Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Financial overview of the NHS in Scotland 2009/10”

Wednesday 22 December 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 29 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

29 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 4 is consideration of a section 23 report entitled “Financial overview of the NHS in Scotland 2009/10”. I invite the Auditor General to brief the committee.

Mr Black
link

Thank you, convener. As the committee well knows, each year, with Audit Scotland's help, I bring to Parliament a report on the financial performance of the national health service in Scotland and, every second year, there is a report not only on NHS finances but on performance in the round. This report, which came out last week, looks only at the NHS’s financial performance.The commentary is drawn mainly from the reports by auditors on each of the 14 health boards, the nine special boards and the Scottish Government health directorates. However, it also draws on the performance reports that we have produced over the year and a variety of other sources.The report is in two parts: the first comments on the financial health of the NHS in Scotland in 2009-10 and the second summarises the challenges for the future, many of which will be very familiar to the committee. With regard to financial health, in 2009-10 the NHS in Scotland spent £10.8 billion and ended the financial year with a £43 million underspend against its budget, £42 million of which was a revenue underspend and £1 million a capital underspend. That revenue underspend is 0.4 per cent of the overall budget of the NHS in Scotland.For the second year running, all NHS bodies met their financial targets. One really important sign of good financial health in an NHS body is its ability to meet its recurrent or day-to-day expenditure from its recurrent income within the financial year in question. I am pleased to be able to report to the committee that, this year, NHS bodies have been less reliant than in previous years on non-recurring funding to meet their financial targets or to support their financial position.The NHS continues to report good progress against the efficiency programme. Once again I stress to members that we do not audit the numbers that have been reported, but the report itself mentions that in 2009-10 NHS bodies reported cost savings exceeding £202 million, including £166 million of recurring savings and £36 million of non-recurring savings. Clearly, severe financial pressures lie ahead and NHS bodies fully recognise that they will have to deliver further financial savings at a higher rate if they are to continue to deliver their services within budget. They forecast that in 2010-11 they will need to achieve £274 million of savings, which is a substantial 36 per cent more than the savings that were delivered in 2009-10.The committee well knows that over recent years there has been substantial capital investment in the NHS. Back in 2003-04, capital spend was about £120 million; by 2009-10, that figure had risen to £772 million. That level of capital investment is unlikely to be repeated in future years—at least in the short to medium term—and although the impact of that will vary across NHS bodies, it will certainly have an effect on the planned capital programme. Exhibit 7 on page 11 lists 12 major projects that each have a value in excess of £50 million and a total estimated value of up to £2.6 billion.That leads me quite naturally to the challenges for the future, which is covered in the second part of the report. It might be useful for the committee to look at exhibit 8 on page 13, in which we attempt to summarise the main financial pressures that face the health service in the years ahead, and which will become more significant with the constraints on public spending. The committee and I have considered these matters in the past, not least in last year’s report “Scotland’s public finances: Preparing for the future”, but I should remind members of some of the main pressures.First, the growing population of older people is putting real pressure not only on health budgets but on social care budgets. I need not go into what those pressures are, but the report gives examples of them on pages 13 and 14. Expenditure on drugs, of course, is forecast to increase above inflationary levels. Staffing is the biggest cost associated with delivering health services and there has been a substantial rise in the pay bill, which has absorbed much of the increase in funding of the NHS over the past few years. Containing pay costs will be a major challenge for the future.We mention other factors in the report, such as the VAT increases, the cost of financing private finance initiative deals, meeting the commitments to national targets and services and delivering a number of services free at the point of delivery.Given the constrained budgets that are ahead, it will be challenging for the NHS to maintain service levels and quality standards, because costs tend to go up faster than general inflation. The NHS in Scotland is aware of those challenges and is taking a number of actions to prepare for them—which are mentioned in the report—such as the health care quality strategy that came in in May 2010, the plans to generate more efficiency savings and so on. To ensure that that happens, it is clearly going to be absolutely essential that the NHS has good management arrangements and good information systems in place to support those changes.I make no apology for mentioning again the importance of getting better information to allow a more comprehensive assessment of quality and cost effectiveness of NHS services, which is a recurring theme in past reports.I make the obvious point that the NHS does not operate in a vacuum. A lot of the services that really matter for ordinary people are delivered through partnership working, particularly with local government. As budgets become tighter, I think that a strain will be put on some of the partnership arrangements that are in place. The public sector bodies need to work together to ensure that they are clear about the priorities of partnership working and that they are adding value through those arrangements.Changes to how health services are delivered will clearly be contentious. Therefore, there is a need for individual NHS bodies, with their partners, to communicate well with the public to make them aware of the financial challenges and the impact on service delivery.The last financial year was a year of good performance in financial terms for the NHS, but there are significant challenges ahead. As we attempt to outline in the report, the NHS is working hard to deal with some of these unprecedented financial challenges.My colleagues and I will do our best to answer questions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Thank you very much for that, Mr Black.I want to clarify something. You referred to exhibit 8 on page 13 of the report, which shows budget pressures and a list of factors that eased budget pressures, one of which was increased funding from the Scottish Government. I refer you to appendix 1 and 2 on page 20 and 21 of the report. If you look at the revenue resource limit for all NHS bodies in 2009-10 and compare it to the forecast financial performance in 2010-11 you see that the opening revenue resource limit seems to be just over £1 billion less. Is that correct?

