Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Rail Noise and Vibration (Larbert) (PE1302)

Tuesday 25 January 2011 Public Petitions Committee About 14:00 Petitions 185 contributions · 16 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

185 contributions
Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Good afternoon and welcome to the second meeting in 2011 of the Public Petitions Committee. No apologies have been received. Please ensure that all mobile phones and electronic devices are switched off.Agenda item 1 is consideration of current petitions. I suggest that we spend approximately an hour discussing PE1273 and PE1302, which are on the overnight running of freight trains. We have a number of witnesses, and we are keen to have a worthwhile discussion about the issue, which is complex.I welcome to the meeting Anne Massie and Colin Sloper, who are petitioners; the Minister for Transport and Infrastructure, Keith Brown; Frances Duffy, who is an official from Transport Scotland—she is with the minister; Ron McAulay, who is Network Rail director for Scotland; Neil McDonald, who is managing director of DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd; and Mac West, who is roads and transportation manager for Clackmannanshire Council. I thank all the witnesses for their attendance.We will start with questions from committee members. I know that Richard Simpson, who is a local MSP, is keen to become involved in the discussion, too.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Good afternoon to all members of the panel.I have some interest in the petitions in a formal sense, given that I was, for my sins, convener of the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee nearly eight years ago. Obviously, like other members, I am concerned by what is being endured—I think that that is the correct word—by constituents in and around the minister’s and Dr Richard Simpson’s constituencies.My first question is to Mr John O’Neill of Scottish Power. Has Scottish Power ever been able to guarantee turning around each of the proposed 15 coal train sets to Longannet power station in less than two hours? That was mentioned in the Scott Wilson impact report.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

It depends on the size of the train, but I think that the answer is no for the trains that are capable of running on the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine line. The answer will be yes if much smaller sets are run, but significantly more such trains would have to be run to deliver the same tonnage that we expected to be able to deliver over the SAK line.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

But the reality is that 15 sets were mentioned in the report, and it was never going to be possible to avoid night running or even to turn around the 15 sets in 24 hours, given that, if there is a two-hour turnaround time, the maximum would be 12 sets in 24 hours. Is that right?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

If two hours is the optimum time to get trains in and back out into the system in a reliable and robust manner, the answer to the question is probably no.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

So you were never able to guarantee that.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

I do not think that we would have been able to guarantee it unless the trains were much smaller.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Yes, but in real life, the answer is no. That is handy to have on the record because the impact study that Clackmannanshire Council ordered was based on the assumption that there would be 30 paths—that is, 15 train sets would arrive at Scottish Power at Longannet in 16 hours, from 07:00 to 23:00. Scottish Power has now confirmed that that frequency of traffic could never have been handled. That is a bit disturbing.I am looking for the facts, as I want to get things right. The Scott Wilson impact report mentioned the absence of night running on 18 separate occasions—I got a researcher to work on that; I did not do that work myself. The committee and local people were promised that there would be an absence of night running, but that was never going to be the case.14:15

I have a few other questions. The first is for Scottish Power and—let us vary it a little—Mr McDonald of DB Schenker. As the bill went through the committee of the Parliament, it must surely have become obvious to your organisations that the main objections were arising from noise and vibration. One of the real concerns was the overnight running of freight trains, and we were promised that that would not happen. Given that it must have been obvious that that was inadvertently misleading, why did you not make the committee aware of that when it was considering the bill?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

We were unaware of the limitation that the promoter had put in the bill. The stated assumption in the bill was 5 million tonnes, but we always knew that 5 million tonnes could not be run within the 16-hour window. We were supportive of the SAK development—

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

If you knew that, why did you not tell the committee?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

I am not aware that we did or did not tell the committee.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Nobody told the committee. Was it an oversight?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

DB Schenker was not aware that the constraint was going to be placed within the bill. I am still not aware that that constraint was actually in the bill.We were supporters of the bill because it gave us an opportunity to move more tonnage into Longannet power station. We were aware that the line was becoming part of the strategic network of the United Kingdom rail industry, which is a 24/7 railway, and we supported it on the basis that it would be a 24/7 railway. Had we been made aware of the constraint from 23:00 to 07:00, we would not have supported the bill because that would have been contrary to the strategic objectives of a 24/7 railway.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

If only we had heard that seven and a half years ago. Mr O’Neill, do you want to have a shot at responding to that question? It seems straightforward enough to me.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

I can only echo what Mr McDonald has said. Our expectation was that, when the SAK line was put in place, there would be no constraints on the use of that line. We expected the increased capacity to be available on a 24-hour basis.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

At what point after 2003 did you realise that the number of freight trains would need to increase and that the time between 11.00 pm and 7.00 am was not realistic? Were you always aware of that?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

It is a moving picture with these things.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

Since 2003, the network has got busier. By the time things were put in place, the timetabling of the trains that would give us 5 million tonne capability through the system was such that we ended up with the two-hour terminal time at Longannet to enable us to plan regular, reliable and robust programmes that would deliver the tonnage that we required at Longannet.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Robin Harper has a question. Is it on that point?

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Yes, it is. There seems to be a bottleneck in terms of the turnaround time for the trains, which you said is two hours—is that correct?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

The terminal time is two hours. That is the time from the train arriving at the power station to its departure from the power station.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

Would it be possible to decrease that turnaround time? Do other power stations have faster turnaround times for trains of a similar size? If so, have you worked out how much that would cost? Has decreasing the turnaround time been considered?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

We have looked at that. To take a step back, when we had the old HAA wagons coming over the Forth rail bridge, they had a capacity of about 1,000 tonnes a train. The hopper into which the coal is discharged is a 2,500 tonne hopper. The trains have bottom discharge wagons so, when they arrive, they open up and discharge the coal through grids into the hopper. From the hopper, the coal is conveyed either out into stock or to the units. We have to keep a certain amount in the bunker at any point in time—around 500 tonnes—because there are paddle feeders at the bottom that feed the coal on to the conveying systems. So, there is a working capacity for coal of about 2,000 tonnes. In the past, that meant that we could accommodate two trains’ worth of coal in the hopper as storage at any point in time. With the larger train sizes that we are now operating—at 1,600 tonnes—we cannot take the equivalent of two trains. That puts some delay in the system, as a certain amount of time is required to get the bunker clear before we can bring in the next train.A number of factors impact on how quickly we can process coal with the system that we have. Further, what we do on the ground at Longannet has got slightly more complicated. Back in 2002 and 2003, we fed the same diet of coal to all the units, so what came in could be fed to all the units. Now that we have fitted FGD—flue-gas desulphurisation—at Longannet, we have to feed a different diet of coal to the FGD units and the unabated unit. That means that there is double handling of coal to process the right blend of coal to the different units. There is some stop starting, as we have to recover coal from stock to put back on to the belts, and unloading of coal that might be going in or out. That means that the effective rate at which we can take coal away from the bunker overall has decreased slightly.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I want to pursue that, as you have not answered the question whether it is possible to improve the system. Is a different system available or is it possible to improve the system? Would you be able to find money to invest in an improved system?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

