Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“National concessionary travel”

Wednesday 22 December 2010 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 344 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

344 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Item 2 is the section 23 report on national concessionary travel. We have with us today George Mair, who is the director of the Confederation of Passenger Transport UK—Scotland, and Paul White, who is the public affairs executive of the Confederation of Passenger Transport UK—Scotland. Welcome to the committee and thank you for coming to the Parliament in such inclement weather. Before we come to our questioning, would you like to make an opening statement?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

No. We are delighted to be here this morning. We are more than happy to try to answer the questions that you and the committee may have, convener.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

By bus.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We got the service 35 bus.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Were you on the same one as me? I came on the 35 as well.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

More than one person uses the 35 bus, George.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

You are used to carriages, being a lord, George.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. How has the national concessionary travel scheme affected not only the bus companies but services across Scotland? What impact has it had?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

When you look back, you see that we were pushing back frontiers in setting up the scheme. The industry worked with the Scottish Executive and then with the Scottish Government. By reducing 16 schemes to one, we reduced the administrative burden across Scotland, achieved significant savings and lightened the workload for the industry. Instead of multiple claims having to be submitted, one claim now goes to the centre. We pushed back the frontiers of technology with the introduction of ticket machines that were smart card enabled and to an industry standard. We have allowed people to make additional journeys in their local areas as well as cross-Scotland journeys. In looking back, you always see things that you could have done better. However, the scheme has been a huge success. In the early days, additional services were put on, frequencies were increased and vehicle capacity was increased. All in all, the campaign has been pretty positive and successful.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

You made a point about a reduction in administration costs. How significant was that change? Why did moving to one national scheme from the individual schemes make such a difference?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

When we had 16 individual schemes, each local authority had a concessionary travel team. I assume that a big part of the savings came from the fact that local authorities do not need such teams now. We have a centralised team that deals with all the claims from operators throughout Scotland.Now that we are 100 per cent live with the ticket machines, further efficiencies might be gained in the future. I have in mind a figure of £4 million to £5 million of savings per annum, which could increase each year. The saving to the public purse is significant.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

What is the split between local journeys and journeys on what might be described as national routes?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

That question is difficult for me to answer. Transport Scotland might have more information on that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Do you know anything about the popularity of journeys on national routes?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Entitled card-holders in Scotland have two main benefits over those who use schemes elsewhere in the United Kingdom: peak-time travel and cross-boundary travel. When we meet groups who are entitled through disability or age to use the scheme, the general message from them is that they enjoy a benefit. They can travel further afield to meet family members, which they perhaps could not do before.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I will ask about the increase in the cost of the adult single fare. The report points out that such fares“increased by 25 per cent between 2006/07 and 2009/10 while, over the same period, general inflation increased by”only 7 per cent. Does that suggest profiteering by your member companies?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I would not say that at all. It is a recognised fact that industry costs have risen at a higher rate than general inflation. That was recognised in the work that Transport Scotland commissioned from Halcrow. Industry costs in Scotland have risen more than those in other parts of the UK, but costs have risen throughout the UK. In no way do I see profiteering; the situation reflects the cost increases that we have faced.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Given that you receive 67 per cent of the money back from the Government, do you have any incentive to keep fares down?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

The Government’s position is that if operators put up costs, they cheat themselves. As the budget is capped, the budget will run out of money all the more quickly if fares are increased by more than the rate that is needed to keep a business viable. I see no benefit to operators in jacking up fares higher than they need to be. Doing so would have an impact through early application of the cap on the budget and would harm operators commercially.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The Government reduced the reimbursement rate from April from 73.6 per cent to 67 per cent of the adult single fare. When that happened, your organisation said that some services might have to be cut as a result. The reduced rate has now been in place for more than half a year. Are you aware of services having been cut as a result?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I will rewind first to the belief that, with the 67 per cent reimbursement rate, the industry is better off now than it was before. If you are going to make such comparisons, you have to look back at the previous schemes, when operators had a revenue stream from concessionary travel that included, in most cases, a fare that was paid on the bus. In Edinburgh, it was a flat fare of 30p; in Aberdeen it was a quarter of the adult fare. A reimbursement was then paid by the local authority. In many locations, the operators were paid additional costs by local authorities; the operators would submit a claim that indicated that additional resource had been put in and the local authorities would then agree to pay that. If you are looking back, please make sure that you make a real comparison and do not just look selectively at the reimbursement. The 67p in the pound that the operators now get covers the additional cost and the journey reimbursement and it has replaced the fare that the operators used to be paid in locations where fares were charged.Could you repeat your question?

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The Audit Scotland report said that when the Scottish Government said that there would be a reduction in the rate from 73.6 to 67 per cent, your organisation warned that that might mean that services would be cut. Now that it is more than six months after that reduction, is there any evidence that that has happened?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

It is fair to say that there has been a reduction in mileage. We are doing some work with Transport Scotland to look at the cut for this year and to look into next year and beyond. There has been a reduction in mileage and there might also have been an increase in fares as businesses adapt to the lower reimbursement rate that is being paid.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

But you cannot give us any evidence that services have been cut.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I can say only that there has been a reduction in mileage, which indicates that there has been some reduction in service.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Does that suggest that many services depend on the income from the national concessionary travel scheme rather than being able to generate sufficient income from other passengers?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

One of the key things in people’s minds when the scheme was being set up was whether there would be an opportunity to start new services and/or retain some existing services. Over the years, it is inevitable that some services have been kept going because of the 73.6 per cent reimbursement rate that was previously paid. With the reduction to 67 per cent, there is a danger that some routes are not viable and have to be looked at.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That suggests that those who will suffer most from the withdrawal of those services will be people who are entitled to the concessionary travel scheme.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

