Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 25 November 2010 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 15 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2730)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Later today I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Yesterday, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth was forced to apologise to the Parliament for covering up the fact that tax-varying powers were no longer available to us. Presumably, the First Minister knew that too and also hid it. Will he, too, apologise to the Parliament?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I endorse what John Swinney said to the Parliament yesterday. He fully informed me of the situation. Therefore, I join in his apology to the Parliament for not keeping it informed of the developments.

I also support John Swinney in pointing out that—as I am sure Iain Gray must acknowledge, given that he has had time to peruse the documents—the Scottish variable rate was not in a workable condition in 2007 and that it would have taken many millions of pounds to implement it.

I am sure that Iain Gray has seen the quotation in The Times newspaper today, which says:

“It was clear to the Scottish government, both before and after 2007, that there would have to be investment in SVR to maintain the position on implementation”.

When I heard Andy Kerr yesterday, I assumed that he was still under the illusion that £50,000 was all that was required to maintain 10-month availability of the SVR. It seems from that quotation in The Times that, perhaps, there is more documentation to obtain from before 2007 to show what finance ministers really knew before the previous election.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Yesterday, we called for publication of all documentation and we have nothing to fear from that. However, the document that I perused as part of preparation for yesterday’s events was the local income tax consultation paper that the Scottish Government launched on 11 March 2008. That consultation paper makes it clear that, to collect the local income tax, the Scottish Government planned to use the system that Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs had designed to collect the Scottish variable rate. Now the Government tells us that that system was inoperable.

I always thought that the local income tax was unfair, unwanted and unworkable. Now we know that the Scottish Government, too, knew that it was unworkable, even as it launched its plans. True to form, it covered that up as well. Will the First Minister apologise for that?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Luckily, I anticipated Iain Gray’s question, so I brought along the consultation paper on local income tax. It actually says:

“The Government does not propose to use the Scottish Variable Rate (SVR) to replace the council tax”.

That is on page 26, if Iain Gray would like to catch up on it.

I was interested in that because, yesterday, one of the Liberal Democrats quoted the second part of that sentence, which says:

“even though the SVR could, in principle, be introduced relatively quickly.”

Of course it

“could, in principle, be introduced relatively quickly”,

and the principle is the many millions of pounds for which HMRC asks in order to implement it. The revenue wanted millions of pounds to implement the SVR.

Alex Fergusson The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order, Mr Purvis.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
I read a range of quotations in the newspapers. The Herald editorial today asks why John Swinney did not bring the matter to the Parliament. It is puzzled by the fact that he did not, given the obvious political capital, as it puts it, that could be made out of the failing of the past Labour-Liberal Democrat Administration. The Parliament should accept that John Swinney is the sort of person who, when he sees a difficulty and a problem, attempts to solve it, which is what he did. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
Others may have seen the advantages of showing Labour and the Liberal Democrats that Labour finance ministers and Liberal Democrat deputy finance ministers had not kept the SVR in a position that would assure its implementation. Of course the SVR could be implemented relatively quickly if members of the Parliament are prepared to pay a multimillion-pound bill to HMRC. I do not think that that is a good idea at present.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
Of course, the second part of the paragraph that the First Minister read out, on page 26 of the consultation paper—paragraph 4—says:

“the Government believes that earlier preparations made by HMRC for the SVR at the time of devolution should provide a basis for the arrangements that will be needed to implement a local income tax.”

Presumably, the First Minister was suggesting at that point that the Government should indeed spend the many millions of pounds that it knew would be needed to make that system operable, but which it omitted to tell us about.

In a sense, this is an academic debate, because on 11 February 2009 Mr Swinney withdrew his plans to replace the council tax because, he said, there was no parliamentary majority—that is just as well, because there was no collection system either, as it turns out.

Let us talk about what the First Minister was prepared to spend. Why did he continue to spend taxpayers’ money on a staffed-up council tax abolition unit in the civil service for 18 months after the Parliament had told him to drop his local income tax? Will he apologise for that?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
That team is dealing with a range of issues, such as the council tax freeze, which we should remember that Iain Gray was against, then he was for it and then he was against it again, as long as the basket of tax rises was capped. There is a range of things on which Iain Gray had better decide what position he intends to adopt before he gets to the election, never mind pay restraint in the public sector.