We have looked at that and what I have got back from our people is that, to improve the rate at which we can discharge coal and move it through the system, we would have to get back to where we were before, which was a hopper that could take the equivalent of two trains of coal. That would mean uprating the belts and the rate at which we can physically take coal away. We are talking about tens of millions of pounds of investment to do that—it is a large undertaking. The hopper sits underground. We would either have to build a completely new hopper, which would mean diverting rail lines and building new conveying systems, or take out the existing hopper and replace it. That would potentially mean taking out the ability to feed the station for periods of time, which would have a significant impact on the revenues to Scottish Power.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

Can you confirm that there is nothing in principle to prevent Scottish Power from installing a parallel railway line with a parallel hopper and a parallel set of belts? I appreciate what those look like, as I have worked in industry. The issue is that it would involve a very large number in terms of money.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

It is a huge number.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I understand that, but there is nothing physically to prevent you from doing that if you had the will.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

We have had only an initial look to find out what it would cost. We have not done a detailed study. Work would still need to be done to find out exactly where we would put the hopper and how it would be done. We have done a desktop study to show what we would need to do. We would need a significant sum of money.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

It is physically possible.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

That would need to be subject to a detailed study on the availability of land near the existing hopper and other issues. A detailed study has not been done.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

For the record, what was the number of freight journeys when the railway became operational and what is the number now, broken down by day and night time?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

I do not have the information on what the number was when the railway first started. There was a period when Longannet was taking less coal through, when it was making significant investment in its plant. The number varies through the years. Just now there are something like 36 trains per week going through that we operate and a further 12 that are operated by another freight operating company.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

What action did DB Schenker take at the time that it obtained permission under the track access agreement for the night running of freight trains? When was that agreed and for how many trains was it agreed? Who did you consult locally, such as residents?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

We worked with Network Rail as part of our timetabling arrangements, which are annual arrangements. We sought to agree pathings through what is probably the second largest train operation outside London. Trying to path trains through from Ayrshire to Longannet is fairly significant. All the way through 2007 there were some delays to that because there were key issues around additional levies being put on the route, which at that point DB Schenker, or the English Welsh & Scottish Railway Ltd as was, was unable to commit to going on the SAK line and was remaining within the Forth bridge. Those were resolved in late 2007 and early 2008. In February 2008 we applied for the paths for 24/7 working. In July 2008 we agreed those paths for commencement of operation in December 2008.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is interesting, but one thing seems to be missing. What specific discussions took place and how did they take place—if they took place—with local residents along the railway route when overnight running of trains was introduced? Perhaps Mr McDonald and Mr O’Neill could both have a shy at that.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

It is our obligation to work with Network Rail. It is not our obligation to consult along the lines of routes with all local residents.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Did you consult any local residents?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

No, that is not our role.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Thank you. That is clear. Mr O’Neill?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

No. I am not aware that we consulted residents either. As I said before, when the SAK line came in the full expectation was that it would be in 24-hour operation.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

You are saying that that was your organisation’s expectation, but it was not the bill committee’s expectation at all, because we were never told that. When the question was put, we were told that there would not be night running. Mr McAulay, what about you? Has Network Rail had any discussions with the residents who are affected by overnight running?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

Not about the proposals for overnight running.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

So, the organisations that you represent have never talked to local residents about overnight running.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

Let me be clear. When timetable changes are made every year, going out and consulting all the line-side neighbours is not part of the normal process. I understand the special circumstances around this particular railway, but it would not be normal policy to consult.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

No. I am not claiming that we did.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is very clear and very disappointing.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I am not familiar with the exact process when an operator applies for such a permission. What is the process? Who are you answerable to? Who makes the final decision on the application?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

The process is very much one of the train operating companies bidding for train paths in the timetabling process. They make an application or a bid for train paths. We consider that in light of all the other demands on the railway from other train operating companies. If those paths can be accommodated, we are obliged to allow those trains to run.14:30

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

So you would not consult the local community or a local authority.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

The train timetable changes on a fairly major basis once a year, but there is also a second date when it changes, in May. I can understand the particular circumstances around the section of railway that is being highlighted, but the train timetable changes right across Great Britain, and we have about 5 million neighbours. The task of consulting those 5 million neighbours about every change that was made to the timetable would be impractical, I think.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Perhaps I will return to the matter later.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I wish to develop the issues around the contract and the procedures for coal deliveries. My colleagues have already discussed how the coal gets delivered and how it is dealt with once it gets to Longannet.My understanding is that Scottish Power’s contract is with Clydeport, and that Clydeport contracts DB Schenker to deliver the coal. Could Mr O’Neill of Scottish Power clarify what the contract specifies on the delivery of coal? How much coal has to be delivered, at whatever times? How are the times at which it is delivered broken down? As I understand it from the figures that we were given, there are currently 48 rail journeys from Hunterston to Longannet, DB Schenker being the largest contractor that takes the coal. How is the contract worked out between Scottish Power and Clydeport in terms of how much coal is delivered, and when and how it is delivered?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

We have a contract that requires delivery of up to 5 million tonnes a year. When it comes to working out what we want delivered, we give Clydeport an indicative view regarding our requirements, based on the forecast running pattern for the year, and that gets shared with DB Schenker.As far as movements of tonnage are concerned, our only firm contractual commitment is in our schedule a week ahead, when we advise that we require to move a certain number of trains the following week. We have regular dialogue and we keep DB Schenker advised of any updates, so that it has sufficient time to manage the resources that are required.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

There is a contract to shift 5 million tonnes of coal a year from Clydeport, but am I correct in my understanding of your answer that you can operate a week ahead? Can you say that you need a certain tonnage shifted the following week, compared with what was required the previous week?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