By implication, if they have been helping to support services that might otherwise struggle, that is right.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I want to pick up on the question that Murdo Fraser asked about the increase in costs compared to the number of journeys. I do not know whether you have the Audit Scotland report in front of you, but exhibit 6 on page 16 shows that, since 2005, the cost of concessionary bus travel has risen by 53 per cent, from £130 million to £199 million, but the number of bus journeys has risen by only 3 per cent. I think that I picked you up correctly, but are you saying that that difference is entirely attributable to rising costs within the industry?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

You are talking about exhibit 6.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Aye. That is a huge jump in the cost of the scheme when the number of passenger journeys has stayed pretty flat over that period of time. In your answer to Murdo Fraser, you said that that rise was attributable to rising costs in the industry. Is that huge jump entirely attributable to that?09:45

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Are the costs shown the full costs of operating the scheme or the reimbursement to operators?

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Do you have the exhibit in front of you?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Yes.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

The Auditor General states:“the cost of concessionary bus travel increased by 53 per cent, from £130 million to £199 million”.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

That is total costs. The substantial part of that will be concessionary reimbursement which, over the period, goes from £154 million to £187 million. There is an element of that additional cost—£12 million or so in the final year—that must be related to back-office and administrative costs and the youth concession scheme, rather than the underlying concessionary reimbursement to operators.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

It is a hell of a difference. I do not know whether you are looking at the graph but, in the two years prior to the NCT scheme, it was pretty steady—the costs pretty much followed passenger journey numbers.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

That would be 2008-09.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

This significant jump occurred after the NCT scheme was introduced.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I would love to be able to give you the answer to that. What I can say is that we have looked at the position across the UK. In that year, for whatever reason, there was a huge spike in operator costs in England, Scotland and Wales. That would lead me to believe that something throughout the country impacted hugely on the industry. My gut feeling—it is only a gut feeling—is that it is related to fuel price.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Would you be able to evidence any of that if the committee were minded to look further at the reasons behind it? I appreciate and accept what you are saying, but is there any evidence to support it or to give some justification for the differential from 2005 to the present day?

Paul White Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

The CPT produces six-monthly cost indices that look at costs to the industry across the UK, so we could provide you with those dating back to the start of the scheme.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I want to stick with this issue for a moment. It may be that your gut instinct is right and that there was an increase in fuel costs. However, you also said earlier that there were significantly higher increases in operating costs in Scotland compared to the rest of the United Kingdom. What were the specific reasons for the costs in Scotland rising so much higher?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We can demonstrate that through the indicators that Paul White mentioned. In addition, the consultants that undertook work for Transport Scotland recognised that costs had been rising higher in Scotland than in other parts of the UK.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

There are a number of factors. First, the ending of the link to the bus service operators grant meant that, when fuel prices went up, operators were worse off in Scotland than in other parts of the country. The 41.21p that operators in Scotland get is less than our counterparts in England get. That is one issue. Wage and fuel costs will play a big part in that, too.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Forgive me, because I am not entirely familiar with this, but I understand that there is a subsidy, or a payment to the industry. However, in Scotland, we received the money but chose not to use it in that way. You are suggesting that that might have—

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

It is one element that has had an impact on operator costs in Scotland. We can come back with further information but, when the link with BSOG was broken in Scotland, it cost operators something like £2 million. That is compounded year on year.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

But some of that is then recovered through the concessionary travel scheme. Although it has been lost on one hand, it has been recovered elsewhere. Potentially, it then inflates the cost of the concessionary travel scheme.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Yes, but the impact on the Scottish Government is that it has a capped figure and it does not cost it any more money.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Is the rule on the percentage of the adult single fare for each journey made invariable? Is it always the case?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

There were varying rates of reimbursement in Scotland under the previous arrangement. Some rates were higher than the 73.6 per cent rate that was agreed as part of the national scheme; some were lower. The Halcrow report, which Transport Scotland commissioned, looked at the area and concluded that, if we were looking for a mid-range, acceptable level, 73.6 per cent was not too bad.Operators recognised the many benefits that would come from having a single scheme that was managed by a single body. They accepted that they might lose in some areas and gain in others, but they thought that, overall, the scheme was far better.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Let us say that a pensioner is coming from Colinton to the Scottish Parliament, to see me. They get on a number 27 bus. The fare would be £1.20, so Lothian Buses gets 80p. At Forrest Road, they change on to a 35 and Lothian Buses gets another 80p. On the way back, they do the same thing in reverse. Therefore, Lothian Buses will get £3.20 in total. However, if a young man, like Frank McAveety, made the journey, he would buy a day ticket, which would cost less than that.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

When we reviewed the scheme with Transport Scotland and its consultants, ITS Leeds, an allowance for discount tickets was built into the calculation that arrived at 67 per cent. In the absence of that factor, the rate would have been higher than 67 per cent; a discount rate was factored in. The consultants considered the usage of day tickets and, I think, weekly and monthly tickets.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

