1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2873)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2873)
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
As of Tuesday, 6,000 convicted criminals a year will escape jail because the First Minister pushed through legislation against short prison sentences. Kenny MacAskill has said that it is fine, because those convicted criminals are just “daft laddies”. Does the First Minister agree?
First, let us have a look at the phrase “pushed through”. This is a minority Government, which—as Iain Gray knows—has to appeal for support to gain a majority, particularly in legislative terms. The reason why the criminal justice system has been changed in Scotland is because a majority in this Parliament believed that that was the right direction to take.
At various times, Iain Gray says to us that we must follow the will of the Parliament, but what he means is that we must follow the will of the Parliament when it is convenient for him. Changes to other aspects of the justice system have, of course, been carried through by this Administration. The delivery of 1,000 extra police officers on the streets of the communities of Scotland was carried through with support from the Conservative party.
The significant point about the penal changes that have resulted in the lowest level of crime in Scotland for 30 years—whether it be the move to comprehensive and strong community sentences or the 1,000 extra officers on the streets of Scotland—is that none of the changes has been supported by the Labour Party.
At various times, Iain Gray says to us that we must follow the will of the Parliament, but what he means is that we must follow the will of the Parliament when it is convenient for him. Changes to other aspects of the justice system have, of course, been carried through by this Administration. The delivery of 1,000 extra police officers on the streets of the communities of Scotland was carried through with support from the Conservative party.
The significant point about the penal changes that have resulted in the lowest level of crime in Scotland for 30 years—whether it be the move to comprehensive and strong community sentences or the 1,000 extra officers on the streets of Scotland—is that none of the changes has been supported by the Labour Party.
It is all very well having 1,000 additional police officers, but when they arrest criminals, what happens to those criminals matters. Last year, 736 of those 6,000 “daft laddies” were violent offenders, 148 were knife criminals and 17 were sex offenders. This year they will not go to jail at all; they will do community service. We read this morning that they might get “30 days’ hard knitting”. Can the First Minister tell me how many criminals who are given those arduous sentences ever even complete them?
It is not, as Iain Gray puts it, “all very well” that there are 1,000 extra police officers on the streets of Scotland; it is all very important that these officers are protecting people across the country. Not a single one of those officers would have been employed if we had listened to the Labour Party. It is also not the case that a 30-year low in recorded crime is merely incidental. For the first time in recorded crime statistics, the fear of crime is dropping across Scottish communities. My belief is that that is because of the additional officers that have been delivered by this Administration, not one of whom was supported by the Labour Party.
On the presumption against sentences of three months or less, that policy has gained the support not only of parties across this Parliament: we also see when we look down south to England that—if my memory serves me right—the new leader of the Labour Party said at, or around the time of, his party conference that when Ken Clarke brings forward proposals to avoid short sentences, the Labour Party should not show knee-jerk opposition. If Ed Miliband is not showing knee-jerk opposition to penal reform in the Westminster Parliament, why is it that all that Iain Gray has to offer week after week in this Parliament is knee-jerk opposition?
On the presumption against sentences of three months or less, that policy has gained the support not only of parties across this Parliament: we also see when we look down south to England that—if my memory serves me right—the new leader of the Labour Party said at, or around the time of, his party conference that when Ken Clarke brings forward proposals to avoid short sentences, the Labour Party should not show knee-jerk opposition. If Ed Miliband is not showing knee-jerk opposition to penal reform in the Westminster Parliament, why is it that all that Iain Gray has to offer week after week in this Parliament is knee-jerk opposition?
What is important is that the justice system backs those police officers and backs the public. Even those who agree with the First Minister with regard to short sentences—I do not—would tell him that the policy will work only if the community justice system is working, too. The fact is that 40 per cent of those who are sentenced to community service do not finish their sentences. In some parts of Scotland, the figure is as high as two thirds. The community sentence system is not working, but the First Minister is cramming thousands more offenders into it. Everyone knows that many will get off scot free. That is why the First Minister is seen by so many as “Soft-touch Salmond”.
Does the First Minister know how many times, under his Government, someone has to be convicted before they actually go to jail?
Does the First Minister know how many times, under his Government, someone has to be convicted before they actually go to jail?