Under the contract with Clydeport, imported coal is brought into the port of Hunterston in large vessels. Our aim is always to have a stock of coal at Hunterston, so that we can run a pattern of trains. If there is a problem with the shipping schedule at some point and we think that there might be an issue of running out of coal at Hunterston before the next vessel arrives, we might trim back the programme. If we run a slightly reduced programme, that avoids running hard but then stopping suddenly for a week or two weeks. The aim is to smooth it out.The firm contractual commitment for what is moved in any given week is made, in essence, through ordering a week ahead. We also regularly discuss the longer term, so that a view can be taken on our requirements. We give regular updates.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Convener, I should have said at the outset of my questions that I am a resident in the area, not of the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine line, but of the line that runs through Coatbridge. I live within about 100yd of the railway line and I see the freight trains that service Longannet going through. I just want to get that on the record so that people are aware of it. I know the problems that exist not just on the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine line, but all along the line from Hunterston to Longannet.That leads me to my next question, which is about the timetabling of trains and the modelling that has been used by Network Rail, Scottish Power and DB Schenker in relation to the amount of trains that run throughout a 24-hour period. We heard about that earlier. Could the rail freight be accommodated between 7 am and 11 pm rather than overnight? The major concern of one of the petitioners who is here today is the amount of freight trains that run overnight. As I live next to the line, I know when the freight trains come through, and they pass my house at roughly 3 o’clock and 4 o’clock in the morning on their way up to Longannet. I would like to delve deeper into whether Network Rail could accommodate the freight during the day, transporting the coal between 7 am and 11 pm rather than overnight.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

The answer is that it would be difficult to timetable the trains. I am thinking of the route that those trains take. They go along what is referred to as the Paisley corridor, which is one of the busiest sections of railway in Scotland. It is a heavily loaded railway already, and finding paths through it during the day would be difficult. Given that it is difficult to accommodate the train paths that we already have, I think that it would be extremely difficult to find additional ones.I am not going to sit here and say that it would be impossible, because I do not know. I am not a timetable planner, and I would need to go away and model the proposal to find out, but my view is that it would be extremely difficult to find enough paths without interfering considerably with existing traffic on the route.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

I concur with Ron McAulay. In the mid-2000s, we looked at whether it was even feasible to model different timetables through the Paisley corridor, and we were never able to find a timetable model that allowed us to get through that corridor, where there are only two paths an hour, through Glasgow, up to the Edinburgh to Glasgow line, and then on to the Stirling to Kincardine route. A significant recast of the passenger network in Scotland would be needed, and that made it extremely difficult to deliver what was proposed.What we do with regard to the pathing that we use is that, when volume drops, we reduce the amount of sets that we use in the operation, and that reduces the cycles that operate at night time. We already do that throughout the rail network to try to drive the asset utilisation of the sets that we have.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Perhaps the witnesses could further clarify the position. My understanding is that the coal freight trains run on six days of the week. Is that true?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

Yes.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

As I understand it, the day when they do not run is Sunday. One of the issues you have identified with the pathing is the Paisley corridor, where there is competition with other trains, which I assume are passenger trains, during the week. Given that there are fewer passenger trains on a Sunday, why can DB Schenker and Scottish Power not work with Network Rail and ask for some of the freight to be transported on a Sunday rather than during the night?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

As with any strategic transport network, we have to allow some time to get in to maintain and renew the railway. To be frank, if there are six 24-hour operations going on every week, we need to retain sufficient time in the timetable to allow our teams to get in not only on the section from Stirling through to Kincardine but on the whole route, from Hunterston all the way through to Longannet.Please do not assume that we have all day Sunday to do what we want, because we do not. There are still other trains running on those routes and we have to find times between trains—in what we call white space in the timetable—to allow our teams to get in. Those times are very short. I will give you an example: on the Edinburgh to Glasgow line, we are lucky if we get something like four hours at night to get in to maintain the track. It is not possible to do a huge amount in four hours.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

DB Schenker is extremely supportive of a seven-day railway. We have worked with Network Rail over the past number of years to deliver a seven-day railway. In fact, the SAK line was a good example of moving towards that capability. It was one of the first routes on which Network Rail moved to its standardised one-week-in-six maintenance programme.There are significant infrastructure enhancements continuing in Scotland, which will benefit the passengers in the Scottish network over the next few years. Those include work on the Paisley corridor, to which Ron McAulay referred, and the future electrification of the Edinburgh to Glasgow route. Those are significant routes that we would have to try to traverse on a Sunday, and enhancements are usually done on Saturday nights and Sundays.A large proportion of the work to enhance the passenger network for the benefit of the Scottish economy will be carried out on a Sunday, so we could not consistently commit to the capability that John Wilson proposes.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The original Scott Wilson impact study said that there would be 30 paths—that is, 15 trains—in the 16-hour period. My colleague Mr Butler has established that that was never practical or possible. However, we now have 48 trains in six days, which is eight trains a day, and a two-hour turnaround at Scottish Power. Therefore, if the paths were available, it would be possible to accommodate the trains in the timetable that was originally proposed to the bill committee. I understand that there may be a problem with the paths that may be extremely difficult but, technically, from Scottish Power’s end, there is no problem with the delivery of eight trains a day in a 16-hour period because that provides for the two-hour turnaround. Is that correct?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

At a simplistic level, that is true, but the key point about the available number of paths is the amount of train traffic that we are running at the moment, given what we have at Hunterston and what we are moving for various reasons. When we get to the peak winter period, we cannot physically deliver between road and rail the amount of coal that we consume at peak demand. In our peak demand periods, even if they fell outwith the winter, we would require all the capacity to be available because the station would have a demand for that amount of coal.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I understand. So it is eight trains on average, but it may not be eight every week. Am I correct in saying that there was an extended period when there were no deliveries? At one point last year, DB Schenker did not operate trains for a number of weeks. That must have meant that your stocks were oversupplied but, instead of abandoning night-train running—which is offensive to my constituents and disturbs them—over a much more extended period, you stopped all trains, day and night.My purpose in being here is to ensure that we minimise the insult to my constituents who have, unwittingly, been affected by the Parliament’s passing the bill without knowing that you were going to have night running. We did not know that that would happen and we are now asking that you make every possible effort to ensure that night running is eliminated where that is possible and minimised where it is not possible.14:45

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

The only period that I can remember when we had no traffic was during our usual annual shutdown period—a two-week period during which we programme in maintenance work, such as any work that is required on the track at Longannet; maintenance of the rail hopper, which we cannot get to if it is being used on a daily basis; and realigning of hoppers, which takes a long time. We tie in that shutdown with a shutdown of the berth at Hunterston, because, similarly—

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I understand the need for a two-week period for maintenance. I have obviously been misled, because I understood that there was a longer period.