That is a good answer. I can tell that you are from the north-east of Scotland.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Notwithstanding that a discounted rate is paid, in George Foulkes’s example four times the discounted rate would still come to more than 100 per cent of the day ticket. The operators are benefiting artificially from the public purse, as a result of journeys that most sensible people would buy a day ticket before making.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Recent work has been done as part of the Department for Transport’s review of the scheme in England, which indicates that people are really not that sensible when it comes to buying travel tickets. The vast majority of journeys are still single-fare journeys. You might ask why. The research that we have seen indicates that ITS Leeds did a fair and sensible piece of work when it concluded that it was using the right discount factor.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Therefore, operators are benefiting because of people’s stupidity or lack of common sense.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I would not necessarily use those terms. For whatever reason, the vast majority of journeys are still made on a single fare, despite the fact that operators display notices that tell people that they can buy a day ticket for £3, £3.20 or whatever. ITS Leeds considered the likelihood of pensioners making sufficient journeys to warrant their buying a day ticket, and it concluded by applying a discount factor to the calculation.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Can you give us a flavour of how the annual negotiations with the Scottish Government work? How are you represented? The Audit Scotland report states in paragraph 46, on page 15:“The Scottish Government agrees the cap with the Confederation of Passenger Transport (CPT) in advance.”Do you also agree the 67 per cent figure? Which bus companies do you liaise with, or do you seek to liaise with all the bus companies in Scotland? Who sits round the table—are ministers involved? Could you give us a sense of when the negotiations happen and what takes place?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We are an industry representative group, and our members operate more than 90 per cent of scheduled bus mileage in Scotland. They cover the range from individual operators through to the biggest groups in Scotland and UK terms. We are a broad church, and our members operate the vast majority of bus mileage in Scotland. We represent a strong body.I suppose that the best example to give is the work that we did as part of the review of the scheme. We set up various working groups to look at the different aspects of the scheme as part of the big review after three years. That covered everything from reimbursement to administration and, ultimately, led to the Transport Scotland report and list of recommendations.Flowing on from that piece of work, we got into work with Transport Scotland and the consultants ITS, looking at discount and operator additional cost. That work and the work that we have done previously with officials at Victoria Quay and Transport Scotland are very good examples of partnership and positive working. The industry pulled together for ITS probably the biggest data set that has been pulled together in my 29 years in the industry. We worked through the draft report that was received from ITS, and it is fair to say that there were areas that we could agree on and, equally, some areas that we disagreed on. We said that loudly and clearly as we went through the process. Ultimately, ITS recommended a range of figures to the Scottish Government. We met the transport minister and the cabinet secretary, we had an open and frank discussion on the work that had been done and the areas that we had concerns about, and we ultimately concluded an arrangement for three years to take us to the final year of the initial seven-year arrangement. We looked realistically at where the concessionary travel budget would need to be, considering aspects such as increased costs and a growth in the number of journeys, and we agreed a three-year package of £174 million for the current year, £180 million in year 2 and £187 million in year 3. With that, we also concluded an arrangement on BSOG moving to £66.5 million over the three-year period. Part of the logic was that the Government and industry wanted some certainty. That was a fundamental aspiration at the outset of the new scheme—having certainty rather than the situation that prevailed before in which every year managing directors across the country were rolled into local authorities to have meetings about concessionary reimbursement, which was generally always on a downward slide. The new scheme is a far more robust and sensible action.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Were the cap and reimbursement rate agreed by the CPT, or were they imposed by ministers?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We walked away from the meeting making it clear that we were still unhappy with some of the work that ITS had done, but we were pragmatic and we accepted the package that we discussed with the cabinet secretary.10:00

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Do you believe that, in future, the trend in the cost of the scheme to the public, if we have the same scheme, will continue to be upwards?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I guess that it will. The prognosis is that the population will increase, which will result in additional journeys. It is inevitable that operators will face increased costs: fuel will probably get more expensive and wages will have to be increased as inflation rises. Those two factors mean that costs will increase.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Do you believe that the scheme is sustainable, given the current pressures on the public purse?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We have recently committed to getting involved with Transport Scotland in having a wide look at the scheme going forward. Some of those discussions will need to revolve around initiatives that have been touched on but perhaps not picked up on, such as how we manage demand and whether there are things that we can do to reduce the scheme’s cost to the public purse. We need to have a full range of discussions to look at those issues.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

As members have no more questions on that part of the report, we will move on to the section on fraud.When the audit took place, the total value of the fraud that was being investigated, which involved four bus operators, was £1.654 million. Eight operators are now the subject of investigation and report to the courts, and the total value of the fraud that is being investigated is £1.7 million. That would indicate that the problem is growing and that more companies are involved in fraudulent activity. Is that the case?

Paul White Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

No. I would say that the introduction of smart-card ticketing has shown up a significant drop in claims, which would suggest to Transport Scotland that fraud may have been taking place and that investigation is necessary. It is probably the case that rather than there being an upward trend in fraud, the change in ticketing has alerted Transport Scotland to previous fraud. I imagine that electronic ticketing means that it is now more difficult to commit fraud under the scheme.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

CPT and our members welcome any additional work that Transport Scotland can do to identify fraud. We are on record as saying that we will do anything to help to minimise fraud which, ultimately, cheats other companies in the industry out of money that they might well be entitled to, particularly if the cap is applied. We have no support for any operator that does anything underhand and which benefits more than it should. We will happily support Transport Scotland in any work to improve the detection of fraud.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Mr White, you are saying that the new ticketing systems have merely identified what was taking place. They have alerted us to the fact that a substantial level of fraud has taken place over a number of years, which we have become aware of because of their introduction.