Bob Leishman Audit Scotland
link

The opening revenue resource limit is an indicative level. It changes through the year, so you cannot compare the final figure for one year with the indicative figure—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

No, but it gives us an idea that the starting point is just over £1 billion less than it was this year.

Bob Leishman Audit Scotland
link

The expectation is that the resource limits will increase over the year.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That might be the expectation, but in budgeting terms, we are being told that the opening gambit is a budget that is more than £1 billion less than it was last year.

Bob Leishman Audit Scotland
link

If you look at previous reports, the same trend would be—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We are not living in usual times and there is no guarantee that the kind of increases that came through previously would continue across all departmental budgets. Is that correct?

Bob Leishman Audit Scotland
link

Those are decisions that the Government will have to take over the course of the year for the whole of the health budget.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

As things stand just now, what is being planned is a budget that is more than £1 billion less than it was.

Mr Black
link

That might not be absolutely the correct interpretation. As Bob Leishman said, during the year, extra resources become available. During the year, the efficiency programme will be kicking in to deliver savings. We are not really in a position today to give you an indication about what the outturn will be for 2010-11, but the indications are that the health boards will be coming in on balance. However, what the actual level of spend will be we cannot say in December; there is some way to run until the end of March.Another point that is possibly worth making is that, according to the recent budget announcement by the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth, the rate of increase will slow down, but it is my understanding from the published information that the plan for next year is a total budget of £11.4 billion, which will be 1.6 per cent higher than that for the current year.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay—that is fine. Do members have questions or comments?

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

One of the themes in the report is the need for better financial information on cost, activity and quality. Paragraph 54 and onwards on page 17 of the report expands on that basic principle. It seems that we are very good at measuring inputs in the health service, such as the money that is spent and the number of staff who are employed, and that we are quite good at measuring outputs, such as whether we meet targets for waiting times, but we are not very good at all at measuring outcomes—in other words, whether people are actually healthier.I thought that it was interesting that the Audit Scotland report made reference to the Nuffield Trust report, the centre for Public Policy for Regions report and the Parliament’s Health and Sport Committee report, all of which have come out within the past year and have developed the themes of how we are doing relative to performance elsewhere and whether we are getting good value for money. Can you say more about what has been done to benchmark us against other countries or other health service performances and how we are going to get a better picture of the value-for-money element?