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

I am not aware of any period beyond the one that I mentioned.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The petitioners have informed me that there was a longer period during which trains were not run. They said that it was much longer than two weeks. I accept the need for a two-week maintenance period, but there was another period during which trains were not run for a considerable length to time.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

Can you clarify when that was?

Anne Massie
link

It was a period of three weeks, as far as I know.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

Do you have dates?

Anne Massie
link

I do not sit up in my bed every night and look at the clock.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Questions and responses should come through the convener. I ask Anne Massie to clarify her understanding.

Anne Massie
link

He does not believe me when I say that the trains stopped running for three weeks, but I cannot prove that I am right, because I do not sit up at night and count the trains as they go through. If I did that, I would get no sleep whatsoever.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

On the running times that Richard Simpson raised, was there any curtailment of the number of freight journeys that were made during the severe weather that we had in December? I am aware that a number of level crossing barriers were frozen open or closed.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

In December, as we are all aware, we had some of the worst weather that the UK network has faced for many years. In the north and north-east of England in early December, severe snow storms blocked points into power stations. That lasted for three or four days as the power stations were dug out. Every rail freight yard in the north and north-east of England suffered that same set of circumstances. In the third week, it happened in Scotland to the same level—it may even have been worse, because temperatures in Scotland at that time fell as low as -14°C or -15°C.By the time the snow had been cleared from the points, the coal in the trains had frozen. You might not know that it takes time and effort to get frozen coal out. On 26 December, two thirds of the wagons in the DB Schenker fleet had frozen coal in them, and it took us a week to get that tipped. At that point, you would have seen a reduction in freight throughout the UK rail network—not only coal but every commodity area, including Royal Mail, fast-moving consumer goods and heavy freight.I hope that that gives some clarification.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Very briefly; I am conscious of time marching on.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I am conscious of time, too, but I have a question for Scottish Power. Was there any operational loss to Longannet during the period in which freight trains did not run or their operation was curtailed?

John O’Neill Scottish Power
link

We had difficulties in feeding coal to the station due to the factors that Neil McDonald has just pointed out. We had a long spell during which we could not physically get any coal into the station. However, we always build stock as we move into the winter period, precisely to cover such situations. In most winters, we have periods when we have frozen loads and lost deliveries, although they are not always as long as this year’s period was. Naturally, therefore, our stock comes down as we move out of winter. For the reason that I mentioned earlier, we cannot physically deliver all the coal that is needed and ensure that we have sufficient stock there as a buffer. The whole point of having stock is to accommodate situations in which there are interruptions to the supply. We need to ensure that we have sufficient stock to cover those situations. However, throughout that period, we had difficulties. Even recovering coal from stock was difficult. We had to bring in additional machinery to break up stock coal to be able physically to feed the units.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

We have heard that it would be difficult, if not impossible, to stop overnight trains running. Is that a correct assessment, or can we take a glimmer of hope from the suggestion that you could go back and look at the whole system—the paths, as you call them?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

I will try to explain. The rail network is a strategic transport network that is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Within that timeframe, we have to undertake maintenance on it and we need to renew it every so often but, otherwise, it is there to be used. If people bid for train paths and to move commodities by rail, we welcome that. We cannot say, “No, you can’t run at that time,” if the train path can be accommodated.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Okay. Can you tell the committee what speed the trains run at in the area that we are speaking about, especially where the petitioners live? Who monitors that speed and whether it is being exceeded? Who has that responsibility and how regularly is that done?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

The speed of the traffic from Hunterston right through to Longannet will vary considerably. There will be sections where the speed is up at about 60mph and there will be sections, especially towards the end, on some of the freight-only parts of the new line, where it will be down to about 30mph. On who monitors the speed, we have speed guns such as those that you see the police using on the road system. However, the speed is monitored 24 hours a day, seven days a week—or whenever the train is running—through the black box that sits in the train itself. The black box records the speed at which the train is travelling, and the train operators monitor the black boxes regularly to ensure that their drivers are behaving.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

Good afternoon, folks. One of the main issues to have come before the committee has been the aggravation of noise due to night running, which seems to be a genuine problem. In your opinion, is the current track design adequate and appropriate for the service that is being run over it? When does the mitigation of a noise barrier kick in? The petitioners have stated that they are of the opinion that the noise level has reached something like 80 dB, which is quite high. When did you last measure the daytime and night-time noise levels? Are you willing to carry out any further survey as required by the petitioners? It seems to be a big issue for them.

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

We have carried out surveys of noise and vibration along the length of the line. We also produced a model that extended 300m to either side of the line, which covered around 6,200 houses. The criterion that was used to assess whether mitigation was appropriate was whether a property suffered a noise level of more than 55 dB representing an increase greater than 5 dB on the noise level prior to the railway opening. Along the length of the SAK line, 44 properties qualified under that criterion.We took another look at where those properties sat. Some of them were separated by a single property that was set slightly further back, so that the property in the middle would not have qualified. It seems illogical just to put a barrier across the front of those two houses; it is more logical to continue the barrier to give consistent protection. That increased the number of properties that were to be offered noise mitigation to 66.Almost all those properties were visited towards the tail end of last year. The proposals for noise barriers were explained to the residents and the majority of them have accepted them. The intention is that, in the coming months, the council will let a contract for installation of those barriers at those 66 properties. One or two residents have declined the offer of mitigation because the barrier would spoil their view or for other reasons. That is the current situation.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

At how many locations along the line are the day and night operations being monitored? Are the noise levels now higher than they were at the start of proceedings in 2003?

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

The railway only opened to traffic in 2008 and the noise measurements were carried out in 2009. Freight traffic started to run in December 2008 and we delayed the noise measurements until after that freight traffic was running so that we could catch the impact of all the traffic that was running on the line, including overnight traffic.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Do Mrs Massie and Mr Sloper think that the mitigation that has been described is sufficient.