Paul White Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

That is potentially the case.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

What other explanations are there?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I am conscious that the team at Transport Scotland has used a number of means to identify fraud. For example, it can look for anomalies in the number of journeys that are made per mile. It is undoubtedly true that the introduction of smart-card-enabled ticketing machines will have given Transport Scotland an additional and stronger handle on identifying where fraud might be taking place.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

It would be helpful if Audit Scotland could provide members with a note of the companies involved and the relevant amounts. I presume that if those cases are the subject of court proceedings, that information will be in the public domain. We cannot talk about any items that are sub judice, but could we have a look at the information?

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Can we be told which companies have been charged? I presume that that information is in the public domain.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That is what I was asking. Can Audit Scotland provide that information?

Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland
link

The question might be better addressed to Transport Scotland because it will have the information and because there are sub judice issues on which we are not fully up to speed. We need to be careful about what we say to you on that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I accept that there are sub judice issues but, if companies have been charged, that is a matter of public record.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Does the Confederation of Passenger Transport know whether the companies that have been charged with fraud are some of its members?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We are not aware of the companies concerned. We know that there are cases under investigation, but we do not know the individuals or companies that are involved in them.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

What does the confederation do to investigate cases in which fraud has been identified?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We are on record as having said to Transport Scotland that if a company is found guilty of fraudulent actions, we will support their being struck off the membership, the traffic commissioner for Scotland being advised of the situation and their good repute being called into question.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

What is the timescale for that process? If companies are being investigated, does Transport Scotland make you aware of that at all?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We have regular discussions with Transport Scotland. Obviously, it does not go into detail but, in the past, it has indicated that it is investigating some companies. That is great. We have the same view on BSOG. If any operator is gaining additional advantage by foul means, it is not acceptable and we will support and help Transport Scotland with that if we can.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

What is the total number of operators under your auspices?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We have just under 100 members in Scotland.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

We know that eight companies are being investigated. Two cases have certainly been sent to the courts for further deliberation and that is probably being considered for the others.Short of going to court, if you are aware that a company has figures that are perhaps not as accurate as they should be—I am picking my words carefully—can you intervene at any stage to try to sort that company out and sober it up a bit?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

No. We do not get information at individual company level unless we ask for it. We are not a policing group but a representative group. We do not have data of that kind.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Does it not worry you that nearly a tenth of the organisations that you represent are perhaps not doing what you would like them to do? Do you have no responsibility to try to sort that out?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We would have to know whether any of those companies were members. If they were eventually found guilty, they certainly would not be members for any time beyond that. Equally, we would support a report being given to the traffic commissioner, because that business’s repute would be in severe question.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

If one or two companies—perhaps larger companies—had been involved in fraud and you had to take action, how would you fill the gap if they were unable to provide the service?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

The market would fill it. I am pretty sure that somebody else would step in and run services. In certain areas, we have seen companies disappear virtually overnight and, the following day, other operators pick up on the services or the local authority step in and put some services out to tender. Generally, the market will pick up on commercial opportunities.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Does your organisation have an annual review of issues that have been thrown up, including concerns about fraud? Have you discussed at a senior level how you wish to address fraud?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Yes. We meet regularly with the membership. We brief our members via newsletters and e-mails. Our position is clear: we will not be shy in dealing with any member that loses repute. The likelihood is that they would not be members because the traffic commissioner would probably remove their right to operate buses.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

My question relates to this issue. My understanding from an answer that Mr White gave is that since its introduction the NCT system has enabled us more readily to identify potential fraud. I know that hindsight is a wonderful thing, but how on earth were we not in a position to spot potential fraud at the outset of the scheme?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

That question should really be addressed to Transport Scotland. My organisation has no input from members other than on the global number of passengers that are carried in Scotland. We have no input to the local commercial issues for operators.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

You mentioned the three-year review and the involvement of your members in the overview of how the scheme is working. You also mentioned working groups that looked at particular areas of the scheme. Was there a working group that looked at fraud?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I would have to come back to you on that. I am sure that fraud would have been in there somewhere, but rather than give you a specific answer at this point, I would have to check the different groups that were set up.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

When or if a member is found guilty of an offence such as fraud, what disciplinary procedures does the CPT have for considering the case and taking action against a member?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

The organisation has a code of practice and, when members join the organisation, they are expected to live by it. If there is an infringement of that, we review the membership, most likely in conjunction with our head office. If the infringement is as serious as an operator being investigated and found guilty of defrauding the Government through concessionary reimbursement or BSOG, I have no doubt that the company would lose its reputation and cease to exist, and it would certainly no longer be a member of CPT.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Would such a case have to go before a panel of members, a committee or a board, or would it happen automatically through the CPT?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

It would not be a board. Our office, in consultation with our head office in London, would make a decision; it would not be a collection of members at a monthly meeting. I have no experience of it happening. If the situation arose, we would present a report to the head office in London, set out the facts and decide whether the company had breached the code of practice. If it was as bad as someone being found guilty of fraud, I have no doubt at all that the company would not be a member.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So that has not happened to any of your Scottish members yet. Is that right?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Yes.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

There might well be operators that have been refused membership or rejected because of their loss of reputation. I would have to check on that.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to ask about overstaging, which is when a passenger is issued a ticket for a journey that is longer than the one they want to make, which we know goes on. Some of us at this table have had constituents coming to us with examples of it. Most travellers are not particularly fussed about it because it does not affect them personally, but it is fraud on the part of a bus operator. Do you have any evidence of how widespread the practice is?10:15

