2. To ask the Scottish Executive how links are being strengthened between Scotland and Malawi. (S3O-12894)
Official Report · Chamber
Malawi
Scottish Executive Question Time Europe, External Affairs and Culture
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Fiona Hyslop SNP 6
- David Stewart Lab 2
- Maureen Watt SNP 1
- Liam McArthur LD 1
- Elaine Smith Lab 1
- Ted Brocklebank Con 1
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 1
The record
13 contributions2. To ask the Scottish Executive how links are being strengthened between Scotland and Malawi. (S3O-12894)
Scotland has a special link with Malawi, which remains central to the Scottish Government’s international development policy. As part of a programme of events in November 2010 to mark the fifth anniversary of the signing of the co-operation agreement between Malawi and Scotland, the Scottish Government held a trade event to promote trade links with Malawi and a networking event for current Scottish Government Malawi grant holders to promote links between projects and the sharing of best practice. We also provide funding for networking organisations such as the Scotland Malawi Partnership, which helps organisations in Scotland to build and strengthen links with their counterparts in Malawi. In February last year, I visited Malawi to see how Scottish Government funding is making an impact. I met ministers and officials from the Government of Malawi during my time there to strengthen the already strong Government-to-Government relations.
Will the minister join me in welcoming to the gallery Constance Kilimo? She is the first parliamentary intern from the National Assembly of Malawi.
The minister will, of course, be aware of the recent very successful and constructive cross-party visit to Malawi. There are challenging issues there, such as the conditions in the women’s prison in Chichiri. Will the minister undertake to discuss with the Scottish Prison Service how to export best practice in areas such as training and prison visiting?
The minister will, of course, be aware of the recent very successful and constructive cross-party visit to Malawi. There are challenging issues there, such as the conditions in the women’s prison in Chichiri. Will the minister undertake to discuss with the Scottish Prison Service how to export best practice in areas such as training and prison visiting?
I am pleased to welcome Constance Kilimo, and I was pleased to take part in activities during the previous Commonwealth Parliamentary Association Scotland branch visit in February last year to build links at the parliamentary level. I am keen to support such links, and I look forward to meeting members of the more recent cross-party delegation to find out lessons.
I reassure David Stewart that one of the strands of our relationship with Malawi is governance issues, and work with the Scottish Prison Service has already taken place. Michael Matheson raised the issue with me previously. As far as I recall, some of the programme funding supports work in prisons. Obviously, we would be interested to hear further about the member’s concerns and whether anything that relates to the on-going programme can be done to help colleagues in Malawi. We recognise that there are big challenges, but we have made progress in some areas. We are already addressing conditions in prisons as part of our support programme.
I reassure David Stewart that one of the strands of our relationship with Malawi is governance issues, and work with the Scottish Prison Service has already taken place. Michael Matheson raised the issue with me previously. As far as I recall, some of the programme funding supports work in prisons. Obviously, we would be interested to hear further about the member’s concerns and whether anything that relates to the on-going programme can be done to help colleagues in Malawi. We recognise that there are big challenges, but we have made progress in some areas. We are already addressing conditions in prisons as part of our support programme.
Presiding Officer, as you know, I was part of the delegation that returned from Malawi this week. I was privileged to be part of that delegation. Mrs Constance Kilimo, who is in the gallery, travelled back with us. She is on a pilot programme in which she will receive direct support and training in priority areas that will best aid the running of the National Assembly of Malawi. She is a special assistant to the clerk of the National Assembly of Malawi. Does the Scottish Government have any similar schemes for Government officials from Malawi? If not, will the minister consider such schemes in the future?
It is clear that there are frequent meetings that relate to the oversight of the agreement and frequent exchanges, and there is a lot of co-operation between policy officials in the Scottish Government and the Malawi Government. We think that the relationship between CPA Scotland and the National Assembly of Malawi is a strong way of building on the Government’s strands; indeed, I have discussed that with colleagues previously. We as a Government are keen to help to promote funding from different sources for that agreement.
If the Malawi Government makes requests for more exchanges on a more permanent basis, we will be happy to entertain them, but it is important that we recognise that our co-operation agreement with the Malawi Government is based on there being an equal relationship and that we would not want to impose exchanges that it did not request.
If the Malawi Government makes requests for more exchanges on a more permanent basis, we will be happy to entertain them, but it is important that we recognise that our co-operation agreement with the Malawi Government is based on there being an equal relationship and that we would not want to impose exchanges that it did not request.
link
Like Maureen Watt, I welcome Constance Kilimo to the gallery. I thank her and all those who hosted the delegation to Malawi last week. The visit was memorable.
The minister laid particular emphasis on the importance of Government-to-Government and Parliament-to-Assembly relationships, but does she agree that many of the relationships between community groups, school groups and others in Scotland and counterparts in Malawi predate the co-operation agreement? For example, there are links between the presbytery in Thyolo and the presbytery in my constituency and between the St Magnus festival and Limbe choir in the south of Malawi. What efforts is the Government making to support those links in a way that makes people feel that they are part of a wider effort in deepening and broadening the ties between our countries?