Anne Massie
link

A couple of gentlemen came to look at my property. At the moment, I have 40ft leylandii trees on either side of my property and they baffle the noise. There is a gap between one belt of trees, and another gap right where my bedroom window is. My bedroom is 7m from the track. That gap is where I hear most noise. I also hear it past my garage at the end of my garden because there are no trees there. I have a 1.8m fairly closely boarded fence in front of the trees, which also helps to baffle the noise.My garden is below the level of the track so the wheels are more or less at head height. A burn runs through my garden and the gap is at the point where the burn runs under the railway line. There is no way that a fence can be put there to stop any noise coming in my bedroom window. My bedroom will always have noise because of where the burn runs. The fence overlaps the gap but it does not stop the noise because the noise comes over the top. A 3m fence would be needed. I believe that Mac West mentioned a 3m fence, but putting that in would mean taking out some of my trees, which would cause more of a problem. They would also have to take out the fence that is already there; it is still in very good condition because it was put in just before I bought the house.I have certainly been offered mitigation. I must challenge what Mac West said, however, because I have neither accepted nor refused mitigation because I have never been offered it in writing. I will do nothing on mitigation until the night-time trains are stopped. There is no reason why they cannot go back across the rail bridge, across the Forth and up through Culross.15:00

Colin Sloper
link

Unfortunately, I do not live in Clackmannanshire so I do not recognise the statements. Falkirk Council has never measured the decibels where I live. No one has come to my door. Furthermore, I do not know what the legislation or guidance is regarding vibration. My experience is that at least six nights a week we are woken up by the noise. Not to put too fine a point on it, it is like an earthquake in my house. I have a one-year-old daughter in the next bedroom, and every night when I wake up I think, “This is the night I’m going to have to get my daughter out the house.” It is not acceptable. As a citizen of Scotland, I say that it is not good enough.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I understand that Transport Scotland was going to carry out a survey and report on the noise and vibration levels along the track. Has that survey been undertaken? If so, when are we likely to see the results?

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

That is the work that Mac West was referring to. Transport Scotland is working closely with Clackmannanshire Council and providing it with support to take that forward. It is the council that is carrying out the survey.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

So it is the council and not Transport Scotland.

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

We are not carrying the work out separately. We are supporting Clackmannanshire Council to do it locally.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

What is Transport Scotland’s input? Does it concern you that a new transport link is causing such grief and disappointment to the people who live alongside the track?

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

We have been working closely with the council to provide it with support, including funding support, for the investigations and mitigation measures.

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

Yes.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

How does Clackmannanshire Council feel about being the promoter of the line, given the indications back in 2003 about the number of trains that could be expected and the predicted noise levels, and what is actually happening now?

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

We are disappointed that local residents are being disturbed. We are working with Transport Scotland to put in place mitigation measures where the criteria are being breached. My chief executive led a meeting with DB Schenker and Network Rail to discuss the possibility of reducing or ceasing overnight freight running. Unfortunately, at that meeting DB Schenker explained its view that in order to fulfil its contract to deliver coal to Scottish Power, it had to continue running services overnight.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Mr Sloper, has the problem generally been in the night? I do not know which railway line you live close to.

Colin Sloper
link

Larbert. Trains going towards the power station are bad enough but the trains coming back are the 60mph ones. They are empty, and the vibrations are huge. I do not recognise what Transport Scotland is doing in relation to Clackmannanshire Council, unless someone can tell me that the council is undertaking a survey for all residents affected along the entire length of the line.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

That is why I wanted clarification. Surely it is not all up to Clackmannanshire Council. How is Transport Scotland resourcing the other councils along the route? I represent Cumbernauld and Kilsyth, and people in my constituency have to put up with the night-time running of freight trains. Surely, as the strategic transport authority, Transport Scotland has a role to play here.

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

The work that we are helping Clackmannanshire Council with is to monitor noise from the introduction of the new railway, not noise in the railway network as a whole.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Does Transport Scotland have no remit for rail noise?

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

For rail noise as a whole?

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

It does not. Noise from a railway’s general operations is covered more by environmental legislation. Mr McAulay will explain what happens on the existing railway.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

I apologise that the explanation will start to become complicated, but I ask members to bear with me. Two railways are involved: one is the new railway that was built under the private act—the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Act 2004—and the other is the operational railway that has been there for about 150 years. The railway that has been in place for a long time is covered by all the existing railway legislation, which applies across Great Britain. How all that applies in Scotland is no different.The railway as a whole is a strategic transport network that is there to be used. The new railway’s benefit is that it has taken probably thousands of lorries off the road and put their contents on rail. Rail is a far more environmentally friendly means of transporting coal, although I understand the implications for local residents.

Anne Massie
link

We are aware of that.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

Thank you.In general, the line is there to be used at whatever hours allow it to be used—24/7. Freight trains run on the line already. Having coal trains on the line just increases the usage of the existing railway.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

What legislation regulates noise and vibration? Is it UK or Scottish legislation? How is it enforced?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

It is UK legislation.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

I imagine that the UK Government enforces it.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I do not know whether anybody can throw light on that.

Keith Brown SNP The Minister for Transport and Infrastructure · Ochil
link

I understand that the Office of Rail Regulation determines that matter. However, a complication is that the 1996 noise regulations that have been referred to do not apply to Scotland, and no contemporaneous legislation was made for Scotland. That might have been an oversight, or perhaps it was assumed that the Scotland Act 1998—which was considered shortly afterwards—would deal with the matter. No noise regulations apply, but it is true to say that the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine line has followed the standards that would apply if such regulations were in place.I understand that the responsibility lies with the Office of Rail Regulation, but I am about to be corrected.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

I apologise for correcting the minister, but the ORR does not deal with noise. The ORR is an economic and safety regulator, not an environmental regulator. Local councils’ environmental health departments probably apply the regulations.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Will Clackmannanshire Council clarify whether that is the council’s role?