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I had experience of that in my previous role as managing director of a bus company. It is difficult because I genuinely believe that reputable businesses are not trying to get anything out of the scheme other than what they are entitled to.You are talking about a human interface that lasts, at most, for a matter of seconds. There are a range of different attitudes on both sides of that transaction. The driver might be under stress and pressure from dealing with traffic congestion. The passenger might be new to concessionary travel and having to state an alighting stage, which is industry jargon. If you ask them, “Where are you going?” they say, “I’m gaun tae Auntie Jeannie’s.”The transaction is a difficult one and I could not sit here and say, in all honesty, that drivers never get it wrong—they occasionally do. However, when I used to get letters from people who were concerned that the driver had overstaged their ticket, it was often not overstaged. The ticket went to the final stage in that particular fare band, so the operator gained no money but, from the individual traveller’s point of view, it was staged to a point beyond where they were alighting. Overstaging does happen; we are dealing with human beings. However, sometimes the customer’s perception of overstaging is different from the position in reality, because it is within the fare band.Is the current approach the best way to do it? Certainly, that question was part of the work that was done, and the option that Transport Scotland concluded it wanted to go forward with was shadow fares. When we were having discussions on the scheme back in the early days, I remember that it was suggested that we should have tap on, tap off, but that did not happen. Would using average fares negate overstaging? I am not sure, but it is certainly a matter that we could revisit in the work that we have just started with Transport Scotland.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is helpful. The issue is that it is very difficult to know how widespread overstaging is unless, as you say, individual passengers write to you and draw it to your attention.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I urge you to urge your constituents to let the local bus company know when they experience overstaging, because that is the only way that it can deal with the matter. If particular drivers are struggling because they are from outwith Scotland and do not understand the destination, that is a training issue, but it will not be addressed if people do not get in touch with the local bus company and make it aware of the situation. They should give the company the bus ticket, because the information is on it and the companies will follow the issue up with the drivers involved.Bus companies are not saying to the drivers, “Always stage the ticket to the end of the route.” I genuinely do not believe that that is the case.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Several people in my constituency have come to me with tickets that are overstaged; none of them has been understaged. All the honest mistakes have been made in favour of the bus companies. I have had no satisfactory response on why that should be.Mr Mair, you mentioned that you had suggested a tap-on, tap-off system. Can you tell us what you mean by that?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

This information is anecdotal, but it might be helpful. We used shadow fares when I was the MD in Aberdeen, which was back when the scheme was overseen by Grampian Regional Council. The council was pretty hot. It had a team of guys that would go on and do checks on the buses. They looked for out-of-date passes, which the driver is supposed to check for, and for tickets that were overstaged or understaged. Often more tickets were understaged than were overstaged. There was a balance over time.What was the second question?

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

You said that a tap-on, tap-off system was suggested but was never taken up. Can you tell us more about that?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Another piece of equipment would be added to the ticket machine. When the passenger gets on the bus, they place the card over the machine, which indicates that the card is valid and the passenger is entitled to a journey, and the passenger goes into the saloon of the vehicle. When they leave, they touch another mechanism. It is a bit like the Oyster card. That system would record the actual stop at which the passenger alights.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Why was that suggestion not taken up?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I guess that it was linked to the additional costs that would be involved in putting the equipment on every bus in Scotland.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Was an estimate done for the cost of that option? Was it ruled out at the time on the basis of cost?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

I would need to go back through the files to see if that was done. Colleagues from Transport Scotland might be able to tell you.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

I have a final question. You said that you had ideas about how the costs of the scheme could be kept down in future. Will you tell us about some of those ideas? How practical are they and how likely are they to be successfully implemented?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

We would not claim, I think, that these are our ideas; they are ideas that are there. At this point, they are perhaps not politically acceptable, but things move on.Operators often have a good dialogue with pensioner organisations. We could envisage a scheme whereby pensioners pay a flat 20p fare. Across 157 million journeys, that would significantly lighten the load on the public purse. Would the pensioners be overly upset about paying 20p? That option is worth looking at. In England, the age criteria for eligibility are being linked to changes in the pension age. That is another option that could be considered. Another issue that could be examined is why people make pre-9 o’clock journeys. Where are people going pre-9 o’clock? A multitude of options that have the potential to lighten the load could be looked at. I guess that it is up to you guys to make the decision.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

Those are all policy changes rather than changes that bus operators themselves could introduce to make the scheme more efficient or more effective. Is that correct?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Yes.

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

So, to ask a direct question about what the industry can do to reduce costs, do you believe that you have gone as far as you can to contain and cap costs? From an operator’s viewpoint, is it the case—as I think you said previously—that costs will continue to rise?

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Any amount of research indicates that since privatisation in 1995 through to recent times, the industry has been extremely good at managing costs downwards—

Nicol Stephen LD Aberdeen South
link

But it has not been very good in the past few years.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Costs have gone up.

George Mair Confederation of Passenger Transport UK
link

Yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I thank both Mr White and Mr Mair for their very helpful contributions this morning. We will clearly need to follow up some issues with Transport Scotland. I hope that through various agencies working together we can improve what is already a remarkably effective scheme.I suspend the meeting briefly to allow a changeover of witnesses.10:23 Meeting suspended.