The minister laid particular emphasis on the importance of Government-to-Government and Parliament-to-Assembly relationships, but does she agree that many of the relationships between community groups, school groups and others in Scotland and counterparts in Malawi predate the co-operation agreement? For example, there are links between the presbytery in Thyolo and the presbytery in my constituency and between the St Magnus festival and Limbe choir in the south of Malawi. What efforts is the Government making to support those links in a way that makes people feel that they are part of a wider effort in deepening and broadening the ties between our countries?
Liam McArthur is right to focus on our people-to-people links and strengths. When I talk to other Governments and when I have discussions in the European Union, people are struck by the strength of the people-to-people and community-to-community relationships, which must be recognised and supported and which go back decades, if not longer. Even now, we probably underestimate the number of school-to-school and church-to-church relationships.
We support the Scotland Malawi Partnership and we encourage people who have relationships with Malawi to be part of that organisation, which provides the opportunity for voluntary organisations to network and share their experience and practice. That is one way in which we support the people-to-people link with Malawi.
We support the Scotland Malawi Partnership and we encourage people who have relationships with Malawi to be part of that organisation, which provides the opportunity for voluntary organisations to network and share their experience and practice. That is one way in which we support the people-to-people link with Malawi.
The initiative between North Lanarkshire Council and Shire Highlands education division in Malawi is the only local authority partnership to be recognised by the Department for International Development and the British Council. It involves a large cluster of school partnerships that are focused around Coatbridge and Chryston. What practical and immediate financial support can be offered to help to build capacity for that beneficial and sustainable initiative?
North Lanarkshire Council has developed that partnership itself and is to be commended for it. Much of our support for the Network of International Development Organisations in Scotland and for non-governmental organisations that work in the area relates to capacity building and learning lessons from elsewhere, as Elaine Smith knows. Many of the positive links concern teacher training and have been beneficial both ways.
The Government can support several avenues. There is a bidding round. In 2010-11, £5 million of Scottish Government funding—way above the baseline funding of £3 million to which we are committed—was spent on supporting initiatives in Malawi.
It is important that we hear about and support good initiatives. Many of them are conducted on a tendering basis. We would need to think carefully about what North Lanarkshire Council was doing and to avoid displacing what is obviously a good scheme.
The Government can support several avenues. There is a bidding round. In 2010-11, £5 million of Scottish Government funding—way above the baseline funding of £3 million to which we are committed—was spent on supporting initiatives in Malawi.
It is important that we hear about and support good initiatives. Many of them are conducted on a tendering basis. We would need to think carefully about what North Lanarkshire Council was doing and to avoid displacing what is obviously a good scheme.
As another of the members who have recently returned from Malawi, I commend to the minister the twinning arrangements that are being trialled with 10 MPs from Malawi. I was fortunate to have a valuable meeting with my partner, John Hiwa, who is the member for Ntcheu West; other MSPs met their partners. Does the minister agree that extending that twinning scheme would only strengthen local links with Malawi and contribute to increased mutual benefits for both countries in the partnership?
On my visit to Malawi in February last year, I was pleased to meet some MPs who planned to be part of the twinning arrangement. It is important that the twinning arrangement succeeds. I know that demand for it exists. One member of the Malawi Parliament—an energising woman from Chiradzulu—was keen to join when I visited, but the initial capacity of 10 had been reached.
I am pleased that Ted Brocklebank has promoted the scheme, which he should talk about with his colleagues. I am interested to hear about members’ recent visit, as I suspect are other members. I encourage the cross-party delegation to invite members to a meeting to hear about the visit and to encourage those who are elected in May to engage in the twinning arrangement.
I am pleased that Ted Brocklebank has promoted the scheme, which he should talk about with his colleagues. I am interested to hear about members’ recent visit, as I suspect are other members. I encourage the cross-party delegation to invite members to a meeting to hear about the visit and to encourage those who are elected in May to engage in the twinning arrangement.
Questions 3 and 4 were not lodged and question 5 was withdrawn.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2011 →- Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 53
- Multiple Sclerosis Specialist Nurses Questions · 4
- Broadband (Speed Target) Questions · 4
- Road Maintenance (Liquid De-icer) Questions · 5
- M8 Questions · 8
- Rural Abattoirs Questions · 8
- Cowal Hospice Questions · 6
- A80 Questions · 9
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- New National Examinations First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Glasgow Sheriff Court (One-stop Shop) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Pupil Support Assistants Questions · 4
- Further Education Questions · 6
- Further and Higher Education (Courses) Questions · 6
- School Estate (Glasgow) Questions · 5
- Education (Capital Expenditure) Questions · 6
- Budget for Bursaries Campaign Questions · 6
- Further Education (Student Numbers) Questions · 7
- Les Compagnons du Devoir Questions · 4
- Antonine Wall Questions · 8
- Malawi Questions · 13
- Celtic Connections Questions · 11
- Fair Trade (Purchasing) Questions · 6
- China Plan Questions · 4
- Certification of Death (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 32
- Certification of Death (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
- Further Education Colleges Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.