I point out to Iain Gray that it is absolutely true that if we were to implement local income tax, we would have to have a contract with the revenue so that we could proceed with implementation. A new contract would be essential to do that, but that would involve paying for a contract for a tax that is fair and which would be implemented. Iain Gray seems to suggest that we should have paid millions of pounds to introduce a tax that was not going to be implemented. If he went outside on to the streets of Edinburgh—this time not to demonstrate outside the Parliament with a no pay freeze banner, but to ask, “Should we pay many millions of pounds to the Inland Revenue for a variable rate that we’re not going to implement?”—even fewer people would support that than support the Edinburgh tram project.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link
No—I am asking why the First Minister has spent more than £250,000 on a local income tax that the Parliament does not want and which he will not implement.

Yesterday, we discovered that the Government had secretly stopped spending money on a tax power that the Parliament should have. Today, we find that it was secretly spending money on a tax that we do not want and which it has given up on. It is not good enough to say that the local income tax unit was working on a range of things, none of which was the thing that is in its title. In fact, the Government has spent more money on the unit since local income tax was dropped than it spent on it before the policy was dropped.

It is bad enough that this Parliament does not know what the Scottish Government is doing. The real problem is that it does not know what it is doing, either. The Government is an incompetent shambles. Will the First Minister apologise for that?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Gordon
link
That was a true demonstration of labouring a question. I believe that John Swinney was right to apologise to Parliament yesterday for not bringing the matter to the Parliament for a decision. I join in that apology, but that does not change the underlying twofold issue. First, it is quite clear that the Scottish variable rate was not in a condition in which it could be implemented. Right up until the debate yesterday, Andy Kerr was talking about £50,000, but it is clear that it would take many millions of pounds to prepare the SVR to a state of readiness.

Secondly, the only point at which we should be prepared to pay a multimillion-pound bill is when we are going to invoke the power, which remains available to the Parliament. It does not make sense to pay the bill unless we decide to move forward and invoke the power.

Iain Gray does not seem to like my points so far. I accept the point about reporting to the Parliament, but on the principle of when we should pay multimillion-pound bills, I cite this morning’s Daily Record editorial:

“Swinney may have made the right decision back in 2007 given the costs involved and his own government's plans not to use the tax during their term in office.”

If the Daily Record believes that John Swinney probably made the right decision, we can assume that a broad swathe of Scottish society agrees.

  1. A Budget for Scotland’s People Debate · 140
  2. Nigg Yard Questions · 6
  3. Animal Welfare Questions · 4
  4. Scottish Investment Bank Questions · 4
  5. Scottish Coal (Opencast Coal Reserves) Questions · 6
  6. Business Start-up Rate Questions · 4
  7. Local Authority Housing Allocation Questions · 6
  8. Local Food Sourcing (Public Bodies) Questions · 4
  9. Equine Welfare Questions · 5
  10. M8 Baillieston to Newhouse (Upgrade) Questions · 6
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 15
  12. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
  14. Fuel Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Police Officers First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Irish Economy First Minister’s Questions · 6
  17. Class Sizes (Orkney) Questions · 4
  18. Education and Lifelong Learning (Budget) Questions · 6
  19. Outdoor Education Questions · 4
  20. Textiles Industry (Skills) Questions · 6
  21. Gaelic-medium Education Questions · 6
  22. Early Years Education Questions · 4
  23. City of Glasgow College Questions · 4
  24. Free School Meals Questions · 4
  25. St Andrew’s Day Questions · 6
  26. Cultural Co-ordinators (Termination of Contracts) Questions · 4
  27. Scots Language Questions · 6
  28. Public Art Questions · 6
  29. Museums (Report on Funding) Questions · 6
  30. China (Visit) Questions · 4
  31. Cultural Activity (Linlithgow) Questions · 5
  32. Children’s Hearings (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 51
  33. Children’s Hearings (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 21
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 13
  35. St Andrew’s Day 2010 Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.