10:25 On resuming—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I welcome from Transport Scotland David Middleton, the chief executive; Alastair Mitchell, the head of bus, taxi and concessionary fares policy; and George Hanning, the head of concessionary travel and integrated ticketing. Mr Middleton, before we go into questions—there will be one or two questions that follow on from what we heard previously—do you have any introductory remarks?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

No, convener; I am happy to proceed with questions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. Thank you. Anne McLaughlin wants to ask some questions about the roll-out of technology but, before I bring her in, I would like to refer you to the original budget for the electronic ticketing machine technology. In 2004, it was costed at £9 million. In August 2010, Transport Scotland estimated the total set-up cost as £42 million. That is a staggering difference. Was that due to incompetence, or were there unforeseen factors between 2004 and 2010? If so, what were they?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is clear from the Audit Scotland investigation that the basis of the original £9 million was not clear. Certainly, as the Audit Scotland report reflects, things such as the cost of the machines to be put in every bus suggest that that figure did not have an accurate basis. It is clearly not a good story to go from £9 million to £42 million. As the story unfolded and precise calculations were made of the technology, the equipment and the back-up services needed to make it an effective scheme, you can understand why the £9 million figure did not equate very well. I hope that the committee will be satisfied that £42 million has a sound basis in terms of what it has to be spent on to make the scheme effective.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Okay. It is encouraging to know that £42 million has a sound basis in terms of making the scheme effective. Presumably officials in the Scottish Executive produced the figure of £9 million to enable ministers to advocate a scheme and say at that time that it was an effective and accurate figure. Why did officials get their calculations so badly wrong?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not think that I have a basis to speak for the 2004-05 thinking around the £9 million. Audit Scotland has tried its best to bottom that out. It is clear that there was not a precise basis for the £9 million.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

So Audit Scotland has tried to bottom it out but failed. There is no one among the civil servants who is able to tell Audit Scotland, and you, the head of Transport Scotland, are not able to tell us. Basically, we had civil servants at the time advising ministers, and ministers advising Parliament, but they did not have a Scooby Doo about the figures, which are clearly completely inaccurate. We now have an accurate figure, but politicians in this Parliament made a decision to implement a scheme based on what we were told was an accurate figure that was produced by civil servants at the time, and no one seems to be able to tell us how it was calculated. Is that not just farcical?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I will leave the committee to draw its conclusions. I cannot speak for the calculation of the £9 million. We and Audit Scotland have tried, at the Scottish Government end and at the Transport Scotland end, to see what the precise basis of the calculation was. It may have been an aspirational or a hoped-for figure, but the fact is that once we began to calculate the precise costs of the technology and infrastructure needed to make the scheme work well—we believe that the scheme is now working well and that the report reflects that it is now working a lot better—it was clear that £9 million was not properly based.10:30

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

We will consider how well the system is working, but I will stick with the current subject for the moment. You tell me that no one in the civil service can tell us how the figure was calculated, yet the Parliament based its decision on the figures that civil servants produced. If the figures had been different, Parliament might not have decided to proceed with the scheme; we do not know—it might well have proceeded anyway.To be frank, it beggars belief that no one in the system can give the answer. Nothing has been recorded, which is a worry; nothing can be demonstrated; and no one is available to tell us how the figure was reached. I do not know whether that is just how Transport Scotland and the transport department have operated or whether that is an indictment of the Government in general. If we have no means of determining how figures were calculated only six years ago in any branch of the civil service, we have a seriously dysfunctional organisation. How can we hold anyone to account when you cannot give us the figures?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I understand what you say. All that I can say is that Transport Scotland takes forward plenty of other projects on roads and railways all the time. The scheme was not originally Transport Scotland’s responsibility. Many prestigious schemes have run on time and on budget.Ministerial priority was given to getting the concessionary travel scheme under way—it had impetus at the time. Initial figures were arrived at. Audit Scotland has investigated the basis of the £9 million. In a way, it would be odd if I came to the committee with a separate explanation that Audit Scotland had not studied. It would be improper for me to suggest that a further bank of information existed that Audit Scotland could not access.I regret the situation, although it occurred some time ago. All that I can speak for is what we have done in the past few years to make the scheme work and to make it effective. We have had to purchase the infrastructure and the technology and to put machines on buses to make the scheme work as well as possible. Those costs, which we can show, are soundly based and are effective in making the scheme work.I understand perfectly well what you say about the unsatisfactory nature of the original number.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

To be clear, no one anywhere in the civil service can show how the £9 million was calculated. No documentary evidence anywhere in the civil service shows the calculations for that figure. To be frank, as far as we know, the figure looks as though it was plucked out of thin air.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I was not around at that time. In going through the report with Audit Scotland, we have tried our best in all quarters to be helpful and to see whether anything could be turned up to explain the basis of the £9 million. As the report says, a clear basis for the figure that relates to the costs that were required to put into effect the scheme’s infrastructure is not available.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I was not sure—I thought it was Tavish Scott. I am not sure whether I can ask a fellow committee member my questions, so I will address them to Transport Scotland. I am astonished that nothing—no paperwork anywhere—says, “The figure is £9 million because the machines cost this amount, we need this number of units and we have this quote from this company and another quote from another company.”Mr Middleton said that we now have precise figures. I appreciate that he was not involved at the relevant time, but I am astonished that the figures to make up the £9 million were not precise. The £9 million was just a guesstimate—and a pretty bad guesstimate at that.I cannot question a fellow member of the committee. I am a back bencher and I do not know how this operates, but is it normal practice for ministers to be told, “This is how we’ve come to this conclusion” or is it normal practice for them just to be given figures and to accept them and give them to Parliament, which we then accept in good faith? I find this utterly astonishing.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

