a way forward. That is how I intend to proceed.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

On Ms Craigie’s question, I was seeking to describe the process that was gone through in the STPR. Mr Rumbles is correct to paraphrase, and perhaps to put more eloquently than I did, the concept of the length of the road corridor. It is also worth recognising that the first recommendation in the STPR was to implement the road safety plan.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

What criteria would need to be employed at the Laurencekirk junction to justify it being included in the next 10-year cycle of the STPR?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

The obvious point to make is that the ability to work through the projects in the STPR will be driven by the money and resources that are available. The project is in the STPR, and we considered it previously on the ground of safety. What seems to be causing something of a bottleneck is the wide variety of cost estimates. In this situation—unlike in many other road projects—where a third party will be involved in paying for the work, trying to deal with that uncertainty is the right way to move forward. It is not possible to give a definite answer about how long that will take. I am concerned to work out how things can be moved forward in the meantime.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Can you give an undertaking to ensure that the junction, with all its complications and road safety issues, will be included in the next STPR round?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

Unfortunately, I cannot give much of an assurance beyond the next short period. However, I would not be undertaking this work unless we were seriously thinking about what we can do in relation to this matter.Incidentally, this issue is not the only one that we have considered. When I went up to the junction recently I came back down during the hours of darkness, and I was struck by the fact that many similar junctions that involve people turning right off a carriageway—although they do not necessarily feature two or three junctions together—are well lit, but that junction is not. I asked—and I am still asking—Transport Scotland to tell me about the extent to which such lighting can improve the safety record. The initial response that I have received is that it would not have that much of an impact at Laurencekirk. There is a question about whether we should spend between £500,000 and £1 million on something that might not have a big effect and which might be superseded by a more substantial project, depending on other developments. However, such issues are worth thinking about, and I stress that I am trying to consider the issue afresh, from a different angle, to see how we can move things forward.The third part of the safety measures that were previously committed to—the final one, which concerns the northern junction—has not yet been completed. We will soon have an indication about how those measures are working.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I accept that you are coming to this issue with a fresh approach and in good faith—that goes without saying. You said that you have asked Transport Scotland to consider conducting a cost refinement exercise in respect of a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk, in order to get a more focused costing rather than the range of between £4 million and £20 million. Is that correct?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is certainly an attempt at a fresh approach. Can you, without breaking confidences, say whether you mentioned that when you met Jill Campbell? If you did, what was her response? If you did not, what was her response to the general discussion?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I did not mention that to her. We had a discussion that included the potential for developments around the junctions, which was perhaps a trigger for considering the sort of exercise that you mention. The exercise might be useful in this case because the work involves other parties who will have to calculate the amount that they would have to invest in the work.We had an amicable discussion about her concerns about the junctions, and I took in information at that time.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Mike Rumbles can speak for himself, but I believe that the paramount concern of everyone who is concerned about this matter—the petitioners, the constituency member and his constituents—is safety, and the improvement of the junction. To an extent, I am encouraged by the fact that you have at least asked Transport Scotland to consider issues around what was, in my old councillor days, described as improving the lux factor—in other words, the lighting in and around the area. That might or might not be advantageous, but I am grateful that that is being explored.When will the cost refinement exercise be completed, approximately?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

That is a good question, which my officials might be able to answer. It will be initiated soon.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

I am afraid that we do not have a timescale for that. The minister asked us to carry out the work, and we are working through how long it might take. One issue is how much detail we go into. At present, as the minister suggested, we are not being asked to do a “Design Manual for Roads and Bridges” stage 2 exercise, which would be a considerably larger exercise.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

But we are talking about months, rather than a year.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

We have been asked to undertake a relatively short exercise.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

You say “a relatively short exercise”—that is what I wanted to hear; I did not want a final date. I take it that when the exercise is completed, the Government—whichever Government—will return to the petitioner, the constituency member and all the interested parties to discuss the results.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

The real purpose of doing that is to make some of the interested parties more aware of the information—or to give them better information—on which they can base decisions. We want to make that available to all interested parties, including the petitioner.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

If the cost refinement exercise refined the cost in a way that was advantageous to what the petitioner desires—and what I guess most folk desire—would that help in moving Transport Scotland to say, at least, that a grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk would be, to use a non-technical term, a goer?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

To go back to my previous point, the vital funding decisions will be taken by people other than Transport Scotland, so it would depend on that.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

On a note of caution—because I do not want to give the impression that this is more than it might be—I should say that the report will be heavily caveated because of things such as ground conditions and some of the other imponderables, as I mentioned in response to Cathie Craigie’s example of Auchenkilns. It is worth bearing that in mind, but I am hopeful that the report will give better-quality information to those who are taking the decisions, which includes—although not exclusively—Transport Scotland.