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

I am not an environmental health officer, but I know that the council has considered the Environmental Protection Act 1990. Whether noise from a railway is classed as a statutory nuisance under that act is up for debate. There is no clear view on that.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We are going to the heart of the matter in national terms, to which the minister and Transport Scotland are important. As Mr McAulay said, we are working with others to develop the network in Scotland to benefit passengers, freight and the economy. However, nobody takes responsibility for protecting citizens. No one authority stands up to say, “If a new development takes place, we are here for the citizens.” I am concerned about that for the future, as well as for the cases that we are dealing with.Everyone has simply handed the responsibility on to everyone else. We have not yet got an answer to the question why Clackmannanshire Council, which at the time happened to be under the minister’s leadership—although I do not think that that is relevant—

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

But you thought that you would just mention it.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Indeed. Clackmannanshire Council must have received instructions, presumably from the Labour Government at the time or Transport Scotland, that non-night running was to be part of the impact study. After all, we would not be sitting here now and the bill committee would not have debated the objections in the way that it did had the original impact study said, “There will be 24-hour running”, or, “There is likely to be 24-hour running”. The study and, indeed, the report specifically said that there would be no night running. No one stood up at that point and said, “Actually, Network Rail have to allow access”. That has been made clear repeatedly; indeed, there is no question about that. Notwithstanding noise and vibration—the issue is irrelevant anyway because we have no powers over any of this—if the operator applies for access, if Scottish Power want it and if it is safe, these trains will run. I have received no answer from Clackmannanshire Council or Transport Scotland about how we ended up in this mess in the first place and why no one ensured that the bill committee could have a real debate about the real potential for 24-hour running.The second part of my question is actually my original point: who protects the citizen?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I will leave to one side the question of Clackmannanshire Council’s role in this, which I have discussed with Richard Simpson before. I have seen the Official Report of the bill committee’s deliberations, which shows that it was told of the likelihood of night-time running.However, as Richard Simpson has pointed out and as has been pointed out at a previous meeting of this committee, the environmental impact study was heavily reliant on information provided by the Scottish Executive. I believe that Dr Simpson said that knowledge of railways was extinct for 25 years in Clackmannanshire Council; as members will appreciate, a small council that had no rail would have no expertise in that area and would therefore be heavily reliant on the information in question. It is also true to say that as the bill proceeded the environmental impact study was not used because the concern was to promote the railway’s construction.Who defends the public interest is an important question—indeed, it is probably the crux of the matter. We have to accept that we have a privatised 24-hour-a-day rail network in this country. As I understand it—and I have been examining the issue for some time now—responsibility for legal action over noise abatement would fall to Clackmannanshire Council but it is fair to say that the outcome would be very uncertain.On the separate question of who under the regulations is able to say that freight trains should stop running, I understand—I might well be corrected by Ron McAulay—that that power lies not with us but with the Office of Rail Regulation. If Richard Simpson or someone else can show us the legal basis on which we might be able to take action, I will be very interested in hearing what they have to say. However, the power is simply not there.The picture is fragmented. I realise from meetings that I have had with constituents and others that people find that frustrating but the Scottish Government has no legal basis to act on this matter. That power lies with others, and it is up to them to explain what they can do.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I have a couple of questions for the minister. First, is he able to reference for the record the exact part of the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee’s deliberations in which we were told that there would be night running? I cannot recall it.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

If I find the reference, I will be happy to give it to you, but it was in a question-and-answer session between Rob Gibson and Alex Deans, who said that, as has been mentioned before, the intended hours would be 6 am to 11 pm, although they could not rule out night-time running. I will pass that on to the committee.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

It sounds like a throwaway line to me, but, having, like many, sat through countless hours of that committee’s deliberations, I would be really grateful for the reference.Although I hate the expression, we are where we are and we have to try to deal with the problem. Did you say that Clackmannanshire Council is more or less responsible for noise mitigation and for trying to do the best for the people along the line who are affected?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

No. What I—and I believe Mac West—said is that the council has the power to take action over noise abatement, although the legal outcome is uncertain.15:15

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

But is the council responsible, through its environmental health or protection department, for trying to do its best for residents of Clackmannan in terms of noise mitigation? I direct my question to Mr West.

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

In a general sense, yes—that is correct. However, it is very unclear—opaque is the word that seems to be in vogue—whether noise from a railway constitutes a statutory nuisance.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Mr McAulay may be able to help us with that.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

I do not claim to be a legal expert, so please take what I am saying as coming from a layman in that sense. Under the railway regulations, there is an immunity for railways from statutory nuisance, which means that we are exempt from that legislation. However, although the legislation has been there for many years, that has never been tested.We seem to be concentrating on the potential to try to enforce things, but I am concerned that we—the rail industry, Transport Scotland, Clackmannanshire Council and Network Rail—have not got the noise barriers in place yet. We need to get those in place to see whether they make a difference and improve the conditions that many of the residents are experiencing. I appreciate that that will not help Mr Sloper, but it may help other residents along the way. That is the first step that needs to be taken.I have looked very closely at all the results of the noise and vibration monitoring that has been carried out, originally by Falkirk Council, and most recently by Transport Scotland and Clackmannanshire Council as detailed in their report.On vibration, it strikes me that all the readings are below any level that would cause damage to property. We need to consider the issues on factual evidence, and take readings to be able to measure them against things. Measuring noise and vibration is a very complex science, and I do not claim to be an expert on that either. However, the levels that we are finding in monitoring vibration suggest that the vast bulk of the readings are below what human beings would normally be able to pick up. So far, the study has shown that there is an impact on one or two properties that would mean that those residents might notice the vibration but it would not cause damage to property.On the noise issues, we have identified 66 properties that would no doubt benefit from noise barriers. We need to get those barriers in place so that we can find out whether they make a significant difference to those people. Transport Scotland and Clackmannanshire Council are progressing that as quickly as possible. We are happy to help them with access if they need to come into the railway grounds to get the barriers in place. I think that the barriers will help to make a difference—perhaps not for everyone, but they will help.Mrs Massie raised the issue of trees. I am not trying to be cheeky, but I have had some experience of that through the Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill. We had to go through various noise and vibration policies with the parliamentary committee to ensure that what we built would not create nuisance for neighbours. One thing that came across very clearly from the experts was that trees do not provide any noise insulation. I recommend the installation of the close-boarded noise barrier, because I think that it would make a difference.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I think that Mrs Massie wants to respond, and Mr Sloper wants to say something about vibration. I am conscious of time, so we will have a final question to follow and then move on.

Anne Massie
link

I will be very quick. I have stood in my garden and waited for a train to come by. I hear the train coming from beyond my garden, where there is a field with no barriers whatsoever. I do not hear it when it is coming through my garden past the burn until it gets to my bedroom window. I hear it there, and then I do not hear it until it passes my garage. I have a long garden—it is an acre—and I hear it down there. I do not care what science says—the trees baffle the noise.

Colin Sloper
link

Nobody has undertaken vibration studies on my property or any other in my street or, as far as I am aware, on my estate. I would welcome the opportunity for vibration studies to be undertaken at my property, and I am sure that some of my neighbours would welcome that on theirs. I would also welcome the opportunity to understand at what level vibration becomes a nuisance, because I am sure that waking up a one-year-old at 2 or 3 in the morning is not good. If it is found that the vibration level exceeds the legislative standard, if there is such a thing, what will be done? I want an undertaking that something will be done. I am not on the SAK line, but it is unacceptable that I have a one-year-old who cannot sleep at night, a wife who is stressed by the situation and a house that has cracks in a wall. If it falls down, which I seriously hope it does not, who is liable?

