1. To ask the Scottish Executive what assessment it has made of the impact on schools in Orkney of its class size commitment for primary 1 to primary 3. (S3O-12099)
Michael RussellSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning · South of Scotland
Schools census data published since 2007 indicate that the proportion of Orkney’s primary 1 to primary 3 pupils in classes of 18 or fewer in successive years was as follows: in 2007, the proportion was 41.4 per cent, which is good; in 2008 it was 43 per cent, which is better; and, in 2009, it was 44.8, which is very much better. The census data for 2010 are due to be published next week, on 1 December.
Orkney is the second highest performing council in this respect, and we believe that, as with other councils that are following a class size reduction policy, its pupils will benefit from enhanced interaction with their teachers.
I think that Papdale primary school is due some plaudits, as it is the only primary school with multiple class intake.
I assure the minister that I need no persuading of the benefits of smaller class sizes, particularly in the early years. However, they are only one element in ensuring a quality education.
It might not surprise Mr Russell to learn that, in Orkney, parents and teachers have not been kept awake at night worrying about classrooms overflowing with pupils. In many instances, the concern has been, and remains, the precise opposite. I acknowledge the Government’s position regarding the class size commitment, but will the minister accept that allowing headteachers the flexibility to manage their staff and financial resources in a way that best meets the needs of the school and its pupils is desirable?
Does he acknowledge that as local authority budgets and, therefore, school budgets become tighter, that flexibility will become even more essential? Does he agree that if, in order to keep class sizes lower throughout primaries 1 to 3, class sizes balloon elsewhere in the school, pupils with additional support needs struggle to receive the support that they need, and some pupils are prevented from remaining in the same classes as their friends, that brings into some question the overall benefits that are achieved?
Michael RussellSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning · South of Scotland
Like the curate’s egg, that question was good in parts. I accept the argument that class size reduction is important, I agree that it is not the only element of good education—good teaching is exceptionally important—and I agree that there should be flexibility for headteachers in many aspects of education policy and delivery. I also know that that question will be raised again in this chamber this afternoon.
However, I do not accept that there should be a free-for-all with regard to class sizes. I know that Orkney is an enlightened local authority and I look forward to seeing its director of education at tomorrow’s Association of Directors of Education in Scotland conference, but I think that one or two less enlightened local authorities might use any substantial change in this policy to very much weaken the important connection between young people and teachers that the class size policy represents.
Mr McArthur should support what we are trying to do, and should not try to trim it.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.