Nanette Milne Con North East Scotland
link

I have a small point that relates to process under the STPR. How much consideration is given to the disruption and interruption in such a corridor each time there is a serious or fatal accident? The roads can be closed for many hours at a time.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

That was of interest at the STPR level, which is very strategic, but it was related to the number of accidents. One of the other corridors that we looked at was the A82, which has very different challenges.We consider the interruption that is caused to the network as part of our management of the network itself. We keep monitoring the network as a whole to see where the accidents occur; that work is on-going. If there are any patterns, we would take action to redress those. We do not consider the issue directly, but through the proxy of on-going monitoring.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

This discussion is interesting, but I am very disappointed. The minister said that there will be a cost refinement exercise for developers—that is what he started off saying; then he added that it would be for other interested parties. Transport Scotland has already stated in its own report, which is heavily caveated, that the cost of the junction will be £4.3 million. Is the minister aware of the cost for every death that we have had at the Laurencekirk junction? If we consider the cost of police, fire and rescue, ambulance services, road repairs and everything else, the total comes out at almost £1 million for each accident. That means that £4 million of taxpayers’ money has already been spent for the four deaths so far and there are many more accidents in and around Laurencekirk. The minister should put the emotional topic of deaths to one side—as difficult as that is—and consider the money side of the issue.What irritates me more than anything else is that we have a minister here who has responsibility for Transport Scotland and we are looking at the transport budget, but we are not considering the fact that the taxpayer is paying for all the problems at Laurencekirk. If the £4.3 million had been spent at Laurencekirk, we would have saved lives as well as money. That is an awful thing for the relatives of the dead, who are listening to the debate today, to cope with. We are interested only in ensuring that we save lives and spend taxpayers’ money well. That is a win-win situation for everybody. I return to the point that, when Mr Anderson is looking at the strategic view of the corridor, he should look at how we use taxpayers’ money to the best effect, especially when we are looking to save lives.16:15

I make this plea to the minister, who, I am pleased to see, has listened to everybody so far—I am just worried that he is listening too much to his civil servants. Let us reconsider the junction and refine the costs again, looking at the wider context of the spending of taxpayers’ money. I ask him please not to rely on developers coming along and paying for the improvements. Please do the right thing and put it in the strategic plan. We do not need to spend the money before May 2011; we just need a commitment for the future that it will be spent after that. We want a commitment to do the right thing.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I apologise if I am wrong, but I am pretty certain that I never said that this was being done for developers. The Official Report will tell us whether that is true.Obviously, I and everyone here regret any death on any public road. Trunk roads comprise about 6 per cent of the roads in this country, yet they account for two thirds of the traffic. There are historical pressures on trunk roads that cannot be solved in any one period, so we must prioritise—it is as simple as that. I make the point again that, if we lose a substantial amount from our capital programme, that will have an impact on the projects that we can proceed with. I do not accept that the real cost is £4 million. I have read the same papers that Mike Rumbles has read and I do not accept that that is the real cost. Neither am I willing to accept, on the basis of the papers that I have seen, that the junction would cost up to £23 million. The point of asking for the cost refinement exercise is to get more certainty about the figure. We are trying to move the thing forward, and decisions on where we go will be better informed after the cost refinement exercise—that is why I have chosen that route.Hugh Gillies has more information on the points that Mike Rumbles has raised.