No, it is certainly not normal practice for them just to be given figures. There are plenty of projects that are taken forward with clear estimates of the actual costs. There are schemes across the range of Transport Scotland’s activities—most obviously road schemes, some of which are very large—which run on time and on budget.The NCT scheme was a groundbreaking area. I am to some extent speculating in looking back, but it was an area in which ministers at the time wanted to make progress; they wanted to put a national scheme into operation and speed was of the essence. It may be that the figures speculated about were heroic at the time. I do not think that I can add to the fact that, following the Audit Scotland review, no clear basis can be found for the £9 million. I do not think that that would ever be considered normal or appropriate practice.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I am glad to hear that. In 2004, the £9 million figure was given. The scheme should have been completed by 2006—it should have been rolled out by then. A new Government comes in and inherits not just the £9 million estimate but, because the scheme has taken so long, an additional bill for £33 million—if my maths is correct. That money has to come from other services. I find that deeply concerning. I am glad to hear that it is not normal practice.I want to look at the length of time things have taken. I think that, originally, the scheme was to be fully operational by April 2006. The roll-out of the machinery was not completed until August 2010. The report states:“Transport Scotland now expects the back-office systems ... to be fully operational by December 2010”.Are they fully operational now? If not, when will they be?I also want to go through the reasons given in the external review. You said yourself that we are talking about groundbreaking technology that had never been used before. Why choose to use something that has not been tried and tested?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

First, I can confirm that it is now fully operational, in line with the report. Gordon Hanning, who oversees the implementation of the scheme, is probably best placed to talk about your second point.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

The nameplate says that we have George Hanning with us—

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

His name is Gordon Hanning.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I beg your pardon, Mr Hanning. We were given wrong information. I am sorry about that.

Gordon Hanning Transport Scotland
link

It is probably a bit like the £9 million; I do not know why the decision to go for that type of technology was taken. I came in—

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

I am sorry to interrupt, but using groundbreaking technology that has never been used before is a risk, is it not?

Gordon Hanning Transport Scotland
link

Yes. That is partly why the cost has come out at about £42 million. There were aspects of rolling out that technology that we had not anticipated. Certainly when I came into the role we thought that we were purchasing something that, when you plugged all the pieces together, would work. That patently was not the case. When we started to roll out ticket machines, the first batch that we put out in Shetland in late 2006 actually went quite well. It was only when we rolled out more ticket machines and started introducing them to smart cards that we realised that the technology was nowhere near as reliable as we had initially thought. We had to spend quite a lot of time, money and effort on systems integration. We have learnt a lot about rolling out information technology projects. We have the biggest ITSO scheme in the world. Others are still struggling with it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Sorry, what is that?

Gordon Hanning Transport Scotland
link

The technology goes by the name of ITSO. It is a sort of specification. You have two options when you roll out smart-card technology. You can go to one supplier, which will roll out the whole system for you and, usually, hold you to ransom. Look at the costs of Oyster in London, for example. It can do only a handful of things, although it does them very well, and it is very expensive. The alternative is ITSO, which attempts to put together what we call an open specification, in which you can get more than one supplier of cards, ticket machines and back-office equipment, which is probably good for keeping costs under control and getting the system to evolve and meet all your future requirements. That is the route that we chose. We still have the biggest ITSO scheme in the world; we are one of the very few places that has rolled it out at all, and we have rolled it out pretty successfully. I do not doubt that we will discuss, later, what the technology does, but it works: it enables us to do our job and to manage the scheme in ways that we could never have done under the old type of arrangements with show and go.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

The external review highlighted that properly skilled staff were not in place at the time.

Gordon Hanning Transport Scotland
link

That is absolutely right. It is very specialised IT: there are certain aspects of testing ticket machines and of ensuring that they do all the different IT-related things that they are supposed to do that your average civil servant would never have the skills to do. However, we have developed the skills to manage projects such as this one. As I say, we completed it, albeit a little later than we expected.I look at how other people are getting on with rolling out much smaller schemes. They are not making the level of progress that we have made. We can point to the fact that by 2008 we had a decent number of machines out and that by 2010 we had dealt with the last rump-end of it, which was in the Western Isles.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

The report also said that contracting arrangements were “weak”, which gave private sector advisers too much influence. How did you, and how do you, guard against private advisers and contractors having too much influence?

Gordon Hanning Transport Scotland
link

I have learned an awful lot from overseeing this programme, but I suppose that it is like anything in life: if we were starting all over again we would do it differently. With the benefit of hindsight, I would say that too much of the risk for this programme sat with Transport Scotland. Perhaps more of the risk should have sat with the suppliers.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

You have said that we now have properly skilled staff in place and that the technology is groundbreaking, and you have spoken fairly convincingly about that. Without commenting on the escalation in costs or on the length of time the project has taken, would you say that it is worth while and that it is value for money?

Gordon Hanning Transport Scotland
link

Yes. As simple as that—yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

May I ask Mr Middleton how he travelled to the Parliament this morning?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I travelled by bus.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Good. Did you expect questions on the increase in costs for this particular scheme to be asked at today’s meeting?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I would have anticipated them, yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

So, in preparation for the meeting, you went through all the papers.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I hope that I did, yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

And you cannot find any reason why the cost escalated and why it was predicted to be £9 million.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

No, I cannot. That was what Audit Scotland said in its report and it would have been odd if, in preparing for the meeting, I had found another set of considerations that proved differently.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Did you look at the papers that were used in drawing up the recommendation to the minister that the cost should be £9 million?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I looked at the papers that were relevant to the study that Audit Scotland published.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Some of those papers might have been private papers. Did you look at all the papers that were used by Transport Scotland in drawing up the recommendation to the minister?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

At the time—2002 to 2004-05—I was in the main part of what is now called the Scottish Government, rather than in Transport Scotland. I looked at no papers that were not available to Audit Scotland.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

So all the papers that were used in drawing up the recommendation to the minister were made available to Audit Scotland.