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

It falls to me to answer that question, but I do not think that there is an answer that you will find acceptable. The railway has been there for 150 years and the use of the railway is covered by the current legislation. I would hope that the vibration levels are not at any sort of level that would cause any damage to your property. Normally, the local council, which I assume in this case is Stirling Council or Falkirk Council, monitors vibration.

Colin Sloper
link

It is Falkirk Council.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

All I can suggest is that Mr Sloper contacts the council and asks it to carry out monitoring. As to what happens with the results of that, I will not pretend that there is a magic wand to be waved that will address all this, because it is part of the existing operational railway.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Mr McAulay, you said that you were involved in the Airdrie-Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill and that you talked about mitigation measures for some issues that arose in that regard. Mr Butler, were there similar discussions when you were convener of the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Yes. Perhaps this is more for the conclusion of the discussion but, with regard to what Mr McAulay said about dealing with the present situation, a short to medium-term action has to be taken. I am aware that Transport Scotland and Clackmannanshire Council are working together with residents on mitigation and that Network Rail has made an offer through Mr McAulay about access. However, I suggest that through you, convener, we try to ensure that, although it will not be a complete fix, short-term mitigation is undertaken.Is the Scottish Government willing to review the overnight running of freight trains on the SAK line to see whether it is possible to limit that with regard to time or number? Can it be ensured that modern wagons are used that cause minimum noise and vibration? Can it be considered whether it is feasible to reduce the number of wagons? Can the introduction of Sunday daytime running be considered in order to reduce the night-time use of the line? There is a raft of possible long-term measures that I would hope the Government would be interested in looking at, perhaps in conjunction with the Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee, if not in this diet then in the coming one. Consideration should be given to minimising the aggravation to citizens of Scotland that is caused by overnight running on the SAK line. Would the minister be willing to give an undertaking on that?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

I will address first the point that was discussed previously about on-the-record discussions and then come back to your second point. At the meeting of the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee on 27 October 2003, Rob Gibson asked:“Is it true that freight movements often take place during the night rather than when passenger traffic is greatest?”Alex Deans answered:“That might well be the case. Our indication at the moment, however, is that most of the freight movement will take place during the day because the main freight operator, Scottish Power, will need to transport coal to Longannet power station during that facility’s operational hours. However, I do not think that we can guarantee that there will never be any night-time operations.”—Official Report, Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee, 27 October 2003; c 17.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I do not think that we are in disagreement here. The Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee looked at the issue of night-time running and paused for thought. It was told that it would happen on an exceptional basis. We were told 18 times in the impact report that there would not be the volume of night-time running that there obviously has been, so we are not contradicting each other, but what Mr Gibson was told—inadvertently, I am sure—did not give the whole picture, even if he was not misled. He was told that night-time running might happen in exceptional circumstances, but we have been told today that there was no guarantee that it would happen exceptionally. In fact, we have been told, frankly, that night-time running would be the way of it, despite what the bill committee was told 18 times in the impact report.Therefore, minister, you can understand my concern and great aggravation, on the part not simply of members of the committee but of the public who, like members, listened to and took part in the bill process in good faith. I think that we are not in disagreement. As one of the local members, you must be as disappointed as I am. I pose that as a rhetorical question—I am sure that you would say yes. I asked whether you would give an undertaking to go ahead with a review, which could be held by this Government or whichever one succeeds it after the election.

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

A number of the measures that you mentioned, such as those to do with the frequency of trains and the nature of the rolling stock and the sets that are used, have been looked at in depth. You have had answers from people who know far more about such matters than I do. Richard Simpson, I and others, along with some of the petitioners, have been looking into the issue for a number of years. I do not want to hold out any false hope, because that is the basis on which the trains are running. I repeat that the Scottish Government has no power to insist on any of the measures that you mentioned.I understand your question about whether there is scope to do anything else, but I would not say that we are talking about a review. I am fairly new in this post and I will be happy to look at the information that the Government holds on the issue and to see whether it might be possible to bring the parties together to establish whether anything more can be done. We are talking only about practical possibilities, because we do not have the legal power to insist on any of the action that is sought, but discussions could be held.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Following on from that, is the present Scottish Government—I know that you cannot bind a future Government, regardless of its political colour—willing to give an undertaking to work with Westminster colleagues in the present UK Administration on these matters? You made a fair point when you said that a collective response across the Governments in these isles is required. Would you agree to that?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

Yes, there are specific areas on which we must work jointly. I mentioned that the noise regulations have not been brought in in Scotland. I have already asked officials to bring forward proposals so that we can consider how to address that anomaly.There is also the issue of the Office of Rail Regulation and whether responsibility for that should be devolved or reserved. We seem to have a very different picture for trains in Scotland. I will speak to Westminster colleagues about that in due course. I will be happy to pursue those issues.The Office of Rail Regulation has just produced a report on the performance of the rail network, which I will discuss with it, and I will be happy to raise the issue of the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine line.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I know that you cannot say yea or nay on the reserved/devolved issue and neither will I—I will not fall into that elephant trap—but is it fair to say that you are saying to the committee that the present Scottish Government is not averse to working in co-operation with the Westminster Government under the present settlement?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

Those discussions will take place, regardless of what is reserved and what is devolved.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I have a short question for Mac West. Clackmannanshire Council is talking about mitigation measures being put in place along the line where problems have been identified. Who will pay for those measures? Will the local authority take on that onus, or can compensation be sought from Network Rail, say? As I understand it, the construction of the SAK line attracted major public subsidy. It would be interesting to find out who will pay for the mitigation measures that have been necessitated by the overnight running of freight trains along the line.

Mac West Clackmannanshire Council
link

On the SAK line, the vast majority of the funding came from Transport Scotland. It has a budget set aside for those mitigation measures.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

In effect, it is the Scottish Government, through Transport Scotland, that is funding the mitigation measures.