Hugh Gillies Transport Scotland
link

The figure of £4.3 million refers to a BEAR Scotland report that was published in October 2009, which was distributed among the committee. A refinement was added to that, which was provided to the committee, for clarification. BEAR Scotland clarified that the estimate of £4.3 million was misleading and that what was meant should have been better defined. A lot of potential additional costs were not added into that figure.The reason why the BEAR report of 2009 was produced was—you are right, Mr Rumbles—that there have been changes in accident rates over the three junctions. The accident rate at the southern junction, since the first remedial measures were carried out in 2005, has gone backwards in terms of both number and severity. Yes, there was an increase in the accident rates at the middle and north junctions; hence, the remedial action that is taking place inclusive of the outstanding north merge junction improvement.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Can I respond to that, convener?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

The BEAR report that was produced for Transport Scotland was a standard report. Time and again when we address the issue, we look at the accident statistics, but there is no dispute about the accident statistics. I get irritated when I am told that the accident rate at the southern junction is slightly better. We must look at all three junctions together. The plan was to build a grade-separated junction at the southern exit and to close off the middle and northern sections so that people could not cross the dual carriageway. Laurencekirk must be looked at as a whole. Please do not mislead members of the committee by saying that the accident statistics have improved. The situation around the three junctions at Laurencekirk, since the short-term, temporary safety measures were put in in 2005, has got worse and it is only a matter of time before we have another death at that junction. That is what this is all about.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I understand what Mr Anderson is saying. I know where he is coming from and I do not want to attack him. However, it is not terribly interesting to people who live in Montrose, Marykirk or Laurencekirk, on the A937, which crosses the A90, to be told that the A90 is the priority. If you live on the A937, you have no alternative way of getting to other places. There are no options—that is your road. If the junction is dangerous, as it is—I invite anyone who does not believe that to try driving across it in rush hour—that is what you see. It does not matter how many thousands of other people go up and down the other road. That is of no interest to you if you want to cross it.

David Anderson Transport Scotland
link

I agree entirely—transport is an entirely personal thing. People make choices about transport all the time based on their own interests. If they are on a particular road, that is the road in which they are interested.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I invite the committee to consider how it wishes to proceed with the petition.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I suggest to colleagues that we continue the petition, as there are many questions that must be answered or clarified. Like other members, I welcome the minister’s instruction to Transport Scotland to undertake a cost refinement exercise. That is not the be-all and end-all, because it is the result of the exercise that will be of interest to everyone concerned.We should continue the petition and await what we hope will be early reporting of the exercise’s conclusions, which, I hope, will be able to come before this committee. If they cannot, it is one of those cases in which we are left with no option but to include the matter in our legacy paper, if colleagues agree, and to make a strong recommendation to the successor committee. I hope that the exercise will be focused, targeted and reasonably rapid, so that we can look at the petition again, but there are issues outstanding. We all, however, welcome the fresh eye that the minister has cast on the matter. Let us hope that that moves things forward.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Does the committee agree to that approach?Members indicated agreement.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We agree that the petition will be continued on that basis.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

In his response to questions, the minister challenged the Government’s own statistics on how much it costs—the figure is almost £1 million per accident—to clear up after a fatal accident. Those statistics are not my statistics or the campaigners’ statistics—they are Government statistics. Will the minister be invited to write to you on the issue? I would like to see his reasoning for challenging the Government’s statistics.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I am sure that the committee would welcome some clarity on the issue.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I cannot respond to that, as I never challenged the stats that were mentioned. The Official Report of the meeting will show that.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

To be fair, I do not think that it was a challenge. According to my recollection—I am sure that the Official Report will show this—the issue of the total cost of clearing up after a fatal accident was mentioned. Like other members of the committee, I am sure, I would like the Government to provide a response in purely informational terms. That would be satisfactory to all parties.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Absolutely.I am conscious that the minister has had a long afternoon, but I understand that he is prepared to give us a quick update on the progress of PE1098 from Lynn Merrifield and PE1223 from Ron Beaty, on school bus safety. We will not come to the petitions until later in the meeting, but given that the minister is here and that we have some frustration about progress, I wonder whether he will be good enough to give the committee a quick update.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

All that I can say is that I have written to Mike Penning, the relevant minister at Westminster, to see whether he can take the matter forward. I was involved to some extent in a previous role, but the matter was taken forward by Stewart Stevenson. I have asked to have further discussions with Mike Penning on the issue. A joint letter about new regulations that are to be introduced has been agreed between the two of us.I was not expecting to discuss the matter today, but I can get more information to the committee. I am happy to give you a copy of the letter that I have sent to Mike Penning asking for an early discussion, if you do not have it already. Essentially, the discussion will be about the devolution of powers to insist that school buses have seat belts. That is the point that we have reached; I have not yet received a response.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Thank you very much for that helpful information and your attendance this afternoon—and I understand that you do not now have to attend your other committee meeting. I also thank Transport Scotland officials.

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 185
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 71
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 11
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.