I point out to Iain Gray that he cannot just sweep away the fact that he believes that the 1,000 extra officers are not being backed up in the judicial system, for two reasons. One is that if it had been up to the Labour Party they would not have existed at all—they would not have been there to be backed up by the judicial system. Secondly, as we saw in the Public Petitions Committee’s debate on knife crime, and in other evidence that has been submitted to that committee, that police officers such as John Carnochan—who said, “I’ve been a cop for 34 years”—support the direction of travel of this Parliament and this Government with regard to the judicial system.
We should judge these matters by results, and we have the ability to do so. The approach of this Government to crime and punishment in Scotland has delivered a 30-year low in recorded crime and 1,000 extra officers in the streets and communities of Scotland. It also recognises the futility of short sentences, after which the vast majority of offenders reoffend, and it recognises the hope that is represented by community justice, after which the majority of offenders do not reoffend.
The Labour Party’s position is ridiculous and impossible and does not serve the people of Scotland.
We should judge these matters by results, and we have the ability to do so. The approach of this Government to crime and punishment in Scotland has delivered a 30-year low in recorded crime and 1,000 extra officers in the streets and communities of Scotland. It also recognises the futility of short sentences, after which the vast majority of offenders reoffend, and it recognises the hope that is represented by community justice, after which the majority of offenders do not reoffend.
The Labour Party’s position is ridiculous and impossible and does not serve the people of Scotland.
As ever, the First Minister has no answer to any of the questions. I have freedom of information figures that show that some first-time prisoners had 40 previous convictions. They had not not reoffended; they had reoffended 40 times before they went to jail. Hundreds of them had 10, 20 or 30 previous convictions before they ever faced jail. They do not go to jail, and some of them do not even turn up for community service, and all of that happened before the Scottish Government abolished thousands of short sentences. It is not right.
Does the First Minister understand that it is the law-abiding public who are being treated like “daft laddies” by him?
Does the First Minister understand that it is the law-abiding public who are being treated like “daft laddies” by him?
I believe that
“The Commission recommends that, if the Act”—
that is, the Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Act 2007—
“is to be implemented, its implementation must follow the implementation of this Commission's other recommendations and the achievement of a reduction in the short sentence prison population”.
That, of course, is a quotation from the report of Henry McLeish, the former Labour First Minister of Scotland.
We should compare the position of Henry McLeish—a former First Minister, who experienced these matters in office, saw the futility of short sentences and made a recommendation that was backed by a majority of this Parliament—with the position of Iain Gray, who has nothing constructive to offer and is left flailing about in the face of the fact of there being 1,000 extra police officers on the streets of Scotland who are delivering a 30-year low in reported crime, and of the progressive reform of the criminal justice system of Scotland is making this country a safer place, under this Government.
“The Commission recommends that, if the Act”—
that is, the Custodial Sentences and Weapons (Scotland) Act 2007—
“is to be implemented, its implementation must follow the implementation of this Commission's other recommendations and the achievement of a reduction in the short sentence prison population”.
That, of course, is a quotation from the report of Henry McLeish, the former Labour First Minister of Scotland.
We should compare the position of Henry McLeish—a former First Minister, who experienced these matters in office, saw the futility of short sentences and made a recommendation that was backed by a majority of this Parliament—with the position of Iain Gray, who has nothing constructive to offer and is left flailing about in the face of the fact of there being 1,000 extra police officers on the streets of Scotland who are delivering a 30-year low in reported crime, and of the progressive reform of the criminal justice system of Scotland is making this country a safer place, under this Government.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2011 →- Double Jeopardy (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 53
- Multiple Sclerosis Specialist Nurses Questions · 4
- Broadband (Speed Target) Questions · 4
- Road Maintenance (Liquid De-icer) Questions · 5
- M8 Questions · 8
- Rural Abattoirs Questions · 8
- Cowal Hospice Questions · 6
- A80 Questions · 9
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- New National Examinations First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Glasgow Sheriff Court (One-stop Shop) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Pupil Support Assistants Questions · 4
- Further Education Questions · 6
- Further and Higher Education (Courses) Questions · 6
- School Estate (Glasgow) Questions · 5
- Education (Capital Expenditure) Questions · 6
- Budget for Bursaries Campaign Questions · 6
- Further Education (Student Numbers) Questions · 7
- Les Compagnons du Devoir Questions · 4
- Antonine Wall Questions · 8
- Malawi Questions · 13
- Celtic Connections Questions · 11
- Fair Trade (Purchasing) Questions · 6
- China Plan Questions · 4
- Certification of Death (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 32
- Certification of Death (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
- Further Education Colleges Members’ business · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.