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

Yes.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

And you still cannot assess or deduce why the figure of £9 million was arrived at?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I cannot add to the findings of Audit Scotland about that, no.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

The cost is now up to £42 million. Can you identify precisely where the additional costs came from?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

The report makes clear where the costs were encountered over the lifetime of the project, and what the money was spent on—for example, on the machines in each bus, and in the back-office and support services to make those machines effective.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

But there is still the question of why the additional costs were not anticipated when the figure of £9 million was drawn up. Why is there a disjunction between what actually happened and what was predicted? Why was it different?10:45

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

It is clear that the £9 million was not soundly based. I do not think that I have attempted to suggest other than that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

So, how do we now, in looking at it, ensure—and how do you ensure—that the same thing is not happening with some of your current projects?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

All projects are different. As I said previously, which may be a bit of a cliché, this scheme was groundbreaking; a smart card technology alongside the policy of a national concessionary travel scheme took us into new territory. We have a range of other projects, most obviously infrastructure projects. As I mentioned, road schemes have their own natural process through public inquiry and estimates presented to Parliament. There are many very large-scale road projects. For example, two big motorway projects that are going ahead at present are some of the largest projects in a generation, but I am glad to say that they are on time and on budget.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

They are traditional projects. Another groundbreaking project is the Forth replacement crossing. How can you be confident about the figure that you presented for that project?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

We are confident about that figure. The basis of the figure work for the cost estimates for the Forth replacement crossing has been widely available and, of course, was debated in Parliament during the Forth Crossing Bill. The competitive dialogue period with the two consortia that are bidding for the Forth replacement crossing has recently concluded. The two international consortia will submit their bids in the new year. Clearly, when it comes to awarding the contract we hope that the terms of the contract and its basis will give Parliament and all in Scotland confidence that the cost estimates that we have displayed thus far are accurate and will reflect the costs of this very important project.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

So the terms of the contract for the ticketing scheme did not reflect the costs that you anticipated?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I said that the £9 million did not properly anticipate the costs that were required to roll out the project as it developed and as we worked on the technology, which Gordon Hanning has discussed, to put the machines into every bus. Clearly, the £9 million was not soundly based and there is no point in my seeking to dispute that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Yes, but you do not seem able to indicate why. You state that you are sure of other projects; I took the example of the Forth replacement crossing. How can we be sure that if this happened once, it will not happen again?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I can only point the committee to the range of road improvements, rail contracts and other financial arrangements that Transport Scotland enters into. Partly because of the recent bad weather, not a huge amount of publicity was given to the opening of the Airdrie to Bathgate rail link, which Network Rail and ourselves have taken forward and which was a fixed-price contract. We believe that the project has been delivered at that fixed price and we hope that it will prove to be value for money. There is also the example of the £200 million Clackmannanshire bridge project, for which we are on time and on budget.Transport Scotland has taken forward a range of projects since its establishment in 2006. I am more than happy for the committee and others to pore over the range of projects that we have undertaken. I think you would find that, generally speaking, we are pretty good at the business of budgeting and delivering projects on time and on budget. It is regrettable that there is a story around the ticketing project, but the £9 million figure was arrived at some time ago—six years ago—and it clearly was not soundly based at that time. However, we believe that the costs that Transport Scotland has incurred in implementing the project are soundly based and are now making it an effective scheme, as Gordon Hanning described in his evidence.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I apologise for sticking with the £9 million, but it is clearly in the public interest that we try to get to the bottom of it. I do not know whether the Auditor General’s report is in front of you. Paragraph 24 on page 9 says that the £9 million was set aside in 2004 and that“A year later,”we“realised that this budget was unrealistic—it was not”even“enough to buy an ETM for every bus”.For goodness’ sake, surely when equipment for buses is to be bought the first thing somebody in the system does is estimate the number of buses and the cost of the equipment. The committee is known for having been astonished at almost every meeting it has held in the past three and a half years—

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

And perplexed. I join that feeling now. I have been a member of the committee for as long as my colleague Murdo Fraser, but I am utterly gobsmacked that somebody in the system could not estimate the cost of a unit and the number of buses, do a wee multiplication and come up with a figure. It is clear that the cost was more than £9 million. Furthermore, those involved did not even estimate the cost of back-office administration. How on earth do we get an explanation for that? You have said that you were not in Transport Scotland at the time. Who was in the organisation and could answer our questions?

David Middleton Transport Scotland
link

I do not think that I can add to what I have said. We cannot identify precisely the individuals who were around at the time. By looking at all the papers that were available from all parts of the Government, Audit Scotland did its best to find out the basis.As you say, it seems perfectly obvious to think of the price of a machine and do a multiplication. I understand why you make that obvious point. Looking back at the situation leaves me in an uncomfortable position. I wish that the situation were different. However, as for producing evidence to explain the state of affairs, I cannot add to what Audit Scotland said. It would be odd if, after Audit Scotland had published its agreed report, I produced a subsequent set of explanations. That would cast doubt on the process by which Audit Scotland comes into the Government and accesses papers in order to draw up reports such as the report that we are discussing.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Exhibit 3 in the report shows that we spent £650,000 on consultancy fees in 2005, £890,000 in the following year and £900,000 in the year after that. Nearly £4 million has been spent on consultancy fees for the scheme since 2005. Have we obtained value for money for the public purse from the consultancy costs?

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 344
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 1
  4. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.