Frances Duffy Transport Scotland
link

Yes.15:30

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

My question is mainly for Neil McDonald of DB Schenker, but I would love to have the view of Ron McAulay of Network Rail on this, too. It came to our attention earlier in our investigation that the noise comes from old-fashioned bogies with old-fashioned braking systems and bogies that cause a lot of vibration. I presume that those bogies could be replaced fairly easily—you would only have to take the train into the depot, lift the wagon off the bogies, wheel the bogies away and wheel new bogies in underneath. It would not cost £100 million to do that to a train set. It has also been suggested that DB Schenker owns some train sets, which it is using elsewhere, that use more advanced technology. What is that technology? Are the bogies that you are using fitted with the most advanced braking systems? Are they designed to reduce vibration levels? Would you be able to find train sets to use up here that are appreciably quieter and cause less vibration? If not, why not?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

I can answer that in a number of ways.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I ask you to answer it in a number of ways as briefly as possible, as we have gone over time.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

Certainly. EWS—now DB Schenker—was formed in 1996 and has spent more than £800 million on renewing rolling stock that was bought from the Government in 1996 when it was almost 40 years old. Those were two-axled vehicles and we replaced them with the most efficient wagon in the marketplace at that time. For our first wagons, we invited over a company from America, Thrall, and it set up a plant in York. We had a contract with it to develop various types of wagon over a three-year period, and the later of those wagons were the heavy-hopper wagons that are associated with the coal movements. We have 1,140 of those.Technology has moved on since then. In 1999, a bogie was introduced into the marketplace that is marketed by one of our sister companies and it got its first set of orders in 2001.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Mr McDonald, I do not mean to be rude, but I am very conscious of the time. Could you supply Mr Harper with a written response to his question?

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

Yes. There is just one final point that I would like to make.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Very quickly, please. If you could submit written evidence bringing us up to date, that would be useful. I am conscious that the minister has to go to another committee and he is with us for consideration of the next petition.

Neil McDonald DB Schenker Rail (UK) Ltd
link

Those wagons replaced wagons that were far noisier. There has always been noise in the rail network but, at that time, those wagons reduced the noise level. As technology has moved on, different types of bogies have been produced, but we have none of them in our coal fleet. We have them on other types of wagons but not in our coal fleet.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have one tiny question. I asked the minister’s predecessor to look at whether the paths over the Forth bridge were still open and whether it would, therefore, be possible at some points during the week to use those paths for the smaller wagons in order to eliminate the overnight running. Is that a possible alternative? I do not know whether an answer has come back on that.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

In addition, is there a possibility of some Sunday running? I recognise the limitations, but could a solution be found through a variety of different means?

Keith Brown SNP Ochil
link

The answer to the first question is no. Those paths on the Forth bridge are not available, as I understand it, although I stand to be corrected. I cannot answer your question on Sunday running.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

It seems to me that it might give DB Schenker the 24/7 running that it wants, and Network Rail is saying that there could be some Sunday availability.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

I could give you a hugely long answer if you really wanted it, but I know that you do not.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

No. You could give us it in writing in that case.

Ron McAulay Network Rail
link

The answer is that it would be extremely difficult to accommodate Sunday running. Trying to find train paths from Hunterston all the way through to Longannet in what is already a congested network where we need to get in to do maintenance work would be very difficult.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

Thank you for your evidence. It is over to the committee now to decide what we do with the petition.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

This has been a fairly detailed evidence session. I do not think that I am going overboard by saying that it has not been entirely satisfactory.Given that we are near the end of the parliamentary session, I suggest that, in the short term, the committee writes formally to Clackmannanshire Council, Transport Scotland and Network Rail to see how they are proceeding with regard to mitigation measures. I am looking for a timetable of co-ordinated co-operation across all the organisations involved to try to get some relief for constituents along the line. I did not get a chance to ask this but, as well as asking formally about mitigation measures, we should ask Clackmannanshire Council whether it would be willing to consider compensation in the worst cases as well as mitigation.I hope that I am not misquoting the minister, but he said that the Government would not be averse to a review of the larger matters that we have been able only to touch on—these are important matters, but they are not easy to deal with—and that such a review would be undertaken by whoever is re-elected in May, in co-operation with the Westminster Government, because there are overlapping reserved and devolved matters involved. I hope that that would be helpful.Finally, I suggest that we consider putting this in a legacy paper for our successor committee. We could say that the successor committee could, if it wished, press the Government at Holyrood for a review and consider referring the petition to the transport committee that will be in place. I am well aware that those suggestions will not meet the aggravation suffered by the petitioners, but they are the only things that I can think of at the moment.As for the historical stuff, I will leave that sticking to the wall. However, I am not the only one; I am sure that every member of the former Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill Committee has been dismayed at what occurred. Anyway, we are where we are.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I am very conscious, and a little surprised, as others will have been, to discover that the Scottish Government really does not have many powers on these things at all. I wonder whether, apart from anything else, we might write to the Westminster Government to ask what it is proposing to do about it. If powers were simply not given as a mistake, presumably somebody somewhere needs to worry about that. I think that I heard the minister say that he simply did not have the powers and it was not obvious that anybody else had them either. We should ask Westminster whether it has considered that and whether it will consider it.

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

I do not know whether there is clarity at this stage about who should have done what and where it should have been done, but we certainly need to get to the bottom of that. It occurs to me that the Stirling-Alloa-Kincardine Railway and Linked Improvements Bill went through on the specific understanding that there would not be night running. It turns out that the reality has been very different and there do not appear to be any powers to deal with that. There is an issue for Parliament here in terms of its passing legislation without any powers to do anything about such things. I wonder whether it is worth writing to the Presiding Officer about that.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

We could do that, but the private bill process has now changed utterly. I am not saying that a terrible beauty is born, but it is certainly a different process.I take Nigel Don’s point. We could productively write to ask the Westminster Government whether it is willing, if approached by the current or a future Scottish Government, to work in co-operation to deal with these matters, which are complicated, as they involve overlapping devolved and reserved responsibilities, but which need to be tackled.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I agree that we should do that. However, before we do, can we write to ask the Scottish Government to share with us the contact that it has had with Westminster over the issue? It is the wrong way around for us to write to Westminster before we know what the Scottish Government has been doing.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Could we write to ask Scottish Power where it is with the renewal of the contract with the Clyde Port Authority for the supply of coal? Has Scottish Power looked at alternative routes for getting the coal into Longannet?

Rhona Brankin Lab The Convener · Midlothian
link

We will have to finish there. This has been a long session. I thank you all for attending and for your help at the committee today.

  1. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 185
  2. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 71
  3. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  4. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 11
  5. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  6. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  8. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. 14:00 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  13. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  14. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  16. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  17. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  18. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  19. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  20. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  21. 14:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.