Mr Black
link

It has always been problematic to compare the performance of the NHS in Scotland with that of the rest of the United Kingdom because data are captured on a different basis and the systems of delivery are different. As I am sure members of the committee will be aware, there is, if anything, a greater divergence in how the health care systems are operated between, say, England and Scotland than there was in the past. This has, quite frankly, been one of the most complex, difficult and challenging areas of public policy in the UK for many years. It is interesting that expert bodies such as CPPR find it quite difficult to do such comparisons. Very occasionally in our studies we manage to get data that we can use to make comparisons, but we have found it challenging to compare the overall performance of the different systems. That is just the reality of the situation in which we find ourselves.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Is there likely to be any move to a more outcomes-based system of reporting?

Mr Black
link

In the past, I have commented in the committee and elsewhere that the Scotland performs framework provides a good understanding of what the Scottish Government is attempting to achieve. We also have nesting within that the health improvement, efficiency, access and treatment targets that the health directorates publish. There is evidence of improvement on many of those, but it is not yet possible to link those outcomes to the activities and to the cost of activities so that we can get the total narrative about how efficient and effective the health service is.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

In your reply to Murdo Fraser you said that it is difficult to make comparisons because the delivery systems in Scotland are different from those elsewhere in the United Kingdom. Are we able to say with certainty that we can make a valid comparison of expenditure per head of population?

Mr Black
link

The short answer to that is no. We cannot say that with absolute certainty. Exhibit 11 on page 17 of the report simply charts expenditure on health per head of the population, comparing Scotland with Northern Ireland, Wales and England over the past few years.12:15

There are several reasons for differences. They include factors such as population sparsity, deprivation in different parts of the United Kingdom and basic accounting issues such as the differential between use of private medicine in Scotland and England in the health service. Issues that relate to productivity and efficiency might well be involved.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I am astonished by the plethora of special boards. I do not understand why we need the National Waiting Times Centre Board, NHS 24, NHS Education for Scotland, NHS Health Scotland, NHS National Services Scotland and NHS Quality Improvement Scotland, although I understand the need for the State Hospitals Board for Scotland, the Scottish Ambulance Service Board and the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland, which are separate. Do all those boards have their own finance departments and human resources departments and the whole back-office infrastructure?

Mr Black
link

I cannot give a clear and well-informed answer about the arrangements in each body. In general, the boards are free-standing. Of course, some provide services to the rest of the NHS in Scotland—in many respects, they are shared-services organisations. I refer you to the report, “The role of boards”, which I presented to the committee some weeks ago.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

The special boards have different board members. I presume that they could all work together as one board and have joint services. Altogether, the special boards cost £1.2 billion, which is more than 3 per cent of the Scottish Government’s budget. That is a huge amount.

Mr Black
link

I am sure that you understand that such questions and concerns would be best addressed to the Scottish Government. How the boards are set up is a policy matter.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

If we forget about the special boards, there is talk about having one NHS delivery board for Scotland, which would be regressive. Without creating such a board, I presume that savings could be made by amalgamating the special boards.

Mr Black
link

A body such as NHS National Services Scotland provides a wide range of services to the whole NHS. Having that body to do procurement and so on at the national level has certainly produced significant efficiency gains.

Mr Black
link

The Scottish Government would answer that question best.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

The report is really good. As usual, it comes with the Auditor General’s health warning for the future, which is to be expected and is appreciated. To clarify remarks that have been made, I say that the health budget will increase—not reduce—by £191 million next year.I was particularly pleased to read the Auditor General’s comment about recurring savings of about £166 million per year, throughout the NHS. I understand that such money is reinvested in care services, so that is welcome.Our friends in the Western Isles—convener, I think that we dealt with the Western Isles inquiry before your convenership—also appear to be identifying substantial possible recurring savings of about £1 million a year, which is welcome. At this stage in the committee’s life, it is good to look back and to welcome such progress by Western Isles NHS Board, on which it is to be congratulated.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That point is well made. We produced a controversial report on Western Isles NHS Board, which was clearly a dysfunctional organisation—at one point, it had three chief executives—so progress is welcome. From its investigation, the committee understood that there was a commitment to improving matters, so I am glad that that has worked.I thank the Auditor General for his report.12:20 Meeting continued in private until 12:45.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 344
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 1
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.